Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Hallmark Computer Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Hallmark Computer Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 678

File number: ACD 50 of 2015
Judge: BUCHANAN J
Date of judgment: 8 June 2016
Catchwords: MIGRATION – determination of appropriate penalties for respondents’ contraventions of s 140Q of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – first respondent sponsored four employees’ 457 visas – second respondent at all times sole director and ultimate shareholder of first respondent – where respondents’ conduct involved calculated, systematic, repeated and callous infringements of the conditions of visa sponsorship and employee rights – where respondents’ conduct involved numerous breaches of underpaying wages by recovering a portion of them from employees and failing to pay hours of overtime worked – breaches accepted to be of the most serious kind – assessment of penalties not constrained by the penalty for a single contravention, Migration Act s 486V(2) – totality principle applied – restitution payments ordered
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 557

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 140Q, 486R, 486R(6), 486S, 486U, 486V, 486V(2), 486ZD

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), regs 2.79, 2.79(3), 2.86, 2.87, 2.87(1B)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 7) [2016] FCA 424

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Energy Regulator v Snowy Hydro Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 58

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 90 ALJR 113

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Cahill [2010] FCAFC 39; (2010) 194 IR 461; 269 ALR 1

Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20; (2012) 287 ALR 249

Date of hearing: 15 March 2016
Date of last submissions: 20 May 2016 (applicant)
Registry: Australian Capital Territory
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 63
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr T Begbie
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Sabharwal
Solicitor for the Respondents: Parish Patience Immigration Lawyers

ORDERS

ACD 50 of 2015
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

Applicant

AND:

HALLMARK COMPUTER PTY LTD ACN 139 048 365 T/AS HALLMARK COMPUTER INTERNATIONAL

First Respondent

ASHOK ALEXANDER

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 JUNE 2016

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Contraventions by Hallmark Computer

1.In the period October 2012 to March 2014, the first respondent (Hallmark Computer), as an approved Standard Business Sponsor in respect of Ruel Conducto Duran (Mr Duran), contravened s 140Q of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) in respect of each of the following failures to satisfy a sponsorship obligation:

1.1Hallmark Computer failed to satisfy reg 2.79 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) on 35 occasions by paying Mr Duran less than the guaranteed annual earnings specified by Hallmark Computer in its nomination of Mr Duran.

1.2Hallmark Computer failed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Hallmark Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 678
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection brought proceedings against Hallmark Computer Pty Ltd and its sole director and ultimate shareholder, Mr Alexander, for contraventions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The respondents had sponsored four employees' 457 visas, which are temporary work visas for skilled workers. The court had to decide on the appropriate penalties for the respondents' systematic and repeated breaches of visa sponsorship conditions and employee rights, including underpaying wages and requiring employees to repay a portion of their wages. The court also had to determine the restitution payments owed to the employees and the Commonwealth for PAYG tax.

The court found that the respondents' conduct involved calculated and callous infringements of the sponsorship conditions and employee rights. The breaches were of the most serious kind and warranted significant penalties. The court applied the totality principle, which allowed it to consider the cumulative effect of the breaches rather than the penalty for a single contravention. The court ordered restitution payments to the employees and the Commonwealth for PAYG tax. The court also imposed significant penalties on the respondents, which were reduced to a total penalty of $430,000 for Hallmark Computer Pty Ltd and $86,000 for Mr Alexander. The court ordered the respondents to pay the penalties within 28 days and the applicant's costs if not agreed.

The court found that the respondents' conduct involved calculated, systematic, repeated and callous infringements of the sponsorship conditions and employee rights. The breaches included underpaying wages by requiring employees to repay a portion of their wages and failing to pay overtime hours. The court found that the breaches were of the most serious kind and warranted significant penalties. The court applied the totality principle, which allowed it to consider the cumulative effect of the breaches rather than the penalty for a single contravention. The court ordered restitution payments to the employees and the Commonwealth for PAYG tax. The court also imposed significant penalties on the respondents, which were reduced to a total penalty of $430,000 for Hallmark Computer Pty Ltd and $86,000 for Mr Alexander. The court ordered the respondents to pay the penalties within 28 days and the applicant's costs if not agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Restitution

6. The first respondent pay restitution pursuant to s 486S of the Migration Act in respect of the contraventions described in declarations 1, 2 and 3 above in the following amounts:

(a) to Mr Ruel Conducto Duran – $22,002.18; and

(b) to Mr Dennis Baclayanto Escanlar – $21,185.68; and

(c) to Mr Roxanne Espiritu De Guzman – $21,185.68; and

(d) to the Commonwealth – $17,092.

7. The first respondent pay restitution pursuant to s 486S of the Migration Act with respect to the days worked by Mr Escanlar and Mr De Guzman in the period from 29 December 2012 to 10 January 2013 in the following amounts:

(a) to Mr Dennis Baclayanto Escanlar – $822.50; and

(b) to Mr Roxanne Espiritu De Guzman – $822.50; and

(c) to the Commonwealth – $355.

Penalties against Hallmark Computer

8. Subject to order 10 below:

(a) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 1.1 and 1.3, a penalty against the first respondent of $100,000.

(b) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 2.1 and 2.3, a penalty against the first respondent of $100,000.

(c) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 3.1 and 3.3, a penalty against the first respondent of $100,000.

(d) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 4.1 and 4.2, a penalty against the first respondent of $100,000.

(e) For the contraventions referred to in declaration 1.2, a penalty against the first respondent of $65,000.

(f) For the contraventions referred to in declaration 2.2, a penalty against the first respondent of $65,000.

(g) For the contraventions referred to in declaration 3.2, a penalty against the first respondent of $65,000.

(h) For the contraventions referred to in declaration 4.3, a penalty against the first respondent of $50,000.

Penalties against Mr Alexander

9. Subject to order 11 below:

(a) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 1.1, 1.3 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $20,000.

(b) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 2.1, 2.3 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $20,000.

(c) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 3.1, 3.3 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $20,000.

(d) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 4.1, 4.2 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $20,000.

(e) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 1.2 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $13,000.

(f) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 2.2 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $13,000.

(g) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 3.2 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $13,000.

(h) For the contraventions referred to in declarations 4.3 and 5, a penalty against the second respondent of $10,000.

Total Penalties

10. (a) The total penalties referred to in order 8 be reduced to a total penalty against the first respondent of $430,000.

(b) The first respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pursuant to s 486R of the Migration Act the total pecuniary penalty referred to in order 10(a) in the amount of $430,000.

11. (a) The total penalties referred to in order 9 be reduced to a total penalty against the second respondent of $86,000.

(b) The second respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia pursuant to s 486R of the Migration Act the total pecuniary penalty referred to in order 11(a) in the amount of $86,000.

Time for Payment

12. The amounts referred to in orders 6, 7, 10 and 11 be paid within 28 days.

Costs

13. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs as taxed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The fourth employee was, after a period, required to work in a non-skilled capacity. He was also required to make cash repayments from his fortnightly pay as discussed below. When, on 27 September 2013 he refused to do so any longer he was dismissed and in subsequent proceedings commenced in the Fair Work Commission he negotiated a settlement. No further payment to him is sought in the present proceedings. Agreed facts By a joint defence filed on 8 September 2015, each of the respondents admitted each paragraph of the statement of claim relevant to that respondent. In addition, a statement of agreed facts was filed on 23 November 2015 setting out a number of propositions which, apparently, the respondents are content for the Court to accept as facts which might bear on the assessment of penalties, although some matters appear to me likely to be outside the specific knowledge of the respondents. Further short agreed statements were filed on 5 February 2016 and 4 March 2016. The first set out the agreed position concerning restitution and PAYG tax for the three underpaid employees and the second recorded a one-off bonus paid to each at some stage in their employment. In two cases a bonus of $2,000 was paid “for being employee of the year” and in one case a “Christmas bonus” of $500 was paid. Those facts seem to me to have no bearing on the matters for decision. Having regard to the agreed calculations for the amounts payable for restitution, and my acceptance of the claim for further payment to two employees based on agreed facts, the remaining matters concern whether declarations should be made, and their terms, and what penalties should be imposed. Declarations The parties were agreed that declarations should be made, and their terms. Notwithstanding that agreed position, I had misgivings initially about the need to make the declarations sought by the Minister, even though they were not opposed by Hallmark Computer or Mr Alexander and even though they were appropriately precise. My principal reservation related to the fact that orders imposing penalties and granting compensation incorporate the findings which sustain and explain those orders. Declarations are granted to determine legal controversy. They are a vindication of legal rights. The statutory rights in the present case, in large measure, will be vindicated by the imposition of penalties. To that extent, arguably, the declarations sought and agreed do no more than state the legal foundation which calls for the imposition of the penalties, and once those penalties are imposed that might constitute a sufficient public record which renders declarations (in the present case at least) superfluous and unnecessary. However, there are two related matters which have persuaded me, in the present case, to make the declarations sought by the Minister. The first is that the penalties to be imposed, and the orders for compensation, are to an extent aggregate in nature. The second is that there are some contraventions which will not attract a separately stated penalty.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Based on the admissions in the pleadings and the agreed facts (to which I refer in more detail hereunder), I accept the following submissions by counsel for the Minister: 2.… Hallmark Computer failed on numerous occasions to satisfy its sponsorship obligations under the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) in respect of each of the 4 sponsored persons. The contraventions can be summarised as follows: 2.1.Guaranteed earnings contraventions: Each fortnight, Hallmark Computer required each of the sponsored persons to repay to it, in cash, a portion of his net wages for that fortnight. On each such fortnight this reduced the wages paid to the sponsored person to a level significantly below his respective guaranteed earnings, contrary to the sponsorship obligation in reg 2.79(3). 2.2.Work without pay contraventions: Each fortnight, Hallmark Computer required each of 3 of the sponsored persons to work additional hours and refused to pay him for those hours. Additionally, 2 of the sponsored persons were required to work for a period in which they were not paid at all. Again, this led to fortnightly failures to comply with the sponsorship obligation in reg 2.79(3). 2.3.Nominated occupation contraventions: Each fortnight, Hallmark Computer required one of the sponsored persons to work in an (unskilled) occupation other than his nominated (skilled) occupation, contrary to the sponsorship obligation in reg 2.86. 2.4.Recovery contraventions: Through each of the repayments constituting the guaranteed earnings contraventions, Hallmark Computer recovered costs from the sponsored persons, contrary to the sponsorship obligation in reg 2.87. 3.Mr Alexander was personally and centrally involved in each of these contraventions, aiding and abetting them in breach of s 140Q of the Migration Act: see s 486ZD. (Bold in original.)Orders sought or agreed The proceedings in this Court were commenced on 2 June 2015 by application and statement of claim. They sought declarations, civil penalty orders and restitution orders. The parties have agreed that orders for payment to three of the employees should be made in the amounts of $22,002.18, $21,185.68 and $21,185.68 respectively and that an amount of $17,092 should be paid to the Commonwealth for PAYG tax due on those amounts. In addition, the Minister seeks an order (which is not agreed) of further compensation for two of those three employees equivalent to one week’s pay when, as admitted on the pleadings, they were required to work but were not paid. The amounts are $822.50 payment to each employee and $355 total payment to the Commonwealth for PAYG tax on those amounts. Although the orders were not agreed, the facts were. The payments should be made as the Minister submitted. The fourth employee was, after a period, required to work in a non-skilled capacity. He was also required to make cash repayments from his fortnightly pay as discussed below. When, on 27 September 2013 he refused to do so any longer he was dismissed and in subsequent proceedings commenced in the Fair Work Commission he negotiated a settlement. No further payment to him is sought in the present proceedings. Agreed facts