CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd & Ors v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd & Ors [2001] QSC 388
PARTIES: CA & MEC MCINALLY NOMINEES PTY LTD ACN 009 926 863, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE MCINALLY SUPERANNUATION FUND
(first plaintiff)
COLIN WALTER JOHNSON AND EILEEN RUTH JOHNSON
(second plaintiff)
ROY HERBERT EVANS AND BETH EVANS
(third plaintiff)
MORLUX PTY LTD ACN 006 947 977
(fourth plaintiff)
BRADLAND PTY LTD ACN 051 353 998
(fifth plaintiff)
THELMA CLARE MOURANT
(sixth plaintiff)
v
HTW VALUERS (BRISBANE) PTY LTD ACN 052 004 672
(first defendant)
MATTHEW KOZIORA
(second defendant)
ALAN LUDLOW
(third defendant)
BELLS SOLICITORS (A “FIRM”)
(fourth defendant)
COMMERCIAL UNION ASSURANCE COMPANY OF AUTRALIA LIMITED ACN 004 478 371
(first third party)
R E BROWN AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED ACN 083 259 107
(second third party)
FILE NO: S10662 of 1999
DIVISION: Trial Division
DELIVERED ON: 16 October 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 1 October 2001 – 3 October 2001
JUDGE: Chesterman J
ORDER: Judgment for the first third party in the action brought against it by the first, second and third defendants, with costs to be assessed on the standard basis
CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE – PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY INSURANCE – where defendants had been careless in valuation of commercial property – where settlement reached between all parties except in the first, second and third defendants’ claim against the first third party – where defendants did not give notice of a claim to the first third party – whether s 54 Insurance Contracts Act operates to overcome the failure to give notice

INSURANCE – PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY INSURANCE – where the first, second and third defendants did not call evidence of their liability to the plaintiffs – whether terms of settlement proved liability and quantification of liability - whether the settlement reached between the first, second and third defendants and the fourth defendant is reasonable

STATUTES – ACTS OF PARLIAMENT – INTERPRETATION – whether s 54 Insurance Contracts Act operates to overcome a failure to give notice under s 40(3) Insurance Contracts Act

STATUTES – ACTS OF PARLIAMENT – PARTICULAR WORDS AND PHRASES – SPECIFIC INTERPRETATIONS – interpretation of “claim” in s 40(1) Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)

Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 40, s 54

Einfeld v HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-450, not followed

FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Australian Hospital Care Pty Ltd (2001) 75 ALJR 1236, distinguished

Newcastle City Council v GIO General Ltd (1997) 191 CLR 85, followed

Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (1998) 192 CLR 603, cited

COUNSEL: Mr G A Thompson SC and with him Ms H Bowskill for the first, second and third defendants
Mr P A Keane QC and with him Mr L F Kelly for the first third party
SOLICITORS: Minter Ellison for the first, second and third defendants
Thynne & Macartney for the first third party
  1. CHESTERMAN J: Only a remnant of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd and HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd was heard by the Queensland District Court. The dispute arose from a claim for damages for professional negligence against HTW Valuers, which had valued a commercial property. A settlement was reached between all parties involved except for the first, second, and third defendants’ claim against the first third party. This claim was contested by the first third party, leading to the current litigation. The primary legal issue the court had to resolve was whether section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) could override the failure to provide notice of a claim to the first third party under section 40(3) of the same Act. Additionally, the court had to determine if the settlement terms between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant were reasonable and if the settlement proved the liability and quantified the damages of the first, second, and third defendants.

The court examined whether the failure to give notice of a claim could be overridden by section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act. The court found that section 54 did not operate to excuse the failure to give notice under section 40(3). The court also considered the interpretation of the term "claim" in section 40(1) of the Insurance Contracts Act, concluding that the term was not satisfied by the settlement reached. Furthermore, the court held that the settlement terms did not prove the liability or quantify the damages of the first, second, and third defendants. Consequently, the first third party was found not liable to the first, second, and third defendants. The court also determined that the settlement reached between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant was reasonable.

The court's decision resulted in a judgment in favour of the first third party, with costs to be assessed on the standard basis. The first, second, and third defendants' claim against the first third party was dismissed. The court's interpretation of the statutory provisions and the reasonableness of the settlement played a crucial role in reaching this conclusion.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the first third party in the action brought against it by the first, second and third defendants, with costs to be assessed on the standard basis

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute concerning professional indemnity insurance and a valuation error made by HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (the defendants) in their assessment of a commercial property. The defendants were found to have been careless in their valuation, which led to a legal dispute. The plaintiffs, CA & MEC McInally Nominees Pty Ltd, initiated proceedings against the defendants for the valuation error. A settlement was reached between all parties except in the claim made by the first, second, and third defendants against the first third party. The defendants did not give notice of this claim to the first third party as required by section 40(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). The defendants argue that section 54 of the same Act operates to overcome this failure to give notice.

The matter came before the court as a result of the unresolved claim between the first, second, and third defendants and the first third party. Prior to this court, the dispute had not been fully settled. The court was required to determine the implications of the failure to give notice under section 40(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and whether section 54 of the same Act could mitigate this failure. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the settlement reached between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant was reasonable and whether the terms of the settlement proved liability and quantified the liability of the first, second, and third defendants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) operates to overcome the failure to give notice under section 40(3) of the same Act.
2. Whether the terms of the settlement between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant proved liability and quantified the liability of the first, second, and third defendants.
3. Whether the settlement reached between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant is reasonable.

Held
1. The court concluded that section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) does not operate to overcome the failure to give notice under section 40(3) of the same Act.
2. The court held that the terms of the settlement between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant did not prove liability and did not quantify the liability of the first, second, and third defendants.
3. The court found that the settlement reached between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant was not reasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), which provides a remedy for insurers who are prejudiced by a failure to give notice as required under section 40(3). The court considered whether this section could operate to overcome the failure to give notice. The court held that section 54 does not provide a remedy in this situation, as it is concerned with prejudice to the insurer and not the failure to give notice. Therefore, the failure to give notice under section 40(3) was not overcome by section 54.
Next, the court considered whether the terms of the settlement between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant proved liability and quantified the liability of the first, second, and third defendants. The court noted that the first, second, and third defendants did not call evidence of their liability to the plaintiffs. The court held that the terms of the settlement did not prove liability and did not quantify the liability of the first, second, and third defendants.
Finally, the court examined whether the settlement reached between the first, second, and third defendants and the fourth defendant was reasonable. The court noted that the settlement did not include the first third party and that the first, second, and third defendants had not called evidence of their liability to the plaintiffs. The court held that the settlement was not reasonable.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) does not operate to overcome the failure to give notice under section 40(3) of the same Act. Additionally, the court held that the terms of a settlement do not prove liability and quantify the liability of the parties involved if evidence of liability is not called, and that a settlement is not reasonable if it excludes a party who may be liable for the claim.