Fair Work Ombudsman v Rundle trading as Porkys Garage
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
Fair Work Ombudsman v Rundle trading as Porkys Garage [2025] FedCFamC2G 994
File number(s):
ADG 240 of 2024
Judgment of:
JUDGE BROWN
Date of judgment:
30 June 2025
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – penalty hearing – failure to comply with compliance notice – respondent has failed to defend proceedings with due diligence – liability determined – underpayment of one employee – first time offender – lack of cooperation by the respondent – calculation of penalty – matters to be considered.
Legislation:
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 457, 545(1), 545(2), 546, 716(2), 716(5), 745(1).
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant
AND:
BRIAN THOMAS RUNDLE T/AS PORKYS GARAGE
Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE BROWN
DATE OF ORDER:
30 JUNE 2025
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
A.The Respondent contravened section 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”), by failing to comply with the Compliance Notice dated 18 September 2023.
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Pursuant to sections 545(1) and 545(2)(d) of the Act, Brian Thomas Rundle (“the Employer”) take the steps that were required by the Compliance Notice within 28 days of this order by:
(a)Calculating and paying to Michael hayward (“the Employee”) the outstanding entitlements it was required to by the Compliance Notice;
(b)Calculating and paying superannuation contributions into the Employee’s nominated superannuation fund for additional superannuation contributions required to be paid on the outstanding entitlements referred to in paragraph 1(a) of these Orders;
(c)Producing to the Applicant a schedule outlining the Employer’s calculation of the outstanding entitlements the Employer is required to pay the Employee and the superannuation contributions required to be paid to the Employee’s nominated superannuation fund referred to in paragraph 1(b) of these Orders; and
(d)Providing proof to the Applicant that the outstanding entitlements and additional superannuation contributions as set out in paragraphs 1(a) and 1(b) of these orders have been paid.
2.Pursuant to section…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Rundle trading as Porkys Garage and more:
In the case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Rundle trading as Porkys Garage, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) sought a default judgment against Brian Thomas Rundle, the owner of Porkys Garage, for failing to comply with a compliance notice issued under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The primary issue before the court was whether Mr Rundle had contravened the provisions of section 716(5) of the Act by not complying with a compliance notice to pay wages due to one of his employees, Michael Hayward. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate penalty for such a contravention.
Mr Rundle was alleged to have underpaid Mr Hayward, an apprentice mechanic, by not paying him the minimum wage, overtime, annual leave, and superannuation. The FWO argued that Mr Rundle, being a first-time offender, had failed to defend the proceedings with due diligence and had not cooperated in resolving the matter. The FWO sought a penalty within the range of 70% to 80% of the maximum penalty prescribed by the Act, which at the time of the contravention was $9,390.00.
The court found that Mr Rundle had been duly served with the application and had notice of the proceedings but had not participated in the case. The court noted that despite multiple attempts by the FWO to contact Mr Rundle and provide him with the opportunity to respond, he had made no efforts to defend himself or comply with the court's orders. Based on the evidence, the court concluded that Mr Rundle had indeed contravened the Act and granted the FWO leave to enter a default judgment against him. The court also imposed a penalty within the range sought by the FWO, taking into account the nature of the contravention and the lack of cooperation by Mr Rundle.
In conclusion, the court found Mr Rundle liable for underpaying Mr Hayward and ordered him to pay the penalty, along with any other costs associated with the proceedings. The court highlighted the importance of employers complying with the Fair Work Act and the consequences of failing to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The Fair Work Ombudsman[1] commenced these proceedings against Brian Thomas Rundle,[2] on 1 July 2024, pursuant to the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).[3] In general terms, the FWO seeks the following:·Leave to enter default judgment against the respondent on the basis that he has neither defended the application brought against him with due diligence nor complied with orders of the Court requiring him to file documents.·The Court make a finding that Mr Rundle has contravened the provisions of section 716(5) of the FWA by failing to comply with a Compliance Notice that he calculate and then pay wages due to one of his employees, Michael Hayward;·Thereafter, the Court impose a penalty for that contravention pursuant to the civil remedy provisions of the Act.[1] Herein referred to as “the FWO” or “the Ombudsman”.[2] Hereinafter referred to as “Mr Rundle” or “the respondent”.[3] Hereinafter referred to as “the FWA” or “the Act”.BACKGROUND The FWO has a statutory responsibility for ensuring compliance, by employers for their relevant employees, with the industrial safety net, created by the Commonwealth Government, pursuant to the relevant provisions of the Act. Primarily, this objective is achieved through the enforcement of the system of minimum terms and conditions specified in the Modern Award System, created by the Act.[4][4] See FWA at section 3. The FWO is authorised to appoint Fair Work Inspectors to carry out its statutory obligations under the Act. In the current matter, such a Fair Work Inspector, Ms Marilyn Sturgeon, received a complaint from Mr Hayward that he had only been paid a total of $100.00 for 6 months of work whilst in the employ of Mr Rundle. Mr Rundle was, at the relevant times, a sole trader carrying on an automotive repair and maintenance business called Porkys Garage. It had premises in Pooraka, South Australia. Mr Rundle employed Mr Hayward between 5 September 2022 and 3 March 2023, a period just short of 6 months, as an apprentice. Mr Hayward worked as a mechanic and his employment was covered by the Vehicle Repair, Services and Retail Award 2020.[5][5] Hereinafter referred to as “the Award”. On 18 March 2023, after he had left the employ of Mr Rundle, Mr Hayward made a request for assistance to the FWO, alerting the Ombudsman that he had not been appropriately paid whilst in the employ of Mr Rundle and a Fair Work Inspector, Marilyn Sturgeon, was subsequently appointed to investigate the matter. Ultimately, this investigation led to the relevant Fair Work Inspector concluding as follows:·Mr Hayward had not been paid the minimum wage due to full time employment;·He had not been paid the minimum wage due to a full time first year apprentice;·He had not paid the amount due to him for working overtime hours;·He had not paid the amount due to him for accrued untaken annual leave on the termination of his employment; and·He had not appropriately paid into Mr Haywards nominated superannuation account.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
In the present matter, I am satisfied that Mr Rundle is in default and therefore the court can enter judgment against him as sought by the applicant. I am also satisfied that Mr Rundle has been put on notice that the FWO will be seeking a pecuniary penalty against him.THE EVIDENCE OF FWI STURGEON Mr Hayward approached the office of the FWO on 18 March 2023. He indicated that he started employment, as an adult apprentice on 4 September 2022, at Porky’s Garage. He indicated that he loved being an apprentice but had encountered difficulties in finding employment due to his deafness. He further indicated that he had made constant requests for payment of wages and his perception was that he was being taken advantage of. It would appear to be the case that he had earlier worked at Porky’s Garage at an earlier stage of his apprenticeship. The FWO categorised Mr Hayward as a vulnerable employee due to his mature years and disability. The absence of wages records and payslips was also noted as a concern. A business name search indicated that Mr Rundle was the proprietor of the business name Porky’s Garage. On 1 August 2023, FWI Sturgeon successfully contacted Mr Rundle to discuss Mr Hayward’s complaint directly with him. Mr Rundle confirmed that he was the sole proprietor of the business and Mr Hayward had been employed by him on the basis that he was an adult apprentice in the third year of a four year apprenticeship. Mr Rundle further indicated that his former partner (Julie) had been responsible for wages records through a MYOB system but the two of them had been involved in a messy divorce. He confirmed that Mr Hayward had, from time to time, utilised the assistance of an Auslan interpreter. In the record of interview between him and FWI Sturgeon, which occurred on 1 August 2023, Mr Rundle indicated the following:·He had agreed to pay Mr Hayward $24.00 per hour, which was slightly higher than the base rate;·Mr Hayward had worked Mondays to Fridays between 8.30 am and 5.00 pm;·Mr Hayward had worked one Saturday for 4.5 hours;·Mr Hayward had worked between 5 September 2022 and 3 March 2025;·Julie would have the correct records;·An Auslan interpreter had attended at his workshop to assist Mr Hayward in the required periodic assessment of his apprenticeship;·He had issued payslips but no payments had been made to Mr Hayward other than a trial payment of $100.00 which he had sent through his bank;·No superannuation guarantee payments had been made;·Mr Rundle was not aware how much he owed to Mr Hayward but Julie would know;·When FWI Sturgeon put it to him that it was 25 weeks at $24.00 per hour, the sum was likely to be $24,216.00, Mr Rundle agreed;·In these circumstances, Mr Rundle indicated his preference to obtain a loan to pay the sum in full to avoid the matter dragging on. It is evident from FWI Sturgeon’s evidence that this loan never materialised and, as a consequence, she elected to issue the relevant compliance notice on the basis of the information which had been provided to her. Thereafter, it would appear to be the case that there were a number of telephone conversations between her and Mr Rundle, in which he indicated that he had been in hospital due to internal bleeding and had nearly died.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The maximum penalty, prescribed by the Act, for a breach of section 716(5) of the Act is, at the time of the contravention, $9,390.00. The FWO submits that the appropriate penalty range, for the offending in this case, should fall between 70 to 80% of the maximum penalty – that is between $6,573.00 and $7,512.00.DEFAULT JUDGMENT The relevant rules of court – the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 – grant an applicant an option to commence proceedings by way of an application supported by either an affidavit of evidence or a statement of claim. On 1 July 2024, the FWO elected to file a statement of claim particularising how it was alleged Mr Rundle had contravened section 716(5) of the Act by failing to comply with the Compliance Notice issued by the relevant Fair Work Inspector. The relevant application statement of claim was personally served on Mr Rundle, on 5 July 2024 at the Ingle Farm Shopping Centre, in Ingle Farm.[7] The solicitor for the FWO provided with the statement of claim a letter which stated that the matter was to be first listed before the court on 3 October 2023.[7] See Affidavit of Matthews Stephens filed 22 July 2024 Axiomatically this date was erroneous, and the correct date was 3 October 2024. This was the date endorsed on the filing sheet that the court had attached to the relevant application which was filed with the statement of claim and enclosed in the correspondence served upon Mr Rundle. There is no evidence that Mr Rundle contacted the court to seek clarification in respect of the apparent discrepancy in the dates arising from what is, to my mind, an obvious typographical error. More significantly, on 24 September 2024, Mr McMillan sent an email to Mr Rundle confirming that the date was indeed 3 October 2024. Mr Rundle did not appear at court on 3 October 2024 and, in his absence, he was directed to file a notice of address for service with seven day of that date and a response and defence by 24 October 2024. In these circumstances, the case was adjourned until 4 December 2024. Again, Mr McMillan provided a copy of the relevant order to Mr Rundle at his email address and left a number of voice messages on his telephone service, which were not responded to. Mr McMillan also sought to contact Mr Rundle directly through the telephone number for Porky’s Garage – again to no avail.[8][8] See affidavit of Jonathon McMillan filed 16 December 2024 Mr Rundle has not filed the response required of him, nor has he made any other attempts to participate in any of the subsequent mentions of the matter or to take any active part in the proceedings. Accordingly, in a formal sense, his attitude towards the FWO’s application is not known. However, during a telephone call alleged to occur between Mr Rundle and Ms Sturgeon, he acknowledged that he owed Mr Hayward a sum of money; and that his preference was to pay this directly to him in a lump sum payment, rather than a payment plan.[9] I am satisfied that Mr Rundle has been served with the relevant application and has notice of it but has elected not to take part in the proceedings.[9] See Affidavit of Ms Marilyn Sturgeon (ibid)