Reported Decision:
(2006) 14 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-701
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Limited v Gordian Runoff Limited (formerly GIO Insurance Limited) & Ors [2006] NSWSC 223 HEARING DATE(S): 11/10/05, 12/10/05, 17/10/05-21/10/05, 24/10/05-27/10/05, 31/10/05-3/11/05, 7/11/05-10/11/05, 14/11/05-16/11/05, 21/11/05-24/11/05, 28/11/05, 1/12/05, 5/12/05-7/12/05, 12/12/05-15/12/05, 30/1/06, 20/2/06-24/02/06, 27/02/06-3/3/06
JUDGMENT DATE :
12 April 2006JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial ListJUDGMENT OF: Einstein J DECISION: Policies do not respond. Short minutes of order to be brought in. CATCHWORDS: Professional Indemnity insurance - Construction of contracts of insurance - Conditions - Exclusionary provisions - Deeming provisions - Multi-layered scheme of insurance put in place by Baulderstone Hornibrook ["BHE"] as Head Contractor for the design and construction of third runway extending into Botany Bay at Kingsford Smith Airport - Reinforced Earth construction - Sand loss from reinforced earth walls resulting in voids and settlement - Costs of carrying out design and construction work to rectify subject walls likely to exceed $60 million - Initial proceedings brought by Sydney Airports Corporation ["SACL"] against BHE - Initial proceedings settled in the absence of acceptance [by upper lay insurers] that policies responded - Reasonableness of settlement of initial proceedings - Identification of the substance of claim made by SACL - Present proceedings commenced by BHE against insurers [including upper layer insurers] seeking declarations of entitlement to indemnity and associated relief - Exclusion providing that policy would not indemnify in respect of claims made against insured arising out of construction work performed involving the means, methods, techniques, sequences, procedures and use of equipment - Primary questions of fact as to whether excessive sand loss caused by reason of design defects or construction work - Principles of construction - Sundry questions of proper construction and nature of policy provisions - Construction issues including meaning of phrase "arising out of" - Identification of which are "insuring clauses" - Rectification of contracts of insurance - Claims to rectify policies including to change retroactive date - Issues concerning pre-conditions - Notification issues - Consideration of what circumstances notified - Consideration of sundry exclusion clauses - Proper construction of word "claim" when used in an insurance policy - Whether one claim or two claims - Whether any breach of professional duty by BHE giving rise to SACL's claim committed in the course of BHE itself conducting one of defined professional activities - Consideration of deeming provisions - Implied terms - Exclusion in respect of claims for any legal liability imposed upon insured pursuant to law of contract but only when such legal liability would not have been imposed upon pursuant to law of tort - Exclusion providing that policy would not indemnify in respect of claims made which relate to any contractual or other duty or obligation assumed by insured not assumed in the normal conduct of the insurer's profession as defined - Whether insurers breached obligations of utmost good faith inter alia by failing to investigate promptly - Consideration of source and content of duty of good faith in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd v Gordian Runoff... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2006] NSWSC 223
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd ("BHE") sought relief from its professional indemnity insurers, including Gordian Runoff Ltd, in respect of a settlement agreement made with Sydney Airports Corporation Ltd ("SACL") concerning defective works carried out by BHE. BHE, as the head contractor, had constructed a reinforced earth retaining wall at the Sydney Airport. A loss of sand from the wall resulted in voids and settlement, which SACL claimed caused by BHE's defective design and construction. The estimated cost to rectify the works exceeded $60 million. The court had to determine whether BHE was entitled to indemnity from its insurers and if the settlement agreement with SACL was reasonable. The court also needed to interpret various policy provisions, including exclusions, deeming provisions, and the meaning of the phrase "arising out of."
The court found that the settlement with SACL was reasonable. It concluded that the primary issue was whether the sand loss was due to design defects or construction work. The court determined that the settlement did not amount to an admission that the work was defective. It also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by not promptly investigating the claim. The court interpreted the insurance policies to find that the insurers were liable for indemnity, subject to certain exclusions. The court rejected the insurers' argument that the policy did not respond to claims arising out of construction work. It held that the settlement did not constitute two claims but one, and that the insurers' exclusion clauses did not apply. The court also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim.
The court ordered that the insurers indemnify BHE in respect of the settlement agreement with SACL, subject to certain exclusions. The court also ordered that the insurers pay BHE's costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal, and that the insurers bear their own costs. The court found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim, and that the breach caused prejudice to BHE. The court ordered that BHE's costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal, be paid by the insurers. The court also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim, and that the breach caused prejudice to BHE.
The court found that the settlement with SACL was reasonable. It concluded that the primary issue was whether the sand loss was due to design defects or construction work. The court determined that the settlement did not amount to an admission that the work was defective. It also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by not promptly investigating the claim. The court interpreted the insurance policies to find that the insurers were liable for indemnity, subject to certain exclusions. The court rejected the insurers' argument that the policy did not respond to claims arising out of construction work. It held that the settlement did not constitute two claims but one, and that the insurers' exclusion clauses did not apply. The court also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim.
The court ordered that the insurers indemnify BHE in respect of the settlement agreement with SACL, subject to certain exclusions. The court also ordered that the insurers pay BHE's costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal, and that the insurers bear their own costs. The court found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim, and that the breach caused prejudice to BHE. The court ordered that BHE's costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal, be paid by the insurers. The court also found that the insurers had breached their duty of good faith by failing to promptly investigate the claim, and that the breach caused prejudice to BHE.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi