Fair Work Ombudsman v A To Z Catering Solution Pty Limited (No.3)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v A TO Z CATERING SOLUTION PTY LIMITED & ANOR (No.3) [2018] FCCA 3574
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Assessment of pecuniary penalties for contraventions of provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) – grouping of contraventions – whether s.557(1) of the FW Act is first applied to multiple contraventions before s.556 of the FW Act – pecuniary penalties assessed.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.44, 45, 90(2), 125, 323(1)(a), 417, 421, 535, 536, 539, 546, 556, 557(1)
Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth), r.3.44
Registered and Licensed Clubs Awards 2010, cl.17, 23.2, 29.1, 29.4(a), 30(2)

Cases cited:

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue [2009] HCA 41
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union & Ors (The Australian Paper Case)(No.2) [2017] FCA 367
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (the BKH Contractors Case) (No.2) [2018] FCA 1563
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Huddy(No.2) [2017] FCA 1088
Contin v The Queen [2012] VSCA 247
Director Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2015] FCAFC 59
Fair Work Ombudsman v A to Z Catering Solution Pty Limited & Anor (No.2) [2018] FCCA 2299
Fair Work Ombudsman v Australian Wild Tuna Pty Ltd & Anor [2016] FCCA 2626
Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No.3) [2011] FCA 579
Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr [2018] FCA 5
Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd trading as New Shanghai Charlestown [2017] FCA 1301
Flight Centre Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No.2) [2018] FCAFC 53
Gibbs v City of Altona [1992] FCA 374
In Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Upton (The Gorgon Project Case) (No.2) [2018] FCA 897
Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080
Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7
Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan [2008] FCAFC 70
R v Holder (1983) 3 NSWLR 245
Rocky Holdings Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2014] FCAFC 62

Applicant: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
First Respondent: A TO Z CATERING SOLUTION PTY LIMITED (No.2)
Second Respondent: MOHAMMED MOSEEM YASIN
File Number: SYG 3448 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Manousaridis
Hearing date: 9 November 2018
Date of Last Submission: 9 November 2018
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 7 December 2018

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Easton
Solicitors for the Applicant: Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Second Respondents: Mr I Latham
Solicitors for the Second Respondents: Segelov Taylor Lawyers
No appearance by the first respondent

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

  1. The second respondent was involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of s.45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay at least 11 hours’ worth of Late Work to Ms Chalker during the period…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v A To Z Catering Solution Pty Limited (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 3574
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned the assessment of pecuniary penalties for contraventions of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth) and the *Fair Work Regulations 2009* (Cth). The applicant, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO), sought penalties against the first respondent, A To Z Catering Solution Pty Limited (AZC), and the second respondent, Mr Yasin, who was found to be involved in AZC's contraventions. The court had previously made declarations that AZC, and Mr Yasin by his involvement, had contravened various sections of the FW Act and FW Regulations, including provisions relating to payment of wages and record-keeping. The court was required to determine the appropriate pecuniary penalties for these contraventions.

The legal issues before the court were primarily concerned with the methodology for assessing pecuniary penalties, particularly in circumstances involving multiple contraventions. This included considering whether section 557 of the FW Act, which allows for the aggregation of contraventions arising out of a course of conduct, should be applied before or in conjunction with other penalty assessment principles. The court also needed to determine the maximum penalty units applicable to each contravention, taking into account the relevant penalty unit value at the time of the contraventions and any legislative amendments.

In determining the penalties, the court adopted an approach previously accepted in *Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd trading as New Shanghai Charlestown*. This approach involved identifying separate contraventions, considering whether to deal with them independently or aggregate them under s 557 of the FW Act, adjusting for any overlap to avoid double penalties, assessing penalties for each group of contraventions in isolation, and finally applying the totality principle to ensure the overall penalties were appropriate and proportionate to the conduct viewed as a whole. The court also confirmed the maximum penalty units for each contravention and the value of a penalty unit at the relevant time, which was $170.

The court made declarations that Mr Yasin was involved in contraventions of sections 44, 45, 323, 535, and 536 of the FW Act, and regulations 3.44(1) and 3.44(6) of the FW Regulations. It also made an additional declaration that Mr Yasin was involved in AZC's contravention of section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay Ms Chalker for at least 11 hours of late work. The court proceeded to consider the assessment of pecuniary penalties based on these declarations and the established methodology.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before I consider that question, I should note that after I made the Declarations the applicant (FWO) filed short submissions in which she submitted that, given the findings I made in my reasons for judgment I published on 24 August 2018 (earlier judgment),[1] I should also have made a declaration to the following effect:The second respondent was involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay at least 11 hours’ worth of Late Work to Ms Chalker during the period 1 December 2013 to 23 April 2014, in accordance with clause 29.4(a) of the Registered and Licensed Clubs Award 2010.[1] Fair Work Ombudsman v A to Z Catering Solution Pty Limited & Anor (No.2) [2018] FCCA 2299 Mr Yasin does not submit a declaration to this effect would not reflect findings I made in the earlier judgment. I am satisfied that my making a declaration to the effect proposed by the FWO would reflect findings I made in the earlier judgment, and I propose, therefore, to make such declaration at the time I publish these reasons. In these reasons for judgment, therefore, I will proceed on the basis that Mr Yasin contravened the provisions identified in the Declarations and the declaration I propose to make when I publish these reasons. Under s.546(1) of the FW Act this Court may, on application, order a person to pay a pecuniary penalty the Court considers is appropriate if the Court is satisfied the person has contravened a civil remedy provision. Under s.546(2) of the FW Act the pecuniary penalty the Court may impose must not, where the person is an individual, be more than “the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in subsection 539(2).” The maximum penalty units specified in the table in s.539(2) of the FW Act for the contraventions of each of s.44, s.45 and s.323 of the FW Act at the relevant time was 60 penalty units, and the maximum penalty units for contraventions of s.535 and s.536 of the FW Act was 30 penalty units.[2] By the combined operation of s.539(3) of the FW Act and reg.4.01A(1) and reg.4.01A(2) of the FW Regulations, the maximum penalty units for each contravention of reg.3.44(1) and reg.3.44(6) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) is 20 penalty units. Under s.12 of the FW Act, “penalty unit” has the meaning given by s.4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). For the period that is relevant to these reasons for judgment, $170 was the “penalty unit” provided for by s.4AA.[2] Section 539(2) was amended by the Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth) where the penalty units for contravention of s.535 and s.536 were increased from 30 to 60 In her written submissions the FWO referred to the approach for assessing penalties Bromwich J in Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd trading as New Shanghai Charlestown accepted as correct:[3](1)Identify the separate contraventions, with each breach of each obligation being a separate contravention, and each breach of a term of the Award being a separate contravention.(2)Consider whether each separate contravention should be dealt with independently or with some degree of aggregation for those contraventions arising out of a course of conduct, noting that s 557 of the FW Act provides that two or more contraventions of a given civil remedy provision are to be taken to be a single contravention if committed by the same person and arising out of a course of conduct by that person. (3)Consider whether there should be further adjustment to ensure that, to the extent of any overlap between groups of separate aggregated contraventions, there is no double penalty imposed, and that the penalty is an appropriate response to what each respondent did. (4)Consider the appropriate penalty in respect of each final individual group of contraventions, taken in isolation.(5)Consider the overall penalties arrived at, including by reference to those which may be proposed by the FWO (as permitted by Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; 258 CLR 482 (CFMEU Civil Penalties Case) at [64]) and what is proposed by the respondents, and apply the totality principle, to ensure that the penalties for each respondent are appropriate and proportionate to the conduct viewed as a whole, making such adjustments as are necessary: see Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080; 166 IR 14 at [30]; Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8; 165 FCR 560 at [23] [71] and [102]. [3] [2017] FCA 1301, at [36]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 24 August 2018 I made declarations (Declarations) that the second respondent, Mr Yasin, was involved in a number of contraventions by the first respondent (AZC) of s.44, s.45, s.323, s.535, and s.536 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), and of reg.3.44(1) and reg.3.44(6) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) (FW Regulations). In these reasons for judgment I consider the question of penalties. Before I consider that question, I should note that after I made the Declarations the applicant (FWO) filed short submissions in which she submitted that, given the findings I made in my reasons for judgment I published on 24 August 2018 (earlier judgment),[1] I should also have made a declaration to the following effect:The second respondent was involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay at least 11 hours’ worth of Late Work to Ms Chalker during the period 1 December 2013 to 23 April 2014, in accordance with clause 29.4(a) of the Registered and Licensed Clubs Award 2010.[1] Fair Work Ombudsman v A to Z Catering Solution Pty Limited & Anor (No.2) [2018] FCCA 2299 Mr Yasin does not submit a declaration to this effect would not reflect findings I made in the earlier judgment. I am satisfied that my making a declaration to the effect proposed by the FWO would reflect findings I made in the earlier judgment, and I propose, therefore, to make such declaration at the time I publish these reasons. In these reasons for judgment, therefore, I will proceed on the basis that Mr Yasin contravened the provisions identified in the Declarations and the declaration I propose to make when I publish these reasons. Under s.546(1) of the FW Act this Court may, on application, order a person to pay a pecuniary penalty the Court considers is appropriate if the Court is satisfied the person has contravened a civil remedy provision. Under s.546(2) of the FW Act the pecuniary penalty the Court may impose must not, where the person is an individual, be more than “the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in subsection 539(2).” The maximum penalty units specified in the table in s.539(2) of the FW Act for the contraventions of each of s.44, s.45 and s.323 of the FW Act at the relevant time was 60 penalty units, and the maximum penalty units for contraventions of s.535 and s.536 of the FW Act was 30 penalty units.[2] By the combined operation of s.539(3) of the FW Act and reg.4.01A(1) and reg.4.01A(2) of the FW Regulations, the maximum penalty units for each contravention of reg.3.44(1) and reg.3.44(6) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) is 20 penalty units. Under s.12 of the FW Act, “penalty unit” has the meaning given by s.4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). For the period that is relevant to these reasons for judgment, $170 was the “penalty unit” provided for by s.4AA.[2] Section 539(2) was amended by the Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth) where the penalty units for contravention of s.535 and s.536 were increased from 30 to 60