South Metropolitan Health Service v Jones

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   SOUTH METROPOLITAN HEALTH SERVICE -v- JONES [2024] WADC 44

CORAM:   CURWOOD DCJ

HEARD:   18 JANUARY 2024

DELIVERED          :   7 JUNE 2024

FILE NO/S:   APP 40 of 2023

BETWEEN:   SOUTH METROPOLITAN HEALTH SERVICE

Appellant

AND

CHRISTINE JONES

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   WORKERS' COMPENSATION ARBITRATION SERVICE (WA)

Coram:   ARBITRATOR SMITH

File Number            :   A111566


Catchwords:

Workers' compensation - Appeal from arbitrator - Alleged error of law by arbitrator's failure to  provide adequate reasons for decision - Arbitrator's reasons were adequate in all of the circumstances - No error of law - Appeal dismissed

Legislation:

Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA)

Result:

Leave to appeal refused
Appeal dismissed

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : Mr P E Jarman
Respondent : Mr D R Clyne

Solicitors:

Appellant : Jarman Legal
Respondent : Simon Walters

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Amaca Pty Ltd v Werfel [2020] SASCFC 125

Atanasoska v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd [2009] WASCA 17

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Brady [2008] WASCA 250

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Treby [2018] WASCA 60

Browne v Browne [2019] WASCA 1

Department of Education v Azmitia [2015] WASCA 246

DL v The Queen (2018) 266 CLR 1

Dodson v Woolworths Group Limited [2020] WADC 157

Duluxgroup (Australia) Pty Ltd v Chapple [2023] WASCA 83

Engine Protection Equipment Pty Ltd v Miller [2018] WASCA 55, 20

Ewart v Caruso [2013] WASCA 266

Gordon v Ross [2006] NSWCA 157

Greenslade v Hiew [2022] WASCA 47

Hawker Pacific Pty Ltd v Lang [2015] WASCA 256

Hunter v Transport Accident Commission & Michael Avalanche [2005] VSCA 1

Lloyd v Faraone [1989] WAR 154

Lockwood-Hall v BHP Billiton Nickel West Pty Ltd [2015] WASCA 232

Marks v Coles Supermarkets [2021] WASCA 176

Paridis v Settlement Agents Supervisory Board [2007] WASCA 97; (2007) 33 WAR 361

Player v Avery [2022] WASCA 147

R v Sexton [2018] SASCFC 28

Resi Corporation v Munzer [2016] SASCFC 15

River Hill Contracting Pty Ltd v Moore [2023] WASCA 111

Sharon Property Pty Ltd v The Presiding Member of the Metro Inner-North Joint Development Assessment Panel [2022] WASC 332

Shellharbour City Council v Rigby [2006] NSWCA 308; (2006) Aust Torts Reps 81‑864

Skinner v Broadbent [2006] WASCA 2

Skippers Aviation Pty Ltd v Curtin [2015] WADC 82

Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247

Soulos v Pagones [2023] NSWCA 243

Summit Homes v Lucev (1996) 16 WAR 566

Thomas v Chandler MacLeod [2015] WADC 78

Velez Pty Ltd v Tudor [2011] WASCA 218

Waterford v The Commonwealth of Australia (1987) 163 CLR 54

Whalan v Kogarah Municipal Council [2007] NSWCA 5

CURWOOD DCJ:

  1. On 23 October 2019, the respondent, Christine Jones, drove into the grounds of her workplace at Rockingham General Hospital, where she worked for the appellant, South Metropolitan Health Service, as an executive assistant.  As she entered the hospital grounds…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Metropolitan Health Service v Jones and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WADC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of South Metropolitan Health Service v Jones, the appellant, the South Metropolitan Health Service, sought to appeal an arbitrator's decision regarding a workers' compensation claim. The dispute centred on whether the arbitrator had provided adequate reasons for their decision, which the appellant argued constituted an error of law. The case was heard in the District Court of Western Australia.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the arbitrator's failure to provide adequate reasons for their decision amounted to an error of law, warranting an appeal. The court had to consider the principles governing the adequacy of reasons provided by decision-makers in workers' compensation matters, as well as the specific provisions of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA). The court also needed to determine whether the error, if any, was material to the outcome of the case.

The court found that the arbitrator's reasons were adequate in all the circumstances. It held that the appellant had not demonstrated that the arbitrator's decision involved an error of law. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and existing case law, which emphasised that a failure to give adequate reasons could constitute an error of law, but this must be assessed in context. The court concluded that while the reasons might have been more detailed, they were sufficient to allow for meaningful review and did not prejudice the appellant's ability to argue their case effectively. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

The court did not make any further orders, as the dismissal of the appeal upheld the original arbitrator's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant has brought this appeal pursuant to s 247 of the Act which provides:247.Appeal against arbitrator's decision made under Part XI(1)If written reasons for an arbitrator's decision under Part XI in respect of a dispute are given to a party to the dispute (whether as required by section 213 (3) or otherwise), the party may, with the leave of the District Court, appeal to the District Court against the decision.(2)Subject to subsection (3), the District Court is not to grant leave to appeal unless -(a)in the case of an appeal in which an amount of compensation is at issue -(i)a question of law is involved and the amount at issue in the appeal is both -(I)at least $5 000 or such other amount as may be prescribed by the regulations; and(II)at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against;… In this appeal, the appellant relies on both s 247(2)(a)(i) and s 247(2)(a)(ii). It is not in issue that the amount is worth at least $5,000 or 20% of the amount awarded by the arbitrator. Whether an appeal ground is properly categorised as raising a question of law is, in many cases, a difficult assessment. The distinction between errors of law, errors of fact and mixed errors of law and fact can be elusive. Relevant principles include:1.An appeal will involve a question of law if the court, tribunal or statutory decision‑maker whose decision is under appeal has made an error of law or an error of mixed law and fact.[38]2.A failure to give reasons, or adequate reasons, for a decision, may constitute an error of law. This general proposition must, however, be considered in the context of the provisions of s 213(4) of the Act which I refer to in [37] below.[39]3.An appeal on a question of law is narrower than an appeal that merely involves a question of law. Where an appeal lies on a question of law the subject matter of the appeal is the question or questions of law. If a question raised by a litigant, properly analysed, is not a question of law, linguistic gymnastics in the formulation of the grounds of appeal cannot convert it into a question of law.[40]4.A court, tribunal or statutory decision‑maker does not make an error of law merely because the court, tribunal or decision‑maker finds facts wrongly or upon a doubtful basis.[41]5.A ground of appeal that a tribunal has failed to take into account a consideration which, in the circumstances, it was bound to take into account, alleges an error of law. There is a distinction between failing to take into account relevant considerations which a tribunal is obliged to take into account, on the one hand, and failing to take into account a particular piece of evidence, on the other.[42]6.A decision does not involve an error of law unless the error is material to the decision, in the sense that it contributes to the result so that, but for the error, the decision may have been different.[43][38] Atanasoska v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd [2009] WASCA 17 [20] (Buss JA with whom Wheeler & Pullin JJA agreed) (Atanasoska); Hawker Pacific Pty Ltd v Lang [2015] WASCA 256[15] (judgment of the court); Department of Education v Azmitia [2015] WASCA 246 [120] (Mazza JA with whom Buss JA & Chaney J agreed); Ewart v Caruso [2013] WASCA 266[25] (Newnes JA with whom McLure P & Murphy JJA agreed).[39] Lloyd v Faraone [1989] WAR 154, 163 (Malcolm CJ); Summit Homes v Lucev(1996) 16 WAR 566, 569 (Ipp JJ with whom Kennedy & Rowland JJ agreed); Velez Pty Ltd v Tudor [2011] WASCA 218 [57] - [70] (Murphy JA with whom Pullin & Newnes JJA agreed) (Velez).[40]Paridis v Settlement Agents Supervisory Board [2007] WASCA 97; (2007) 33 WAR 361 [53] (Buss JA) (Paridis); Atanasoska [21]; Skippers Aviation Pty Ltd v Curtin [2015] WADC 82 [20] (Davis DCJ). See also Sharon Property Pty Ltd v The Presiding Member of the Metro Inner-North Joint Development Assessment Panel [2022] WASC 332 [98] (Solomon J); BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Treby [2018] WASCA 60 [41] ‑ [42] (judgment of the court); Lockwood-Hall v BHP Billiton Nickel West Pty Ltd[2015] WASCA 232 [82] (Newnes JA with whom Chaney J agreed). [41] Paridis [55] referring to Waterford v The Commonwealth of Australia (1987) 163 CLR 54; Atanasoska [21].[42] Paridis [57]. [43] Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321, 353 (Mason CJ); BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Brady [2008] WASCA 250 [15] (with whom Wheeler & Buss JJA agreed); Thomas v Chandler MacLeod [2015] WADC 78 [26] (O'Neal DCJ).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established