FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 93
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v McConnel... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2012] FCAFC 93
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd, the primary issue was whether the conduct of McConnell Dowell, in withdrawing permission for welding work to be done by Hanlon Labour Services on site, constituted discrimination under section 45 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth). The dispute centred on whether discrimination, as defined under the Act, required proof of an adverse impact on the person or entity discriminated against. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the decision of the primary judge correctly interpreted the statutory requirements and whether there was sufficient evidence to substantiate a claim of discrimination.
The legal issues the court had to address were twofold. First, whether the primary judge had correctly interpreted section 45 of the BCII Act by requiring proof of an adverse impact to establish discrimination. Second, assuming such proof was necessary, whether there was any evidence that the actions of McConnell Dowell had an adverse impact on Hanlon Labour Services. The court had to balance the interpretation of the statute with the evidence presented in the case to determine the validity of the discrimination claim.
The court found that section 45 of the BCII Act did indeed require proof of an adverse impact to establish discrimination. It ruled that without evidence of an adverse impact on Hanlon Labour Services, the claim of discrimination could not be substantiated. The court highlighted that while the decision by McConnell Dowell was taken for a proscribed reason, the absence of evidence of any adverse effect precluded a finding of discrimination. The court concluded that the appeal was to be dismissed as there was no error in the primary judge's interpretation and application of the statute.
In summary, the appeal was dismissed, and McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd was ordered to pay the costs of the Respondent. The court found that the primary judge had correctly interpreted the statutory requirements and that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate a claim of discrimination under section 45 of the BCII Act. The decision underscored the necessity of proving an adverse impact to establish discrimination and the importance of presenting adequate evidence in such claims.
The legal issues the court had to address were twofold. First, whether the primary judge had correctly interpreted section 45 of the BCII Act by requiring proof of an adverse impact to establish discrimination. Second, assuming such proof was necessary, whether there was any evidence that the actions of McConnell Dowell had an adverse impact on Hanlon Labour Services. The court had to balance the interpretation of the statute with the evidence presented in the case to determine the validity of the discrimination claim.
The court found that section 45 of the BCII Act did indeed require proof of an adverse impact to establish discrimination. It ruled that without evidence of an adverse impact on Hanlon Labour Services, the claim of discrimination could not be substantiated. The court highlighted that while the decision by McConnell Dowell was taken for a proscribed reason, the absence of evidence of any adverse effect precluded a finding of discrimination. The court concluded that the appeal was to be dismissed as there was no error in the primary judge's interpretation and application of the statute.
In summary, the appeal was dismissed, and McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd was ordered to pay the costs of the Respondent. The court found that the primary judge had correctly interpreted the statutory requirements and that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate a claim of discrimination under section 45 of the BCII Act. The decision underscored the necessity of proving an adverse impact to establish discrimination and the importance of presenting adequate evidence in such claims.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The Appellant is to pay the costs of the Respondent.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Section 45 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (“the BCII Act”) prohibits discrimination by one person against another on the ground that the employment of the second person’s building employees is, or is not, covered by an industrial agreement. The central question in this appeal is whether, to establish that a person has been discriminated against for the purpose of s 45, it is necessary to prove that the discrimination had any adverse impact or effect on that person. The facts The facts were largely agreed. McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (“McConnell Dowell”) was one party to a joint venture engaged in about October 2008 to design and build the Corio Quay North No 4 Ship Loader project at the port of Geelong. Building work began on the project in about February 2009. McConnell Dowell subcontracted some of it to Hanlon Industries Pty Ltd (“Hanlon”). The work subcontracted to Hanlon involved the fabricating, painting, assembly and delivery to the Corio Quay site of a network of structural steel beams that would ultimately form part of the extension of the North wharf component of the project. In March 2009 McConnell Dowell granted permission to Hanlon to carry out welding associated with the assembly of the structural steel at the site. The fabricated and painted but unassembled steel beams were delivered to the site in early May 2009 and on or about 7 May 2009 two workers came on the site to do the welding. They were employees of Hanlon Labour Services Pty Ltd (“HLS”), a company related to Hanlon and which provided Hanlon’s labour. They welded on the site on at least 7, 8 and 11 May 2009. But on 12 May 2009, by which time Hanlon had completed the assembly of one of the five bays and started work on another, McConnell Dowell wrote to Hanlon withdrawing its permission to do the welding on site. The letter read:Re: On Site WeldingWe refer to the terms of the your (sic) Purchase Order relating to steel fabrication, coating and delivery of access bridge and ship loader platform structural steel. The original requirement of the purchase order was to deliver all steel complete and inclusive of all freight charges to site.Whilst we have agreed to allow site welding of bracing to girder beams on site, our management has reviewed the decision following your request to complete your scope of works on site due to the handling difficulties in your workshop of the large braced girder bays. Please be advised thus:You have advised us that you do not possess any current industrial instrument which covers your workforce in the execution of any site work. You have been engaged by MCD to supply only fabricated steelwork to the Corio project, but not for work to be carried out on site. Accordingly, we will not require your workforce on-site until further notice.We will complete this work direct on site and advise costs to complete to your accountWe thank-you for your understanding in this matter. The letter was sent at the direction of McConnell Dowell’s Southern Region Manager, Civil and Marine, Sam Kapetanas, who did not then know that the workers were employed by HLS, rather than by Hanlon.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
His Honour resolved the first issue against the applicant. At [55] he observed that if Hanlon had been the employer of the relevant employees, then there could be little doubt that the conduct was discriminatory because the effect of the direction was clearly prejudicial to Hanlon. It was no longer able to perform the assembly work at the location most convenient to it and it had to incur the expense of returning the beams to its workshop and of transporting them in assembled form to the quay. It was also required to pay another contractor to finish the assembly work there. At [56], however, his Honour observed:HLS did not suffer any of these consequences. Its two employees were withdrawn from the construction site. Although there was no direct evidence of where they were subsequently deployed, it may be inferred that they continued to perform the work for which they were engaged at Hanlons’ workshop. There was, however, no evidence that this change had any impact, adverse or otherwise, on HLS. There was no evidence about the contractual arrangements between Hanlons and HLS under which Hanlons secured the services of the HLS employees. In particular there was no evidence to suggest that the withdrawal of the workers from the project site had any financial implications for HLS.(Emphasis added.) And at [59] his Honour held that in order for one person to discriminate against another there must be some evidence that the first person’s conduct had an adverse impact on the conduct of the second person. He then said that in the absence of evidence as to the impact on HLS of the requirement that its employees be withdrawn from the site, he was “unable to conclude that it was discriminated against by McConnell Dowell”. It was the finding that there was no evidence that McConnell Dowell’s decision had any adverse impact on HLS (repeated at [83]) that proved to be fatal to the success of the application. That was because his Honour resolved the second question in the applicant’s favour.The issues on the appeal No notice of contention having been filed, the finding in [56], repeated at [83], gives rise to the two issues on the appeal:1.Did the primary judge impose the wrong test? Or, put differently, does s 45 of the BCII Act require proof that the discriminatory conduct have an adverse impact?2.If so, was there any evidence to show that the direction to Hanlon had an adverse impact on HLS? If not, was there evidence to show that the direction to Hanlon discriminated against HLS. Although the appeal is in the nature of a rehearing, error must be shown: Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No. 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424 at [25]. Respect and weight must be given to the decision of the primary judge in deciding what inferences should be drawn from the evidence: Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531.Does s 45 of the BCII Act require proof of an adverse impact? Unlike the various statutes outlawing discrimination on the ground of sex, race, disability, sexual preference and age, there is no definition of “discriminate against” in the BCII Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
This final Ground of Appeal should also be rejected. Given the conclusion that the phrase “discriminate against” requires the Appellant to make out some “adverse impact”, the absence of any evidence as to any impact being “adverse” is necessarily fatal. The primary Judge may, with respect, have overstated his conclusion (at para [56]) that there was an absence of evidence of any impact “adverse or otherwise”. His Honour was certainly correct, however, in concluding that there was an absence of evidence as to any impact being “adverse”.CONCLUSIONS The conclusion that the appeal is to be dismissed is, perhaps, unsatisfactory. The primary Judge accepted, and it was not challenged on appeal, that Mr Kapetanas’ decision “… was properly to be characterised as being taken on the ground that [Hanlon Industries Pty Ltd] and [Hanlon Labour Services] did not have an industrial agreement covering the work being undertaken by the [Hanlon Labour Services] employees at the construction site”: [2011] FCA 1344 at [81], 285 ALR at 296. Conduct which has been taken for a proscribed reason thus escapes the reach of s 45 simply because there was no evidence – or no sufficient evidence – of any “adverse” effect upon Hanlon Labour Services. But that conclusion is dictated by the manner in which the case was conducted before the primary Judge. If those bringing a complaint of unlawful discrimination fail to adduce evidence to support that complaint, that is a deficiency as to the conduct of the case rather than any deficiency in the legislation. Why further evidence of the impact upon Hanlon Labour Services was not adduced in unknown. Nor is it relevant for present purposes to speculate. Whatever the reason, concurrence is expressed with the conclusion of the primary Judge. The appeal should be dismissed with costs. No error is exposed in the manner in which his Honour interpreted and applied s 45. Section 45 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (“the BCII Act”) prohibits discrimination by one person against another on the ground that the employment of the second person’s building employees is, or is not, covered by an industrial agreement. The central question in this appeal is whether, to establish that a person has been discriminated against for the purpose of s 45, it is necessary to prove that the discrimination had any adverse impact or effect on that person. The facts The facts were largely agreed. McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (“McConnell Dowell”) was one party to a joint venture engaged in about October 2008 to design and build the Corio Quay North No 4 Ship Loader project at the port of Geelong. Building work began on the project in about February 2009. McConnell Dowell subcontracted some of it to Hanlon Industries Pty Ltd (“Hanlon”). The work subcontracted to Hanlon involved the fabricating, painting, assembly and delivery to the Corio Quay site of a network of structural steel beams that would ultimately form part of the extension of the North wharf component of the project. In March 2009 McConnell Dowell granted permission to Hanlon to carry out welding associated with the assembly of the structural steel at the site. The fabricated and painted but unassembled steel beams were delivered to the site in early May 2009 and on or about 7 May 2009 two workers came on the site to do the welding. They were employees of Hanlon Labour Services Pty Ltd (“HLS”), a company related to Hanlon and which provided Hanlon’s labour. They welded on the site on at least 7, 8 and 11 May 2009. But on 12 May 2009, by which time Hanlon had completed the assembly of one of the five bays and started work on another, McConnell Dowell wrote to Hanlon withdrawing its permission to do the welding on site.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.