Seizovic and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (General)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Seizovic and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (General) [2018] AATA 1084 (1 May 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2015/6109

Re:Aleksander Seizovic

APPLICANT

AndCommonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Date:1 May 2018

Place:Brisbane

I set aside the decision made on 17 October 2006, as affirmed on 19 October 2015, to determine under s 30(1) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 the applicant’s percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment as Class C with effect from 2 October 2006. In substitution it is determined that Mr Seizovic’s incapacity in relation to civil employment is between 30% and 60%, and that he be classified as Class B with effect from 2 October 2006, being the day following his discharge from the Navy.

..........................[SGD]..........................................

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

CATCHWORDS

DEFENCE – Defence force retirements and death benefits – service in Royal Australian Navy – medical discharge – invalidity benefit granted – applicant classified as Class C – the kinds of civil employment that might be reasonably undertaken – the degree to which the retirement impairments diminished the applicant’s capacity to undertake the kinds of civil employment – the applicant could reasonably undertake the role of mechanical engineering technician – applicant to be classified as Class B – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973
Navigation Act 2012

CASES

Fury and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2005] AATA 382
Re X and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1980) 3 ALN N58
Re The Hospital Benefit Fund of Western Australia Inc v Minister for Health, Housing and Community Services (1992) 111 ALR 1, [1992] FCA 599, (1992) 39 FCR 225, (1992) 16 AAR 566, 28 ALD 5
Re Colin Robert Beattie and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [1993] AATA 79
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House (1989) 91 ALR 286

SECONDARY MATERIALS

‘Standards for the medical examination of seafarers and coastal pilots’ – Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

1 May 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 17 October 2006 a determination was made by a delegate of the then Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority that the applicant’s invalidity classification from service-related health conditions in relation to civil employment was to be small (20%) or Class C, pursuant to s 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973) (“the Act”), with effect from 2 October 2006.[1]

    [1] Exhibit A, T-Documents, T2 at p. 14.

  2. On 18 February 2014 the applicant requested a review of this determination. On 19 October 2015 the Defence Force Case Assessment Panel affirmed the original decision.

  3. On 16 November 2015 the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision made by the respondent.

    BACKGROUND

  4. The applicant was born on 29 September 1957. He served in the Royal Australian Navy (“the Navy”) for over 24 years, for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seizovic and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (Genera... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 1084
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) regarding the classification of an applicant's incapacity for civil employment. The applicant, who had served over 24 years in the Royal Australian Navy, was medically discharged in October 2006 due to various physical and psychological impairments. CSC had classified him as Class C, indicating a significant but not total incapacity for civil employment. The applicant sought a review of this classification, arguing that the kinds of civil employment identified by CSC were not reasonably available to him given his qualifications, experience, and medical restrictions.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the applicant's percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment, and consequently, his classification under section 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. This required the Tribunal to consider the applicant's vocational, trade, and professional skills, qualifications, and experience, and then assess the kinds of civil employment he could reasonably undertake, taking into account the extent to which his impairments diminished his capacity for such employment. The Tribunal had to apply the principles established in cases like *Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House*, which emphasise a broad approach to identifying "kinds of civil employment" and consider what a hypothetical person with the applicant's attributes might reasonably undertake, even if some further learning or certification was required.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the applicant possessed several engineering diplomas and trade qualifications, he lacked the specific tertiary qualifications and applicable experience to be classified as a mechanical engineer or marine transport professional. The Tribunal accepted the applicant's evidence that these roles, particularly in civilian shipping, would require further extensive training and specific certifications, and that his medical restrictions, including limitations on standing and avoiding repetitive upper limb activity, would hinder his ability to perform such duties. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the applicant's adjustment disorder and avoidance of stress would make the role of a training officer, despite his experience in training, an unreasonable undertaking. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the original decision and determined that the applicant's incapacity fell between 30% and 60%, classifying him as Class B.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On 16 November 2015 the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision made by the respondent.BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 29 September 1957. He served in the Royal Australian Navy (“the Navy”) for over 24 years, for the period 8 March 1982 to 30 July 2002 and the period 7 April 2003 to 1 October 2006. On 14 June 2005 the applicant requested a posting to Brisbane on compassionate grounds, which was granted and extended until the end of 2005. On 16 January 2006 he was posted back to HMAS Gascoyne. Between 28 April 2006 and 8 May 2006 the applicant stayed in Brisbane on leave as his son required emergency surgery. At this time he also sought discharge ‘at own request’, and requested a discharge date of 20 May 2006 as he had an open job offer due to commence in late May 2006. The applicant was advised that his leave would not be extended beyond 8 May 2006, and he was told to report back to HMAS Gascoyne by that date. On 3 May 2006 the applicant advised that he would be on convalescent leave for a week, and provided documentation from a medical officer indicating that he should remain in Brisbane until at least 14 June 2006.[2] [2] Exhibit B, Service Medical Records, at p. 29. On 12 May 2006 the applicant applied for discharge on compassionate grounds as a discharge at own request had been refused. The request for discharge on compassionate grounds was also refused. On 21 July 2006 the applicant applied for an invalidity benefit and discharge on medical grounds. On 19 August 2006 it was determined that the applicant’s naval service should be terminated on the basis that he was medically unfit. On 1 October 2006 the applicant was formally discharged, with a separation date of 2 October 2006.[3] [3] Exhibit A, T-documents, T31.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 26 of the Act provides that an ‘invalidity benefit’ is payable to a member of the scheme where they’ve retired on the grounds of invalidity or physical or mental incapacity. Section 30 of the Act sets out the process for determining the classification for the member’s incapacity:(1)Where a member of the scheme … is, or is about to become, entitled to invalidity benefit, CSC shall determine his percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment and shall classify him according to the percentage of incapacity as follows: There are no other matters prescribed for the purposes of s 30(2)(d). In Re Colin Robert Beattie and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [1993] AATA 79, DP Forgie outlined the proper approach to consideration of the same issue that arises in this case, and cited the following extract from Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House (1989) 91 ALR 286 at pages 289-290 relating to s 30(1A) of the Act (a provision which mirrors s 30(2)):"Sub-section (1A) requires consideration, not of employments the member has followed or would be likely to follow, but of the kinds of civil employment which a person with the skills, qualifications and experience identified in para (a) might reasonably undertake. The words `kinds', `might' and `reasonably' all indicate that a narrow view is not to be taken. As was made clear by Davies J, when sitting as president of the Tribunal in Re Thomson and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1987) 6 AAR 424 at 433-4, an individual is likely to have open to him a wide range of employment opportunities of various kinds. The sub-section does not narrowly scrutinise one example of the kinds of employment open in the particular circumstances. For example, if a man can operate a backhoe, it would be wrong to think of backhoe operation as the kind of employment open to him - it is rather a specific example of a kind of employment which includes the operation of post-hole diggers and a host of other pieces of equipment.It should also be observed that the primary question posed by para (b) is not what an employer might do, nor even what the particular member might do, but what a hypothetical person with the relevant skills qualifications and experience `might reasonably undertake'. Substituted expressions may tend to lose the peculiar force of the statutory language, which does not at all suggest that the absence of a particular licence, or the need of a particular refresher course, would constitute a barrier. People constantly undertake employments which require some degree of new learning or the obtaining of a new certificate or licence; to do so involves a small increment upon their existing skills, qualifications and experience. The statutory test is not whether the postulated person already has everything that is requisite, but whether a person with his skills, qualifications and experience might reasonably undertake the kind of employment in question. The extent to which in some way he might have to prepare himself bears on whether he might reasonably undertake the employment, which is the ultimate question under the paragraph, but the fact that he must do so does not debar him. It is a question of degree.One thing which is abundantly clear is that para (b) does not restrict a member to the employments in which he is now engaged in his impaired state. That would be to mock the statutory purpose, which is to find an objective criterion for the assessment of the extent of the impairment. The criterion is a broad one which relates to categories of employment and not to particular occupations. It is concerned with the range of occupations open to the person described, so that the effect of the disability may be measured against the opportunities that might have been open.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following issues are not disputed between the parties:a)the skills, qualifications and experience held by the applicant; andb)the nature of the applicant’s impairments.ACCEPTED EVIDENCE The evidence reflects that the applicant was educated to Year 12, and went on to obtain several Diplomas and Advanced Diplomas including:[5]a)Advanced Diploma in Mechanical Engineering; b)Advanced Diploma in Frontline Management; c)Advanced Diploma in Engineering in Marine Systems; d)Diploma of Engineering – Industrial Management; e)Graduate Diploma in Engineering Maintenance Management; and f)Fitter and Machinist Trade Certificate.[5] Exhibit A, T-Documents, T2 at p. 32. The parties do not dispute the content of the reviewable decision which outlines the applicant’s ‘retiring impairments’, or the impairments which rendered him unable to undertake the full range of duties required for his employment and caused him to receive an invalidity discharge. These are listed as:[6] i.Adjustment disorder with anxiety and depressed mood;ii.C6/7 disc prolapse with left CT nerve compression; iii.ACL rupture of the left knee with associated meniscal tears; iv.Chondral fissure medial formoral condyle;v.Ruptured anterior cruciate ligament of the right knee with tear of the medial meniscus; and vi.Medial and lateral compartment osteoarthritis.[6] Exhibit A, T-Documents, T2 at p. 36.APPLICANT SUBMISSIONSKinds of civil employment The applicant’s submissions reflect that his work experience is predominantly as a Marine Technical Sailor in the Navy. It was submitted that the kinds of civil employment that could be reasonably undertaken as outlined in the reviewable decision and relied upon by the respondent are incorrect. The applicant has argued that he has no professional training or experience as a ‘Marine transport professional’ or a ‘Mechanical engineer’. He submitted that he would need to obtain a relevant Bachelor degree (a Bachelor of Applied Science (Nautical Science) and a Bachelor of Applied Science (Marine Engineering) respectively) to be qualified to perform these jobs. He further argued that as all civilian shipping falls under the Navigation Act 2012, these employment types would require the applicant to hold the relevant degree as well as a certificate of medical fitness in accordance with Australian Maritime Safety Authority (“AMSA”) Marine Order 9. I note that since the time of the applicant’s submissions, Order 9 has been repealed and replaced by Order 76. When providing evidence at the hearing, the applicant confirmed that he knew of the requirements to be a mechanical engineer. He stated that he had determined that many civilian roles similar to his in the Navy required “a lot more training”. He stated that he had previously tried to make the change to becoming a mechanical engineer, but was not able to as it required a Bachelor in Engineering and registration as a professional engineer. However, the applicant also submitted that post-service he took a role working in a mechanical field, and to get this role he used his Advanced Diploma in Mechanical Engineering.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant has received benefits as a Class C member and there may have to be an adjustment made. I also had no submissions on this matter, but it is not part of my function on review to make a decision regarding any adjustment that may have to be made. In most cases where a reviewable decision has been set aside the applicant has sought review of the decision within the reviewable period and there would be no need to make an adjustment. This is a case where the respondent has quite properly granted an extension of time to the member to make an application to review the original decision. DECISION I set aside the decision made on 17 October 2006, as affirmed on 19 October 2015, to determine under s 30(1) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 the applicant’s percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment as Class C with effect from 2 October 2006. In substitution it is determined that Mr Seizovic’s incapacity in relation to civil employment is between 30% and 60%, and that he be classified as Class B with effect from 2 October 2006, being the day following his discharge from the Navy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent disputed the applicant’s reference to the application of the Navigation Act 2012 and the AMSA guidelines, as this material applies exclusively to seafaring roles and there is no evidence to suggest that the kinds of civil employment identified are exclusively seafaring roles. Further, they submitted that the AMSA guidelines are only intended to be used as a guide by medical practitioners when assessing fitness for sea, and are not to be taken as strict requirements to qualify for seafaring roles. The respondent noted that there has not been an opinion provided by a doctor on the application of the guidelines to the applicant.CONSIDERATIONKinds of civil employment Having regard to s 30(2)(a) of the Act, I have to consider the vocational, trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience of the applicant; and under s 30(2)(b) of the Act I have to consider the kinds of civil employment that the applicant could reasonably undertake. The applicant has contended that regard should be had to the qualifications which are now prescribed under the Navigation Act 2012, but in my view it would be an error to have regard to legislation that was passed some six years after the applicant was discharged in October 2006. I accept the evidence of the applicant that the kinds of civil employment that the applicant could reasonably undertake should not include the occupations of a mechanical engineer and a marine transport professional. The applicant gave cogent reasons concerning those occupations and his explanations were quite properly not challenged in cross-examination. To be a mechanical engineer or a marine transport professional the ABS criteria require a relevant tertiary qualification or 5 years applicable experience. While the applicant has a number of engineering diplomas, in giving evidence he explained that he did not qualify for professional registration and that he was unsuccessful in obtaining registration as a mechanical engineer. There is no evidence that the applicant has the applicable experience to qualify him to be a mechanical engineer and a marine transport professional. The respondent quite properly acknowledged that the applicant would have some difficulty in undertaking the heavy physical demands required of a marine transport professional. I have determined that the applicant could not reasonably undertake the duties of a training officer. In his evidence the applicant explained that he had experience of on the job training of crew. He has completed an instructor course, and has an advanced diploma in frontline management and five years’ experience in training submarine crews. However, the applicant had not undergone any training courses for a period of approximately four years at the time of his discharge. It is also important to appreciate that the applicant at the time of his discharge had medical restrictions such as no standing for more than one hour and to avoid repetitive upper limb activity. Having regard to this I do not think that he could reasonably undertake the duties of a training officer. At the time of his discharge he also had medical restrictions to avoid stress. Having regard to the retiring impairment of an adjustment disorder I have made an assessment that the stress experienced by the applicant at the time of his discharge would be an obstacle to him undertaking the duties of a training officer.