Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1156

Citation: Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1156
Parties: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v KENTWOOD INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ACN 086 269 794) and JIAN YANG ZHANG
File number: WAD 127 of 2009
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 27 October 2010
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW - underpayment of workers - where workers recruited internationally - application of civil penalties - relevant principles

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - where respondents did not appear at trial - where trial adjourned previously due to lack of representation for respondents and unavailability of respondents’ witnesses - where there is no adequate evidence for the reason of non-appearance or lack of representation - repeated warnings given

Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 51A, 52(2)
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 719, 722, 728
Federal Court Rules O 32 r 2, O 35 r 8
Cases cited:

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560
Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (ACN 086 269 794) [2010] FCA 98
Hamilton v Whitehead (1988) 166 CLR 121

John Holland Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 2) (2010) 192 IR 431

Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14
Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7
Metropolitan Health Services Board v Australia Nurses Federation (2000) 99 FCR 95
Regional Express Holdings v Clark (2007) 165 IR 251
Stuart-Mahoney v CFMEU (2008) 177 IR 61
Textile, Clothing and Footwear Union v Givoni (2002) 12 IR 250
Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661
Zomba Production Music (Aust) Pty Ltd v Roadhouse Productions Pty Ltd (in liq) (2001) 53 IPR 520

Date of hearing: 12 April 2010
Date of last submissions: 2 September 2010
Place: Perth
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 255
Counsel for the Applicant: R Hooker
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondents: The Respondents did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 127 of 2009

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant

AND:

KENTWOOD INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ACN 086 269 794)
First Respondent

JIAN YANG ZHANG
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 OCTOBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

1.The applicant do file and serve within 21 days a minute of orders as to declarations, repayments, interest and costs reflecting these reasons.

2.Any submissions from the respondents in relation to that minute be filed and served within a further 14 days

3.The applicant have a further 10 days within which to reply.

4.The respondents are to file submissions on penalty within 28 days of service of the applicant’s minute. 

5.The applicant will have 10 days to reply to those submissions. 

6.The determination as to penalty will be adjourned until receipt of those submissions.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2), the Fair Work Ombudsman brought proceedings against Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Zhang, for breaches of the National Employment Standards (NES) and the National Australian Processing Standard (NAPS) under the Fair Work Act 2009. The breaches included underpayments to Chinese employees who were on a Subclass 457 visa and sponsored by Kentwood. The employees were promised certain terms of employment in China, but upon arrival in Australia, they found that the written agreements provided to them were different and did not reflect the oral agreements made prior to their arrival.

The court had to determine the appropriate rate of interest for pre-judgment and post-judgment periods and the penalties to be imposed on Kentwood and Mr Zhang for the contraventions. The Fair Work Act sets out the prescribed rates for interest, which are 6% above the cash rate published by the Reserve Bank of Australia. The court found that a higher rate post-judgment serves as an incentive for satisfying the judgment, while a lower rate should be considered for pre-judgment interest due to variables that may not be the judgment debtor's responsibility.

Regarding penalties, the court followed a structured approach in determining the appropriate penalty for each contravention. The court considered each contravention of the NES and NAPS as separate contraventions but also allowed for the possibility of treating multiple contraventions as a single contravention if they arose out of a course of conduct. The maximum penalty for a body corporate like Kentwood was 300 penalty units, and for an individual like Mr Zhang, it was 60 penalty units. The court then considered the appropriate penalty for each contravention, taking into account the circumstances of the case and any common elements among the contraventions. Finally, the court reviewed the aggregate penalty to ensure it was an appropriate response to the conduct leading to the contraventions.

In conclusion, the court ordered Kentwood and Mr Zhang to pay penalties for the contraventions, as well as declarations, orders to remedy the detriment suffered by the employees, pre-judgment interest, and costs. The specific amounts and rates of interest were determined based on the court's findings and the provisions of the Fair Work Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The following matters were not admitted by the respondents but were proven at trial by uncontested evidence adduced by the employees. I accept their evidence. Facts common to all Employees (not admitted by the Respondents) Each Employee was a Chinese citizen and holder of a Temporary Business (Long Stay) – Standard Business Sponsorship (Subclass 457) visa (Subclass 457 visa), sponsored by Kentwood to work in Australia. While in China each Employee was offered employment with Kentwood and accepted employment with Kentwood. Each Employee had to make a payment prior to being offered a position with Kentwood which included payment for his visa to Australia:(a)Mr Yuan paid Mr Xiao Jun Zhang (Jun) 2,500 Renminbi (RMB) and was told by Jun that this money would be paid to Mr Zhang and was for his visa to Australia; (b)Messrs Zeng, Hang and Guo each paid Mr Xu Zhao Gan (Mr Xu) 15,000 RMB in or around April 2006 to secure employment with Kentwood and each was told by Mr Xu that this payment included payment for obtaining his visa to Australia; (c)Mr Shen paid Mr Xu 15,000 RMB in August 2006 to gain employment with Kentwood. Each Employee’s contract of employment with Kentwood was partly oral and partly written. The written employment agreement provided to each of the Employees on behalf of Kentwood was not consistent with the oral terms of employment that were offered to, and accepted by the Employees. For some of the Employees the written agreements provided by the respondents’ solicitors on 7 March 2007 to the applicant in response to the applicant’s Notice to Produce Documents dated 16 February 2007 are not the same written agreements initially provided to the Employees by the respondents for signing (Purported Written Agreements):(a)The first time that Mr Yuan saw the Chinese version of the employment agreement and the Beijing Sunshine agreement purportedly signed by him on 7 December 2005 was in August 2008 when an officer of the then Workplace Ombudsman gave them to him at his request. Mr Yuan believes that amendments were made to the documents signed by him after he had signed them; (b)The first time that Mr Shen saw the Chinese version of the employment agreement purportedly signed by him on 25 August 2006 was on 3 December 2007 when an inspector from the then Workplace Ombudsman showed it to him. Mr Shen noted that there were differences between the two documents; (c)The first time that Mr Hang saw the Chinese version of the employment agreement purportedly signed by him on 21 April 2006 was on 5 December 2007 when an inspector from the then Workplace Ombudsman showed it to him. Mr Hang noted that, whilst it looked similar to the one he had signed in China, there were differences. The material terms of each Employee’s contract of employment included terms that:(a) the Employee would be paid a wage or salary expressed in RMB:(A) in Yuan’s case a base annual salary of 39,100 RMB; (B) in Zeng’s case 3,600 RMB per month; (C) in Hang’s case 120 RMB per day; (D) in Guo’s case 120 RMB per day; and(E) in Shen’s case 3,600 RMB per month. (b)Messrs Yuan, Zeng and Hang would be paid monthly; (c)the Employee would work nine hours per day, six days per week, plus overtime as required; (d)overtime would be paid after nine hours on any day Monday – Saturday and for all hours worked on Sunday in cash at the rate of $20 for six hours or 20 RMB per hour; (e)food, accommodation, medical expenses, the cost of the visa to Australia and translation services would be paid by Kentwood, not by the Employee.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The FCR for post judgment interest by O 35 r 8 provides:8 Interest on judgmentThe prescribed rate at which interest is payable under paragraph 52 (2) (a) of the Act is:(a)in respect of the period from 1 January to 30 June in any year — the rate that is 6% above the cash rate last published by the Reserve Bank of Australia before that period commenced; and(b)in respect of the period from 1 July to 31 December in any year — the rate that is 6% above the cash rate last published by the Reserve Bank of Australia before that period commenced.Note Subsection 52 (2) of the Act provides that interest is payable:(a)at such rate as is fixed by the Rules of Court; or(b)if the Court, in a particular case, thinks that justice so requires — at such lower rate as the Court determines. In my view the appropriate rate at which interest should accrue post judgment is 10.5% per annum. However, different considerations govern the rate of interest in these two situations. A higher rate post judgment operates as an incentive for satisfying the judgment. Prior to judgment there may be many variables including delay, for which the judgment debtor may not be totally responsible. I consider 6% is a more appropriate figure and in the minute of orders that I will ask the applicant to prepare, the calculation of interest up until judgment should be computed at 6% per annum or 0.0164383% per day. PENALTY Subsection 719(1) of the WR Act enables the Court to impose a penalty in respect of a contravention of an applicable provision by a person bound by the provision. Relevantly, ‘applicable provision’ is defined to include:(a) a term of the Standard; and(b) a term of a collective agreement. Pursuant to cl 31 of Sch 8, on 27 March 2006, the NAPSA came into operation. Under cl 43 of Sch 8, a term of the NAPSA may be enforced as if it were a term of a collective agreement, and therefore an ‘applicable provision’ for the purposes of s 719(1). Subsection 719(2) provides that where two or more contraventions of an applicable provision are committed by the same person, and the contraventions arose out of a course of conduct by the person, the contraventions shall, for the purposes of s 719, be taken to constitute a single contravention of the provision. Pursuant to s 719(4)(b), the maximum penalty that may be imposed by the Court on Kentwood in respect of each of the contraventions is 300 penalty units. The maximum penalty that may be imposed on Mr Zhang in respect of each of the contraventions is 60 penalty units. A penalty unit is separately defined under s 4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) to be $110. Accordingly, the maximum penalty that may be imposed by this Court for each contravention of the Standard or the NAPSA by Kentwood is $33,000, and for each contravention of the Standard or the NAPSA by Mr Zhang is $6,600.A Structured Approach for the Court in Determining Penalty The applicant submits that the Court should take a four step approach to determining an appropriate penalty. 1.First, each contravention of each separate obligation sourced in the Standard or the NAPSA is a separate contravention of an applicable provision for the purposes of s 719 of the WR Act. However, pursuant to ss 719(2), a court may treat multiple contraventions of the same applicable provision as a single contravention, if the Court considers them to be part of a single ‘course of conduct’. It is then necessary to identify the maximum penalty for each separate contravention.2.Second, it is necessary next to consider an appropriate penalty to impose in respect of each contravention (whether a single contravention alone or as part of a course of conduct), having regard to all of the circumstances of the case.3.Next, to the extent that two or more contraventions have common elements, this may be taken into account in considering what is an appropriate penalty in all the circumstances for each contravention. The respondents should not be penalised more than once for the same conduct. The penalties imposed by the Court should be an appropriate response to the respondents’ actions. 4.Finally, having fixed an appropriate penalty for each separate contravention, group of contraventions or course of conduct, a final review of the aggregate penalty is necessary to determine whether it is an appropriate response to the conduct which led to the contraventions. Put another way, a court may apply an overall ‘instinctive synthesis’ (Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560 at [46] per Graham J). Identifying the contraventions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows that Mr Zhang was involved in Kentwood’s contraventions of the NAPSA and the Standard.ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS In addition to the imposition of a penalty, relief sought by the applicant in these proceedings includes:(a)Declarations that Kentwood and Mr Zhang committed those breaches found by the Court to have occurred.(b)Orders to the direct benefit of the Employees who have suffered detriment by the respondents’ acts and omissions, remedying the detriment to the extent of the respective underpayments;(c)Ancillary relief for the payment of pre-judgment interest on the amounts of the respective underpayments; and(d) Costs. Section 719 and s 722 of the WR Act provide:719 Imposition and recovery of penalties(1)An eligible court may impose a penalty in accordance with this Division on a person if:(a)the person is bound by an applicable provision; and(b)the person breaches the provision.(2) Subject to subsection (3), where:(a)2 or more breaches of an applicable provision are committed by the same person; and(b)the breaches arose out of a course of conduct by the person;the breaches shall, for the purposes of this section, be taken to constitute a single breach of the term.(3)Subsection (2) does not apply to a breach of an applicable provision that is committed by a person after an eligible court has imposed a penalty on the person for an earlier breach of the provision.(4)The maximum penalty that may be imposed under subsection (1) for a breach of an applicable provision is:(a)60 penalty units for an individual; or(b)300 penalty units for a body corporate.(5)If, in a proceeding under this section in relation to an AWA, it appears to the eligible court that a party to the AWA has suffered loss or damage as a result of a breach of the AWA by the other party, the court may order the other party to pay the amount of the loss or damage to the first‑mentioned party.(6)Where, in a proceeding against an employer under this section, it appears to the eligible court that an employee of the employer has not been paid an amount that the employer was required to pay under an applicable provision (except a term of an AWA), the court may order the employer to pay to the employee the amount of the underpayment.(7)Where, in a proceeding against an employer under this section, it appears to the eligible court that the employer has not paid an amount to a superannuation fund that the employer was required, under an applicable provision (except a term of an AWA), to pay on behalf of a person, the court may order the employer to make a payment to or in respect of that person for the purpose of restoring the person, as far as practicable, to the position that the person would have been in had the employer not failed to pay the amount to the superannuation fund.(8)Without limiting the generality of subsection (7), the eligible court may order that the employer pay to the superannuation fund referred to in subsection (7), or another superannuation fund, an amount equal to the amount (in this subsection called the unpaid amount) that the employer failed to pay together with such additional amount as, in the opinion of the court, represents the return that would have accrued in respect of the unpaid amount had it been duly paid by the employer.(9)An order must not be made under subsection (6) or (7) in relation to so much of an underpayment as relates to any period more than 6 years before the commencement of the proceeding.10)A proceeding under this section in relation to a breach of an applicable provision must be commenced not later than 6 years after the commission of the breach.722 Interest up to judgment(1)In exercising its powers under subsection 719(5) or (6) or in a proceeding under section 720 or 721, the eligible court must, upon application, unless good cause is shown to the contrary, either:(a)order that there be included in the sum for which an order is made or judgment given, interest at such rate as the Court or court of competent jurisdiction, as the case may be, thinks fit on the whole or any part of the money for the whole or any part of the period between the date when the cause of action arose and the date on which the order is made or judgment entered; or(b)without proceeding to calculate interest in accordance with paragraph (a), order that there be included in the sum for which an order is made or judgment given, a lump sum instead of any such interest.(2) Subsection (1) does not:(a)authorise the giving of interest upon interest or of a sum instead of such interest; or(b)apply in relation to any debt upon which interest is payable as of right whether by virtue of an agreement or otherwise; or(c)authorise the giving of interest, or a sum instead of interest, otherwise than by consent, upon any sum for which judgment is given by consent.DECLARATION