Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd (No 3) [2024] FCA 277  

File number: SAD 187 of 2019
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 27 March 2024
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW — where held in principal reasons that the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) was successful in establishing that Pelican Point Power Ltd’s (PPPL) Short Term PASA inputs submitted after 3 February 2017 at 12.14 pm contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) National Electricity Rules (NER) — where at the outset of the proceedings the Court made an order that liability be heard separately, and in advance of, the determination of what relief should be granted — where relief sought is declarations and civil penalties — where the AER seeks declaratory orders under s 44AAG(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) to the effect that PPPL is in breach of a State energy law as defined in s 4 of the CCA — where dispute between parties as to the form of declarations with respect to contraventions of cl 3.7.3(e)(2) and cl 3.13.2(h) — whether declarations within the scope of the case advanced at the trial as to liability — where dispute between parties as to the number of contraventions of cl 3.7.3(e)(2) — declarations made

CONSUMER LAW — where the AER seeks the imposition of civil penalties on PPPL — consideration of relevant matters pursuant to s 64 of the National Electricity Law and  Trade Practices Commission v CSR Limited [1990] FCA 521; (1991) 13 ATPR 41-076 — consideration of the nature and circumstances of the contravening conduct — whether the contraventions arose out of the conduct of senior management or at a lower level — consideration of the nature and extent of any loss or damage suffered as a result of the contraventions — consideration of authorities involving contraventions of the NER — whether PPPL had in place, and was complying with , a compliance program — consideration of the difficulty in detecting the contraventions —whether PPPL has engaged in any similar contravening conduct — consideration of the size and financial position of PPPL and the ENGIE Group — whether there has been co-operation and timely disclosure by PPPL — where one civil penalty should be imposed — where civil penalty of $900,000 imposed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 4, 44AAG

National Electricity Law ss 2, 2AA, 9, 28, 64, 66, 67, 74, 79, 82, 116

National Electricity Rules (Version 88) cll 3.7.2, 3.7.3, 3.8.14, 3.8.20, 3.13.2, 3.13.6A, 4.8.4, 4.8.9, 4.8.15, 4.9.8

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 8.03

National Electricity (South Australia) Act 1996 (SA) s 6

National Electricity (South Australia) Regulations, reg 6  

Cases cited:

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Delor Vue Apartments CTS 39788 [2021] FCAFC 121; (2021) 287 FCR 388

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; (2022) 274 CLR 450

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 159; (2017) 258 FCR 312

Australian…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) took action against Pelican Point Power Ltd (PPPL) in the Federal Court, asserting that PPPL had contravened specific provisions of the National Electricity Rules (NER). The central dispute was whether PPPL's Short Term PASA inputs, submitted after 3 February 2017, breached cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER. The AER sought declaratory orders under s 44AAG(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and civil penalties. The court had to determine whether the declarations proposed by the AER were within the scope of the case advanced at the trial and the number of contraventions of cl 3.7.3(e)(2). Additionally, the AER sought to impose civil penalties on PPPL, requiring consideration of various factors under s 64 of the National Electricity Law.

The court found that the AER had successfully established that PPPL's submissions contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER. It held that the declarations sought by the AER were within the scope of the case and identified 100 contraventions. The court imposed a civil penalty of $900,000 on PPPL, taking into account the nature and extent of the contraventions, the importance of the obligations breached, and various other factors such as the contraventions' impact on customers and financial losses. The court noted that the contraventions did not lead to the load shedding on 8 February 2017 and did not cause any specific impact on customers or financial losses, but acknowledged the significance of the breached obligations in maintaining the power system's reliability.

The court made declarations regarding PPPL's contraventions of cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER and ordered that PPPL pay a civil penalty of $900,000. The court noted that it would hear the parties regarding costs. The ratio of the decision was that the AER's submissions regarding the number and nature of contraventions were upheld, leading to the imposition of the specified penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. With respect to the contraventions identified in the aforesaid declarations, Pelican Point Power Ltd pay a civil penalty of $900,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Fourth, PPPL’s contraventions did not lead to the load shedding which occurred on 8 February 2017 and nor would it have been reduced in duration had the contraventions not occurred. PPPL’s contraventions did not have a specific impact on customers and nor did those contraventions cause any financial losses. At the same time, it must be acknowledged and taken into account that the nature of the obligations breached are important and are intended to enable AEMO to manage the reliability of the power system.CONCLUSIONS The following declarations will be made:(1)By each of its four short term PASA submissions made between 6 February 2017 at 11:00 and 7 February 2017 at 11:25 identified below for each of the future trading intervals during the 8 February 2017 trading day identified below, the respondent contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the National Electricity Rules (NER) by submitting short term PASA availability values of 220 MW that did not represent its current intentions and best estimates as to the physical plant capability of the Pelican Point Power Station that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice which was 320 MW. In addition, there will be an order as follows:(3)With respect to the contraventions identified in the aforesaid declarations, Pelican Point Power Ltd pay a civil penalty of $900,000. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the AER’s written outline of opening submissions at the trial as to liability, it contended that there were 10 contraventions of cl 3.7.2(d)(1) (MT PASA submissions), the first on 16 November 2016 and the last on 27 January 2017. There was one contravention of cl 3.13.2(h) which occurred on 11 November 2017 and that contravention continued for 89 days. There were 1,344 “discrete” contraventions of cl 3.7.3(e)(2) (ST PASA submissions) being 28 submissions each containing entries for 48 trading intervals.The Declarations which will be made It will assist in understanding the arguments and the reasons for their acceptance or rejection if I set out at this point the declarations which I consider should be made. They are as follows:1.By each of its four short term PASA submissions made between 6 February 2017 at 11:00 and 7 February 2017 at 11:25 identified below for each of the future trading intervals during the 8 February 2017 trading day identified below, the respondent contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the National Electricity Rules (NER) by submitting short term PASA availability values of 220 MW that did not represent its current intentions and best estimates as to the physical plant capability of the Pelican Point Power Station that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice which was 320 MW. Annexure A to these reasons is a document prepared by PPPL which relates to the declaration it contends is appropriate in the sense that it identifies the period of contravening conduct and it shows the results of the various arguments it puts as to the number of contraventions. Columns A, B and C in Annexure A identify the 24 ST PASA submissions and the date and time they were made by PPPL. Column D summarises the AER’s case as to the number of contraventions. Columns A, B, C and D contain the same information as the AER’s table which is set out above (at [13]). Annexure A shows that the first ST PASA submission was made on 6 February 2017 at 11:00 and the AER contends that it gave rise to 48 contraventions. PPPL disputes this on the ground that it would not have been reasonably known to PPPL on 6 February 2017 that GT12 could have been run for approximately four hours on 8 February 2017. This is PPPL’s first argument. PPPL’s second argument is that submissions 5 to 24 in the yellow box in Annexure A cannot constitute contraventions because, although they were made, they do not relate to the period covered by ST PASA submissions. This argument raises construction issues concerning certain rules in the NER. PPPL’s third argument is reflected in the number of contraventions shown in Column E. It is that only those submissions made 24 hours or more before the relevant trading interval are capable of constituting contraventions. That follows, on PPPL’s argument, because of the reference in the definition of PASA availability of availability “on 24 hours’ notice”. PPPL’s fourth argument is reflected in the number of contraventions shown in Column F. It is that it is only the ST PASA submissions that involve a change to PASA availability from that previously submitted that are capable of constituting contraventions. There are no contraventions, on PPPL’s argument, where there has been no change to information previously submitted. If this, and only this, argument succeeds, then there are 100 contraventions. If this argument and the first and second (or first and third) arguments succeed, then there are arguably no contraventions, although PPPL accepts that it may be appropriate to regard the second submission involving 37 contraventions as a “‘new’ (and incorrect) submission”.