Melbourne City Council v Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Melbourne City Council v Telstra Corporation Limited [2020] FCAFC 200  

Appeal from: Telstra Corporation Limited v Melbourne City Council [2020] FCA 305
File number: VID 232 of 2020
VID 234 of 2020
Judgment of: GLEESON, CHARLESWORTH, O'BRYAN JJ
Date of judgment: 20 November 2020
Catchwords: COMMUNICATIONS LAW – whether New Payphone Cabinets are “low-impact facilities” within the meaning of clause 6 of Sch 3 to the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) exempt from planning laws – where Telstra sought planning approval to display commercial advertising on New Payphone Cabinets – where New Payphone Cabinets to be installed only after planning approval to display commercial advertising obtained – whether primary judge erred in concluding that the New Payphone Cabinets are “low-impact facilities” – appeal allowed with costs
Legislation:

Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 3, 7, 15, 484, Sch 3

Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth) s 6

Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 1997 (Cth)

Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 2018 (Cth) s 3.1

Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) s 31

Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic) ss 6, 77, 149A

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; 175 CLR 564

DBB16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 178; 260 FCR 447

Gill v Donald Humberstone & Co Ltd [1963] 1 WLR 929; [1963] 3 All ER 180

Hutchison 3G Australia Pty Ltd v City of Mitcham [2006] HCA 12; 80 ALJR 711

NBN Co Limited v Pipe Networks Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 475; 295 FLR 256

Nominal Defendant v GLG Australia Pty Ltd [2006] HCA 11; 228 CLR 529

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access
Number of paragraphs: 173
Date of hearing: 3 August 2020
Counsel for the Appellants: T Sullivan QC, MJ Batty and K Wood
Solicitor for the Appellants: City Legal, Melbourne City Council and City Legal, Brisbane City Council
Counsel for the Respondents: SR Morris QC and R Chaile
Solicitors for the First Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons
Solicitors for the Third Respondent: Maddocks

ORDERS

VID 234 of 2020
BETWEEN:

MELBOURNE CITY COUNCIL

Appellant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ABN 33 051 775 556)

First Respondent

SYDNEY CITY COUNCIL

Second Respondent

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL

Third Respondent

order made by:

GLEESON, CHARLESWORTH, O'BRYAN JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

20 November 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The declaration made by the primary judge on 10 March 2020 be set aside.

3.The originating application in proceeding VID500/2019 be dismissed.

4.The order for costs made on 17 March 2020 be set aside.

5.The first respondent pay the costs of the appellant below and in this appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ORDERS

VID 232 of 2020
BETWEEN:

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL

Appellant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ABN 33 051 775 556)

First Respondent

MELBOURNE CITY COUNCIL

Second Respondent

SYDNEY CITY COUNCIL

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Melbourne City Council v Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCAFC 200
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Melbourne City Council v Telstra Corporation Limited, the primary judge made a determination regarding the classification of new payphone cabinets installed by Telstra. The dispute hinged on whether these cabinets constituted "low-impact facilities" under clause 6 of Schedule 3 to the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth). The classification would exempt these facilities from certain planning laws. Telstra sought planning approval to display commercial advertising on these new cabinets, which were only to be installed after obtaining such approval. The court had to decide whether the primary judge was correct in concluding that the new payphone cabinets qualified as "low-impact facilities."

The court found that the primary judge erred in concluding that the new payphone cabinets were "low-impact facilities." The judges reasoned that the primary use of these cabinets was to display commercial advertising, which is not a permitted use under the criteria for low-impact facilities. The court emphasised that the assessment of whether a facility is low-impact involves a prospective enquiry into the intended uses of the facility. The design and intended use of the cabinets pointed to commercial advertising as a primary function, which disqualified them from being considered low-impact facilities. Consequently, the appeals were allowed, the primary judge's declaration and order for costs were set aside, Telstra's originating application was dismissed, and Telstra was ordered to pay the costs of the appellants and the appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The declaration made by the primary judge on 10 March 2020 be set aside.

3. The originating application in proceeding VID500/2019 be dismissed.

4. The order for costs made on 17 March 2020 be set aside.

5. The first respondent pay the costs of the appellant below and in this appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Determination restated (with minor amendments) the terms of the Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 1997. The amendments included the addition to para (d) of Item 2 the phrase “or displayed as part of the supply of a content service”. As can be seen, those words appear in the Determination in connection with a public payphone instrument but not in connection with a public payphone cabinet or booth. The explanatory memorandum to the Determination said this of the amendment:Current arrangements do not permit the installation of public payphones as low-impact facilities if the payphone displays advertising other than advertising related to the supply of the standard telephone service.However, technological change and customer demand will require payphones to contain, for example, interactive multimedia payphone instruments. In order to be able to supply such services, carriers will need to secure the involvement of commercial organisations, which will require commercial advertising on display screens or on the public payphone instrument.This amendment enables carriers to advertise on a discreet screen or static display located on the payphone instrument. Advertising of this nature must not be used for general advertising purposes and must specifically relate to the content service of the commercial organisation.Further, it is not considered appropriate that carriers be permitted to advertise on the actual payphone booth and therefore item 1 (d) of Part 5 [now Part 6 in the current Determination] remains unamended. Advertising on the payphone cabinet is highly visible and would require local government approval.FACTS The following objective facts are drawn from the reasons of the primary judge and are not subject to challenge. Telstra is modernising its existing payphone network. The upgrade involves the replacement of existing and dated payphones and booths with the New Payphone Cabinets. The front view of the New Payphone Cabinets (depicted below) includes a shelf structure with open glass sides, housing a payphone and a digital screen. The rear view (depicted below) is comprised of a digital LED screen. The larger versions of the New Payphone Cabinets are more than 3m high and 1m wide. In 2017 Telstra entered into an agreement with AdBooth Pty Ltd titled “out of Home Advertising Program Agreement” relating to the installation of cabinets having the same appearance and functions as the New Payphone Cabinets and the display of advertising on their digital screens. The primary judge described AdBooth’s responsibilities under that agreement as:(a)designing and developing the New Payphone Cabinets, in conjunction with Telstra;(b)producing/supplying the New Payphone Cabinets;(c)obtaining planning permits for the display of commercial advertising on the New Payphone Cabinets;(d)together with Telstra, selecting locations for the New Payphone Cabinets with regard to advertising value;(e)installing and maintaining the New Payphone Cabinets;(f)the production, installation, removal and management of all advertising (including STS related, or other Telstra, advertising) displayed on the 32” screens; and(g)all aspects of the sales, production, installation and removal of third-party commercial advertising on the 75” screens.Reasons at [35].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, the evidence adduced at trial requires a conclusion that the proposed New Payphone Cabinets are not low-impact facilities because the function they are designed to service is the display of commercial advertising. As stated earlier, Item 6-1 of the Determination must be construed in a practical manner and, by the same reasoning, must be applied in a practical manner. It can be accepted that a future use of the proposed New Payphone Cabinets to display commercial advertising that is remote or speculative would not satisfy condition (d). However, in this case, commercial advertising is not remote or speculative. Such use is one of the central functions that the New Payphone Cabinets is designed to serve.Conclusions In conclusion, I would uphold the appeals broadly on the grounds stated in paragraphs 1(a), (b), (d) and (e) of the notices of appeal. As to grounds 1(a) and (b), I consider that the primary judge erred in characterising Telstra’s intended use of the New Payphone Cabinets as a future, conditional intention to display commercial advertising. Telstra’s intended use of the New Payphone Cabinets was to display commercial advertising as evidenced by the commercial arrangements for their design and installation and the steps taken to implement those arrangements. As to grounds 1(d) and (e), I consider that the primary judge erred in failing to find that one of the functions that the proposed New Payphone Cabinets were designed to serve is commercial advertising not limited to standard telephone advertising and, for that reason, the proposed Cabinets did not satisfy condition (d) of Item 6-1 and were not low-impact facilities. On that basis I would order that the declaration made by the primary judge on 10 March 2020 and the order for costs made on 17 March 2020 be set aside, that Telstra’s originating application be dismissed and that Telstra pay the costs of the appellants below and of these appeals.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph (e) does no more than to state a legal conclusion that would follow should the remaining grounds be upheld.CONSIDERATION Four observations may be made from the outset. First, Item 1 of the table in Pt 6 is to be understood as describing the features of a facility that is to be installed at a future time. The provisions conferring immunity from the operation of certain State laws could not have meaningful operation if the uses to which the facility is to be put were unable to be identified in advance of its installation. The prospective analysis ensures that there will be certainty as to the rights and obligations of the carrier at the time of the installation of the facility vis a vis others who may have a legal interest in opposing the installation. It follows that the assessment of a facility against the criteria necessarily involves a prospective enquiry as to the uses to which the facility is to be put once it is installed. As part of that prospective assessment, criterion (b) directs attention to its design. In most cases, it will not be difficult to demonstrate that a carrier has the subjective intention to operate a facility to achieve the purposes for which it is designed. The subjective intent of the carrier may be relevant to the limited extent that it is manifested in the design intent under criterion (b). Second, a facility that may be installed without first obtaining approval under State planning laws may then be used in the manner described in Item 1 without first obtaining approval under State law for that use. Third, the words added by amendment to criterion (d) of Item 2 are relevant to the proper interpretation of Item 1, as the difference in text informs the question of what constitutes a “content service”. On one interpretation, text of the amendment tends to suggest that the display of commercial advertising is something that may occur incidentally in the course of providing a content service, but it is not to be regarded as the supply of a content service in and of itself. Fourth, the question of whether the display of commercial advertising constitutes the supply of a “content service” necessarily impacts upon the interpretation and application of the criteria as a whole. If the display of commercial advertising is the supply of a content service (as opposed to something that may occur in the course of supplying a content service), then criterion (d) must be understood as prohibiting a use (commercial advertising for goods and services other than standard telephone services) that would otherwise be permitted under criterion (a), (b) and (c). On the other hand, if the display of commercial advertising is not a content service, then criterion (d) may be understood as permitting installation of a facility for a use (namely the display of commercial advertising for standard telephone services) that might otherwise fall foul of criteria (a), (b) or (c). Having made those observations, it is necessary to emphasise the confines of the arguments advanced on the appeal.