Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 58

Citation: Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 58
Parties: AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR  v SNOWY HYDRO LIMITED (ACN 090 574 431)
File number: VID 364 of 2014
Judge: BEACH J
Date of judgment: 12 February 2015
Catchwords: ELECTRICITY – contraventions of cl 4.9.8(a) of National Electricity Rules – scheduled generator not complying with dispatch instructions of Australian Energy Market Operator – claims for pecuniary penalties – proceedings brought by Australian Energy Regulator under s 44AAG of Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – National Electricity (Victoria) Law – National Electricity (NSW) Law
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 4(1), 44AE, 44AI, 44AAG, 76, 80
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191(3)(a)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
National Electricity (New South Wales) Act 1997 (NSW) ss 5 and 6
National Electricity (NSW) Law ss 34, 58, 59A, 64, 67, Sch 1, cl 33 of Sch 2, cl 24 of Sch 3
National Electricity (SA) Law ss 2AA(1)(c), 34, 59A, 64, 67, Sch 1, cll 6(2)(b) and 41 of Sch 2
National Electricity (South Australia) Act 1996 (SA) s 6, Sch
National Electricity (South Australia) Regulations reg 6(1), Sch 1
National Electricity (Victoria) Act 2005 (Vic) ss 5 and 6
National Electricity (Victoria) Law ss 34, 58, 59A, 64, 67, Sch 1, cl 24 of Sch 3
National Electricity Rules cl 4.9.8(a)
Cases cited: ACCC v EnergyAustralia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 336
ACCC v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 3) (2005) 215 ALR 301
ACCC v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (1997) 145 ALR 36
ACCC v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 640
ASIC v Ingleby (2013) 275 FLR 171
Barbaro v The Queen; Zirilli v The Queen (2014) 88 ALJR 372
CFMEU v Cahill (2010) 269 ALR 1
ICI Australia Operations Ltd v TPC (1992) 38 FCR 248
Markarian v R (2005) 228 CLR 357
Matthews v The Queen; Vu v The Queen; Hashmi v The Queen [2014] VSCA 291
Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd (2004) ATPR 41-993
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v ACCC (1996) 71 FCR 285
Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v ACCC (2012) 287 ALR 249
TPC v CSR Ltd (1991) ATPR 41-076
Date of hearing: 6 February 2015
Date of last submissions: 10 February 2015
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 172
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P R D Gray QC with Mr T Clarke
Solicitors for the Applicant: DLA Piper Australia
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C A Moore SC with Mr D Roche
Solicitors for the Respondent: Minter Ellison

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 364 of 2014

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
Applicant

AND:

SNOWY HYDRO LIMITED (ACN 090 574 431)
Respondent

JUDGE:

BEACH J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 FEBRUARY 2015

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Snowy Hydro Limited, a significant electricity generator in Australia, was found by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) to have contravened several clauses of the National Electricity Rules (NER), specifically clause 4.9.8(a). This clause mandates that scheduled generators must comply with the dispatch instructions of the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO). The AER brought these proceedings under section 44AAG of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and sought pecuniary penalties, compliance declarations, and compliance orders against Snowy Hydro. The Federal Court of Australia was the forum for this dispute.

The legal issues before the court encompassed whether Snowy Hydro had indeed contravened the specified provisions of the NER, the appropriate level of pecuniary penalties, and whether the declarations and compliance orders sought by the AER were justified. The court also had to consider the factors that should be taken into account in determining the penalties, including Snowy Hydro's cooperation with the AER, its admissions of wrongdoing, and its efforts to rectify its conduct.

The court found that Snowy Hydro had contravened the NER by not complying with the dispatch instructions of AEMO, thus justifying the imposition of penalties. In determining the penalties, the court considered Snowy Hydro’s cooperation during the investigation, its admissions, and the savings achieved by avoiding a trial. The court concluded that the penalties proposed by the AER and agreed upon by Snowy Hydro were appropriate, given the circumstances of the contraventions, the need for deterrence, and Snowy Hydro’s significant cooperation. The court also found that the declarations sought by the AER were necessary and appropriate, serving public interest by recording the court's disapproval, vindicating the AER's claims, and acting as a deterrent to future non-compliance.

The court ordered Snowy Hydro to engage an independent compliance expert to review and amend its internal documents regarding compliance with the NER. It also imposed pecuniary penalties on Snowy Hydro for each contravention, totaling $400,000, and ordered Snowy Hydro to pay a contribution to the AER's costs of $100,000. Snowy Hydro was also granted leave to discontinue its cross-claim without any order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

10. The Respondent engage, within 15 business days from the date of the order, at its own expense, a suitably qualified independent compliance expert acceptable to the AER (the Expert) to check the accuracy of and amend, if necessary, all current internal documents relating to the Respondent's compliance with clause 4.9.8(a) of the Rules, including the NEM Dispatch Compliance Guidelines, so that those internal documents accurately reflect the Respondent's obligations to comply with clause 4.9.8(a) of the Rules; and that the Respondent must:

(a) with the assistance of the Expert, identify all internal documents relating to the Respondent's compliance with clause 4.9.8(a) of the Rules;

(b) provide the internal documents identified under paragraph (a), above to the Expert;

(c) provide the Expert with any assistance that the Expert reasonably requires to amend the internal documents, including but not limited to obtaining legal advice;

(d) amend the internal documents as required by the Expert; and

(e) within 3 months of the date of this order, provide a written report signed by the Expert and the General Counsel of the Respondent to the Chief Executive of the AER:

(i) describing the expertise of the Expert and confirming his or her independence;

(ii) stating precisely how each of the steps in paragraphs 10(a), (b), (c) and (d) have been completed;

(iii) annexing a copy of the internal documents that were identified in accordance with paragraph 10(a); and

(iv) annexing a copy of the internal documents amended in accordance with this order.

PENALTIES

11. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $60,000 in respect of Contravention 1.

12. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $50,000 in respect of Contravention 2.

13. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $40,000 in respect of Contravention 3.

14. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $60,000 in respect of Contravention 4.

15. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $60,000 in respect of Contravention 5.

16. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $60,000 in respect of Contravention 6.

17. The Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days of the order a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $70,000 in respect of Contraventions 7, 8 and 9.

COSTS

18. The Respondent pay within 14 days of the order a contribution to the Applicant's costs of and incidental to this proceeding in the sum of $100,000.

OTHER ORDERS

19. The Respondent have leave to file a notice of discontinuance of its Cross-Claim in these proceedings, and there be no order as to costs on the Cross-Claim.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is entitled to significant credit for cooperating with the AER during the investigation and for having admitted contravening the Rules, thereby saving the AER and the Court (and ultimately the community) the cost and burden of a trial. Snowy Hydro is entitled to a reduction from the penalty that otherwise would have been appropriate. The discount that has been applied reflects the appropriate admissions and the substantial savings which would otherwise have been incurred if these proceedings had proceeded to trial. (h) Conclusion I have considered the relevant range of potential penalties that are suitable to each of the admitted contraventions. It seems to me that the penalties suggested by the parties are within the appropriate range in respect of each contravention. Each penalty is a substantial percentage of the maximum prescribed and well satisfies the principal object of general and specific deterrence. Penalties of the magnitude suggested are also supported by Snowy Hydro’s inadvertence for some contraventions, the fact that senior management did not directly participate in the contraventions, its significant co‑operation, its willingness to modify its guidelines, its proffering of the s 59A undertaking and that it has not previously been found to have contravened the Rules or the National Electricity Law. There are differences in the various penalties that I will impose, but such differences reflect the differing circumstances. On the basis that I propose to make the declarations sought (see s 44AAG(2)), I will impose the pecuniary penalties suggested by the parties as being appropriate in all the circumstances. DECLARATIONS Pursuant to s 44AAG(1) of the CCA and s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA), the Court can make the declarations sought. The Court has a wide discretionary power. In the present case:(a)The proposed declarations relate to conduct that contravened the Rules and the contraventions have been identified by the parties with precision. (b)It is in the public interest for the AER to seek to have the declarations made and for the declarations to be made. The AER has the role of applying to the Court for orders in respect of breaches of State energy laws (including the Rules and the National Electricity Law), and has a genuine interest in seeking the declaratory relief. (c)Snowy Hydro is a proper contradictor as the person who contravened the National Electricity Law and the Rules and is the subject of the declarations. (d)More formally, the making of declarations appears to be a necessary precursor to the imposition of pecuniary penalties (see the prefatory words to s 44AAG(2)). Further, the declarations sought are appropriate as they:(a)record the Court's disapproval of the contravening conduct;(b)vindicate the AER's claim that Snowy Hydro contravened the National Electricity Law and the Rules;(c)assist in clarifying the law; and(d)act as a deterrent to others from contravening the National Electricity Law and the Rules.COMPLIANCE ORDERS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Snowy Hydro acknowledges that the controller could and should have shut down the units promptly so as to comply with the dispatch instruction for DIs 17:05, 17:10 and 17:15.(d) Additional generation revenue earned by Snowy Hydro as a consequence of the contraventions The additional revenue (net of fuel costs) that Snowy Hydro earned during each of the dispatch intervals specified below from its non-compliance with the dispatch instructions is estimated to be as follows: The estimated net revenue gained for Contravention 1 and Contravention 2 set out in the above table is confined to an estimate of the additional net revenue earned by Snowy Hydro by the generation of the Murray Units during DI 15:50 and DI 16:15 only. The estimates do not include an estimate of any additional net revenue earned by Snowy Hydro during DI 15:55 and DI 16:00 and DI 16:20 and DI 16:25 by the combined effect of the 15:47 ramp rate rebid and each of Contravention 1 and Contravention 2. In relation to Contravention 1, as a consequence of the 15:47 ramp rate rebid coupled with Snowy Hydro's failure to comply with the dispatch instruction for DI 15:50:(a)Snowy Hydro received higher dispatch targets for DI 15:55 and, potentially, DI 16:00; (b)the spot price for TI 16:00 was marginally higher for TI 16:00 than it would have been had the contraventions not occurred; and(c)Snowy Hydro earned greater spot revenue from its generation during DI 15:55, and potentially DI 16:00, than it would have if it had complied with the dispatch instruction for DI 15:50 (see [43]). Due to Snowy Hydro's failure to comply with the dispatch instruction for DI 16:15, Snowy Hydro received higher dispatch targets for DI 16:20, and potentially DI 16:25, and therefore earned greater spot revenue from its generation during DI 16:20, and potentially DI 16:25, than it would have if it had complied with the dispatch instruction for DI 16:15 (assuming that all other market conditions remained unchanged). It is difficult to quantify these additional amounts. Any attempt to do so involves speculation about the reaction of other market participants and Snowy Hydro to the market circumstances which resulted from Contravention 1 and Contravention 2 and what they might have done had Contravention 1 and Contravention 2 not occurred. Nevertheless, it is less likely that market participants would have had time to change their behaviour in response to market circumstances resulting from Contravention 1 in DI 15:55 and Contravention 2 in DI 16:20, as they would have had limited time to react to Snowy Hydro's conduct and submit rebids in respect of those intervals. The position is less clear in respect of DI 16:00 and DI 16:25, when other market participants would have had more time to react to any observable market consequences of Snowy Hydro's behaviour and Snowy Hydro, had it complied with the target for DI 15:50, may have been able to submit a further rebid in time to produce a different target in DI 16:00. Further, Snowy Hydro's generating units in the NSW region of the NEM may have received higher targets had the Murray Units received lower targets in subsequent dispatch intervals, and Snowy Hydro may have received increased revenue from inter-regional settlement residues resulting from increased flows from NSW into Victoria. Inter-regional settlement residues are created when electricity generated in one region of the NEM is sold into a neighbouring region, and represent the volume of electricity that flows between regions, valued at the price difference between the regions. Registered participants are able to buy rights to receive these settlement residues through an auction process run by AEMO. On 29 November 2014, Snowy Hydro held the rights to half of the inter-regional settlement residues that would have resulted from increased flows from NSW to Victoria in a subsequent interval.PECUNIARY PENALTIES(a) Quantum of penalties agreed by the parties