Background
Background to the litigation
This judgment concerns the appropriate penalty to be imposed for admitted fair work contraventions by the respondents in relation to the Compliance Notices. BACKGROUNDDocuments before the Court This matter has a lengthy procedural history. While the Court is reluctant to “copy and paste” large sections of the pleadings filed in a matter, sometimes doing so is helpful. This approach is particularly useful when, as here, the Respondents failed to attend either the default hearing or the penalty hearing. In this matter, the relevant pleadings outline the nature of the contraventions and detail a failure on the part of the Respondents to engage with the Applicant, the Court and, indeed their own lawyers (despite the best efforts of those lawyers). The Respondents were represented by Ryan & Durey Solicitors from 11 January 2021 to 18 June 2021. The only document the Respondents filed was a Response dated 25 January 2021. This was filed whilst the Respondents were legally represented. Their solicitors were removed as solicitors on 18 June 2021. The materials relied on for the purposes of this judgment are thus limited to: (a)an Application and a Statement of Claim filed on behalf of the Applicant on 15 October 2020;(b)two affidavits of service of Cheryl Lorraine Harrison sworn and filed on behalf of the Applicant on 26 October 2020;(c)a Response filed on behalf of the Respondents on 25 January 2021;(d)a Notice of Withdrawal of Solicitor filed on behalf of the Respondents on 18 June 2021;(e)an Application in a Case for Default Judgment and supporting affidavit of Sara Anicic affirmed and filed on behalf of the Applicant on 23 July 2021;(f)an affidavit of service of Dawn Plenk affirmed and filed on behalf of the Applicant on 30 July 2020;(g)written submissions filed on behalf of the Applicant on 8 September 2021;(h)an affidavit of Jodi Lee Gribben affirmed and filed on behalf of the Applicant on 8 September 2021; (i)an affidavit of Jodi Lee Gribben affirmed and filed on behalf of the Applicant on 27 October 2021; and(j)email correspondence tendered by the Applicant at the penalty hearing comprising an email from the Australian Government Solicitor to the known email addresses of the Respondents dated 11 August 2021 attaching a letter of even date and an email from the Australian Government Solicitor to the known email addresses of the Respondents dated 28 October 2021 attaching a letter of even date (together marked as Exhibit 1).The Contraventions and Compliance Notices By way of background, the Court notes the contents of the Statement of Claim filed on 15 October 2020. That document details the relevant contraventions under section 716(5) of the FW Act. It notes, relevantly, that from July 2019 to January 2020, Fair Work Inspector Jodi Gribben (“FWI Gribben”) undertook an investigation into the First Respondent’s compliance with Commonwealth workplace laws (the “First Investigation”). The particulars of the First Investigation are then detailed in the Statement of Claim as follows: PARTICULARSThe First Investigation commenced following requests for assistance made to the Applicant from employees of the First Respondent, including Clive Munn and Toni Simpson (the First Compliance Notice Employees).6.During the course of the First Investigation, FWI Gribben had a telephone conversation with, or corresponded with, the Second Respondent in relation to some or all of the First Compliance Notice Employees.7.As a result of the First Investigation, FWI Gribben formed a reasonable belief, within the meaning of section 716(1) of the FW Act, that at all relevant times:(a)the Restaurant Industry Award 2010 (the Award) covered and applied to the First Respondent in respect to the employment of the First Compliance Notice Employees;(b)during the period between 19 June 2017 and 8 June 2019 the First Respondent employed Clive Munn (the Munn Period);(c)during the Munn Period, Clive Munn performed work as a cook for the First Respondent on a full-time basis, specifically as a Cook Grade 5 under the Classification Structure in Schedule A to the Award;(d)during the period between 9 December 2017 and 25 November 2018 the First Respondent employed Toni Simpson (the Simpson Period);(e)during the Simpson Period, Toni Simpson performed work as Food and Beverage Attendant on a casual basis, specifically as a Food and Beverage Attendant Grade 2 under the Classification Structure in Schedule A to the Award;(f) the First Respondent failed to pay Clive Munn:(i)his annual leave entitlements accrued during his period of employment upon cessation of his employment with the First Respondent;(ii)the minimum rate of pay applicable to him under the Award for overtime worked;(iii)the minimum rate of pay applicable to him under the Award for ordinary hours worked on a public holiday;(g) the First Respondent failed to pay Toni Simpson:(i)the minimum casual rate of pay applicable to her under the Award;(ii)the minimum rate of pay applicable to her under the Award for ordinary hours worked on a Saturday and Sunday; and(iii)the minimum rate of pay applicable to her under the Award for ordinary hours worked on a public holiday.8.By reason of the matters pleaded in paragraph 7 above, FWI Gribben formed a reasonable belief, within the meaning of section 716(1) of the FW Act, that the First Respondent had contravened the following in respect of the First Compliance Notice Employees in respect of the Munn Period and Simpson Period:(a)Clause 34.1 – failing to pay the First Compliance Notice Employees their applicable rates for ordinary hours worked on a public holiday;(b)Section 90(2) of the FW Act and clause 35.2(b) – failing to pay Clive Munn accrued untaken annual leave entitlements on termination of his employment;(c)Clauses 33.1(a), 33.2(a), 33.2(b), and 33.2(c) – failing to pay Clive Munn his applicable overtime rates (150% for the first two hours and 200% thereafter for overtime worked on a weekday, 175% for the first two hours and 200% thereafter for overtime worked on Saturdays and 200% for overtime work on a Sunday);(d)Clauses 13.1 and 20 – failing to pay Toni Simpson her applicable base rate and 25% casual loading; and(e)Clause 34.1 – failing to pay Toni Simpson her applicable penalty rate of 150% for ordinary hours worked on a Saturday and Sunday.(together, the First Compliance Notice Entitlements).The First Compliance Notice9.On 21 January 2020, FWI Gribben gave the First Respondent a notice pursuant to section 716(2) of the FW Act (the First Compliance Notice) by:(a)posting the First Compliance Notice to the registered office of the First Respondent located at [omitted] (the Registered Office); and(b)sending an email to the Second Respondent at [omitted] and attaching a copy of the First Compliance Notice.10.The First Compliance Notice was delivered to the Registered Office on 23 January 2020.11.Pursuant to section 716(2) of the FW Act, the First Compliance Notice required the First Respondent to:(a)remedy the direct effects of the contraventions pleaded at paragraph 8 above by 14 February 2020 by taking the following specified action in respect of the First Compliance Notice Employees (the First Specified Action):(i)identify the number of hours (the Hours) worked by each First Compliance Notice Employee during their employment periods in respect of which the First Compliance Notice Entitlements were required to be paid under the Award;(ii) identify the amount the First Respondent paid to each First Compliance Notice Employee during their employment periods in respect of the First Compliance Notice Entitlements (having regard to the Hours, where applicable);(iii) calculate the amount the First Respondent should have paid each First Compliance Notice Employees during their employment periods in respect of the First Compliance Notice Entitlements (having regard to the Hours, where applicable);(iv)make a payment to each First Compliance Notice Employee of the difference between the amounts identified by the actions in paragraphs 11(a)(ii) and 11(a)(iii) above;(v)make a record of the information and amounts identified as a result of the actions in paragraphs 11(a)(i) to 11(a)(iii) above and the amount of payment identified as a result of paragraph 11(a)(iv) above;(vi)calculate and pay any additional superannuation contributions required by clause 30.2 of the Award in respect of the amounts required to be paid to the First Compliance Notice Employees by the First Respondent as a result of the steps taken at paragraphs 11(a)(i) to 11(a)(v) above to the Superannuation Fund chosen by each of the First Compliance Notice Employees; and(b)produce to the Applicant reasonable evidence of its compliance with the First Compliance Notice by producing a schedule of underpayments and proof that full payment was made to the First Compliance Notice Employees by 21 February 2020.12.The First Compliance Notice met the requirements of section 716(3) of the FW Act.13.On 11 February 2020, FWI Gribben reminded the First Respondent of the due date for compliance with the First Compliance Notice by sending an email to the First Respondent at [omitted] attaching a copy of the First Compliance Notice. The email address of [omitted] is listed on the First Respondent’s website at [omitted] under the ‘Contact’ tab.Failure to comply with the First Compliance Notice14. The First Respondent did not:(a) take the First Specified Action by 14 February 2020 or at all; or(b)produce to the Applicant any evidence of compliance with the First Compliance Notice by 21 February 2020 or at all.15.By reason of the matters pleaded in paragraph 14 above, the First Respondent failed to comply with the First Compliance Notice and thereby contravened section 716(5) of the FW Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
A brief Response was then filed on 25 January 2021. As the relevant contraventions are now deemed to have been admitted it is not necessary to outline the contents of that document in detail. What is noted, however, is that it is evident from the filing of this document that the Respondents did initially attempt to engage with the Applicant and, as will be discussed below, this is relevant, to some extent, to the issue of penalty. Further, it is noted that, in the Response, although the Respondents dispute ever having received the First Compliance Notice and Second Compliance Notice, they did agree to the making of various orders sought by the Applicant.Application in a Case for Default Judgment On 15 June 2021, chambers received email correspondence from the Applicant’s representative which stated that the parties had been unable to reach agreement on any statement of agreed facts (as required by order 2 of the orders made by this Court on 11 May 2021) as “the Respondents’ legal representatives had been unable to obtain instructions from the Respondents in relation to which matters the Respondents would or would not agree to”. The Applicant's representative also noted that the Respondent’s legal representative had advised that they would no longer act for the Respondents. The Applicant’s representative also indicated that they would seek to confer with the Respondents directly once their legal representatives were no longer acting. On 18 June 2021, the Respondents’ representative filed a notice of withdrawal of lawyer on behalf of the Respondents. On 23 July 2021, the Applicant’s representative contacted Chambers and advised that they had written directly to the Respondents on 23 June 2021. It was noted that, at the time of writing, the Respondents had not returned a signed statement of agreed facts or filed and served a defence. The Applicant’s representative also noted it had not received any communication from the Respondents to correspondence from the Applicant dated 23 June 2021 (or at all). The Applicant’s representative foreshadowed the filing of an application in a case and supporting affidavit for default judgement to be entered against the Respondents. That application in a case and a supporting affidavit were filed on 23 July 2021. It is evident that, after filing their Response on 25 January 2021, the Respondents basically ceased engaging with the Applicants or their own lawyers. As noted above, this failure to engage lead the Applicant to file an application in a case for default judgment dated 23 July 2021. The application for default judgment was accompanied by an affidavit of Sara Anicic affirmed 23 July 2021. Relevantly, that affidavit outlines the Applicant’s attempts to liaise with the Respondents (and their solicitors) and the service of documents generally. Relevantly, it provides:5.On 24 October 2020, Dingwall Hilder Nominees Pty Ltd and Ms Hilder were served by a process server handing the Application and Statement of Claim dated 15 October 2020 to Ms Hilder, details of which are contained in the Affidavits of Cheryl Lorraine Harrison sworn and filed on 26 October 2020.History of proceedingsRespondents’ required to file a Defence and Response6.On 3 November 2020, the proceeding was listed for a directions hearing before Judge Kendall. I appeared for the Applicant via telephone and Ms Hilder appeared in person and on behalf of Dingwall Hilder Nominees Pty Ltd (with leave). At the directions hearing, Judge Kendall made orders that included requiring the Respondents to file and serve a Defence on or before 1 December 2020.7.On 3 December 2020, I received an email from Jarrod Ryan of Ryan & Durey Solicitors advising me that Ryan & Durey Solicitors had ‘just been instructed by the First and Second Respondents to represent them’, and were currently obtaining instructions. Mr Ryan requested the FWO's consent to an amended timetable for the filing of a Defence and Reply, stating that Ryan & Durey Solicitors can prepare consent orders if the FWO was agreeable to the dates proposed. Annexed and marked ‘SA-1’ is a copy of this email correspondence dated 3 December 2020.8.Over the course of 8 to 16 December 2020, I followed up Jarrod Ryan of Ryan & Durey Solicitors regarding the provision of consent orders in the terms described in his email of 3 December 2020. On 22 December 2020, Mr Ryan sent me an email stating that they had ‘finally received our cost agreement back and instructions to act’ and suggested a further amended timetable for the filing of a Defence and Reply. Annexed and marked ‘SA-2’ is the email correspondence between myself and Mr Ryan from 3 December 2020 to 22 December 2020 (without attachments). 9.On 11 January 2021, Ryan & Durey Solicitors filed Notices of Address for Service on behalf of the Respondents. 10.On 12 January 2021, the Court made orders by consent amending the timetable for the filing of a Defence and Reply. Order 1 required the Respondents to file and serve a Defence on or before 25 January 2021. 11. On 25 January 2021, the Respondents filed a Response.12.On 8 February 2021, I wrote to Ryan & Durey Solicitors. In that letter, I drew to the Respondents attention that the Respondents had failed to file a Defence. I also raised a number of matters that were set out in the Respondents’ Response that did not enable the FWO to understand the Respondents’ position. I requested that the Respondents file a Defence by 17 February 2021 if the Respondents denied any of the allegations contained in the Statement of Claim. Annexed and marked ‘SA-3’ is a copy of the letter dated 8 February 2021. 13.On 17 February 2021, Alyce Cassettai of Ryan & Durey Solicitors sent me an email stating that they had ‘been unable to obtain instructions’ and were ‘endeavouring to obtain instructions’ in order to respond to our letter dated 8 February 2021 and would do so once they had instructions. Annexed and marked ‘SA-4’ is a copy of the email correspondence dated 17 February 2021.14.On 18 February 2021, I corresponded with Alyce Cassettai of Ryan & Durey Solicitors, seeking the Respondents’ response to the matters outlined in my letter dated 8 February 2021 (referred to in paragraph 12 above). 15.I did not receive a response to the matters outlined in my letter dated 8 February 2021.16.On 9 March 2021, the Court made orders by consent amending the timetable for the filing of a Defence and Reply. Order 2 required the Respondents to file and serve a Defence on or before 25 March 2021. 17.On the same day, Ryan & Durey Solicitors emailed me a letter dated 9 March 2021. In that letter, Ryan & Durey Solicitors stated that their “client will proceed with the ... proceedings without opposition" and that, as such, “the Respondents consent to each of declarations sought in paragraph 29 of the Statement of Claim”. Annexed and marked ‘SA-5’ is a copy of the letter dated 9 March 2021. Attempts to agree to Statement of Agreed Facts18.On 18 March 2021, I sent a letter enclosing a draft Statement of Agreed Facts and draft consent orders to Ryan & Durey Solicitors. I requested that Ryan & Durey Solicitors advise us if any amendments were sought to the draft Statement of Agreed Facts and draft consent orders or, if no amendments were sought, to return the signed Statement of Agreed Facts and consent orders on or before 29 March 2021. Annexed and marked ‘SA-6’ is a copy of the email correspondence and letter dated 18 March 2021 (without attachments).19.From 29 March 2021 to 28 April 2021, I corresponded with Ryan & Durey Solicitors to follow up on the Respondents’ position regarding the draft Statement of Agreed Facts and draft consent orders. On each occasion, I was advised by Ryan & Durey Solicitors that they were unable to obtain instructions from the Respondents. I also telephoned Ryan & Durey Solicitors on 28 April 2021 to follow up on the Respondent's .position and was advised by Alyce Cassettai that Ryan & Durey Solicitors were clarifying their client's instructions. Annexed and marked ‘SA-7’ is a copy of the email correspondence between 18 March 2021 and 28 April 2021.20.On 6 May 2021, following an email of 5 May 2021 to the parties from the Court, Ryan & Durey Solicitors emailed me stating that they were still unable to obtain instructions from the Respondents, but asked that I advise whether the FWO would be agreeable to amended draft consent orders. I responded on the same day, providing further amended draft consent orders and seeking the Respondents' consent to those orders by 7 May 2021. I did not receive a response regarding the amended draft consent orders.21.On 11 May 2021, Jarrod Ryan of Ryan & Durey Solicitors and I attended a directions hearing during which orders were made by Judge Kendall. Order 2 required the parties to file a Statement of Agreed Facts on or before 25 May 2021. 22.On 18 May 2021, I received an email from Jarrod Ryan of Ryan & Durey Solicitors stating that Ryan & Durey Solicitors were still finalising instructions but provided some comments to the draft Statement of Agreed Facts that were still subject to the Respondents' instructions. Annexed and marked ‘SA-8’ is a copy of the email correspondence dated 18 May 2021 (without attachment). 23.On 20 May 2021, I sent a letter to Ryan & Durey Solicitors advising of the FWO’s position in respect of the Respondents’ proposed amendments to the draft Statement of Agreed Facts and requested a response by 10am AWST on 24 May 2021 . Annexed and marked ‘SA-9’ is a copy of letter dated 20 May 2021.24.On 25 May 2021, I received an email from Alyce Cassettai of Ryan & Durey Solicitors stating that Ryan & Durey Solicitors were “endeavouring to speak to our client in order to obtain instructions to respond”. On 26 May 2021, I sent a letter to Ryan & Durey Solicitors following up a response to the draft Statement of Agreed Facts and requesting a response by 10am AWST on 3 June 2021. Annexed and marked ‘SA-10’ is a copy of the email correspondence dated 25 May 2021 and letter dated 26 May 2021.25.By telephone on 10 June 2021, Alyce Cassettai of Ryan & Durey Solicitors advised me of their intention to withdraw as solicitors.26. On 15 June 2021, I emailed Judge Kendall’s Chambers regarding the orders made by his Honour on 11 May 2021 and the status of the proceeding. Annexed and marked ‘SA-11’ is a copy of the email correspondence, and a subsequent exchange of 16 June 2021. Ryan & Durey Solicitors were copied into this email correspondence. 27.On 18 June 2021, Ryan & Durey Solicitors filed a Notice of Withdrawal as Lawyer on behalf of the Respondents. Attached to this notice was the Notice of Intention to Withdraw as Lawyer Ryan & Durey Solicitors stated they had served on the Respondents. That notice identified the following email and postal address of the Respondents, and gave the Respondents notice that the ·court and parties could use these addresses as their address for service, until they appointed another lawyer or fi led a Notice of Address for Service:Respondents' contact email: [omitted] and [omitted]. Respondents’ last known address: [omitted].Respondents’ last known address: [omitted].28.To date, the Respondents have not given notice that they have appointed another lawyer, and have not filed or served a Notice of Address for Service. Attempts to contact Respondents29.On 23 June 2021, I sent a letter to the Respondents setting out a summary of the recent events in the proceeding, enclosing prior correspondence with Ryan & Durey Solicitors, and requesting that the Respondents advise me of their position by 7 July 2021 by either returning a signed Statement of Agreed Facts or filing and serving a Defence. I sent the letter and its enclosures to the 2 email addresses listed in the Notice of Withdrawal as Lawyer dated 18 June 2021. Annexed and marked ‘SA-12’ is a copy of the email and letter dated 23 June 2021 (without attachments).30.I caused a copy of the letter dated 23 June 2021 and its enclosures to be express posted to the postal address listed in the Notice of Withdrawal as Lawyer dated 18 June 2021. The tracking number for that correspondence shows that it was delivered and left in a safe place on 24 June 2021. Annexed and marked ‘SA-13’ is a screenshot from the Australia Post website showing the tracking results for this correspondence.31.I also caused a copy of the letter dated 23 June 2021 and its enclosures to be express posted to [omitted]. This address is the registered office of Ink Rims Pty Ltd, a registered Australian proprietary company of which the Second Respondent is the sole director. The tracking number for that correspondence shows that it was delivered and left in a safe place on 24 June 2021. Annexed and marked ‘SA-14’ is a copy of a Company Extract Current & Historical for Ink Rims Pty Ltd dated 23 June 2021 and a screenshot from the Australia Post website showing the tracking results for the correspondence.32.As at the date of this affidavit, I have not received any communication from the Respondents in response to the letter dated 23 June 2021 or at all. 33. To my knowledge, the Respondents have not filed a Defence.34.I verily believe that the parties were not able to comply with order 2 of the orders of Judge Kendall dated 11 May 2021 (the May Orders) requiring the parties to file a Statement of Agreed Facts because Ryan & Durey Solicitors were unable to obtain instructions from the Respondents and, once the Respondents became self-represented, the Respondents did not respond to our letter dated 23 June 2021. In particular my belief is based on the following matters:34.1.I provided a draft Statement of Agreed Facts to Ryan & Durey Solicitors on 18 March 2021, as described in paragraph 18 above;34.2.The only substantive response I received was the one described in paragraph 22 above, which Ryan & Durey Solicitors stated was sent without confirming instructions from the Respondents;34.3.I further provided a copy of the draft Statement of Agreed Facts directly to the Respondents on 23 June 2021, as described in paragraphs 29-31 above, and to date have received no response.35.The FWO was granted leave to not comply with order 4 of the May Orders as set out in paragraph 26 above, and annexure SA-11.36.To my knowledge, the Respondents have not filed or served any evidence on which the Respondents propose to rely in accordance with order 4 of the May Orders.Default Judgment