AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Limited
[2004] FCA 1330

CORRIGENDUM

AMP FINANCIAL PLANNING PTY LTD v CGU INSURANCE LTD
V465 of 2003

HEEREY J
18 OCTOBER 2004 (CORRIGENDUM 26 OCTOBER 2004)
MELBOURNE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 465 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

AMP FINANCIAL PLANNING PTY LTD (ACN 051 208 327)
APPLICANT

AND:

CGU INSURANCE LTD (ACN 004 478 371)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 OCTOBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

CORRIGENDUM

1.At paragraph [62] of the Reasons for Judgment delete “prudent insurer” and replace with “prudent uninsured”.

I certify that the preceding one (1)  paragraph is a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Heerey.

Associate:

Dated:            26 October 2004

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Limited [2004] FCA 1330

INSURANCE – policies of indemnity insurance – applicant licensed securities dealer – negligent investments made by “securities representatives” under the Corporations Law – settlements made by applicant with investors while liability to indemnify still reserved by respondent insurer and before any breach of policies – whether respondent liable under policies – whether applicant required to prove its legal liability to investors by admissible evidence – whether doctrines of estoppel or waiver available to applicant – whether respondent engaged in unconscionable conduct or misleading and deceptive conduct or breached obligation of utmost good faith – whether applicant liable to investors under s 819(2) of the Law – whether insured would have had a defence to claims by investors under s 819(4) of the Law – settlements made under pressure from Australian Securities and Investments Commission – whether settlements reasonable – whether claims within terms of policies – whether liability under policies for applicant’s investigation and legal costs

WORDS AND PHRASES – “civil liability claims” – “insured professional business practice” – “prudent uninsured”

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 12CA, 12DA 12DB(1)(g)
Corporations Law ss 94, 817, 819, 820
Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 13

Post Office v Norwich Union Fire Insurance Society Ltd [1967] 2 QB 363 at 374 cited
Brice v J H Wakerbarth (Australasia) Pty Ltd [1974] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 274 at 276 cited
Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Limited v Rocco Pezzano Pty Limited (1998) 193 CLR 603 applied
Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR (NSW) 88 applied
Parker v Lewis (1873) LR 8 Ch App 1035 applied
The Distillers Company Bio-Chemicals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1 applied
General Omnibus Company Ltd v London General Insurance Co Ltd [1936] IR 596 cited
Hurlock v Council of the Shire of Johnstone [2002] QCA 256 not followed
C E Heath Underwriting & Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd v Campbell Wallis Moule & Co Pty Ltd [1992] 1 VR 386 distinguished
Nigel Watts Fashion Agencies Pty Limited v GIO General Limited (1995) 8 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-235 distinguished
ACN 007…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd, the central dispute revolves around the obligations and liabilities of AMPFP under its insurance policies with CGU Insurance, specifically whether CGU is responsible for compensating AMPFP for settlements it made to investors, and whether CGU is liable for unpaid claims under the policies. The court was tasked with determining whether AMPFP could establish its liability to investors through admissible evidence and whether CGU was liable for damages of settlements made prior to any breach of the policies by CGU.

The court addressed two primary issues. Firstly, it was established that AMPFP must provide admissible evidence of its legal liability to investors, rather than relying solely on proof of settlements. The court found that settlements between AMPFP and investors did not constitute claims for civil liability as defined in the policies. The court rejected AMPFP's argument that requiring such proof would necessitate numerous separate trials, suggesting that a more manageable approach could involve suing for a declaration of rights in a few test cases.

Secondly, the court ruled that CGU was not liable for damages related to settlements made before any breach of the policies by CGU. The court referenced the principles in Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Limited v Rocco Pezzano Pty Limited, noting that while an insured party can recover reasonable settlement amounts as damages if the insurer breaches the contract, this does not apply to settlements made before any breach occurs. The court also dismissed AMPFP's claims of estoppel, waiver, or breaches of good faith by CGU as grounds for liability.

The court concluded that AMPFP failed to prove its liability to investors by admissible evidence, and therefore, CGU was not liable for payouts made prior to any breach. The issue of CGU's obligation to indemnify AMPFP for unpaid claims was adjourned for further submissions. Consequently, the proceeding was stood over to allow the parties to make additional submissions on this unresolved matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

The proceeding stand over for further submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd (AMPFP) and CGU Insurance Ltd (CGU) concerning insurance policies. AMPFP claims that it is entitled to indemnity from CGU for certain settlements made with investors, while CGU denies liability. The policies cover claims for civil liability arising from the conduct of AMPFP's professional business practice. The dispute hinges on whether AMPFP's settlements with investors qualify as civil liability claims under the policies, and whether CGU is liable for AMPFP's payouts on these settlements. The case has gone through a trial, and the court is now considering whether CGU should indemnify AMPFP for unpaid claims and whether there is any estoppel, waiver, or unconscionable conduct by CGU that would affect liability.

The proceeding was commenced on 13 June 2003. The matter proceeded to trial, where the court heard evidence and submissions from both parties. The trial resulted in a set of findings that AMPFP had not sufficiently proved its liability to the investors by admissible evidence. The court also determined that CGU was not liable for AMPFP's payouts on settlements made before any breach of the policies by CGU. The case is now before the court for further submissions on whether CGU is obliged to indemnify AMPFP for unpaid claims under the policies.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The present proceeding was commenced on 13 June 2003.Issue 1: Must AMPFP establish by admissible evidence, and not merely by proof of the Settlements, that it was legally liable to Investors? The Policies for the 1999 and 2000 years are identical for present purposes. The insuring clause is cl 3.1 under which CGU agrees to “provide cover … for Claims for Civil Liability (including contractual liability) arising from the conduct of the Insured Professional Business Practice”. “Civil Liability” is defined in cl 12.1 as“Liability for the damages, costs and expenses which a civil court orders the Insured to pay on a Claim (as opposed to criminal liability or penalties). It includes the legal costs of the person making the Claim, for which the Insured become liable.”“Claim” is defined in cl 12.2 as:“Any originating process (in a legal proceeding or arbitration), cross claim or counter claim or third party or similar notice claiming compensation against or served on an Insured.” A settlement between AMPFP and an Investor does not answer the description of Claims for Civil Liability within the meaning of the Policies. CGU insured AMPFP against claims, not settlements. If AMPFP has to prove its liability to Investors, clearly it has not done so by admissible evidence. All that has been proved is that AMPFP believed it was, or might be, liable to the Investors. In an action on an insurance policy the occurrence of the insured event must be proved by admissible evidence, as must every element in any other cause of action. Senior counsel for AMPFP complained that requiring such proof meant that it would have to conduct 63 separate trials within the present trial. I do not agree with this gloomy scenario. It would have been open to AMPFP to sue for a declaration as to its right of indemnity: Post Office v Norwich Union Fire Insurance Society Ltd [1967] 2 QB 363 at 374, Brice v J H Wakerbarth (Australasia) Pty Ltd [1974] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 274 at 276, MacGillivray on Insurance Law 10th ed. 2003 at 28-5. AMPFP could call, say, three or four Investors chosen as typical examples. CGU might well have agreed on a selection of test cases. Even if it did not, if AMPFP proved its liability to three or four Investors, and overcame the various defences of CGU based on terms of the Policies, then it is hard to believe the remaining claims would not be resolved by negotiation or mediation. AMPFP would be in the position of being able to wheel up batches of Investors in case after case, a daunting prospect for the most obdurate of insurers. Running a case with a few Investors in the way suggested need not have been markedly more difficult and expensive than the present case, which involved a six day trial and a court book of 24 lever arch folders.Issue 2: Is CGU liable in damages for AMPFP’s payouts on the Settlements (assuming them to be reasonable) when the Settlements were made before any breach of the Policies by CGU? If there was a breach by CGU of the contracts of insurance constituted by the Policies, AMPFP could recover as damages the amount of a reasonable settlement it had entered into as a consequence of such breach. As McHugh J said in Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Limited v Rocco Pezzano Pty Limited (1998) 193 CLR 603 at [33]:“As a general rule, a contract breaker must be taken to have reasonably contemplated that its breach may force the innocent party into litigation with third parties and that the innocent party may conclude that it is in its best interest to compromise the third party’s claim.”In Unity an insured who had sued a broker and an insurer and settled with the latter was entitled to recover from the broker the difference between (i) the amount payable under a policy which, but for the broker’s negligence, the insured would have obtained and (ii) the amount of the settlement. The insured only had to show that the settlement was reasonable: see per Hayne J at [128]-[135]. Although arising in an insurance context, Unity did not, insofar as the High Court was concerned, involve an action for damages for breach of a contract of insurance. Rather the Court was concerned with the more general question of the rights of the innocent party to a contract who as a result of the breach, and in furtherance of the duty to mitigate, compromises litigation with a third party. But the general principles propounded apply to all contracts, including contracts of insurance.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HEEREY J
Issues
1. Must AMPFP establish by admissible evidence, and not merely by proof of the Settlements, that it was legally liable to Investors?
2. Is CGU liable in damages for AMPFP’s payouts on the Settlements (assuming them to be reasonable) when the Settlements were made before any breach of the Policies by CGU?
3. Should there be a declaration that CGU is obliged to indemnify it under the Policies in respect of unpaid claims?

Held
1. AMPFP must establish by admissible evidence, and not merely by proof of the Settlements, that it was legally liable to Investors. The court found that AMPFP had not met this requirement.
2. CGU is not liable in damages for AMPFP’s payouts on Settlements made before any breach of the Policies by CGU. The court held that CGU could not be held liable for these payouts.
3. The question of whether CGU is obliged to indemnify AMPFP under the Policies in respect of unpaid claims is adjourned for further submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HEEREY J

Again there was no prior written agreement. Ebsworth and Ebsworth’s letter of 11 May 2001 does not mention costs.Issue 11: Should there be a declaration that CGU is obliged to indemnify it under the Policies in respect of unpaid claims? This issue received virtually no attention at the trial although it is raised in par 1 of AMPFP’s application. AMPFP’s case was directed, understandably enough, towards recovery of the amounts it has paid out. It did not articulate an alternative case based on the assumption that it failed in its recovery claim but (as I have now held) succeeded on issues concerning terms of the Policies. The Policies are still on foot; there has been no suggestion of avoidance for non disclosure or like grounds. I think it is reasonable that the parties be given the opportunity to make further submissions on this issue, in the light of my findings. The matter will be stood over for that purpose.Summary of findings AMPFP had to establish by admissible evidence, and not merely by proof of the Settlements, that it was legally liable to Investors. CGU is not liable in damages for AMPFP’s payouts on Settlements made before any breach of the Policies by CGU. AMPFP cannot avoid that result by reason of any estoppel or waiver, or any unconscionable conduct, misleading and deceptive conduct, or breach of the obligation of utmost good faith on the part of CGU. AMPFP would probably have been liable to Investors under s 819(2) of the Law but probably would have had a defence under s 819(4). The Settlements were not reasonable. The claims of the Investors were Civil Liability Claims within cl 3.2 of the Policies. The claims were in the course of the Insured Professional Business Practice of AMPFP. The claims are not excluded from indemnity by cl 6.3(e). Any liability under the Policies does not include AMPFP’s investigation costs and legal costs. The question of CGU’s liability to indemnify AMPFP for unpaid claims is adjourned for further submissions.