Walker and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 817

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N1999/1172

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      WAYNE WALKER
  Applicant
           And    DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT  AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr M J Sassella, Senior Member Commodore B G Gibbs AM RAN, Senior Member           

Date13 September 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is set aside and in substitution therefor the Tribunal decides: a) As of 11 January 1982, the Applicant's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment was 60 per cent or more, resulting in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act; and b) In accordance with section 34 of the Act, on and from 10 December 1982, the Applicant's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment was nil.

..............................................
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS – classification for invalidity benefits – incapacity in relation to civilian employment – physical or mental impairment at time of retirement.
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973, ss 30, 34, 37, 99
Cocks v Commissioner for Superannuation (1990) 21 ALD 297
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Britt (1984) 4 FCR 306
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House (1989) 22 FCR 138
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v O'Fee, unreported Federal Court, 6 June 1985
Freeman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1985) 5 AAR 156
Re Thomson and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1987) 6 AAR 424

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr M J Sassella Commodore B G Gibbs   

APPLICATION

  1. This is an application by Wayne Walker ("the Applicant") for review of a decision of the defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority ("the Respondent") dated 13 March 1998 in respect of Mr Walker's entitlement to invalidity benefit. That decision affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Respondent dated 22 April 1997 that the percentage of the Applicant's incapacity was ten per cent and that he be classified Class C in respect of his incapacity with effect from 12 January 1982.

  2. Mr Walker was represented at the hearing of his application by his wife, Mrs Lynne Walker, and the Respondent was represented by Mr Ron Whithear of counsel.

  3. On 12 August 1996 the Director General Personnel Support and Conditions – Army, in response to representations by the Applicant including those dated 13 December 1995 (Document AH/170), wrote to the Respondent (Document BS) stating that it had been determined under section 37 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 ("the Act") that the Applicant could have been discharged from the army medically unfit. He had in fact been discharged on 11 January 1982 "not suited to be a soldier".

  4. On 9 September 1996 the Assistant Chief of General Staff of the Army determined (Document CA) that at the time of the Applicant's discharge from the army, grounds existed on which he could have been retired on invalidity grounds.

  5. On 11 April…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Autho... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 817
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Walker and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority involved a dispute over the classification of the applicant's incapacity for invalidity benefits. The applicant, a former member of the Australian Defence Force, sought to have his incapacity reclassified in light of his alleged post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the applicant's incapacity had increased to the point where it warranted a higher classification for invalidity benefits.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant's incapacity had deteriorated to the extent that it warranted a higher classification for invalidity benefits. The court had to consider the medical evidence and the provisions of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the applicant's post-traumatic stress and depressive episodes had developed to the point where they constituted a significant impairment of his capacity for appropriate kinds of civil employment.

The court found that the applicant's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment, including trades assistant, service station attendant and labourer, was 60 per cent or more as of 11 January 1982. This resulted in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act. The court rejected the applicant's argument that his incapacity had increased to the point where it warranted a higher classification. The court found that the medical evidence strongly supported the proposition that the applicant had developed PTSD some time after 1982, but that this did not constitute a deterioration of his impairment from the time of his retirement. The court held that the applicant's incapacity had not increased to the extent that it warranted a higher classification for invalidity benefits.

The decision of the Defence Force Superannuation Tribunal was set aside and in its place the Federal Court decided that the applicant's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment, trades assistant, service station attendant and labourer, was 60 per cent or more as of 11 January 1982, resulting in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act. The applicant's application for a higher classification for invalidity benefits was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr Walker, a former member of the Defence Force, who sought benefits under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. Mr Walker claimed that he was entitled to Class A invalidity benefits, which are the highest category of benefits, due to his incapacity in relation to civilian employment. The primary issue is whether Mr Walker's incapacity was due to a physical or mental impairment present at the time of his retirement from the Defence Force. The medical evidence provided by Dr Davies and Dr Mason indicated that Mr Walker's depression and stress reaction were significant at the time of his retirement, with Dr Davies stating that Mr Walker could not work as a trades assistant, sales assistant, or labourer immediately after leaving the army due to acute disturbance. However, Dr Davies believed that Mr Walker could resume work after the acute disturbance period resolved, which was clearly over by September 1982. Dr Mason, on the other hand, initially recommended Mr Walker's discharge from the army in 1981, but later modified his views, considering that Mr Walker's strong desire to leave the army and the assault incident could have influenced his condition. Dr Mason assessed Mr Walker's capacity for civil employment, considering it minimally diminished for trades assistant or sales assistant roles, and moderately impaired for labourer or military trades assistant or sales assistant roles.

The case came before the court as an appeal against a decision made by the Tribunal under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. The Tribunal had previously decided that Mr Walker's incapacity did not warrant a Class A classification. The appeal was filed to challenge the Tribunal's decision and seek a reclassification of Mr Walker's incapacity to Class A. The court examined the evidence presented by Dr Davies and Dr Mason, focusing on the timing and nature of Mr Walker's impairments and their impact on his ability to engage in civilian employment. The appeal process involved reviewing the Tribunal's findings and the medical evidence to determine the correct classification of Mr Walker's incapacity.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Davies considered that Mr Walker's depression would have been greater soon after leaving the army than it later became. Dr Davies discussed Mr Walker's capacities to work as a trades assistant, sales assistant or labourer. He said that straight after the assault Mr Walker could do none of these. However, the period of acute disturbance would resolve and he could then resume work. Dr Davies considered that the period of acute disturbance lingered until Mr Walker's discharge and some time after. However, it was clearly over when he started work in September 1982.Dr Mason's evidence Mr Whithear then called Dr J W Mason, psychiatrist. Dr Mason had recommended in 1981 that the Applicant be discharged from the army (Documents J and K). On 11 January 1995 he wrote to the Applicant modifying his views compared to 1981. He said he had been impressed in 1981 by the Applicant's strong determination to leave the army and to find a means of achieving this. He understood how the assault incident could have made the Applicant more determined to leave. Had Mr Walker told him of the assault that would have added weight to Dr Mason's support for the Applicant to leave the service. Counselling could have been offered but counselling was not likely that late in the piece, and given the Applicant's desire to leave. Dr Mason also wrote a report dated 4 January 2000 (Exhibit R1). He regretted offering the opinions in Documents J and K in 1981 without knowing of the Applicant's sexual assault and his previous good record of work and social competence. He said that he would have attempted to commence treatment for the Applicant's stress reaction had he known the full facts, however he doubted that the Applicant would have been interested, so great was his desire to separate from the army. As regards Mr Walker's post-service employability, Dr Mason considered that Mr Walker's relief at being able to leave the army would have been so great immediately after separation that his civil employment possibilities would not have been restricted at all. They would have become more restricted later as his post-traumatic stress and depressive episodes developed. He assessed the extent to which the Applicant's retirement impairment had diminished his capacity as at 12 January 1982. Mr Walker's capacity was minimally diminished (less than ten per cent) for civil employment as trades assistant or sales assistant. His capacity was moderately impaired (30 per cent to 60 per cent) for work as a labourer or as a military trades assistant or sales assistant. In examination in chief Dr Mason said that he would regard the Applicant's capacity for civil labouring work as only minimally diminished if he made no allowance for his view that the Applicant might regard such work as demeaning in that it would not require him to use his developed skills. In his oral evidence Dr Mason enlarged on his diagnosis in his report of 4 January 2000 of a stress reaction. He was invited by counsel to compare or link that diagnosis with PTSD, a condition the Applicant considers he has. Dr Mason said the two conditions generate similar symptoms but that they are much more acute with PTSD. PTSD was said to come on later as the affected person is unable to adjust or accept or come to terms with what has occurred.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It might therefore seem that Mr Walker should be assessed as having a Class A incapacity from 12 January 1982 until 9 December 1982 and then again from a date in 1995 until the present. However, this would involve applying section 34 of the Act. In order to reclassify Mr Walker in 1995 the impairment that would have to have deteriorated would, on the basis of the Tribunal's earlier finding, be adjustment disorder, the impairment that caused his retirement. The medical evidence strongly supports the proposition that Mr Walker developed PTSD some time after 1982. The classification cannot therefore be reviewed and raised to Class A in 1995.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and in substitution therefor the Tribunal decides:a) As of 11 January 1982, the Applicant's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment, trades assistant (mechanic), service station attendant and labourer, was 60 per cent or more, resulting in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence regarding Mr Walker's incapacity in relation to civilian employment at the time of his retirement from the Defence Force. Dr Davies, a medical expert, testified that Mr Walker's depression would have been greater soon after leaving the army than it later became. He discussed Mr Walker's capacities to work as a trades assistant, sales assistant, or labourer, noting that Mr Walker could do none of these immediately after the assault. However, Dr Davies considered that the period of acute disturbance would resolve and Mr Walker could then resume work. The court noted that the period of acute disturbance lingered until Mr Walker's discharge and some time after, but it was clearly over when he started work in September 1982. Dr Mason, another medical expert, testified that Mr Walker's capacity was minimally diminished for civil employment as a trades assistant or sales assistant, but moderately impaired for work as a labourer or as a military trades assistant or sales assistant. The court considered Dr Mason's assessment that Mr Walker's capacity for civil labouring work would be minimally diminished if his view that such work would be demeaning was taken into account.

The court then turned to the issue of the correct classification of Mr Walker's incapacity under section 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. The court noted that section 30 of the Act provides for a Class A classification where the incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment is 60 per cent or more. The court found that the evidence supported a finding that Mr Walker's incapacity was 60 per cent or more as of 11 January 1982, resulting in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act.

Finally, the court considered whether the Tribunal's decision should be set aside and a Class A classification granted to Mr Walker. The court noted that the medical evidence strongly supported the proposition that Mr Walker developed post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) some time after 1982, but that this could not be used to reclassify Mr Walker in 1995. The court concluded that the decision under review should be set aside and in substitution therefor the Tribunal should decide that as of 11 January 1982, Mr Walker's incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment was 60 per cent or more, resulting in a Class A classification under section 30 of the Act. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a Class A classification under section 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 is appropriate where the incapacity in relation to appropriate kinds of civil employment is 60 per cent or more.