Canadian Pacific Tobacco Co Ltd v Stapleton

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
86 CLR 1

CASES CITED. Michael v. Callil (1945) -

Poole v. Wah Min Chan (1947) Millner v. Raith (1942) -

Potter v. Commissioners of Inland Mitchell U. B. W. Noble Ltd. Mitford v. Reynolds (1842)

Power v. Power (1944) Monahan v. Monahan (1949)

Preston v. Luck (1884) Monds v. Stackhouse (1948)

Printers and Transferrers' Amal- Montreal Trust Co. v. Canadian

gamated Trades National Railway (1939)

Society, Re (1899) Moodie v. Hosegood (1952)

Proudman v. Dayman (1941) (4), Moreau v. Federal Commissioner of

Public Trustee, Ex p. Taxation (1926) Mullin v. Mullin (1901) -

Pye v. Metropolitan Coal Co. Ltd. Nash v. Rochford Rural District

Council (1917) - National Association of Local

R. U. Arnold (1724)

v. Blakeley; Ex p. Association of Corporation (1943) -

Architects, Engineers, Surveyors and Draughtsmen of Australia (1950) Insurance Co. (1951) National Revenue, Minister of V.

Wrights' Canadian Ropes Ltd.

ciliation and Arbitration Ex p. Jones (Builders' Labourers' Case) New Brunswick Railway

296 (1), 297 (1), 299 (1), British and French Trust Corpora-

307 (1), 316 (5), 317 (1) tion Ltd. (1939) Newell U. The King (1936) O'Flaherty v. McBride (1920)

tralian Railways Union's Case) Owen, Inre; Slater v. Owen (1912) 527 (3)

Copestake (1927) Davies (1858) Davis (1881) Performing Right Society Ltd. U.

Bray Urban District Council

Higginson (1843) (1930) Perpetual Executors Trustees &

Agency Co. (W.A.) Ltd. v. Maslen

Ex p. State of (Maslen's Case) (1952) Perpetual Trustee Co. (Ltd.) V.

v. M'Naghten (M'Naghten's Case) (1843)

368 (2), 369 (5), 370 (3) (1942)

V. Metal Trades Employers' Peto v. Pemberton (1628)

Association Exp. Amalgamated Phene v. Popplewell (1862) Phillips v. Federal Commissioner of

Taxation (Phillips' Case) (1947) 391 Phillips's Case see Taxes (Vict.),

Commissioner of v. Phillips. Pianotist Co. Ltd. for the Registra-

Matter of an Application by the (1906) Pinson v. Lloyds and National

Provincial Foreign Bank Ltd. (1941)

Garlick and Coy (1952) Pleasant v. Benson (1811)

v. Windle (1952) Plummer and John v. David (1920) 248 (3)

Radio Corporation Pomfret's Settlement, Re (1952)

Commonwealth (1938)

86 CLR 286 CLR 3

CASES CITED.

Watson v. J. &A. G. Johnson Ltd. Union Steamship Co. of New

Watson's Case see Taxation, Com- (1925) Uxbridge Permanent Benefit Buil-

Watts' Case see Stamp Duties ding Society v. Pickard (1939) - 357 (2)

(N.S.W.), Commissioner of V. Perpetual Trustee Co. Ltd. Wauchope v. Trefle (1942) Weatherley v. Weatherley (1947) Vancouver Malt and Sake Brewing

Weinberger v. Inglis (1918) Ltd. (1934)

Welton v. Saffery (1897) Westbury (Lord), In re Settlement v. Commonwealth (1943)

of; Westmacott v. Bethell (1944) 528 (2) Victorian Stevedoring and General

Contracting Co. Ptv. Ltd. and Meakes v. Dignan (1931) - 60 (4), 63 (3)

West Rand Central Gold Mining

Co. Ltd. v. The King (1905) W. O. Watt (Dec'd.), In the Estate

Wilson v. Jolly (1948) 609 (2), 610 (1)

Wood v. Searth (1855) Waddington U. O'Callaghan (1931) - 607 (3) Wade's Case see Taxation, Federal

Woodbury U. Woodbury (1949) Wrexham Corporation v. Tamplin Wakefield v. Newbon (1844) Walker U. Walker (1952)

Steamship…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Canadian Pacific Tobacco Co Ltd v Stapleton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1952] HCA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Canadian Pacific Tobacco Co Ltd v Stapleton* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia concerning alleged contempt of court. The dispute arose after the Federal Court of Bankruptcy made orders setting aside various dealings by a bankrupt, including transfers of property to Canadian Pacific Tobacco Co Ltd. An undertaking was given to the High Court by the company and another director, as a condition of a stay of proceedings on the bankruptcy order, not to deal with their assets except in the ordinary course of business or for specific purposes. The trustee of the bankrupt's estate sought to have the company and a director found in contempt for breaching this undertaking.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was the admissibility of evidence obtained by a taxation officer from one of the directors. This evidence consisted of alleged confessional statements made during an interview conducted by the officer. The admissibility of this evidence was challenged on the grounds that it was obtained in contravention of section 16 of the *Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1952*, which imposes restrictions on officers divulging or communicating information acquired in the course of their duties.

Dixon C.J., and subsequently the full bench of the High Court, considered the provisions of section 16. The Court held that information obtained by an officer acting under the authority conferred by section 263 of the Act, for the purpose of vindicating the revenue and collecting outstanding tax, was obtained "under the provisions of this Act". Furthermore, the phrase "except in the performance of his duty" in subsection (2) of section 16 was interpreted to include actions authorised by the officer's employment, such as making an affidavit in proceedings aimed at revenue collection. While subsection (3) protects officers from being compelled to divulge information to a court, it does not prevent them from doing so when authorised by the Commissioner. Consequently, the Court found the confessional statements admissible.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.