Fair Work Ombudsman v BSH Transport Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v BSH Transport Solutions Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 90

File number(s): ADG 342 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE BROWN
Date of judgment: 28 February 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – penalty hearing – failure to comply with issued Compliance Notice – claim for unpaid leave entitlements following termination of employment – calculation of penalty – legislative purpose of compliance notices – issues of deterrence – matters to be considered  
Legislation:

Crimes Act 1912 (Cth) s 4AA

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Pt 2-2, ss 3, 90, 99, 539, 546, 550, 681, 682, 701, 706, 712, 716

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8

Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1533

Fair Work Ombudsman v Corporation Sun Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 2849

Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 709

Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 579

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lifestyle SA Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1151

Fair Work Ombudsman v Maclean Bay Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 557

Fair Work Ombudsman v Matcraft Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 272

Fair Work Ombudsman v Trek North Tours & Anor (No 2) [2015] FCCA 1801

Fair Work Ombudsman v Yogurberry World Square [2016] FCA 1290

Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080

Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7

Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

Mornington Inn v Jordon [2008] FCAFC 70

Ponzio v B & P Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 65

Rajagopalan v BM Sydney Building Materials Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 1412

Veen v R (No 2) (1988) 164 CLR 465

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 92
Date of hearing: 9 December 2022
Place: Adelaide
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Bergander-Florek
Solicitor for the Applicant: HWL Ebsworth
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Kernahan
Solicitor for the Respondents: Johnston Withers Lawyers

ORDERS

ADG 342 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

BSH TRANSPORT SOLUTIONS PTY LTD

First Respondent

BRENTON PHILIP SMITH

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE BROWN

DATE OF ORDER:

28 February 2023

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

A.The First Respondent contravened section 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”) by failing to comply with the Compliance Notice.

B.The Second Respondent was involved, within the meaning of section 550(2) of the Act, in the contravention of section 716(5) of the Act by the First Respondent, and has therefore contravened section 716(5) of the Act pursuant to section 550(1) of the Act.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 545(1) of the Act, the First Respondent take the steps that were required by the Compliance Notice:

(a)within 14 days of this order, produce to the Applicant a schedule that sets out the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v BSH Transport Solutions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman filed proceedings against BSH Transport Solutions Pty Ltd for underpaying employees, resulting in a case before the Fair Work Commission. The dispute centres on whether BSH, under the direction of its sole director, Mr Smith, breached the Fair Work Act by failing to pay its employees the correct wages and entitlements. The case requires the court to determine the appropriate penalties for these breaches, taking into account factors such as corrective action, cooperation, and deterrence.

The legal issues the court had to address include whether Mr Smith, as the director of BSH, had both actual and apparent responsibility for ensuring compliance with the Fair Work Act, the extent of corrective action taken by BSH post the issuance of the Compliance Notice, and the appropriate level of penalty considering the lack of cooperation and contrition shown by BSH. Additionally, the court needed to assess the importance of deterrence in setting the penalties, particularly in light of the failure to comply with the Compliance Notice.

The court found that Mr Smith was responsible for managing BSH and ensuring compliance with the Fair Work Act. While some corrective action was taken, it was deemed insufficient and too late. BSH's lack of cooperation and formal expressions of contrition were also noted, leading to a reduction in penalty discounts. The court emphasised the importance of deterrence, highlighting the failure of the Compliance Notice process and the need to protect the industrial safety net provided by relevant awards. Consequently, the court imposed penalties that reflect the seriousness of the breaches and the need to deter similar conduct in the future.

The final orders of the court will include the imposition of penalties on BSH Transport Solutions Pty Ltd for the identified breaches of the Fair Work Act, taking into account the factors of corrective action, cooperation, and deterrence. The court's decision underscores the necessity for employers to comply with award obligations and the consequences of non-compliance, particularly when it leads to the institution of proceedings by the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Jambekar has also deposed that BSH is known to the FWO in the sense that inquiries have been made to, by other employees of BSH, between 2016 and 2021 in respect of annual leave and other wage discrepancy. None of these matters proceeded to litigation or resulted in the issue of Compliance Notices. Finally, Mr Jambekar has deposed that Mr Smith remains the sole director of BSH. He is also the registered proprietor of fourteen pieces of real property in South Australia. The Evidence of Mr Smith Mr Smith deposes that he has been operating BSH since 2004. It provides a freight service primarily between Roxby Downs and Adelaide. It employs seventeen drivers and five administrative staff. Mr Smith is also involved in driving. He has provided BSH’s profit and loss statement for the financial year ending 30 June 2021. No evidence was led regarding what those records revealed in respect of the financial strength or otherwise of the business. The effect of Mr Smith’s affidavit is that he remains of the view that Ms Murphy has not provided an adequate explanation to him regarding irregularities regarding how she utilised the sum of $1,600.00 received from one of BSH’s creditors prior to her emailing her resignation to him. As previously indicated, in her absence, it was difficult for him to access necessary payroll records, given his other responsibilities in the business. In these circumstances, he did the best he could to answer the FWO’s inquiries via his accountants. He has recently changed accountants. The implication of this change being that he was not satisfied with the services previously provided to him.Legal Principles Applicable to Penalty Hearings The approach, which the court is required to take, in respect of these contravention proceedings, has been delineated in a number of decisions of the Federal Court.[18] The process can be summarised as follows:·The court should identify each separate contravention, arising from a breach of either the applicable award or the FWA itself. Pursuant to section 539(2) each such contravention is a distinct incident for penalty purposes;·The court should determine whether any of these incidents arise in a single course of conduct, within the terms envisaged by section 557(1); ·Then give consideration as to whether any of these contraventions contain elements and factor this into considering what is an appropriate penalty, in all the circumstances, for each contravention;·Thereafter, the court should fix an appropriate penalty for each single or group contravention, taking into account all relevant circumstances; and·Finally, the court should apply the totality principle. This final step constitutes a review of the aggregate penalty calculated, and envisages a consideration of whether such a penalty is an appropriate response to the conduct, which lead to the various contraventions in question. This case has been described as a process of intuitive synthesis.[19][18] See Fair Work Ombudsman v Lifestyle SA Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1151 at [42] (Mansfield J), citing Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 579 at [10] (McKerracher J). [19] Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8 at [55] (Graham J).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Smith was responsible as its director for the management of BSH’s management and had both actual and apparent responsibility for ensuring it complied with its obligations under the FWA.Corrective action, cooperation and contrition Some corrective action has been taken by BSH but it occurred at a late stage well after the issue of the relevant Compliance Notice. Ms Murphy received her most recent payment on 30 May 2022, a year after the Notice was issued and after the proceedings were instituted. No formal expressions of contrition have been made. The proceedings themselves have not proceeded with any degree of seamlessness. Although it has proceeded on the basis of a SOAF, the process leading to its filing took a significant period. In these circumstances, counsel for the FWO submits that BSH has displayed a somewhat lackadaisical approach to the enforcement process which should reduce any discount in respect of penalty to one of 10% for admitting liability and one of 5% in respect of the late payments to Ms Murphy. Deterrence As I have already observed deterrence has two aspects – general deterrence directed towards the community as a whole, and specific deterrence directed towards the individual concerned whose conduct is to be sanctioned. As the High Court has recently indicated, issues of deterrence must be accorded primacy in the imposition of any civil penalty. In Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd,[27] Judge Hartnett said as follows in respect of the importance of the Compliance Notice process in the industrial regulatory system in this county:The Explanatory Memorandum to the Fair Work Bill 2008 (Cth) provides that compliance notices were designed to be another option to deal with non-compliance instead of pursuing court proceedings. It was to be a less costly and less time consuming procedure. Section 716 of the FW Act allows a person to whom a compliance notice is issued an opportunity to rectify an under payment without being subject to civil remedy provisions. The First Respondent’s failure to comply with the Compliance Notice issued has, in these proceedings, caused the Applicant and the Court to spend time and public funds in dealing with civil remedy proceedings which would not have been necessary had compliance occurred.[28][27] Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 709.[28] Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 709 at [11]. As I have already observed, so far as the current matter is concerned, the Compliance Notice procedure has been an abject failure in bringing about a prompt restitution to the employees concerned and the saving imposition on the public purse. One of the central purposes of the modern award system and the related enforcement procedures is to ensure all employees have the benefit of the industrial safety net provided by relevant awards. To be able to enforce the terms of modern awards, Fair Work Inspectors must be able to exercise their compliance powers effectively through investigation and then rectification. When there has been a concerted non-compliance with a Notice issued by a Fair Work Inspector, the court needs to indicate that such non-compliance will be regarded as a serious matter by reference to the quantum of any penalty imposed.