CQS18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

CQS18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 25

File number(s): MLG 1405 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 16 January 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application for judicial review – decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – citizens of Sri Lanka – refusal of Safe Haven Enterprise visa – whether constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction – whether proper formation of required state of satisfaction – whether illogicality or lack of an intelligible justification – whether denial of procedural fairness in failing to consider a claim or substantial argument – whether material jurisdictional error
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36, 46A, 65, 414, 474, 476
Cases cited:

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

ARG15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 174; (2016) 250 FCR 109; (2016) 154 ALD 221

AVJ17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1056

BVD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCA 34; (2019) 268 CLR 29; (2019) 93 ALJR 1091; (2019) 373 ALR 196

BYX17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 41

Calvey v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 104

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 107; (2017) 252 FCR 352; (2017) 347 ALR 173

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; (2018) 258 FCR 175; (2018) 74 AAR 121; (2018) 353 ALR 641

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321

ETA067 v Republic of Nauru [2018] HCA 46; (2018) 92 ALJR 1003; (2018) 360 ALR 228

EVA17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 214; (2018) 262 FCR 304

Htun v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1802; (2001) 233 FCR 136; (2001) 194 ALR 244

Ibrahim v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [2000] FCA 1309; (2000) 63 ALD 37

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610

Ludgero v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCCA 1060; (2021) 358 FLR 215

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v MZYTS [2013] FCAFC 114; (2013) 230 FCR 431; (2013) 136 ALD 547

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11; (2016) 237 FCR 1; (2016) 329 ALR 491

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421; (2019) 93 ALJR 252; (2019) 75 AAR 75; (2019) 363 ALR 599

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSRS [2014] FCAFC 16;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CQS18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of CQS18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involves a judicial review application brought by CQS18, a Sri Lankan national, challenging the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) to affirm a decision of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs to refuse him a Safe Haven Enterprise (SHE) Visa. The primary legal issues before the court were whether there was a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction, whether the Tribunal properly formed the required state of satisfaction, whether the decision was illogical or lacked an intelligible justification, whether there was a denial of procedural fairness in failing to consider a claim or substantial argument, and whether there was a material jurisdictional error.

The court found that while the Tribunal had made some errors in its consideration of country information, these errors were not material to the outcome. The Tribunal had correctly identified that CQS18 was released from detention without charge and was not further arrested or mistreated, which was a significant factor in concluding that he did not have an adverse profile. The court also noted that even if the Tribunal had found that CQS18 could have left Sri Lanka without being stopped, this conclusion was equivocal and did not disprove the primary finding that he was not of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities.

The court further held that the Tribunal had not failed to consider CQS18's claims or substantial arguments, and there was no denial of procedural fairness. The Tribunal's decision was not illogical or lacking an intelligible justification, and there was no material jurisdictional error.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the judicial review application, affirming the Tribunal's decision to refuse CQS18 a SHE Visa. The court found that CQS18 had not discharged the onus of showing that, had the Tribunal not made an error, there was a realistic possibility that the decision could have been different.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At hearing the Court Book (“CB”) was marked as Exhibit 1.BACKGROUND The relevant background facts are as follows:(a)CQS18 is a Sri Lankan national: CB 5, 9 and 58;(b)CQS18 arrived in Australia on 28 June 2012: CB 73;(c)following earlier administrative and judicial processes (the outcomes of which were mainly adverse to CQS18: see CB 257 and 261-262; WZATI v Minister for Immigration [2014] FCCA 2750 (“WZATI – FCCA”) and WZATI v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 923 (“WZATI – FCA Appeal”)), on 13 April 2016 the Minister lifted the bar in s 46A of the Migration Act allowing CQS18 to lodge a further protection visa application: CB 443;(d)on 23 September 2016 CQS18 applied for the SHE Visa;(e)on 16 February 2017 CQS18 attended an interview with a delegate of the Minister’s Department (“Delegate Interview”), and provided post interview submissions to the Delegate on 28 February 2017 (“CQS18’s Delegate Submissions”): CB 414 and 446;(f)on 10 April 2017 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant CQS18 a SHE Visa: CB 437-460;(g)on 13 April 2017 CQS18 applied to the Tribunal for review of the Delegate’s Decision: CB 461-468;(h)on 20 July 2017 CQS18 provided submissions dated 20 July 2017 the Tribunal (“CQS18’s Tribunal Submissions”): CB 495-502;(i)on 3 August 2017 CQS18 attended an almost four-hour Tribunal hearing by videolink with his representative and with the assistance of a Tamil interpreter: CB 520-523;(j)on 16 August 2017 CQS18’s representative made a written request for an extension of time to provide further submissions to the Tribunal: CB 527, and an extension having been granted: CB 529, on 4 September 2017 provided the further submissions to the Tribunal: CB 532-538;(k)on 19 April 2018 the Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to refuse to grant CQS18 a SHE Visa: CB 542-586; (l)on 22 May 2018 CQS18 filed a judicial review application in the Melbourne Registry of this Court (then styled the Federal Circuit Court of Australia); (m)on 14 June 2022 a Registrar of the Court made orders that the proceedings be transferred to the Perth Registry of the Court and that the judicial review application be listed for final hearing; and(n)on 8 February 2023 CQS18 filed the Amended Judicial Review Application.TRIBUNAL DECISION In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal commenced by setting out the:(a)background to the application for review: CB 543 at [1]-[7];(b)criteria for a SHE Visa: CB 543-544 at [8]-[13]; and(c)mandatory considerations the Tribunal needed to take into account: CB 544 at [14]. In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal then summarised CQS18’s claims and evidence at CB 545-550 at [17], including the following:(a)he left Sri Lanka because he fears he will be attacked or killed due to his previous involvement with the LTTE;(b)he had worked for the LTTE from 1994-1997 whilst he was employed at a shop and he did not think he had any choice but to do these things for the LTTE and almost everyone in the Vanni region supported the LTTE. He feared that if he refused them they would accuse him of giving secrets to the Sri Lankan Army (“SLA”) and execute him;(c)the LTTE had occupied CQT18’s (CQT18 is CQS18’s wife) family farm and CQS18 had no choice but to allow the LTTE to occupy this land;(d)in 2002 CQS18 and his family moved to Jaffna due to concerns about safety and for improved job opportunities. In their visits to CQT18’s family CQS18 would sometimes speak with LTTE people and the LTTE knew he was living in Jaffna and asked him to work for them there. CQS18 did not, however, work for the LTTE in Jaffna;(e)the SLA had been monitoring all persons who had relocated from CQS18’s hometown to Jaffna and so the SLA knew who CQS18 was and has a video of CQS18 participating in a protest (“Protest Video”) held in Jaffna;(f)CQS18 was arrested by the Criminal Investigation Department (“CID”) in Colombo when he visited there to apply for a visa to enter the United Kingdom where he hoped to go for work. CQS18 was arrested together with three of his friends by the CID who suspected him of being a supporter of the LTTE, even though the local police did not. The CID was suspicious of CQS18’s visit to an area in Colombo and assumed he was part of the LTTE because he was from the Vanni and that he was in Colombo to be involved in LTTE activities;(g)CQS18 was beaten by CID officers whilst detained and not given food or water and CID officers wanted him to sign a paper declaring that he was part of the LTTE. When CQS18 refused they continued to beat him and he feared that if he signed the paper he would be interrogated on the notorious 4th Floor of the CID building and would not return. CID released CQS18 only after taking his fingerprints and signature and after this incident CID visited him in his house in Colombo three times in week following a bomb blast a short distance away;(h)in 2007 CQS18 was asked by the SLA to give them his motorbike and he refused. A friend of CQS18 also refused to give the SLA his (the friend’s own) motorbike and a few days later the friend was killed. CQS18 knows of about four people this happened to and he was worried the same would happen to him so he gave his motorbike to the SLA for 15 days. The SLA knew CQS18’s brother is a mechanic and so they went to CQS18’s brother to tell him that CQS18 must give them his motorbike. His brother lied to the SLA that CQS18 had sold the motorbike but the SLA did not believe him and said if CQS18 would not give them his motor bike they would kill him. So CQS18 gave the SLA his motorbike for a second time. CQS18 no longer owns the motorbike;(i)in June and July of 2008, within a one month period, three of CQS18’s friends were killed by the SLA which accused them of being LTTE supporters, and anyone who supported the LTTE in 2006 and before was killed;(j)in 2008 LTTE members left CQT18’S family’s property but left behind approximately four sea containers full of weapons which the SLA discovered and linked the title of the farm to CQT18’s mother. SLA questioned CQT18’s mother about the ownership of the property and who permitted LTTE to use the property and she told the SLA that CQS18 and CQT18 own the farm but that they were in India (but they were in Jaffna). The CID returned to CQT18’s mother’s home twice looking for CQS18 and he feared the SLA would execute him for permitting the LTTE to use the land;(k)in mid-2008 a close friend of CQS18’s aunt who had worked for the Eelam People’s Democratic Party (“EPDP”) told CQS18 that the CID has the Protest Video and that it was not safe for him to stay in Jaffna. Despite there being many people at the protest there were only three or four people burning tyres and after hearing this warning CQS18 was very afraid as the Jaffna is a small place and it would be difficult to escape the CID easily, and CQS18 knew that other people that were helping the LTTE had already been killed;(l)CQS18 obtained a clearance certificate to leave Jaffna, obtaining this at an office where he was not known and where they did not suspect him of being an LTTE supporter. The office for the clearance certificate is separate from the CID and the SLA and they were aware that CQT18 and the children would remain. At the time they did not have a system of sharing information. After CQS18 left for Colombo the SLA did not believe CQS18 was in Colombo and asked CQT18 and CQS18’s brother about his whereabouts and what happened to his motorbike. The SLA told CQT18 that CQS18 had “narrowly escaped”;(m)in Colombo CQS18 did not report to the police but hid at a friend’s house whilst an agent assisted him to get a passport and visa and for safe exit through the airport. The agent knew CQS18 was in hiding and in Colombo without permission. CQS18 paid the agent 250,000 rupees. In India CQS18 stayed in hiding in Chennai as he was afraid of being identified as an LTTE supporter; he later brought CQT18 and the children to India because they were afraid to remain in Sri Lanka after the SLA questioned CQT18 about CQS18. CQT18’s aunt helped them leave. When CQS18 registered their names in Chennai he said he had not had involvement with the LTTE and that they had been displaced from Sri Lanka because of the war;(n)CQS18 left India because there was no future for his family there and they had no status and lived as refugees. He had also heard that the Indian government was sending Sri Lankans back and he was afraid he would be deported back to Sri Lanka;(o)as to the impact of the data breach described in the Data Breach Letter CQS18 had kept his whereabouts a secret, telling only his parents and some of his siblings and because of the data breach Sri Lankan authorities and others will now know he is in Australia. This has made things worse for CQS18 because the authorities will know he has asked for asylum in Australia and the Sri Lankan government will assume CQS18 is criticising it;(p)CQS18 is unable to rely on the Sri Lankan government for protection because it is the Sri Lankan authorities including the SLA he fears persecution from;(q)CQS18 has been absent from Sri Lanka for a number years and if he was to return he would be considered a terrorist because he is perceived as being an LTTE member. The SLA is looking for him in his hometown and if he returns to Sri Lanka the SLA could find him wherever he goes in Sri Lanka. His fingerprints and personal details are in the CID system. If CQS18 returns to the larger city in Sri Lanka he fears the EPDP will kill him for being an LTTE supporter and the EPDP could find him wherever he goes in Sri Lanka;(r)CQS18’s brothers still live in Sri Lanka. They do not have problems with the SLA or the CID but if CQS18 were to live with them, they would also be at risk of harm for supporting him;(s)in the north of Sri Lanka, there is still one SLA personnel to every four Tamil citizens and CQS18 fears the CID will listen into telephone calls and this will cause problems for people such as his brothers;(t)CQS18 reads in Tamil newspapers that the Tamil people are unhappy that the government are not looking after their interests after the war, and unrest is starting to build;(u)CQS18 has previously stated that he was not involved with the LTTE, and that it was his brother who was involved but he said this because he was scared. He was interviewed when he had only been in Australia for five days and his only contact with government people before that was in Sri Lanka where the SLA and CID killed people for being involved with the LTTE. As this was all he knew, he did not know what the Australian government would do to him if they knew he worked for the LTTE so he said that he did not and he was worried that they would think he was a terrorist if he admitted to involvement with the LTTE;(v)in relation to his earlier protection visa application (as to which see WZATI – FCCA and WZATI – FCA Appeal): (i)CQS18 only met the lawyer providing legal assistance once at the start and then only on the phone and CQS18 did not know if the lawyers were with the Department or private lawyers; and(ii)at the then Refugee Review Tribunal CQS18 could not say anything new and he thought his protection visa would be refused if he said he was involved with the LTTE; and(w)CQS18 is still very scared to be admitting to his involvement with the LTTE as he is still afraid that the Sri Lankan Government will find out about that involvement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant background facts are as follows:(a)CQS18 is a Sri Lankan national: CB 5, 9 and 58;(b)CQS18 arrived in Australia on 28 June 2012: CB 73;(c)following earlier administrative and judicial processes (the outcomes of which were mainly adverse to CQS18: see CB 257 and 261-262; WZATI v Minister for Immigration [2014] FCCA 2750 (“WZATI – FCCA”) and WZATI v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 923 (“WZATI – FCA Appeal”)), on 13 April 2016 the Minister lifted the bar in s 46A of the Migration Act allowing CQS18 to lodge a further protection visa application: CB 443;(d)on 23 September 2016 CQS18 applied for the SHE Visa;(e)on 16 February 2017 CQS18 attended an interview with a delegate of the Minister’s Department (“Delegate Interview”), and provided post interview submissions to the Delegate on 28 February 2017 (“CQS18’s Delegate Submissions”): CB 414 and 446;(f)on 10 April 2017 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant CQS18 a SHE Visa: CB 437-460;(g)on 13 April 2017 CQS18 applied to the Tribunal for review of the Delegate’s Decision: CB 461-468;(h)on 20 July 2017 CQS18 provided submissions dated 20 July 2017 the Tribunal (“CQS18’s Tribunal Submissions”): CB 495-502;(i)on 3 August 2017 CQS18 attended an almost four-hour Tribunal hearing by videolink with his representative and with the assistance of a Tamil interpreter: CB 520-523;(j)on 16 August 2017 CQS18’s representative made a written request for an extension of time to provide further submissions to the Tribunal: CB 527, and an extension having been granted: CB 529, on 4 September 2017 provided the further submissions to the Tribunal: CB 532-538;(k)on 19 April 2018 the Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to refuse to grant CQS18 a SHE Visa: CB 542-586; (l)on 22 May 2018 CQS18 filed a judicial review application in the Melbourne Registry of this Court (then styled the Federal Circuit Court of Australia); (m)on 14 June 2022 a Registrar of the Court made orders that the proceedings be transferred to the Perth Registry of the Court and that the judicial review application be listed for final hearing; and(n)on 8 February 2023 CQS18 filed the Amended Judicial Review Application.TRIBUNAL DECISION In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal commenced by setting out the:(a)background to the application for review: CB 543 at [1]-[7];(b)criteria for a SHE Visa: CB 543-544 at [8]-[13]; and(c)mandatory considerations the Tribunal needed to take into account: CB 544 at [14]. In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal then summarised CQS18’s claims and evidence at CB 545-550 at [17], including the following:(a)he left Sri Lanka because he fears he will be attacked or killed due to his previous involvement with the LTTE;(b)he had worked for the LTTE from 1994-1997 whilst he was employed at a shop and he did not think he had any choice but to do these things for the LTTE and almost everyone in the Vanni region supported the LTTE. He feared that if he refused them they would accuse him of giving secrets to the Sri Lankan Army (“SLA”) and execute him;(c)the LTTE had occupied CQT18’s (CQT18 is CQS18’s wife) family farm and CQS18 had no choice but to allow the LTTE to occupy this land;(d)in 2002 CQS18 and his family moved to Jaffna due to concerns about safety and for improved job opportunities. In their visits to CQT18’s family CQS18 would sometimes speak with LTTE people and the LTTE knew he was living in Jaffna and asked him to work for them there. CQS18 did not, however, work for the LTTE in Jaffna;(e)the SLA had been monitoring all persons who had relocated from CQS18’s hometown to Jaffna and so the SLA knew who CQS18 was and has a video of CQS18 participating in a protest (“Protest Video”) held in Jaffna;(f)CQS18 was arrested by the Criminal Investigation Department (“CID”) in Colombo when he visited there to apply for a visa to enter the United Kingdom where he hoped to go for work. CQS18 was arrested together with three of his friends by the CID who suspected him of being a supporter of the LTTE, even though the local police did not. The CID was suspicious of CQS18’s visit to an area in Colombo and assumed he was part of the LTTE because he was from the Vanni and that he was in Colombo to be involved in LTTE activities;(g)CQS18 was beaten by CID officers whilst detained and not given food or water and CID officers wanted him to sign a paper declaring that he was part of the LTTE. When CQS18 refused they continued to beat him and he feared that if he signed the paper he would be interrogated on the notorious 4th Floor of the CID building and would not return. CID released CQS18 only after taking his fingerprints and signature and after this incident CID visited him in his house in Colombo three times in week following a bomb blast a short distance away;(h)in 2007 CQS18 was asked by the SLA to give them his motorbike and he refused. A friend of CQS18 also refused to give the SLA his (the friend’s own) motorbike and a few days later the friend was killed. CQS18 knows of about four people this happened to and he was worried the same would happen to him so he gave his motorbike to the SLA for 15 days. The SLA knew CQS18’s brother is a mechanic and so they went to CQS18’s brother to tell him that CQS18 must give them his motorbike. His brother lied to the SLA that CQS18 had sold the motorbike but the SLA did not believe him and said if CQS18 would not give them his motor bike they would kill him. So CQS18 gave the SLA his motorbike for a second time. CQS18 no longer owns the motorbike;(i)in June and July of 2008, within a one month period, three of CQS18’s friends were killed by the SLA which accused them of being LTTE supporters, and anyone who supported the LTTE in 2006 and before was killed;(j)in 2008 LTTE members left CQT18’S family’s property but left behind approximately four sea containers full of weapons which the SLA discovered and linked the title of the farm to CQT18’s mother. SLA questioned CQT18’s mother about the ownership of the property and who permitted LTTE to use the property and she told the SLA that CQS18 and CQT18 own the farm but that they were in India (but they were in Jaffna). The CID returned to CQT18’s mother’s home twice looking for CQS18 and he feared the SLA would execute him for permitting the LTTE to use the land;(k)in mid-2008 a close friend of CQS18’s aunt who had worked for the Eelam People’s Democratic Party (“EPDP”) told CQS18 that the CID has the Protest Video and that it was not safe for him to stay in Jaffna. Despite there being many people at the protest there were only three or four people burning tyres and after hearing this warning CQS18 was very afraid as the Jaffna is a small place and it would be difficult to escape the CID easily, and CQS18 knew that other people that were helping the LTTE had already been killed;(l)CQS18 obtained a clearance certificate to leave Jaffna, obtaining this at an office where he was not known and where they did not suspect him of being an LTTE supporter. The office for the clearance certificate is separate from the CID and the SLA and they were aware that CQT18 and the children would remain. At the time they did not have a system of sharing information. After CQS18 left for Colombo the SLA did not believe CQS18 was in Colombo and asked CQT18 and CQS18’s brother about his whereabouts and what happened to his motorbike. The SLA told CQT18 that CQS18 had “narrowly escaped”;(m)in Colombo CQS18 did not report to the police but hid at a friend’s house whilst an agent assisted him to get a passport and visa and for safe exit through the airport. The agent knew CQS18 was in hiding and in Colombo without permission. CQS18 paid the agent 250,000 rupees. In India CQS18 stayed in hiding in Chennai as he was afraid of being identified as an LTTE supporter; he later brought CQT18 and the children to India because they were afraid to remain in Sri Lanka after the SLA questioned CQT18 about CQS18. CQT18’s aunt helped them leave. When CQS18 registered their names in Chennai he said he had not had involvement with the LTTE and that they had been displaced from Sri Lanka because of the war;(n)CQS18 left India because there was no future for his family there and they had no status and lived as refugees. He had also heard that the Indian government was sending Sri Lankans back and he was afraid he would be deported back to Sri Lanka;(o)as to the impact of the data breach described in the Data Breach Letter CQS18 had kept his whereabouts a secret, telling only his parents and some of his siblings and because of the data breach Sri Lankan authorities and others will now know he is in Australia. This has made things worse for CQS18 because the authorities will know he has asked for asylum in Australia and the Sri Lankan government will assume CQS18 is criticising it;(p)CQS18 is unable to rely on the Sri Lankan government for protection because it is the Sri Lankan authorities including the SLA he fears persecution from;(q)CQS18 has been absent from Sri Lanka for a number years and if he was to return he would be considered a terrorist because he is perceived as being an LTTE member. The SLA is looking for him in his hometown and if he returns to Sri Lanka the SLA could find him wherever he goes in Sri Lanka. His fingerprints and personal details are in the CID system. If CQS18 returns to the larger city in Sri Lanka he fears the EPDP will kill him for being an LTTE supporter and the EPDP could find him wherever he goes in Sri Lanka;(r)CQS18’s brothers still live in Sri Lanka. They do not have problems with the SLA or the CID but if CQS18 were to live with them, they would also be at risk of harm for supporting him;(s)in the north of Sri Lanka, there is still one SLA personnel to every four Tamil citizens and CQS18 fears the CID will listen into telephone calls and this will cause problems for people such as his brothers;(t)CQS18 reads in Tamil newspapers that the Tamil people are unhappy that the government are not looking after their interests after the war, and unrest is starting to build;(u)CQS18 has previously stated that he was not involved with the LTTE, and that it was his brother who was involved but he said this because he was scared. He was interviewed when he had only been in Australia for five days and his only contact with government people before that was in Sri Lanka where the SLA and CID killed people for being involved with the LTTE. As this was all he knew, he did not know what the Australian government would do to him if they knew he worked for the LTTE so he said that he did not and he was worried that they would think he was a terrorist if he admitted to involvement with the LTTE;(v)in relation to his earlier protection visa application (as to which see WZATI – FCCA and WZATI – FCA Appeal): (i)CQS18 only met the lawyer providing legal assistance once at the start and then only on the phone and CQS18 did not know if the lawyers were with the Department or private lawyers; and(ii)at the then Refugee Review Tribunal CQS18 could not say anything new and he thought his protection visa would be refused if he said he was involved with the LTTE; and(w)CQS18 is still very scared to be admitting to his involvement with the LTTE as he is still afraid that the Sri Lankan Government will find out about that involvement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to materiality, the Minister submitted that:(a)even if the Tribunal had erred in the way it treated the country information supplied by CQS18, this error was not material, for two reasons;(i)first, that CQS18 was able to leave Sri Lanka without coming to the attention of the Sri Lankan authorities was an additional reason why the Tribunal concluded CQS18 did not have an adverse profile. So much is apparent from the language used in CB 563 at [73]. The primary reason was that CQS18 had been released from CID detention without charge and was not further arrested or mistreated: CB 563 at [72];(ii)second, as explained above, even if the Tribunal had found, on the basis of the country information, that CQS18 could have left Sri Lanka without being stopped even if he were a person of interest, this conclusion was at best equivocal. It could not have disproved the Tribunal’s primary conclusion that CQS18 was not of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities because he had been released from CID detention in 2007, due to the fact that the Sri Lankan authorities were satisfied he had no links to the LTTE;(b)therefore, CQS18 has not discharged the onus of showing that, had the Tribunal not made an error, there was a realistic possibility that the decision in fact made could have been different: MZAPC at [2] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ; Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421; (2019) 93 ALJR 252; (2019) 75 AAR 75; (2019) 363 ALR 599 at [45]-[46] per Bell, Gageler and Keane JJ. CONSIDERATION OF THE AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONSome findings made by the Tribunal In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal:(a)at CB 550 at [19] notes that in CQS18’s Tribunal Submissions the country information “contains information on passport and exit processes in Sri Lanka” but says nothing further there as to the “exit processes”; (b)says it had regard to the 2017 DFAT Report and the UNHCR 2012 Guidelines to conclude that CQS18 did not have an anti-government or pro-LTTE profile that would bring him to the attention of the Sri Lankan authorities, or the EPDP: CB 557 at [43] and 558 at [47], 560 at [57] and 562 at [65] and [68]; and(c)in considering CQS18’s profile had regard to the fact that he was released without charge, and not arrested or mistreated again, and that it was implausible that the CID would have released CQS18 had it had “ongoing suspicions” that CQS18 “had any connection to the LTTE or a pro-LTTE profile”, and found that CQS18 was released from CID detention “because the authorities were satisfied he had no links to the LTTE”: CB 563 at [72], and in this regard took into account: (i)that CQS18 left Sri Lanka legally under a passport in his own name without difficulty: CB 563 at [73]; and(ii)CQS18’s Tribunal Submissions “that exit processes were lax at that time”, but goes on to note the existence of the DIE Database and that it “contained specific information about individuals suspected of terrorist activity by the … [SIS] … as well as information from … the … [SIS]”: CB 563 at [74],before concluding at CB 563-564 at [75] (emphasis added) that:On the evidence before it, the Tribunal does not accept the applicant had an actual or imputed LTTE or anti-government profile. The Tribunal finds the applicant was of no interest to the Sri Lankan authorities for any reason.