Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd ACN 102 611 423 [2008] FCA 1533

Workplace Relations Act 1996
Workplace Relations Amendment (Work Choices) Act 2005
Retail, Wholesale and Distributive Employees (NT) Award 2000
Workplace Relations Regulations 2006
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth)

Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8; 165 FCR 560
Gibbs v City of Altona (1992) 37 FCR 216
Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan [2008] FCAFC 70
Ponzio v B & P Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd (2007) 158 FCR 543; [2007] FCAFC 65
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (1997) 145 ALR 36
The Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Limited (2001) 108 IR 228

SHARON MAREE BLANDY v COVERDALE NT PTY LTD (ACN 102 611 423)

NTD 14 OF 2007

REEVES J
15 OCTOBER 2008

DARWIN


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

NTD 14 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

SHARON MAREE BLANDY
Applicant

AND:

COVERDALE NT PTY LTD (ACN 102 611 423)
Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 OCTOBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

DARWIN

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Coverdale be penalised the amount of $45,000.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

NTD 14 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

SHARON MAREE BLANDY
Applicant

AND:

COVERDALE NT PTY LTD (ACN 102 611 423)
Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE:

15 OCTOBER 2008

PLACE:

DARWIN

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. Coverdale NT Pty Ltd (‘Coverdale’) owns and operates an Eagle Boys pizza store and four Subway stores at various locations in Darwin in the Northern Territory.  Between mid 2005 and mid 2007, it failed to pay six of its employees their various entitlements under the applicable industrial Award. 

  2. Sometime after these proceedings were issued on 9 August 2007, after initially refusing to accept responsibility, Coverdale reversed that position and paid the employees the underpaid amounts plus interest.  Accordingly, the sole issue remaining for determination in this application is the appropriate penalty to be applied for Coverdale’s breaches of the applicable industrial Award. 

  3. Five of the employees involved in these proceedings were young, ranging in age from 14 to 18 years. Coverdale’s excuse for not paying them their proper Award entitlements was that they were all covered by Australian Workplace Agreements (AWA). Five of the six employees either denied ever signing an AWA, or could not recall having done so. When challenged to produce the duly signed AWAs, Coverdale was only able to produce one and even that one was not properly witnessed. This, and other of Coverdale’s conduct detailed in these reasons, explains why I have decided to apply a significant penalty to Coverdale for its breaches.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  4. Ms Sharon Maree Blandy, the applicant in these proceedings, is the State Director of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1533
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd, Sharon Maree Blandy, the State Director of the Northern Territory Office of the Workplace Ombudsman, brought proceedings against Coverdale NT Pty Ltd for underpaying its employees' wages. The dispute involved six employees, aged between 14 and 18, who were allegedly underpaid their minimum hourly rates, overtime, and other allowances as stipulated by the Award. The employees either denied signing Australian Workplace Agreements (AWAs) or could not recall doing so, and Coverdale could only produce one improperly witnessed AWA.

The court had to decide the appropriate penalty for Coverdale's breaches of the Workplace Relations Act 1996. The legal issues included the nature and extent of the conduct, the circumstances of the breaches, and whether they were deliberate. The court considered the non-exhaustive list of considerations for determining penalties, such as the nature and extent of the conduct, the circumstances, and the need for deterrence.

The court found Coverdale's conduct to be a significant period of continual breaches, with the underpayments amounting to a significant proportion of the total actual wages paid to the employees. The court assessed the appropriate penalty for each breach and applied the totality principle to determine the aggregate total penalty. After considering the factors presented by both parties, the court decided on a penalty of $45,000 for Coverdale's breaches.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Coverdale be penalised the amount of $45,000.

Background

Background to the litigation

Five of the employees involved in these proceedings were young, ranging in age from 14 to 18 years. Coverdale’s excuse for not paying them their proper Award entitlements was that they were all covered by Australian Workplace Agreements (AWA). Five of the six employees either denied ever signing an AWA, or could not recall having done so. When challenged to produce the duly signed AWAs, Coverdale was only able to produce one and even that one was not properly witnessed. This, and other of Coverdale’s conduct detailed in these reasons, explains why I have decided to apply a significant penalty to Coverdale for its breaches.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Ms Sharon Maree Blandy, the applicant in these proceedings, is the State Director of the Northern Territory Office of the Workplace Ombudsman, previously known as the Office of Workplace Services. Ms Blandy was also an inspector appointed by the Minister pursuant to s 84(2) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (‘the pervious WR Act’); and is a workplace inspector appointed by the Workplace Ombudsman pursuant to s 167(2) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 as amended by the Workplace Relations Amendment (Work Choices) Act 2005 (‘the Work Choices Act’). As a workplace inspector, Ms Blandy is able to bring these proceedings (see [14] below). Mr Rodney Coverdale and Mrs Rita Coverdale are both directors of Coverdale and during the period to which these proceedings relate they both worked fulltime in Coverdale’s Casuarina Subway store. Mr Coverdale attended to most of the paperwork for Coverdale’s various stores and was responsible for making up and paying the wages of all its employees. In February 2006, Ms Blandy’s office began an investigation into various complaints that it had received that Coverdale had underpaid the wages of certain of its employees. The employees involved in those complaints were Ms Bourke, Ms Rety and Ms Davis. About three months after that investigation began, Mr Coverdale was asked to pay the underpayments. He initially stated he was uncertain whether he would and then, about a week later (in early June 2006), he stated that he had no intention of paying them. As a part of the investigation, Mr Coverdale was interviewed by Ms Lyn Grevsmuhl, a workplace inspector, on 9 November 2006. That interview was recorded and a transcript was subsequently prepared. In about September 2007, Ms Blandy’s office received a further series of complaints that Coverdale had underpaid the wages of another group of employees. Those complaints involved Ms McGough, Mr Maker and Mr Carcoba. They were each interviewed by Mr Paul O’Brien, a workplace inspector, and Mr O’Brien then conducted an interview with Mr Coverdale on 30 October 2007. That interview was also recorded and a transcript was subsequently prepared. These proceedings were issued on 9 August 2007. In late January 2008, Coverdale’s solicitors indicated to Ms Blandy’s solicitors that it wished to admit the breaches and pay the employees the underpayments plus interest. Accordingly, on or about 8 April 2008, Coverdale’s solicitors provided cheques payable to each of the six employees for the amounts of the underpayments due to them plus interest. At the same time, Coverdale submitted letters of apology addressed to each employee. The parties then prepared and filed an agreed statement of facts. At the hearing before me on 10 June 2008, the parties tendered that agreed statement of facts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

REEVES J
Coverdale has put before me a large number of comparable cases and sought to draw support from them in relation to the penalty that should be applied in this case. As Gray J made clear in McAlray-Smith (at [12]): “This [is] a fundamentally wrong approach. Penalties are not a matter of precedent. The choice of penalty must be dictated by the individual circumstances of a case, not by a line by line comparison with another case.”: see also Buchanan J at [87] and the case referred to: NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285 at 295, per Burchett and Kiefel JJ. Each individual case therefore has to be considered on its own circumstances. Furthermore, as Gray J also pointed out in McAlray-Smith, because of recent frequent changes to the penalties applicable to breaches of this kind under the Workplace Relations Act, it is not possible to say that any appropriate range of penalties has yet been established.CONCLUSION AND THE TOTALITY PRINCIPLE Taking into account all of the considerations discussed above, I believe that a fair and appropriate level of penalties for Coverdale’s breaches to be as follows:FIRST CATEGORY – failing to pay minimum hourly ratesClause 10.2 $ 10,000Clause 14.3 $ 5,000Clause 22 $ 10,000SECOND CATEGORY – Uniform depositsClause 16.1 $ 15,000THIRD CATEGORY – various breaches – ranked by seriousnessMost seriousClause 21 – district allowance – 6 breaches - $ 6,000Mid level of seriousnessClause 14.9 – Sunday duty – 4 breaches $ 2,000Clause 33 – public holidays – 3 breaches $ 1,500Least seriousClause 14.7.1 – overtime – 1 breach $ 250Clause 34.9 – annual leave – 1 breach $ 250Total $50,000Less 10% for extenuating circumstances $45,000 In assessing the fair and appropriate penalties to be applied in this case, thus far I have obviously taken the orthodox approach. That is, I have first assessed the appropriate penalty for each breach and having done so, I should now assess whether the aggregate total amount of the penalty is an appropriate response to the conduct involved: see Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (1997) 145 ALR 36 at [53] per Goldberg J, Kelly at [30] per Tracey J, and McAlray-Smith at [23] per Gray J, at [71] per Graham J and at [97] per Buchanan J, contra The Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Limited (2001) 108 IR 228 at [7] per Finkelstein J. I will not repeat what I have said above about the seriousness with which I regard Coverdale’s conduct. It will suffice to say that the aggregate total figure of $45,000 is much higher than the range of $15,000 to $20,000 proffered by Coverdale. In general terms this is so because I have taken a much more grave view of the nature of the conduct involved than Coverdale has submitted I should. On the other hand, the aggregate total figure of $50,000 is below the lower end of the range proffered by Ms Blandy of $50,000 to $60,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: REEVES J

In summary, Coverdale submitted that:a)The breaches arose through inadvertence rather than a deliberate course of conduct.b)The breaches were admitted at an early stage of the proceedings.c)The underpayments have been remedied with interest.d)Contrition has been shown and an apology issued to each of the employees.e)The breaches essentially constitute one course of conduct and attract the ‘totality principle’.f)Corrective action has been undertaken.g)A total penalty in the range of $15,000.00 to $20,000.00 is appropriate.CONSIDERATIONS IN DETERMINING PENALTY In Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080 (at [14]), Tracey J. adopted “a non-exhaustive range of considerations to which regard may be had in determining whether particular conduct calls for the imposition of a penalty, and if it does the amount of the penalty”. This range of considerations was referred to with approval in Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8; 165 FCR 560, at [60] per Graham J; and at [88–89] per Buchanan J. That list of considerations is as follows:·The nature and extent of the conduct which led to the breaches.·The circumstances in which that conduct took place.·The nature and extent of any loss or damage sustained as a result of the breaches.·Whether there had been similar previous conduct by the respondent.·Whether the breaches were properly distinct or arose out of the one course of conduct.·The size of the business enterprise involved.·Whether or not the breaches were deliberate.·Whether senior management was involved in the breaches.·Whether the party committing the breaches had exhibited contrition.·Whether the party committing the breaches had taken corrective action.·Whether the party committing the breaches had cooperated with the enforcement authorities.·The need to ensure compliance with minimum standards by provision of an effective means for investigation and enforcement of employee entitlements and ·The need for specific and general deterrence.While noting that some of these considerations do not specifically apply in these proceedings, I intend to generally follow this list in these reasons. However, where appropriate, I propose to combine some of these considerations under the one heading.THE NATURE AND EXTENT OF THE CONDUCT Coverdale’s 24 breaches of the Award involved underpayments of the minimum hourly wage rates set by the Award and non-payments of various allowances and loadings under the Award including overtime, Sunday duty, district allowance, and the like. With the exception of two short periods totalling about three months (between 25 January and 23 February 2006 and 10 August and 8 November 2006), these breaches were spread fairly evenly over the two year period, (approximately) between 1 August 2005 and 9 July 2007. In my view this is quite a significant period of continual breaches. The total of the underpayments amounted to a little over $11,000. While this figure may not be particularly large in itself, its significance for the individual employees can be assessed by comparing the amount of the actual wages paid to them during the whole of their employment with Coverdale, to the amount of the underpayments. In Ms McGough’s case, she was paid approximately $9,700 during the whole of her employment against underpayments totalling a little over $5,000. In other words, the underpayments exceeded 50% of her actual wages. In the cases of Mr Maker ($3,200 total actual wages -v- $2,400 underpayments) and Mr Carcoba ($832 total actual wages -v- $812 underpayments) the equivalent figures were 75% and 100% respectively. Therefore, in my view, the underpayments amounted to a significant proportion of the total actual wages paid to these employees.THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CONDUCT AND WHETHER THE BREACHES WERE DELIBERATE