Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 579

Citation: Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 579
Parties: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v KENTWOOD INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ACN 086 269 794) and JIAN YANG ZHANG
File number: WAD 127 of 2009
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 31 May 2011
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – pecuniary penalty – assessment of penalty – approach to determining penalty – factors relevant to determining appropriate penalty – breaches of several terms of award – contraventions of Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – underpayment of employees – whether multiple contraventions should be treated as a single contravention – whether the contraventions arose out of one course of conduct – whether the contraventions can be grouped into categories – assessing the different levels of seriousness of breach – application of totality principle – Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), s 719 – payment of outstanding wages – interest on outstanding wages – declaratory relief
Legislation: Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 182, 182(1), 189, 189(1), 189(2), 235, 235(2), 719(6), 722, 728, 824, 841
Federal Court Rules O 35 r 8
Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 2) (2010) 199 IR 373
Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviation Service Assistance Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 394
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v FUELbanc Australia Ltd (2007) 162 FCR 174
Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1156
John Holland Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 2) (2010) 192 IR 431
Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14
Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7
McDonald v Australian Building and Construction Commissioner [2011] FCAFC 29
Stuart-Mahoney v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2008) 177 IR 61
Warramunda Village Inc v Pryde (2001) 105 FCR 437

Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last submissions: 31 January 2011
Place: Perth
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 53
Counsel for the Applicant: R Hooker
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondents: The Respondents did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 127 of 2009

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant

AND:

KENTWOOD INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ACN 086 269 794)
First Respondent

JIAN YANG ZHANG
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MAY 2011

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The First Respondent contravened s 182(1) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (the WR Act) by failing to pay the minimum hourly rates (as contained in the applicable preserved Australian Pay and Classification Scale (APCS)) in respect of the First Respondent’s employees as follows:

(a)in relation to Zhaolin Yuan,

(i)for the period 27 March 2006…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 3), the Fair Work Ombudsman sought relief against Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd and Mr Zhang for multiple breaches of industrial law, including the underpayment of wages and other entitlements to employees. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issues revolved around the assessment of pecuniary penalties for the contraventions, the approach to determining the appropriate penalty, and whether the contraventions should be treated as a single contravention or grouped into categories based on their level of seriousness.

The court considered the totality principle and the relevance of the contraventions arising from a single course of conduct. It rejected the argument that all contraventions should be treated as a single contravention but accepted that some could be grouped based on common elements. The court emphasised that specific deterrence was relevant given Mr Zhang's ongoing involvement in business operations in Australia. While acknowledging the seriousness of the contraventions, the court determined that imposing penalties at 80% of the maximum penalty would be unduly harsh, particularly as the respondents were first offenders. The court also took into account the limited English proficiency of Mr Zhang, which may have contributed to the breaches.

Ultimately, the court decided to impose penalties that, while substantial, were less than the maximum possible. The total penalties for Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd and Mr Zhang were set at $123,000 and $24,600, respectively. Additionally, the court ordered the respondents to repay the underpaid wages and entitlements to the affected employees, along with interest. The court also granted declaratory relief to underscore the importance of compliance with industrial laws, particularly in relation to low-paid and vulnerable employees. The final orders included specific monetary payments to the employees, penalties to the respondents, and provisions for interest on the unpaid amounts.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The First Respondent pay to Zhaolin Yuan within 28 days:

(a) $69,512.04 in respect of the underpayment of wages and entitlements, pursuant to s 719(6) of the WR Act;

(b) $15,579.09, being interest from 2 February 2007 (the date of termination) to judgment (27 October 2010) at the rate of 6% per annum ($11.43 per day) for 1363 days, pursuant to s 722 of the WR Act and O 35 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules; and

(c) interest from the date of judgment (27 October 2010) on the total sum of $85,091.13, at the rate of 10.5% per annum ($24.48 per day).

2. The First Respondent pay to Zheng Shun Zeng within 28 days:

(a) $47,634.47 in respect of the underpayment of wages and entitlements, pursuant to s 719(6) of the WR Act;

(b) $9,419.49, being interest from 12 July 2007 to judgment (27 October 2010) at the rate of 6% per annum ($7.83 per day) for 1203 days, pursuant to s 722 of the WR Act and O 35 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules; and

(c) interest from the date of judgment (27 October 2010) on the total sum of $57,053.96, at the rate of 10.5% per annum ($16.41 per day).

3. The First Respondent pay to Jian Hang Qi within 28 days:

(a) $48,870.75 in respect of the underpayment of wages and entitlements, pursuant to s 719(6) of the WR Act;

(b) $9,555.70, being interest from 25 July 2007 (the date of termination) to judgment (27 October 2010) at the rate of 6% per annum ($8.03 per day) for 1190 days, pursuant to s 722 of the WR Act and O 35 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules; and

(c) interest from the date of judgment (27 October 2010) on the total sum of $58,426.45, at the rate of 10.5% per annum ($16.81 per day).

4. The First Respondent pay to Zongxin Shen within 28 days:

(a) $28,371.50 in respect of the underpayment of wages and entitlements, pursuant to s 719(6) of the WR Act;

(b) $5,605.98, being interest from 12 July 2007 (the date of termination) to judgment (27 October 2010) at the rate of 6% per annum ($4.66 per day) for 1203 days, pursuant to s 722 of the WR Act and O 35 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules; and

(c) interest from the date of judgment (27 October 2010) on the total sum of $33,977.73, at the rate of 10.5% per annum ($9.77 per day).

5. The First Respondent pay to Jian Guo Qi within 28 days:

(a) $48,216.75 in respect of the underpayment of wages and entitlements, pursuant to s 719(6) of the WR Act;

(b) $9,539.79, being interest from 12 July 2007 (the date of termination) to judgment (27 October 2010) at the rate of 6% per annum ($7.93 per day) for 1203 days, pursuant to s 722 of the WR Act and O 35 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules; and

(c) interest from the date of judgment (27 October 2010) on the total sum of $57,756.54, at the rate of 10.5% per annum ($16.61 per day).

6. The First Respondent pay to the Commonwealth Consolidated Revenue Fund within 28 days $123,000 made up of the following penalties:

$17,000 for contravention of s 182 of the WR Act for 5 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zheng Shun Zeng for the period 2 May 2006 to 12 July 2007;

- Jian Hang Qi for the period 2 May 2006 to 25 July 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 30 September 2006 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 2 May 2006 to 12 July 2007.

$17,000 for contravention of s 189 of the WR Act for 4 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the first five months of employment;

- Jian Hang Qi for the first three months of employment; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the first three months of employment.

- Zheng Shun Zeng for the first three months of employment.

$15,000 for contravention of cl 15 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

$15,000 for contravention of cl 16 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

$15,000 for contravention of cl 20 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007.

$13,000 for contravention of cl 22 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan.

$13,000 for contravention of s 235 of the WR Act for 5 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan;

- Zheng Shun Zeng;

- Jian Hang Qi;

- Zongxin Shen; and

- Jian Guo Qi.

$8,000 for contravention of cl 17 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007.

$10,000 for contravention of cl 13 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

7. The Second Respondent pay to the Commonwealth Consolidated Revenue Fund within 28 days $24,600 made up of the following penalties:

$3,400 for contravention of s 182 of the WR Act for 5 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zheng Shun Zeng for the period 2 May 2006 to 12 July 2007;

- Jian Hang Qi for the period 2 May 2006 to 25 July 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 30 September 2006 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 2 May 2006 to 12 July 2007.

$3,400

for contravention of s 189 of the WR Act for 4 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the first five months of employment;

- Jian Hang Qi for the first three months of employment; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the first three months of employment.

- Zheng Shun Zeng for the first three months of employment;

$3,000 for contravention of cl 15 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

$3,000 for contravention of cl 16 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

$3,000 for contravention of cl 20 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007.

$2,600 for contravention of cl 22 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan.

$2,600 for contravention of s 235 of the WR Act for 5 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan;

- Zheng Shun Zeng;

- Jian Hang Qi;

- Zongxin Shen; and

- Jian Guo Qi.

$1,600 for contravention of cl 17 NAPSA for 1 employee:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007.

$2,000 for contravention of cl 13 NAPSA for 3 employees:

Being:

- Zhaolin Yuan for the period 27 March 2006 to 2 February 2007;

- Zongxin Shen for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007; and

- Jian Guo Qi for the period 19 June 2007 to 12 July 2007.

8. The Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of the action on a party/party basis within 28 days of taxation or agreement, in accordance with s 824 of the WR Act.

9. The Applicant has liberty to apply in the event of non-compliance with any order herein.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no evidence that Mr Zhang intends not to return to Australia or to have no further involvement in the operation of business in Australia (whether through Kentwood or through another entity). Accordingly, since Mr Zhang remains a director of Kentwood, specific deterrence is of relevance to both respondents.CONCLUSION The applicant contends that:(a)The serious course of sustained and conscious underpayment of wages and other entitlements, and related statutory contraventions to the severe detriment of a vulnerable group of low paid employees, requires the Court to impose penalties for each group of contraventions which ‘closely approach the statutory maxima’.(b)In the absence of any credible material or submission put before the Court in mitigation of the contraventions (beyond the fact that the respondents are to be treated as first offenders under the WR Act and related industrial instruments) the total penalties should be in the higher range of penalties available to the Court. The applicant submits that a penalty of not less than 80% of the maximum penalty would be appropriate in all the circumstances of this case.(c)The penalty should be made payable into consolidated revenue pursuant to s 841 of the WR Act. For the following reasons, I do not, with respect, agree that 80% of the maximum penalty is appropriate. First, although I have not had the benefit of submissions on behalf of the respondents in relation to penalty, and notwithstanding that I accept the seriousness of the contraventions, fixing the penalty at 80% of the maximum penalty in the case of a first offender would, in my view, be unduly harsh in most instances. For a recent example of the relevance of a first offence, see Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviation Service Assistance Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 394 per Barker J (at [21]). Secondly, although Kentwood conducted operations in various States (through Mr Zhang), there is no other evidentiary basis on which I could reach a conclusion that the operations of the Kentwood were ‘sophisticated’ in the sense contended for by the applicant. I accept, as the applicant suggests, that there is no evidence that the respondents were unaware that their manner of operation contravened important industrial statutes but given Mr Zhang’s very limited command of English, it would be reasonable to infer that he was not intimately familiar with his legal obligations in that area. While ignorance is not a defence to liability, it might be said that for at least a significant portion of the time during which the offences were committed, there is no indication that the respondents were aware of the seriousness of the breaches. I also take into account the fact that the respondents will be ordered to repay to the employees the sums which should have been paid to them (with interest) and that the respondents will be liable for the taxed or agreed costs of these proceedings. As to grouping of contraventions, in my view it is appropriate to approach the fixing of penalties on the basis of nine breaches rather than 14 in consequence of which the total maximum penalty would be $297,000 for Kentwood and $59,400 for Mr Zheng. The reason for this is that the respondents’ continued breach after February 2007 in relation to the reduction in employee hours would not result in a new contravention but be in the same course of conduct of implementing the terms and conditions of employment decided in December 2005. This is particularly so having regard to the common elements of the contravention. Although there are suggestions that the reduction in hours occurred in response to the respondents’ having been alerted to an investigation, it is not possible to reach a firm view on this topic.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 30 December 2010, the Court was advised that Mr Zhang was in no fit condition, mentally or physically, to comply with the orders or to ‘comprehend the legal process of the case’. I have set out in detail in Kentwood No 2 the measures taken to endeavour to afford the respondents a reasonable opportunity to be heard in relation to all matters concerning this litigation. As against that consideration, the public interest in finality and compliance with important industrial law obligations is to be balanced. It is necessary to proceed to a final determination of this dispute. These reasons are therefore the determination on penalty. Before reaching conclusions on penalty, I will, for convenience, reiterate the substance of the views expressed in Kentwood No 2 on that topic (at [210]-[252]). The same abbreviations have been adopted. DECLARATIONS In Kentwood No 2 (at [210]) I observed that there may be a public interest in the granting of declaratory relief in regulatory proceedings to record the contraventions’ seriousness and to explain the basis for the imposition of pecuniary penalties and other relief (see the analysis by Heerey J in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v FUELbanc Australia Ltd (2007) 162 FCR 174 (at [46]-[66]) and Warramunda Village Inc v Pryde (2001) 105 FCR 437 (per Gray, Branson and North JJ) (at [12])). A declaration in this case may indicate the importance of compliance with statutory standards, particularly in the employment of low paid and/or vulnerable employees. I will make the declarations sought. PENALTY Relevantly, s 719 of the WR Act authorises the Court to impose a penalty in respect of a contravention of an applicable provision by a person bound by the provision. Relevantly, ‘applicable provision’ is defined to include:(a) a term of the Standard; and(b) a term of a collective agreement. Pursuant to cl 31 of Sch 8, on 27 March 2006, the NAPSA came into operation. Under cl 43 of Sch 8, a term of the NAPSA may be enforced as if it were a term of a collective agreement and therefore an ‘applicable provision’ for the purposes of s 719(1). Section 719(2) provides that where two or more contraventions of an applicable provision are committed by the same person and arise out of a course of conduct by the person, the contraventions shall, for the purposes of s 719, be taken to constitute a single contravention of the provision. Pursuant to s 719(4)(b), the maximum penalty that may be imposed by the Court on Kentwood in respect of each of the contraventions is 300 penalty units. The maximum penalty that may be imposed on Mr Zhang in respect of each of the contraventions is 60 penalty units. A penalty unit is defined under s 4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) to be $110. Accordingly, the maximum penalty that may be imposed for each contravention of the Standard or the NAPSA by Kentwood is $33,000, and for each contravention of the Standard or the NAPSA by Mr Zhang, $6,600.The approach in determining penalty