Fair Work Ombudsman v McNeill Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v McNeill Investments Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 40

File number(s): ADG 63 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE BROWN
Date of judgment: 3 February 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair work – underpayment of employee – penalty hearing – where company has been placed into liquidation – failure to comply with notice to produce records or documents – failure to comply with compliance notice – first time offender – calculation of penalty  
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 500(2)

Crimes Act 1912 (Cth) s 4AA

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 3, 539(2), 545, 550, 557(1), 681, 682, 701, 706, 716, 717(1)

Fast Food Industry Award 2010 Sch B

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8
Blandy v Coverdale NT Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1533
Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 709

Fair Work Ombudsman v Devine Marine Group Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1365

Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 579
Fair Work Ombudsman v Lifestyle SA Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1151

Fair Work Ombudsman v Matcraft Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 272

Fair Work Ombudsman v Trek North Tours & Anor (No 2) [2015] FCCA 1801
Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080
Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7

Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

Rajagopalan v BM Sydney Building Materials Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 1412

Veen v R (No 2) (1988) 164 CLR 465

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 153
Date of hearing: Considered on the papers in Chambers
Place: Adelaide
Solicitor for the Applicant: Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman
Solicitor for the First Respondent:: No appearance
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Wallmans Lawyers

ORDERS

ADG 63 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

MCNEILL INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

First Respondent

JASON MATTHEW HOOD

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE BROWN

DATE OF ORDER:

3 February 2023

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

A.the First Respondent contravened section 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”) by failing to comply with the Compliance Notice dated 2 September 2020;

B.the First Respondent contravened section 712(3) of the Act by failing to comply with the notice to produce records or documents dated 18 October 2019; and

C.the Second Respondent was involved, within the meaning of section 550(2) of the Act, in the contravention by the First Respondent declared at paragraph A above.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 545(1) of the Act, the Second Respondent pay within 28 days of the date of this Order:

(a)Ms Kelsey Didenko the sum of ONE THOUSAND AND SIX HUNDRED DOLLARS ($1,600.00).

2.Pursuant to section 546(1) of the Act the Second Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty of TWO THOUSAND AND NINETY FIVE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v McNeill Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Fair Work Ombudsman v McNeill Investments Pty Ltd, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) sought enforcement of a Compliance Notice issued under section 716 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The dispute centred on McNeill Investments Pty Ltd's failure to pay casual employee Ms Didenko her proper wages, overtime allowances, and other loadings stipulated under the relevant Award. The court was tasked with determining whether the FWO's Compliance Notice was valid and if McNeill Investments was required to comply with it.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether McNeill Investments was obligated to comply with the Compliance Notice issued by the FWO, and if not, what consequences should follow. The court considered the FWO's role in enforcing compliance with workplace laws and the mechanisms available to rectify underpayments without resorting to litigation. The court also examined the procedural fairness afforded to McNeill Investments and the effectiveness of the Compliance Notice system in achieving its intended objectives.

The court found that the FWO had a reasonable belief that McNeill Investments had breached the relevant provisions of the Award by failing to pay Ms Didenko her proper wages. It was held that the Compliance Notice was appropriately issued under section 716 of the Act as an alternative to litigation. The court emphasised the importance of the Compliance Notice system in providing an accessible and effective procedure for resolving grievances and promoting cooperative workplace relations. However, in this instance, the system had failed to achieve its objectives, leading to unnecessary litigation and expenditure of public resources.

The court concluded that McNeill Investments, through its director Jason Hood, had a responsibility to rectify the underpayments. Despite some cooperation in the proceedings, the failure to make timely restitution to Ms Didenko undermined the objectives of the Compliance Notice system. The court ordered Jason Hood to pay the sum due to Ms Didenko within 28 days and imposed a penalty of $2,095.00, reflecting the level of cooperation and the need for deterrence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Amongst other things, the Award provided a casual minimum wage; allowances for overtime; loadings for hours worked on Saturday, Sunday and public holidays as well as other loadings relating to the casual nature of the employment and the hours worked.Background On 5 September 2019, the FWO received a Request for Assistance from Ms Didenko.[10] Pursuant to section 700 of the FWA, the FWO appointed Ms Isabel Pires (“Ms Pires”) to investigate McNeill Investment’s compliance with provisions of the Award.[10] See affidavit of Isabel Pires filed 21 December 2021 at [5]. As a consequence of Ms Pires’ initial investigation, the FWO issued a Notice to Produce Records or Documents to McNeill Investments on 18 October 2019. The Notice to Produce required McNeill Investments to produce various records relating to Ms Didenko’s employment by 5:00pm on Friday 8 November 2019.[11][11] See annexure IDSP-1 to affidavit of Isabel Pires filed 21 December 2021. It is an agreed fact evidence that the Notice to Produce was sent via registered post to the registered office of McNeill Investments on 18 October 2019. Subsequently after no communication or compliance with the Notice on behalf of McNeill Investments, Ms Pires made contact with Darryl Hood via telephone on 6 November 2019. Ms Pires deposes Darryl advised that he did not receive the relevant Notice, claiming the address it was sent to was his old accountant’s office and McNeill Investments don’t use them anymore. Following the telephone conversation Ms Pires sent a copy of the Notice via email to an address nominated by Darryl and to his home address. It is Ms Pires’ evidence that she attempted to make contact with Darryl on four separate occasions in November and early December of 2019 however those attempts proved unsuccessful. McNeill Investments failed to provide any documents in response to the Notice to Produce, consequently on 3 December 2019 the FWO issued a letter notifying McNeill Investments of their failure to comply.[12][12] See annexure IDSP-4 to affidavit of Isabel Pires filed 21 December 2021. After her attempts to make further contact with Darryl proved unsuccessful, Ms Pires deposes she made contact with Jason on 10 December 2019 via telephone. It is her evidence they had conversed with words to the effect of her introducing herself as:A Fair Work Inspector with the Fair Work Ombudsman. The reason for my call is because we have received two requests for assistance from former employees[13][13] See affidavit of Isabel Pires filed 21 December 2021 at [12]. Further asking of Mr Jason Hood what was his involvement with the business. Mr Hood responding in the following terms: Me and my brother have been business partners for 20 odd years. I am a director for the two business. As my name is a company director I am responsible for fixing this, because my name is attached to this.[14][14] See affidavit of Isabel Pires filed 21 December 2021 at [12]. The FWO submits that it attempted to make further contact with Jason on four separate occasions following 10 December 2019. However, those attempts were fruitless on each occasion and a voicemail was left.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 717(1) of the Act authorises a person who has been serviced with a Compliance Notice to apply to the court to have the notice reviewed on the basis that there has been no contravention as specified or the notice does not otherwise comply with the applicable legislation.FWI Pires’ Evidence As previously indicated, it is Ms Pires’ evidence that, following being contacted by Ms Didenko in September of 2019, pursuant to section 712 of the FWA she issued a Notice to Produce Records or Documents. FWI Pires contacted Jason Hood, by telephone, in mid-December of 2019, at which stage he acknowledged that, as a director of McNeill Investments, he had a responsibility to fix the underpayment issue. However, thereafter, her attempts to follow through with him, in this regard, were fruitless and her voice messages went unanswered. It was in this context, that the relevant Compliance Notice was issued approximately 11 months after the wage infractions had come to the notice of the FWO. Given the evidence available from FWI, I am satisfied that there is no issue regarding the reasonableness of the belief of the FWO that McNeill Investments had breached the relevant provisions of the Award by failing to pay Ms Didenko her proper casual wage loadings along with other benefits. In addition, in light of its educative role and obligation to promote cooperative workplace relations.[27] It was, in my view, clearly appropriate for the FWO, through the agency of FWI Pires to attempt to engage in correspondence with the respondents in order to see whether the monies due to Ms Didenko could be advanced by the respondents without recourse to litigation. [27] See Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 682(1)(a)(i). In this context, the application of a Compliance Notice issued under section 716 must be considered. In Fair Work Ombudsman v Matcraft Pty Ltd,[28] Judge Kendall explained the legislative intention of a Compliance Notice, as an alternative to litigation, in the following terms:As explained in the Explanatory Memorandum to the Fair Work Bill 2008 (Cth), the purpose of s 716 of the Act is to provide an alternative to litigation. Section 716 is an informal mechanism whereby the applicant can identify potential contraventions of the Act and seek rectification without an employer having to admit liability.One of the objects of the Act is to provide accessible and effective procedures to resolve grievances and disputes and provide effective compliance mechanisms. Section 716 encapsulates this objective by allowing employees to make a request for assistance which the applicant can then resolve through the use of s 716.[29][28] See Fair Work Ombudsman v Matcraft Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 272.[29] See Fair Work Ombudsman v Matcraft Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 272 at [34]-[35] (Kendall J). In addition, as previously indicated, the relevant legislation allows an employer to challenge a Notice if it is believed there are no grounds for its issue or the Notice itself is invalid. In these circumstances, it is the contention of the FWO that if the respondents had complied with the Notice in question, it would have been precluded from bringing these proceedings, with a commensurate saving of public resources.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It would seem to me that there is truth in the submission made to me that Jason Hood has learnt a salutary lesson about the need for vigilance in industrial matters when one is the director of a company employing individuals in a regulated industry such as the fast food industry. As such I do not consider that this is a case calling for a significant degree of specific deterrence, particularly given Jason Hood has not previously contravened any industrial regulation.Conclusions The most significant factor in this case is the failure of the Compliance Notice system to firstly bring about the payment to Ms Didenko to which she was entitled to and secondly avoid litigation. As I am at pains to point out, the laudable and publically advantageous aims of section 716(5) have totally miscarried in this case. Ms Didenko, a young person, is not so significantly disadvantaged. However, significant as the sum in question is to her, they are likely to pale when compared to the costs arising from bringing these proceedings. There is no sweetening of the sour taste accorded by those proceedings by any realisation that, at the very least, after having made their complaints to the industrial arbiter, Ms Didenko did get what she was entitled. Rather Jason Hood states that he is no-longer in a position to make the restitution previously offered. Why this is so has not been the subject of further elaboration. For the reasons relating to its liquidation, McNeill Investments cannot make such restitution and the FWO has elected not to proceed against Darryl Hood. In my view, the mere assertion that he cannot make good the underpayments due to Ms Didenko does not absolve Jason Hood of his obligation arising under section 546(2)(b) of the FWA. The relevant Compliance Notice remains unsatisfied and I propose to order that Mr Jason Hood pay the sum due to Ms Didenko within 28 days of the date of the Court’s order. The maximum penalty for an individual is one of $6,660.00. It was previously agreed a discount of 20% is appropriate given the level of cooperation arising from the admission of liability, bringing the penalty down to $5,328.00. However due to Mr Hood not providing payment to the employee as promised, the FWO submits the penalty should now only carry a 15% discount. Mr Jason Hood is a first offender, who has acknowledged culpability in circumstances in which his brother Darryl must be regarded as attracting of more censure. There is a limited need for specific deterrence. However, some level of uncertainty arises in respect of Mr Jason Hood’s level of personal contrition given the failure to make good his undertaking to make rectification in a timely fashion. In all these circumstances, given the sum in question is moderate in size. In my view, an appropriate penalty for Mr Jason Hood, is one of 37% of the discounted penalty, which is at the lower end of the range agreed between the parties, prior to Mr Jason Hood’s abrogation of his undertaking to make restitution. The penalty is one of $2,095.00.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, Ms Didenko was not provided with her basic award entitlements. As such, a significant objective of the industrial system has been undermined. It remains the case to this date and will remain so. So far as Ms Didenko is concerned, the industrial safety net has failed and her approach to the FWO has provided no practical outcome.Contrition, corrective action and cooperation with authorities The FWO submits the second respondent, Jason Hood has to some extent cooperated with the proceedings in admitted accessorial liability, albeit with the assistance of a mediation and filling a Statement of Agreed Facts, therefore saving the public purse. The need for a full hearing regarding liability has been avoided. However, the most expedient mechanism for expressing contrition is through a speedy rectification of any under payment to an employee. This did not occur through the Compliance Notice procedure itself. Nor did litigation itself bring about any such rectification, notwithstanding that it was offered and formed the basis for the matter proceeding on a statement of agreed fact. The admissions made by Jason Hood have saved time and money. This cooperation should result in a discount on the penalty to be imposed. As indicated above, it was the FWO’s initial position that the discount to be applied should be one of 20% but this was posited on the basis of full rectification. It now contends that the discount should be one of 15%.Size of business It is Jason Hood’s evidence that McNeill Investments sold its Subway franchise on 24 February 2021. I have not been advised as to the terms of this sale. However, given its liquidation, it would appear self-apparent that, as Mr Hood has deposed, the company is in a poor financial state and has significant debts and liabilities. It is well established that the size and financial circumstances of an employer do not, of themselves, provide extenuating circumstances sufficient to reduce the penalty to be imposed for an award infringement or a failure to comply with a Compliance Notice. In this regard, I adopt the comments of Driver FM in Rajagopalan v BM Sydney Building Materials Pty Ltd as follows:Employers must not be left under the impression that because of their size or financial difficulty that they are able to breach an award. Obligations by employers for adherence to industrial instruments arise regardless of their size. Such a factor should be of limited relevance to the Court’s consideration of penalty.[48][48] See Rajagopalan v BM Sydney Building Materials Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 1412 at [27] (Driver FM).General and specific deterrence Deterrence has two aspects – general deterrence directed towards the community as a whole, and specific deterrence directed towards the individual concerned whose conduct is to be sanctioned. As the High Court has recently indicated, issues of deterrence must be accorded primacy in the imposition of any civil penalty. In Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd,[49] Judge Hartnett said as follows in respect of the importance of the Compliance Notice process in the industrial regulatory system in this county:The Explanatory Memorandum to the Fair Work Bill 2008 (Cth) provides that compliance notices were designed to be another option to deal with non-compliance instead of pursuing court proceedings. It was to be a less costly and less time consuming procedure. Section 716 of the FW Act allows a person to whom a compliance notice is issued an opportunity to rectify an under payment without being subject to civil remedy provisions. The First Respondent’s failure to comply with the Compliance Notice issued has, in these proceedings, caused the Applicant and the Court to spend time and public funds in dealing with civil remedy proceedings which would not have been necessary had compliance occurred.[49] Fair Work Ombudsman v Darna Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 709 at [11].