Australian Energy Regulator v AGL HP 1 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Energy Regulator v AGL HP 1 Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 737

File number: SAD 170 of 2019
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 28 June 2022
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW — application for declaration of contravention of National Electricity Rules (NER) pursuant to s 44AAG(1) of Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CC Act), imposition of pecuniary penalties pursuant to s 44AAG(2)(a) of CC Act and order for engagement of compliance expert pursuant to s 44AAG(2) of CC Act — where respondents “Registered Participants” in National Electricity Market and “Generators” with respect to four wind farms (Hallett wind farms) — where during relevant period, each wind turbine at each of Hallett wind farms featured low voltage ride through capability (LVRT capability), a control system activated when voltage dipped below 80% of “nominal voltage” level and seeking to ensure turbines capable of “riding through” certain voltage disturbances — where each wind turbine at each of Hallett wind farms included repeat low voltage ride-through protection system (repeat LVRT protection system), which during relevant period had settings applied so as to be triggered if LVRT capability activated three times within 120-second period and when triggered, caused rotational speed of wind turbine to slow and wind turbine to cease generating active power — where system and settings designed and applied by supplier of wind turbines and respondents not aware of system or settings — where on 28 September 2016, six undervoltage disturbances within period of approximately 90 seconds, in response to fourth of which repeat LVRT protection system activated on a number of wind turbines at each of Hallett wind farms — where prior to connecting each of Hallett wind farms to power system, respondents required to negotiate and determine with Network Service Provider set of performance standards, including for requirements in Sch 5.2 of NER — where pursuant to cl 4.4.3 of NER, respondents required, in accordance with Sch 5.2 of NER, to provide protective systems to protect plant and associated facilities against abnormal voltage excursions of power system — where none of agreed performance standards for Hallett wind farms contained reference to repeat LVRT protection system — where pursuant to cl S5.2.2 of NER, respondents only permitted to apply settings to control system or protection system if approved in writing by Network Service Provider and Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) and prohibited from allowing wind turbines to supply electricity to power system without such prior approval — where respondents agree orders sought by applicant should be made — whether appropriate to make declaration sought — consideration of matters in s 64 of National Electricity Law for which there must be regard in determining civil penalty and other relevant matters — consideration of relevance of statutory maximum in fixing civil penalty in accordance with Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; (2022) 399 ALR 599 — where among other things, parties submit serious breaches of NER compromising AEMO’s ability to maintain power system in…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Energy Regulator v AGL HP 1 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 737
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) brought proceedings against AGL HP 1 Pty Ltd, AGL HP 2 Pty Ltd, and AGL HP 3 Pty Ltd (collectively, the respondents) for contraventions of the National Electricity Rules (NER) by operating wind turbines at the Hallett wind farms without the necessary approvals for the settings of the repeat low voltage ride-through protection system (LVRT protection system). The respondents, who were Registered Participants in the National Electricity Market and Generators with respect to the Hallett wind farms, had not been aware of the LVRT protection system or the settings applied to it, which were installed by the supplier of the wind turbines. The respondents had agreed to the declaration sought by the AER, the amount of pecuniary penalties, the terms of an order for the engagement of a compliance expert, and an order for costs. The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether it was appropriate to make a declaration that the respondents contravened clauses 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the NER by operating the generating units of the Hallett wind farms and allowing them to supply electricity to the power system when the settings for the repeat LVRT protection system had not been approved in writing by the Network Service Provider or the Australian Energy Market Operator.

The court found that the respondents had contravened clauses 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the NER by operating the wind turbines at the Hallett wind farms without the necessary approvals for the settings of the repeat LVRT protection system. The court noted that the respondents were required to provide protective systems to protect their plant and associated facilities against abnormal voltage excursions of the power system and were only permitted to apply settings to control systems or protection systems if approved in writing by the Network Service Provider and the Australian Energy Market Operator. The court considered the agreed facts and the submissions of the parties and found that the respondents had committed serious breaches of the NER, which compromised the Australian Energy Market Operator's ability to maintain the power system in a secure operating state.

The court imposed pecuniary penalties on the respondents in the amount of $1,166,666.67 for each contravention of clause 4.4.3 of the NER and ordered the respondents to pay the AER's costs of the proceeding in the amount of $300,000. The court also ordered the current registered participant for each of the Hallett wind farms, AGL SA Generation Pty Ltd, to engage a suitably independent compliance professional with expertise in compliance with Generator Performance Standards to review and assess its compliance program, identify any gaps or non-conformities, and provide recommendations to remedy any such gaps or non-conformities. The court considered the relevance of the statutory maximum in fixing the civil penalty in accordance with the decision of the High Court of Australia in Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson.

The court made a declaration that the respondents contravened clauses 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the NER between 6 August 2013 and 23 December 2016, by operating the generating units of the Hallett wind farms and allowing them to supply electricity to the power system when the settings for the repeat LVRT protection system had not been approved in writing by the Network Service Provider or the Australian Energy Market Operator. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the pecuniary penalties and the AER's costs and to engage a compliance expert to review and assess its compliance program. The court dismissed all of the remaining claims in the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Pursuant to s 44AAG(2) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the CC Act), the respondents pay the costs of and ensure that the current registered participant for each of the Hallett 1, 2, 4 and 5 wind farms (AGL SA Generation Pty Ltd (ACN 081 074 204)) (the Current Registered Participant):

(a) within 15 days of the making of this order, engages a suitably independent compliance professional with expertise in compliance with Generator Performance Standards (the Compliance Expert), with the identity of the Compliance Expert to be agreed between the AER and the Current Registered Participant, or failing agreement, as proposed by counsel and determined by the Court;

(b) within 15 days of the making of this order, instructs the Compliance Expert to:

(i) review the Current Registered Participant’s compliance program under NER 4.15(b) in respect of the Hallett 1, 2, 4 and 5 wind farms and assess whether it conforms with the requirements of NER 4.15(c);

(ii) identify any aspect of the Current Registered Participant’s compliance program that does not conform, or that may be at risk of not conforming, with the requirements of NER 4.15(c);

(iii) identify any gaps in the existing procedures under the Current Registered Participant’s compliance program; and

(iv) provide recommendations to remedy any such gaps or non-conformities identified in the course of the Compliance Expert’s assessment; and

(c) within six months from the date of this order, provide a written report, signed by the Compliance Expert and the Chief Executive Officer/s (or equivalent) of the Current Registered Participant, to the AER that:

(i) describes the expertise of the Compliance Expert and confirms his or her independence;

(ii) states precisely how each of the steps described in Order 2(b) were completed;

(iii) annexes a copy of the Compliance Expert’s recommendations to the Current Registered Participant;

(iv) states precisely what steps have been taken to give effect to the Compliance Expert’s recommendations;

(v) annexes a copy of all internal documents that were amended as a consequence of the Compliance Expert’s recommendations; and

(vi) states any of the Compliance Expert’s recommendations that were not implemented by the Current Registered Participant.

3. Pursuant to s 44AAG(2)(a) of the CC Act, within 28 days of the making of this order, each Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $1,166,666.67 in respect of the contravention of cl 4.4.3 of the NER referred to in the Declaration.

4. Pursuant to s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), within 28 days of the making of this Order, the respondents pay the applicant’s costs of, and incidental to, this proceeding, agreed in the amount of $300,000.

5. All of the remaining claims in the Amended Originating Application are dismissed.

6. There be liberty to the parties to apply with respect to the identification of the Compliance Expert referred to in Order 2(a).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant in this proceeding is the Australian Energy Regulator and the respondents are AGL HP 1 Pty Ltd, AGL HP 2 Pty Ltd and AGL HP 3 Pty Ltd. The applicant seeks against the respondents a declaration, the imposition of pecuniary penalties and other orders. The applicant and the respondents have agreed the terms of a declaration, the amount of pecuniary penalties, the terms of an order for the engagement of a compliance expert and an order for costs. They have placed before the Court a Statement of Agreed Facts, a Further Statement of Agreed Facts (both within s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)) and Joint Submissions. THE FACTS The statement of facts which follows is taken from the Statement of Agreed Facts and the Further Statement of Agreed Facts. A Glossary, insofar as it relates to expressions in the National Electricity Rules (the NER), is included in these reasons as Appendix A. The “relevant period” for the purposes of the facts which follow is from 6 August 2013 to 23 December 2016. The applicant is a body corporate established pursuant to s 44AE of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the CC Act) and has the functions and powers referred to in s 15 of the National Electricity Law (the NEL), which is set out in the Schedule to the National Electricity (South Australia) Act 1996 (SA). At all material times, the respondents comprised a partnership known as the AGL Hydro Partnership and were Registered Participants in the National Electricity Market (the NEM) and Generators in relation to each of the following wind farms: (1) the Brown Hill (Hallett 1) wind farm; (2) the Hallett Hill (Hallett 2) wind farm; (3) the North Brown Hill (Hallett 4) wind farm; and (4) the Bluff (Hallett 5) wind farm (together, the Hallett wind farms). At all times since at least 31 May 2011, AGL Energy Limited has been the ultimate holding company of each of the respondents. AGL SA Generation Pty Ltd is also a wholly owned subsidiary of AGL Energy Limited and it is now the Generator in respect of the Hallett wind farms. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) is, and at all relevant times since 1 July 2009 was, the independent market and system operator for the NEM, covering the interconnected power system in Australia’s eastern and south-eastern seaboard and Tasmania. Before 1 July 2009, AEMO was known as the National Electricity Market Management Company Ltd (NEMMCO). ElectraNet Pty Ltd (ElectraNet) is, and at all relevant times was, the Network Service Provider of the transmission network to which the Hallett wind farms are connected. Each of the four wind farms is, and was during the relevant period, a generating system comprising a number of Suzlon S88 wind turbine generating units as set out below and, in the case of the Hallett 5 wind farm, there is and was, in addition to Suzlon S88 wind turbine generating units, one Suzlon S97 wind turbine generating unit. The number of Suzlon S88 wind turbine generating units at each farm is as follows:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether it is appropriate to make the declaration sought by the applicant.
2. Whether it is appropriate to impose the pecuniary penalties sought by the applicant.
3. Whether it is appropriate to make the order sought for the engagement of a compliance expert.

Held
1. It is appropriate to make the declaration sought by the applicant. The Court found that the respondents contravened cl 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the National Electricity Rules by operating the generating units of the Hallett 1, 2, 4 and 5 wind farms and allowing those generating units to supply electricity to the power system when the settings for the repeat low voltage ride-through protection system applied to them had not been approved in writing by the network service provider or the Australian Energy Market Operator.
2. It is appropriate to impose the pecuniary penalties sought by the applicant. The Court ordered each respondent to pay a pecuniary penalty of $1,166,666.67 for the contravention of cl 4.4.3 of the NER.
3. It is appropriate to make the order sought for the engagement of a compliance expert. The Court ordered the current registered participant for each of the Hallett 1, 2, 4 and 5 wind farms to engage a suitably independent compliance professional with expertise in compliance with Generator Performance Standards to review and assess the compliance program, identify any non-conformities or gaps, and provide recommendations to remedy any such gaps or non-conformities.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I turn now to the relief sought by the applicant.THE DECLARATION The applicant seeks the following declaration:The Respondents contravened cl 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) between 6 August 2013 and 23 December 2016, by operating the generating units of the Hallett 1, 2, 4 and 5 wind farms and allowing those generating units to supply electricity to the power system when the settings for the repeat low voltage ride-through protection system applied to them had not been approved in writing by the network service provider or the Australian Energy Market Operator.The respondents agree to the making of a declaration in these terms. Clause 4.4.3 of the NER appears under the heading, “Generator protection requirements” and is in the following terms: Generators must, in accordance with schedule 5.2 and Chapter 5, provide any necessary automatically initiated protective device or systems to protect their plant and associated facilities against abnormal voltage and extreme frequency excursions of the power system. Note This clause is classified as a civil penalty provision under the National Electricity (South Australia) Regulations. (See clause 6(1) and Schedule 1 of the National Electricity (South Australia) Regulations.) Clause S5.2.2 of the NER appears under the heading, “Application of Settings” and is in the following terms, relevantly: A Generator must only apply settings to a control system or a protection system that are necessary to comply with performance requirements of this schedule 5.2 if the settings have been approved in writing by the relevant Network Service Provider and, if the requirement is one that would involve AEMO under clause 5.3.4A(c) of the Rules, also by AEMO. A Generator must not allow its generating unit to supply electricity to the power system without such prior approval. … The applicant has established four contraventions by the respondents of cll 4.4.3 and S5.2.2 of the NER between the period from 6 August 2013 to 23 December 2016. The power of the Court to make an order declaring that a person is in breach of a uniform energy law that is applied as a law of the Commonwealth or a State/Territory energy law, is contained in s 44AAG(1) of the CC Act. The NEL, including the NER, is a uniform energy law that is applied as a law of the Commonwealth or a State/Territory energy law. Section 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) is also a source of power to make declarations. The Court must be satisfied that it is appropriate to make a declaration even where the parties agree that a declaration is appropriate. The circumstances in which the Court will consider it appropriate to make a declaration are well established. In the seminal case of Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Limited [1972] HCA 61; (1972) 127 CLR 421, Gibbs J (as his Honour then was) identified (at 437–438) the following matters as relevant to the exercise of the power to make a declaration: (1) the question must be a real and not a hypothetical or theoretical question; (2) the applicant must have a real interest in raising it; and (3) there must be a proper contradictor. Each of these three matters is satisfied in the circumstances of this case.