Australian Energy Regulator v AGL Sales Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Energy Regulator v AGL Sales Pty Limited [2020] FCA 1623

File number(s): VID 1219 of 2019
Judgment of: ANDERSON J
Date of judgment: 12 November 2020
Catchwords:

ENERGY AND RESOURCES – penalty hearing – failure to submit information as required by s 282 of the National Energy Retail Law – declarations and pecuniary penalties – relevant matters to be considered – admitted contraventions of National Energy Retail Law

ENERGY AND RESOURCES – pecuniary penalties – statement of agreed facts and admissions – joint submissions as to quantum of pecuniary penalty – appropriateness of proposed pecuniary penalty

Held: Each Respondent paying a pecuniary penalty of $325,000 is appropriate having regard to the particular circumstances of this proceeding

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 4(1), 44AE, 44AAG(1)(b)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 191

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 21

National Energy Retail Law (ACT) Act 2012 (ACT), s 6

National Energy Retail Law (Adoption) Act 2012 (NSW), s 4

National Energy Retail Law (Queensland) Act  2014 (Qld), s 4

National Energy Retail Law (South Australia) Act 2011 (SA), s 4(3)

National Energy Retail Law (South Australia) Act 2011 (SA), Schedule, ss 2(1), 4, 15, 272, 282(1), 286, 294, 296, 297

National Energy Retail Rules, rr 166(1), 167(1)   

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Limited (No. 2) [2002] FCA 559

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACM Group Ltd (No 3) [2018] FCA 2059

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty Limited [2012] FCA 646

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2016] FCA 1516

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 450

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 453

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 159

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited [2015] FCA 330

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EnergyAustralia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 274

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jetstar Airways Pty Limited (No 2) [2017] FCA 205

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Medibank Private Limited [2020] FCA 1030

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pepe’s Ducks Ltd [2013] FCA 570

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 761

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths (South Australia) Pty Ltd (t/a Mac’s Liquor) [2003] FCA 530

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation [2018] FCAFC 73

Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 58

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited(No 3) [2020] FCA 1421

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Australia Bank Limited [2020] FCA 1494

Chief Executive Officer of Australian Transaction Reports and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Energy Regulator v AGL Sales Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1623
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a penalty hearing concerning the Australian Energy Regulator's (AER) enforcement action against AGL Sales, AGL South Australia, AGL Retail, and Powerdirect (collectively, the Respondents). The AER alleged that the Respondents had failed to submit required information and data to the AER under section 282 of the National Energy Retail Law, which led to proceedings seeking declarations and pecuniary penalties. The key legal issues centred on whether the proposed declarations and pecuniary penalties were appropriate given the admitted contraventions and the circumstances of the case.

The court examined the principles for determining appropriate penalties, including the nature and extent of the breaches, the circumstances in which the breaches occurred, and whether the Respondents had engaged in similar conduct previously. The court also considered the totality principle, ensuring that the total penalty for related offences does not exceed what is appropriate for the entire contravening conduct in question. The parties jointly submitted that the appropriate penalty for each Respondent was $325,000, which the court found to be within the permissible range and appropriate given the admitted conduct and circumstances.

The court concluded that the declarations sought by the AER were precise, related to an extant legal controversy, and involved the AER's genuine interest in the matter. Additionally, the proposed penalty was deemed appropriate, considering the admitted breaches, the Respondents' size, and the parity principle given their shared ownership and resources. The court ordered each Respondent to pay a pecuniary penalty of $325,000 and contribute to the AER's costs, jointly and severally.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

AGL Sales

1. The First Respondent (AGL Sales) failed to submit, in respect of its performance in ACT, NSW, QLD and SA, information and data by the relevant due dates for:

(a) the Quarter 1 reporting period, 1 July 2017 to 30 September 2017 (Quarter 1 Reporting Period), which was to be submitted by 31 October 2017 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(b) the Quarter 2 reporting period, 1 October 2017 to 31 December 2017 (Quarter 2 Reporting Period), which was to be submitted by 31 January 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(c) the Quarter 3 reporting period, 1 January 2018 to 31 March 2018 (Quarter 3 Reporting Period), which was to be submitted by 30 April 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(d) the Quarter 4 reporting period, 1 April 2018 to 30 June 2018 (Quarter 4 Reporting Period), which was to be submitted by 31 August 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018,

and therefore failed to submit to the Applicant (AER) information and data in the manner and form (including by the dates) required by the AER Performance Reporting Procedures and Guidelines (Guidelines) and contravened s 282(1) of each of the National Energy Retail Law (ACT) (ACT Retail Law), the National Energy Retail Law (NSW) (NSW Retail Law), the National Energy Retail Law (QLD) (QLD Retail Law) and the National Energy Retail Law (SA) (SA Retail Law) between 31 October 2017 and 19 September 2018.

AGL South Australia

2. The Second Respondent (AGL SA) failed to submit, in respect of its performance in NSW and SA, information and data by the relevant due dates for:

(a) the Quarter 1 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 October 2017 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(b) the Quarter 2 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 January 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(c) the Quarter 3 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 30 April 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(d) the Quarter 4 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 August 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

and therefore failed to submit to the AER information and data in the manner and form (including by the dates) required by the Guidelines and contravened s 282(1) of each of the NSW Retail Law and the SA Retail Law between 31 October 2017 and 19 September 2018.

AGL Retail

3. The Third Respondent (AGL Retail) failed to submit, in respect of its performance in NSW, QLD and SA, information and data by the relevant due dates for:

(a) the Quarter 1 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 October 2017 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(b) the Quarter 2 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 January 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(c) the Quarter 3 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 30 April 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(d) the Quarter 4 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 August 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

and therefore failed to submit to the AER information and data in the manner and form (including by the dates) required by the Guidelines and contravened s 282(1) of each of the NSW Retail Law, the QLD Retail Law and the SA Retail Law between 31 October 2017 and 19 September 2018.

Powerdirect

4. The Fourth Respondent (Powerdirect) failed to submit, in respect of its performance in ACT, NSW, QLD and SA, information and data by the relevant due dates for:

(a) the Quarter 1 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 October 2017 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(b) the Quarter 2 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 January 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(c) the Quarter 3 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 30 April 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

(d) the Quarter 4 Reporting Period, which was to be submitted by 31 August 2018 and which was not finally submitted until 19 September 2018;

and therefore failed to submit to the AER information and data in the manner and form (including by the dates) required by the Guidelines and contravened s 282(1) of each of the ACT Retail Law, the NSW Retail Law, the QLD Retail Law and the SA Retail Law between 31 October 2017 and 19 September 2018.

THE COURT ORDERS BY CONSENT THAT:

5. AGL Sales pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pecuniary penalties totalling $325,000 in respect of the breaches referred to in order 1 above, within 30 days.

6. AGL SA pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pecuniary penalties totalling $325,000 in respect of the breaches referred to in order 2 above, within 30 days.

7. AGL Retail pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pecuniary penalties totalling $325,000 in respect of the breaches referred to in order 3 above, within 30 days.

8. Powerdirect pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pecuniary penalties totalling $325,000 in respect of the breaches referred to in order 4 above, within 30 days.

9. AGL Sales, AGL SA, AGL Retail and Powerdirect pay a total contribution towards the AER’s costs in the amount of $100,000, within 30 days.

10. AGL Sales, AGL SA, AGL Retail and Powerdirect will be jointly and severally liable for the payment of the costs referred to in order 9.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the question of costs, the Respondents have agreed to make a contribution to the AER’s costs fixed in the total amount of $100,000. Each of the Respondents will be jointly and severally liable for the payment of those costs.CONCLUSION By way of summary, in my opinion, the agreed facts and admissions made in the SOAFA satisfy the three requirements identified by Gibbs J in Forster v Jododex Australia at 437-438 for making the declarations sought. First, the proposed declarations identify with precision the conduct that contravened the Retail Law and are directed to the determination of an extant legal controversy rather than any abstract or hypothetical question. Second, the AER is a public regulator and has a genuine interest in seeking the declarations and for the declarations to be made. Third, the Respondents are each a proper contradictor because they are the subject of the declarations and had an interest in opposing them. I am satisfied that the pecuniary penalty provided for in the Proposed Orders in the amount of $325,000 for each Respondent is a penalty that is “within the permissible range in all the circumstances”: NW Frozen Foods v ACCC at 291 and 299; Mobil Oil at [82] and CEO of AUSTRAC v TAB at [7]. Having considered the relevant matters in the SOAFA and the parties’ joint submissions, and the circumstances to be taken into account in determining the civil penalty in s 294 of the Retail Law (set out above), I am satisfied that the proposed penalty is, in the circumstances, appropriate, having regard to the admitted conduct and in particular:(1)the nature and extent of the breaches;(2)the nature and extent of any loss or damage suffered as a result of the breaches;(3)the circumstances in which the breaches took place;(4)whether the Respondents have engaged in any similar conduct previously and have been found to be in breach of a provision of the Retail Law, the national regulations or the Rules in respect of the conduct; and(5)it appears the Respondents have now established, and complied with, policies, systems and procedures under s 273 of the Retail Law. I am also satisfied that the proposed penalty does not fall foul of the “course of conduct” principle so that it does not result in the Respondents being “punished twice for the same conduct” in respect of relevant acts or omissions that make up multiple contraventions: CFMEU v Cahill at [41]. The proposed penalty is also appropriate having regard to the “totality principle” which requires that the total penalty for related offences does not exceed what is appropriate for the entire contravening conduct in question: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation [2018] FCAFC 73; 262 FCR 243 at [226] and [237]; ACM at [37]; see also Safeway. The totality principle operates as a final check to ensure that the penalties, as a whole, are just and appropriate. Having conducted that final check, I am satisfied that the penalties proposed are, as a whole, just and appropriate in the circumstances of this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Taking into account the period over which the contraventions occurred, the parties jointly submit that the Court should impose pecuniary penalties for each Respondent as follows:(1)Q1 Report contravention: $150,000;(2)Q2 Report contravention: $100,000;(3)Q3 Report contravention: $50,000; and(4)Q4 Report contravention: $25,000.CONSIDERATION Having regard to the principles set out above regarding the approach to fixing a pecuniary penalty, and on the basis of the facts and admissions set out in the SOAFA, I turn to consider whether pecuniary penalties totalling $325,000 for each Respondent (cumulatively, $1.3 million) are appropriate in the circumstances of this case. It is accepted that the Respondents vary in size and that the extent of their respective conduct in breach of s 282(1) of the Retail Law is different. However, in circumstances where each of the Respondents is a wholly owned subsidiary of AGL and shares data and reporting resources, and the contraventions by each of them were similar and occurred in respect of the same periods, it is submitted that it is appropriate to impose an equivalent penalty on each of the Respondents. This, it is jointly submitted, is consistent with the parity principle.Nature and extent of the breach – s 294(a) The Respondents have each admitted to contravening s 282(1) by failing to submit information and data by the dates required between 31 October 2017 and 19 September 2018 (Relevant Period). The information and data submitted in reports by energy retailers under s 282(1) of the Retail Law is important. The information and data to be provided for each of the indicators relates to a variety of performance measures, including areas such as customer numbers, disconnections, debt and hardship assistance. The information and data is in turn published by the AER to inform stakeholders, including policymakers, so they can identify emerging trends and provide better outcomes for consumers. The Respondents accept that their breaches of the Retail Law were serious. The submission of information and data by the dates required by the Guidelines is critical to the AER’s economic and market monitoring function. It helps ensure market transparency and promotes confidence in the retail energy market. It also helps ensure stakeholders are informed which leads to effective policy making. As set out in the SOAFA, the Respondents finally submitted information and data in respect of the Q1, Q2, Q3 and Q4 Reporting Periods, in three tranches on 5 September 2018 (in respect of Schedule 2 to the Guidelines), 12 September 2018 (in respect of Schedule 3 to the Guidelines) and 19 September 2018 (in respect of Schedule 4 to the Guidelines). Accordingly, each of the Respondents contravened s 282(1) for the following periods:(1)Q1 Reporting Period: 323 days (the Q1 Report was due on 31 October 2017);(2)Q2 Reporting Period: 231 days (the Q2 Report was due on 31 January 2018);(3)Q3 Reporting Period: 142 days (the Q3 Report was due on 30 April 2018); and(4)Q4 Reporting Period: 19 days (the Q4 Report was due on 31 August 2018).