AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd [2005] FCAFC 185

CORPORATIONS LAW – Insurance – insurance contracts covering civil liability incurred in business of finance, investment and insurance advice, licensed security dealer and mortgage originator – circumstances arose where there was the possibility of liability arising – insured provided proposal for dealing with claims – insurer agreed in principle – insured repeatedly requested confirmation of indemnity under contracts from insurer – insurer instructed insured to act as a prudent uninsured – whether insurer estopped from denying indemnity – whether insurer failed to act with the utmost good faith – whether s 819(4) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act is a defence to claims against the insured – whether insured’s legal and investigation costs are recoverable as damages for the insurer’s breach of the insurance contracts

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 1989 (Cth), ss 784, 817, 818, 819,
Corporations Law ss 784, 807, 817, 818, 819, 826, 827
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic)
Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s13

Banco de Portugal v Waterlow & Sons Ltd [1932] AC 452 at 506 referred to

Baygol Pty Ltd v Foamex Polystyrene Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1089 cited

Broadlands Properties Ltd v Guardian Assurance Co Ltd (1984) 3 ANZ Insurance Cases 60-552 cited
CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (2001) 188 ALR 439; (2001) 166 FLR 271 referred to
CIC Insurance v Barwon Region Water Authority (1998) 147 FLR 353 discussed
Con‑Stan Industries of Australia Pty Ltd v Norwich Winterthur Insurance (Australia) Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 226, 244 referred to
Distillers Co (Bio-Chemicals) (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1 cited
Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR(NSW) 88 cited
Eslea Holdings Ltd v Butts (1986) 6 NSWLR 175, 185 referred to
Financial Wisdom Ltd v Newman [2005] VSCA 110 discussed
Gutteridge v Commonwealth of Australia (unreported, Supreme Court of Queensland, Ambrose J, 25 June 1993) referred to
Kelly v New Zealand Insurance Co Ltd (1996) 130 FLR 97 referred to
Khoury v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1984) 165 CLR 622 referred to
MK & JA Roche Pty Ltd v Metro Edgley Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 39 referred to
Moss v Sun Alliance Australia Ltd (1990) 6 ANZ Insurance Cases 60-967 referred to
Newman v Financial Wisdom Ltd [2004] VSC 216 discussed
Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (1998) 192 CLR 603 referred to
Vermeulen v SIMU Mutual Insurance Association (1987) 4 ANZ Insurance Cases 60-812 discussed

Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1988) 164 CLR 387 referred to

AMP FINANCIAL PLANNING PTY LTD v CGU INSURANCE LIMITED
VID 1422 OF 2004

MOORE, EMMETT & GYLES JJ

2 SEPTEMBER 2005

SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1422 OF 2004

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCAFC 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd involved a dispute between AMP, a financial planning and insurance advisory firm, and CGU Insurance Limited, the insurer. AMP sought reimbursement from CGU for payments made in settlements with investors who alleged improper conduct by AMP’s representatives. The primary judge dismissed AMP's claims, leading to an appeal by AMP and a cross-appeal by CGU regarding the costs order. The legal issues centered on whether AMP was entitled to reimbursement for the settlements made under the terms of the insurance policies, and if so, to what extent.

The primary judge formulated several questions to address the core issues in the case, including whether AMP had to prove its liability to investors, whether CGU was liable for AMP’s payouts, and if AMP could avoid the non-recovery of amounts paid out before any breach by CGU through estoppel or breach of the duty of utmost good faith. The judge concluded that AMP had not established by admissible evidence that it was legally liable to the investors, and therefore, CGU was not liable for AMP’s payouts made before any breach of the insurance policies. The settlements were also found to be unreasonable due to pressure from the Australian Securities and Investment Commission, and they failed to consider the availability of the s 819(4) defence. Additionally, the settlements did not qualify as Civil Liability Claims under the insurance policies, and AMP’s investigation and legal costs were not covered.

The court further determined that the settlements were not reasonable and that AMP’s liability to investors did not arise in the course of the Professional Business Practice as defined by the insurance policies. The demands of the investors were not excluded from indemnity by the policies, but AMP’s claim for investigation and legal costs was denied as there was no prior agreement entitling AMP to such indemnity. The court found that it was inappropriate to grant declarations in respect of future demands by other investors. Ultimately, the appeal was allowed, the primary judge's orders were set aside, and the matter was remitted to the primary judge for further consideration in light of the findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders of the primary judge be set aside.

3. The matter be remitted to the primary judge.

4.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In its written submissions to the primary judge, AMP outlined such a case. In those submissions, AMP alleged that there were breaches of the Insurance Policies on the part of CGU by reason of its failure to notify its decision on indemnity in respect of any particular demand within a reasonable timeframe. AMP submitted that each time CGU failed to provide indemnity, within the time period after the provision of the information in respect of each demand contemplated by the Protocol, there was a breach of CGU’s implied obligation of utmost good faith and therefore there was a breach of the Insurance Policies in respect of every settled demand. Accordingly, so it was said, if the Court were satisfied that AMP had settled demands reasonably, CGU was liable for AMP’s loss, being the amount paid by taking those steps that were reasonable in order to mitigate its loss and avoid litigation by the investors. CGU countered those submissions by saying that the Statement of Claim simply does not make any such allegations. THE CONCLUSIONS OF THE PRIMARY JUDGE Rather than deal with the issues in terms of the pleadings as such, the primary judge formulated a number of questions for determination. His Honour proceeded on the basis that those questions were the issues thrown up by the pleadings. The questions and the answers given by the primary judge, as presently relevant, were as follows:1.Must AMP establish by admissible evidence, and not merely by proof of the settlements, that it was legally liable to the investors with whom it reached settlements?Settlement between AMP and an investor does not answer the description of Claims for Civil Liability within the meaning of the Insurance Policies. In an action on an insurance policy, the occurrence of the insured event must be proved by admissible evidence, as must every element in any other cause of action. All that had been proved by AMP was that it believed it was, or might be, liable to investors.2.Is CGU liable in damages for AMP’s payouts on the settlements (assuming them to be reasonable) when the settlements were made before any breach of the Insurance Policies by CGU?An insured under an indemnity policy can only recover the amount of a settlement with a third party claimant where the settlement has been made after a breach of the contract of insurance by the insurer. Repudiation by the insurer is a critical element. The breach alleged by AMP in the Statement of Claim did not occur until, at the earliest, 14 November 2002, which was after AMP had made payments to 47 investors. AMP cannot recover, by way of damages, the amounts paid out before any breach occurred.3.If yes to 1 and no to 2, can AMP avoid that result by reason of its having, with CGU’s knowledge, paid the investors under the settlements pursuant to the Protocol, on the basis of:3.1Estoppel;3.2Breach of the obligation of utmost good faith.3.1 AMP could not rely on an estoppel because there was no relevant reliance by AMP. Up until receipt of the letter of 14 November 2002, AMP recognised that CGU had neither admitted nor denied liability to indemnify under the Insurance Policies. CGU made it clear that AMP was to be no worse off in respect of its rights (if any) under the Insurance Policies by negotiating with investors and entering into settlements. Further, AMP had not shown any detriment because CGU’s defence makes it clear that it did not deny AMP’s claim for indemnity on the basis of clauses 12.1, 12.2 and 7.6. Accordingly, AMP is no worse off, vis a vis its policy rights (if any), by having entered into settlements with investors.3.2 An allegation of breach of the duty of utmost good faith requires proof of some want of honesty. There was no want of honesty on the part of CGU and, therefore, there was no failure to act toward AMP with the utmost good faith.4.Did AMP have any liability to the investors under ss 817, 818 or 819 of the Law in respect of any alleged wrongful conduct of Pal or Howarth?In relation to investments made by investors, the conduct of Pal and Howarth was not ‘in connection with’ any securities business or investment advice business of AMP. It was therefore unlikely that AMP could be made liable under s 817. The critical provision was s 819 and CGU did not argue for the non application of s 819. Rather CGU submitted that AMP could have relied on the exculpatory provision in s 819(4).5.If yes to 4, in any proceedings by investors, could AMP have relied on s 819(4) of the Law to avoid liability under s 819(2)?In assessing the potential liability of AMP in a hypothetical and notional action, the possible defences that AMP might raise are plainly relevant. Sections 819(4) would apply where an indemnifying principal is a party because it has been joined as a third party. The policy behind s 819(4) is to mitigate, to some extent, the draconian rigour of s 819, which creates liability whether or not the wrong doer was the agent of the indemnifying principal and whether or not the client had even heard of the indemnifying principal in relation to the impugned conduct. At least where the real principal is before the Court, it is reasonable that the real principal alone should bear the burden. Section 819(4) has that effect.6.Were the settlements reasonable?The settlements were not reasonable. The whole process was so dominated by pressure from the Commission that it was impossible to conclude that the settlements would have been reached in the agreed amounts, or indeed at all, had that pressure not existed. Apart from the question of process, the settlements were also unreasonable because they failed to take into account the availability of the s 819(4) defence, which seemed not to have been considered by AMP at all.7.Were there Civil Liability Claims by investors within the terms of clause 3.2 of the Insurance Policies?Negligence, as a legal cause of action, necessarily involves breach by the defendant of a duty owed to the plaintiff. Under ss 817 or 819, investors sought to make AMP liable under what might be termed a vicarious responsibility imposed by statute. The demands by investors against AMP, therefore, could properly be characterised as being for breach of duty.8.Did any liability that AMP might have had to investors arise in the course of the Professional Business Practice?The obvious purpose of special condition 4 of the Insurance Policies was to provide indemnity for the kind of liability that AMP might incur by way of statutory extension of common law principles of agency. By conducting the kind of business that AMP was conducting, it was going to be exposed to liability for the acts of others in circumstances where common law liability would not attach. It would be a very uncommercial construction of the Insurance Policies to limit the liability to that which might exist at common law.9.Were the demands of the investors excluded from indemnity by clause 6.3(e) of the Insurance Policies?Special condition 4 was designed to make it clear that a particular feature of AMP’s business was covered. To the extent that there was conflict between clause 6.3(e) and special condition 4, the latter prevailed.10.Would any liability under the Insurance Policies include AMP’s investigation costs and legal costs?AMP claimed as part of its damages the time cost of its employees and expenses such as travel and accommodation incurred for internal investigation of the demands by investors. AMP also claimed legal costs paid to its solicitors. There was no prior written agreement between CGU and AMP concerning the costs in question so as to entitle AMP to indemnity in respect of costs. 11.Should there be a declaration that CGU is obliged to indemnify AMP under the Insurance Policies in respect of unpaid and future demands by other investors? The declaration sought by AMP was hypothetical and it was therefore inappropriate to grant declarations in respect of demands that have not been paid by AMP.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This appeal concerns the rights of the appellant, AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd (‘AMP’), under insurance contracts entered into with the respondent, CGU Insurance Limited (‘CGU’). At relevant times, AMP carried on business as a finance, investment and insurance advisor, licensed security dealer and mortgage originator (‘the Professional Business Practice’). The insurance contracts provided for insurance cover in respect of certain types of civil liability incurred by AMP in the conduct of the Professional Business Practice. AMP has made payments totalling in excess of $3,000,000 in settlement of demands made against it by persons who made investments on the basis of advice given by individuals who were representatives of AMP in connection with the Professional Business Practice. AMP claims to be entitled, under the insurance contracts, to be reimbursed by CGU in respect of those payments. A judge of the Court rejected AMP’s claims. AMP now appeals to the Full Court from the orders of the primary judge. CGU has cross-appealed in respect of the costs order made by the primary judge. THE CORPORATIONS LAW AND AMP Chapter 7 of the Corporations Law of New South Wales (‘the Law’) was concerned generally with securities. Part 7.3 of Chapter 7 was concerned with participants in the securities industry. Provision was made for the grant of a licence to carry on business as an investment adviser. Division 3 of Part 7.3 was concerned with the regulation of persons who act as representatives of investment advisers. Under s 807, a natural person was prohibited from doing an act as a representative of an investment adviser unless the investment adviser was the holder of a licence and the person held a proper authority from the investment adviser. The holder of a proper authority was described as a representative of the investment adviser. Division 4 dealt with liability of principals for their representatives’ conduct. Division 5 of Part 7.3 was concerned with the exclusion of certain persons from the securities industry. Power was conferred upon the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (‘the Commission’) to revoke licences. In particular, under s 826(1)(j), the Commission could revoke a licence if the Commission had reason to believe that the licensee had not performed efficiently, honestly and fairly the duties of a holder of an investment adviser’s licence. In addition, under s 827(1), where the Commission was empowered to revoke a licence, the Commissioner could, if it thought it desirable to do so, suspend the licence. At relevant times, AMP was a licensed investment adviser under the Law. In the course of the Professional Business Practice, as a licensed investment adviser, AMP provided financial planning advice to retail clients through a network of individuals who held proper authorities from AMP. The authorisations of such representatives by AMP allowed the representatives to give advice and recommendations on AMP’s behalf in respect of investment in financial products. However, representatives were authorised to provide advice only about financial products on an approved products list published from time to time by AMP. Further, any particular representative was authorised to provide advice only about the particular financial products on the approved products list in respect of which that representative had been accredited to advise.THE INSURANCE POLICIES