Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd
Link copied
CaseCopied
87 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd [2023] FCA 1110
File number:
SAD 187 of 2019
Judgment of:
BESANKO J
Date of judgment:
20 September 2023
Catchwords:
CONSUMER LAW — application for declarations of contraventions of National Electricity Rules (NER) pursuant to s 44AAG(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) — where on 8 February 2017, a day Adelaide recorded a maximum temperature of 42.4 degrees Celsius, the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) had to issue a direction to initiate load shedding to return the power system to a secure operating state in South Australia — where load shedding was not required in similar conditions on 9 February 2017 as AEMO was able to direct Pelican Point Power Limited (PPPL) to synchronise and dispatch GT12 — whether (PPPL) contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER by failing to submit its short term Projected Assessment of System Adequacy (PASA) availability for each trading interval during the 8 February 2017 trading day so as to reflect the true physical plant capability of the Pelican Point Power Station that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice — whether PPPL contravened cl 3.7.2(d)(1) of the NER by failing to submit medium term PASA (MT PASA) availability so as to reflect the true physical plant capability of the Pelican Point Power Station that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice after the gas turbine GT12 was brought from dry to wet storage on 11 November 2016 — whether PPPL contravened cl 3.13.2(h) of the NER by failing to notify AEMO promptly on or after 11 November 2016 of the increased MT PASA availability
CONSUMER LAW — where the AER seeks the imposition of civil penalties on PPPL — where Court made an order that liability be heard separately, and in advance of, the determination of what relief should be granted
CONSUMER LAW — where the highest availability submitted by PPPL in its short term PASA (ST PASA) for the 8 February 2017 trading day was 235 MW — where PPPL’s MT PASA input for 8 February 2017 was 224 MW — consideration of two hypothetical operating scenarios a reasonable generator would have had in mind, 320 MW scenario which involves GT11 and GT12 operating concurrently for four hours and the 8 February counterfactual which involves GT11 operating as it did on 8 February 2017 and GT12 operating on 8 February 2017 as it in fact operated on 9 February 2017 — consideration of principles of statutory interpretation — consideration of proper construction of the defined term “PASA availability” in cll 3.7.2(d)(1) and 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER — where issue as to the nature and extent of the Scheduled Generator’s obligations in submitting estimates or forecasts of MT and ST PASA — consideration of the meaning of “current intentions” and “best estimates” — consideration of how much non-firm gas PPPL could reasonably expect to have been able to obtain on 8 February 2017 on 24 hours’ notice —…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Energy Regulator v Pelican Point Power Ltd and more:
The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) brought proceedings against Pelican Point Power Ltd (PPPL) for alleged breaches of the National Electricity Rules (NER) and sought civil penalties. The central issue was whether PPPL had failed to submit accurate Projected Assessment of System Adequacy (PASA) availability figures for the Pelican Point Power Station on 8 February 2017. Specifically, the AER argued that PPPL did not submit PASA availability that reflected the true physical plant capability of the station that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice. The court had to decide whether PPPL contravened specific clauses of the NER by not submitting the correct PASA availability figures. The court also had to interpret certain terms within the NER, such as "PASA availability" and "current intentions," and assess whether PPPL's submissions were reasonable given the circumstances.
The court concluded that PPPL did not contravene the NER regarding the medium-term PASA availability for 8 February 2017, as the submissions made were reasonable at the time. However, PPPL did contravene the NER with its short-term PASA inputs submitted after 3 February 2017 at 12:14 pm. The court considered the hypothetical scenarios presented, the physical condition of the gas turbines, and expert evidence to reach its decision. It was held that the AER did not establish that the medium-term PASA availability of 224 MW was not a reasonable forecast at that time. The court found that PPPL's short-term PASA inputs submitted after 3 February 2017 at 12.14 pm contravened cl 3.7.3(e)(2) of the NER.
The court ordered the AER to prepare draft minutes of order reflecting the conclusions within seven days, to be served on PPPL and lodged with the Court. The proceeding was adjourned to a date to be fixed after consultation with the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applicant prepare draft minutes of order reflecting the conclusions in these reasons and/or the orders sought as to the future progress of this proceeding and serve on the respondent and lodge with the Court such draft minutes of order within seven days.
2. The proceeding be adjourned to a date to be fixed after consultation with the parties.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The AER alleges that PPPL had an obligation (which it failed to discharge) in relation to its MT PASA submissions for 8 February 2017 and in relation to each of its 10 MT PASA submissions made after 11 November 2016 to submit MT PASA availability so as to reflect the physical plant capability of the Pelican Point PS that could be made available on 24 hours’ notice after GT12 was brought from dry to wet storage. PPPL, in relation to its MT PASA submissions for 11 February 2017, had an obligation (which it failed to discharge) to notify AEMO promptly on or after 11 November 2016 of the increased MT PASA availability of the Pelican Point PS after GT12 was brought from dry to wet storage on 11 November 2016.FACTS WHICH ARE NOT IN DISPUTE The following facts are taken from the Statement of Agreed Facts signed by both parties. The AER is a body corporate established pursuant to s 44E of the CCA, and has the functions and powers referred to in s 15 of the NEL. PPPL is a company incorporated in England and Wales and is registered in Australia as a foreign country under s 601CE of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). It is wholly owned by International Power (Australia) Pty Ltd trading as ENGIE and previously known as GDF Suez. PPPL is the operator of the Pelican Point PS and is a Registered Participant and a Scheduled Generator within the NER. Pelican Point PS is and was at all material times an aggregated scheduled generating unit under cl 3.8.3 of the NER comprising two gas turbines with designated identifiers GT11 and GT12 and one steam turbine, and scheduled plant within the NER to which AEMO may issue a direction to PPPL under cl 4.8.9(a) and (a1)(1). At all relevant times, Pelican Point PS had a registered capacity of 478 MW. The ability of PPPL to operate the Pelican Point PS at its registered capacity is directly affected by certain operating conditions, including but not limited to, the ambient air temperature, the physical condition of the gas turbines and the steam turbine, the availability of gas supply and the availability of gas transport (operating conditions). Subject to the operating conditions, at all relevant times each gas turbine was capable of generating up to approximately 160 MW. Subject to the operating conditions and subject to one or both of the gas turbines operating, at all relevant times the steam turbine was capable of being operated in conjunction with one or both of the gas turbines to generate up to approximately 79 MW, if only one of the gas turbines was in operation, and up to approximately 158 MW if both of the gas turbines were in operation. Again, subject to the operating conditions, at all relevant times, Pelican Point PS was capable of generating up to approximately 478 MW, if both of the gas turbines were operating in combination with the steam turbine, or up to approximately 239 MW, if only one of the gas turbines was operating in conjunction with the steam turbine. Again, subject to the operating conditions, at all relevant times, Pelican Point PS was capable of a minimum generating capacity of approximately 160–170 MW, if only one gas turbine was operating in conjunction with the steam turbine, or approximately 320–335 MW, if both gas turbines were operating in conjunction with the steam turbine. PPPL does not agree that minimum generating capacity is relevant to whether it has breached any of cl 3.7.2(d)(1), cl 3.7.3(e)(2) and/or cl 3.13.2(h). As I will explain, the 320 MW minimum generating capacity is significant because it is this figure which is relevant to “the basic 320 MW scenario” or, as PPPL referred to it, “the 320 MW, 4 hour ‘benchmark scenario’”.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Both these operating scenarios are, of course, hypothetical. However, they frame the issues concerning reasonable expectations as to the availability of gas supply and gas transport. No other operating scenarios were advanced by the AER.THE EVIDENCE The AER called four witnesses as follows:(1)Mr Tjaart Nicolaas Van Der Walt who is employed by AEMO as Group Manager, NEM Real Time Operations;(2)Ms Philippa Jean Eastgate who is employed by the AER as Assistant Director in its Compliance and Enforcement Branch;(3)Mr Michael Nicholas Sanders who is employed by AEMO as Principal Analyst, Electricity Market Monitoring; and(4)Mr James Arthur Snow, an expert who has extensive experience in the energy industry, including gas with both practical experience and experience as an adviser, reviewer and consultant. PPPL called four witnesses as follows:(1)Mr Darren Foulds who is employed by ENGIE as Head of Trading and Portfolio Management;(2)Mr Debasis Baksi who was employed by ENGIE and was General Manager – South Australian Assets between 2012 to 2020; (3)Mr Michael Weatherly who was employed by ENGIE (International Power), and was Origination Manager between 2015 and 2018; and (4)Mr Andrew O’Farrell, an expert who has spent many years in the energy industry and between 2011 and 2018 was Gas Portfolio Manager for Origin Energy. Each party also tendered a number of documents in support of its case. Without being exhaustive at this stage, the AER placed reliance on the transcripts of conversations between representatives of PPPL and representatives of AEMO on 8 and again on 9 February 2017, the events of 9 February 2017 and, in particular, the fact that PPPL was able to operate the two gas turbines concurrently on that day for about four hours and certain answers International Power (Australia) Holdings Pty Ltd (ENGIE) gave to a notice issued by the AER under s 28(2)(a) and (b) of the NEL and dated 15 June 2018. I will refer to this as the Section 28 Notice. For its part, and again without being exhaustive, PPPL took the Court to a complex and detailed array of provisions in various gas supply and gas transport agreements and submitted that the uncertainties attending the market for gas and gas transport were such that its approach to the PASA submissions was appropriate and not in contravention of the NER. A further matter which was the subject of evidence and relied on by PPPL was the physical condition of GT12 and PPPL submitted that that was relevant to the issue of whether the PASA submissions complied with the NER. Before addressing the evidence and the factual issues, it is necessary to address a number of construction issues concerning the relevant Rules. The parties made extensive and detailed submissions about these issues.CONSTRUCTION ISSUESThe issues identified The AER put forward a list of what it contended were the construction issues as follows:(1)What is the proper construction of the defined term “PASA availability” in cll 3.7.2(d)(1) and 3.7.3(e)(2) when read in context and having regard to the meaning of the defined terms “physical plant capability” and “available capacity”?(2)Is the commercial intention of a Scheduled Generator as to the amount it proposes to generate relevant to the submission it makes as to that aspect of PASA inputs which is PASA availability?(3)In determining the availability of a scheduled generating unit within the definition of PASA availability, which includes a scheduled generating unit that can be made available on 24 hours’ notice, is the generator in making its PASA submissions limited to firm sources of gas and gas transport, or must it also take into account gas and gas transfers it ought reasonably expect that it would practically be able to procure on 24 hours’ notice if required to do so? “Firm” in this context refers to a term which is well understood in the gas industry in connection with the supply of gas and gas transport. It means contractually obliged to supply with a failure to do so attended by penalties and other contractual remedies. There is no binding obligation in the case of non-firm or “as available” gas or gas transport, although a firm obligation will arise on the execution of a Formal Transaction Notice or Confirmation. This was the evidence of Mr Snow which was not disputed and which I accept.(4)What is the nature and extent of the generator’s obligation to submit estimates or forecasts of MT PASA and ST PASA?(5)How is PASA availability for MT PASA affected by a practical limit on how long a generating unit can run for within a day?(6)How is PASA availability for ST PASA affected by how long a generating unit can run for within a day?
Decision
Reasons for decision
First, GT12 was the primary operating turbine in November, December 2016 and the first half of January 2017. The decision in mid-January 2017 to make GT11 the primary operating turbine is to be seen in the context of PPPL’s intention to run only one turbine at a time and the fact that GT11 had had a more recent C-inspection during which superior blades were fitted and GT12 was approaching a required C-inspection. Secondly, Mr Baksi’s nervousness about running two turbines at the same time was based on the risk of not having backup capacity. Thirdly, any difficulty involved in making long-range forecasts concerning GT12 is answered by the fact that there is an ability to change or revise forecasts where there is a change in circumstances, indeed an obligation to do so. Fourthly, GT12 was run for between 14–16 hours on 7 February 2017 and for four hours on 9 February 2017 with no suggestion on the latter date that AEMO’s direction meant that GT12 could not be run because the case fell within cl 4.8.9(c) of the NER. It was run “hard” in late March 2017. Finally, PPPL in its response to the Section 28 Notice did not suggest the physical condition of GT12 was an obstacle to running GT12 on 8 February 2017. The matters referred to were the availability of gas and gas transport.CONCLUSIONS For the reasons I have given, I do not consider that PPPL was required to assess and determine its PASA submissions by reference to the basic 320 MW scenario. PPPL’s liability for contraventions is to be determined by reference to the 8 February counterfactual. The MT PASA covers the 24 month period commencing from the Sunday after the day of publication with a daily resolution (cl 3.7.2(a)). The Scheduled Generator’s obligation is to submit ST PASA inputs, including PASA availability, in accordance with the timetable (cl 3.7.2(d)). The timetable is defined as the timetable published by AEMO under cl 3.4.3 for the operation of the spot market and the provision of market information. As far as MT PASA inputs, including PASA availability are concerned, the relief sought by the AER relates to 10 MT PASA submissions made after 11 November 2016. The 10 submissions are identified in the Statement of Agreed Facts and range in dates from 16 November 2016 to 27 January 2017. The ST PASA must be published at least daily by AEMO in accordance with the timetable and it covers the period of six trading days from the end of the trading day covered by the most recently published pre-dispatch schedule with a trading interval resolution (cl 3.7.3(a) and (b)). The relief sought by the AER relates to 27 ST PASA submissions made in or from 30 January 2017 for each trading interval during the 8 February 2017 trading day. The dates of PPPL’s submissions of its ST PASA inputs for the Pelican Point PS for the 8 February 2017 trading day are identified in the Statement of Agreed Facts as 15 January at 9.52; 30 January at 9.10, 2 February at 6.44 and 9.11; 6 February at 11.00; 7 February at 9.56, 11.22, 11.25, 16.56, 17.00; and 8 February at 6.58, 10.12, 11.14, 12.43, 13.53, 15.22, 15.45, 16.42, 17.17, 17.33, 18.03, 18.23, 18.40, 18.57, 19.08, 19.26, 19.47 and 20.51.