BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Treby

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   BHP BILLITON IRON ORE PTY LTD -v- TREBY [2018] WASCA 60

CORAM:   BUSS P

MURPHY JA

CHANEY J

HEARD:   21 DECEMBER 2017

DELIVERED          :   3 MAY 2018

FILE NO/S:   CACV 14 of 2017

BETWEEN:   BHP BILLITON IRON ORE PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

LEE DIANE TREBY

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

For File No:   CACV 14 of 2017

Jurisdiction              :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   HERRON DCJ

File Number             :   APP 88 of 2015


Catchwords:

Workers compensation - Arbitration - Preference of one medical opinion over competing opinion - Whether open to arbitrator to rely on report - Whether basis of opinion sufficiently disclosed - Whether reliance on report rendered decision unreasonable or irrational

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1906 (WA)
Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA)
Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Arbitration Rules 2011 (WA)

Result:

Leave to appeal refused
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : Dr J T Schoombee & Mr J R Ludlow
Respondent : No appearance

Solicitors:

Appellant : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
Respondent : No appearance

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

A v Corruption and Crime Commissioner [2013] WASCA 288; (2013) 306 ALR 491

Atanasoska v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd [2009] WASCA 17

Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 139

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Brady [2008] WASCA 250

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Treby [2017] WADC 6

Makita (Aust) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48; (2010) 243 CLR 164

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611

Mitchell v Canal Rocks Beach Resort [2002] WASCA 331

Pacific Industrial Co v Jakovljevic [2008] WASCA 60

Pochi v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 36 FLR 482

Pollock v Wellington (1996) 15 WAR 1

Pownall v Conlan Management Pty Ltd (1995) 12 WAR 370

Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott [2016] HCA 22; (2016) 90 ALJR 679

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:

  1. On 21 October 2015, after a hearing in the Workers' Compensation Arbitration Service, the arbitrator, Mr B Nugawela, made orders that the appellant pay the respondent weekly payments of compensation for total incapacity with effect from 3 April 2014, together with statutory allowances in relation to the injury which the arbitrator found had been suffered at work by the respondent. The appellant sought leave to appeal against the arbitrator's decision pursuant to s 247 of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) (the Act). On 20 January 2017, the primary judge, Herron DCJ, refused leave to appeal.[1]  The appellant then brought this appeal pursuant to s 254 of the Act.  For the reasons that follow, leave to appeal should be refused, and the appeal dismissed.

    [1] BHP Billiton Iron Ore…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Treby and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASCA 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd was the appellant in the case against Treby, the respondent, which was heard in the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The primary dispute concerned the validity of an arbitrator’s decision on a workers' compensation claim, focusing on the arbitrator's reliance on the medical opinion of Mr Wong, a neurosurgeon, over that of Dr Flahive, an occupational physician, in determining the nature and cause of Treby's injury. The appellant argued that the arbitrator's decision was flawed because it improperly preferred Mr Wong’s report over Dr Flahive's and because the basis of Mr Wong’s opinion was not sufficiently disclosed. Additionally, the appellant contended that the reliance on Mr Wong's report rendered the arbitrator’s decision unreasonable or irrational.

The court examined whether the appeal to the primary judge involved a question of law or fact, particularly focusing on the arbitrator's application of the burden of proof and the probative value of the evidence. The appellant initially argued that the appeal involved a question of law based on administrative law principles, referencing several High Court decisions. However, in the course of the appeal, the appellant shifted its argument to focus on the proper application of the burden of proof by the arbitrator. The court needed to determine whether the primary judge correctly identified the nature of the appeal and whether the points raised by the appellant were meritorious.

The court concluded that the appeal did not fundamentally involve a question of law but rather a question of fact, as it pertained to the credibility of evidence and the arbitrator’s findings on the nature and cause of Treby's injury. The court held that the primary judge was correct in finding that the appeal involved a question of fact. Furthermore, the court found that the appellant’s arguments were unmeritorious because the arbitrator's findings were supported by the evidence, particularly the respondent’s testimony, which the arbitrator deemed credible. The court also noted that the arbitrator's reliance on Mr Wong's report was not improper, as the report provided a sufficient basis for the arbitrator's decision. The appeal was therefore dismissed.

The court made no further orders beyond dismissing the appeal, affirming the decision of the primary judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Nevertheless, the appellant contends that the appeal to this court relates to a question of law because, in substance (see [55] below), the appeal concerns the primary judge's failure to find that the arbitrator erred in law by accepting the evidence of the neurosurgeon, Mr Wong, over the evidence of Dr Flahive, an occupational physician, in the course of his fact‑finding as to the nature and cause of the respondent's injury.[51] In this regard, the appellant, in its written submissions, placed considerable reliance on administrative law principles.[52] In oral submissions before this court, counsel for the appellant appeared, however, to retreat from any reliance on administrative law principles.[53] Counsel for the appellant appeared, rather, to contend that the appeal to the primary judge involved a question of law because the appeal raised the issue of whether the burden of proof was applied 'properly' by reference to probative evidence.[54][51] The appellant did not take issue with the arbitrator's finding (at [32] above) that causation is established in the present context if the respondent's work duties were a material contributing factor to her injury.[52] Reference was made to a number of decisions in the administrative law context, including Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 249 CLR 332 and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48; (2010) 243 CLR 164. Reference was also made to Pochi v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 36 FLR 482.[53] Appeal ts 43 ‑ 44, 21 December 2017.[54] Appeal ts 35 ‑ 36, 41, 21 December 2017. The arbitrator's findings as to the nature and cause of the respondent's injury were not exclusively based on his review of the medical evidence, but also took into account the evidence given by the respondent (who was cross‑examined by the appellant) and who the arbitrator, in effect, accepted as a witness of truth (see [69] ‑ [70] below). The findings of fact[55] as to the asymptomatic nature of the respondent's condition prior to the commencement of her employment and the progressive worsening of her back pain up to the time of the report of the MRI on 19 March 2013 indicating an L4 inferior endplate fracture were effectively based on the arbitrator's assessment of the respondent's credibility. Appellate intervention in relation to such findings of fact, even in an appeal by way of rehearing, requires the appellant to demonstrate that the findings are flawed by reference to incontrovertible facts or uncontested testimony, that they are glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences, or that the tribunal of fact has failed to use, or has palpably misused, his or her advantage as the trier of fact.[56][55] Arbitrator's reasons [17].[56] Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott [2016] HCA 22; (2016) 90 ALJR 679 [43]. 'Properly analysed',[57] the appeal to the primary judge involved the question of whether the arbitrator erred in fact in his findings as to the nature of the respondent's injury and what caused it, in reliance on the evidence of Mr Wong and the respondent. The primary judge was correct to conclude that, in substance, the appeal did not involve a question of law.[58] However, even if the appeal to the primary judge involved a question of law or questions of law, the substance of the points raised by the appellant before the primary judge, and on appeal in this court, are unmeritorious for the reasons given below. [57] See Atanasoska v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd [21] referred to in [41] above.[58] BHP Billiton Oil Pty Ltd v Treby [96].