Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 1463

File number: QUD 525 of 2015
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 7 December 2016
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – s 354(1) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) – principal contractor ADCO terminated engagement and cancelled further engagement of subcontractor Surf City Cranes Pty Ltd (SCC) – whether ADCO contravened s 354(1) – reversal of onus of proof – whether termination and cancellation of SCC for prohibited reason – subcontractor workers covered by non-union enterprise agreement – substantive and operative reason for termination and engagement – pressure on ADCO from union to remove SCC – prospect of union disruption to ADCO projects – ADCO under pressure to finish projects within time and budget – SCC dispensable to ADCO – SCC replaced with another subcontractor without union enterprise agreement – lack of union enterprise agreement to which workers and union were party was not substantial or operative factor in termination and cancellation – whether ADCO manager contravened s 354(1) – whether manager refused to further engage SCC – whether alleged refusal based on reasons prohibited by s 354(1) – SCC subsequently engaged on other ADCO projects

INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether SCC “employer” for purposes of s 354(1) FW Act – Crane Hire Pty Ltd (Crane Hire) labour hire company in group – whether Crane Hire was “employer” of workers in group business – intention of group directors – employees aware that Crane Hire was employer – rational explanation for group business structure – business structure no sham – SCC “public face” of corporate group – corporate documentation recorded Crane Hire as employer – SCC not employer

Legislation:

Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) s 45(1)(a)(i)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 433(3)(c)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 354(1), 354(1)(a), 361, 793, 793(1)

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)

WorkCover Corporation Act 1984 (SA) s 54

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (2012) 203 FCR 345

Board of Bendigo Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500

Building Workers’ Industrial Union of Australia v Odco Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 104

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2014) 253 CLR 243

Damevski v Giudice (2003) 133 FCR 438

Director, Fair Work Building Inspectorate v ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 602

Fair Work Ombudsman v Eastern Colour Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 55

Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (2011) 198 FCR 174

Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard (2007) 99 SASR 461

Gothard, in the matter of AFG (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (in Liq) v Davey [2010] FCA 1163

Jacinta Arcadia v Accenture Australia (2008) 170 IR 288

Scott v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (No 2) (1966) 40 ALJR 265

Sharrment Pty Ltd v Official Trustee (1988) 18 FCR 449

Snook v London & West Riding Investments Ltd [1967]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v ADCO Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1463
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved the Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate, who brought proceedings against ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging that ADCO had contravened section 354(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by terminating and cancelling the engagement of Surf City Cranes Pty Ltd (SCC), a subcontractor. The Director alleged that ADCO's actions were influenced by pressure from a union, which objected to SCC being on the construction sites, and that the termination was for a prohibited reason. The legal issues before the court were whether ADCO contravened section 354(1) of the Fair Work Act by terminating and cancelling SCC's engagement for a prohibited reason, and whether SCC was the employer of its workers for the purposes of the Act. The court found that SCC was not the employer of the workers in question, but rather Crane Hire Pty Ltd, a labour hire company within the Morrish group of companies. The court also found that ADCO's decision to terminate and refuse to engage SCC was motivated by the avoidance of industrial disruption and consequent delay, rather than any industrial arrangements SCC had with the union. The court held that the claims of the Director concerning ADCO were not substantiated and dismissed the originating application. The court reserved costs of the Director's application to further amend the amended statement of claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

The originating application filed 1 July 2015 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before turning in more detail to the claims of the Director it is useful to outline the background facts, many of which have been agreed by the parties in a Statement of Agreed Facts filed on 1 September 2016.BACKGROUND FACTS ADCO is a national construction company which was involved in the delivery of projects across Australia in 2012 and 2013. Three such projects were at Bond University (the Bond University project), Robina Town Central (the Robina project) and Pindara Hospital on the Gold Coast. Although events at Pindara Hospital were initially the subject of the Director’s claims against the respondent, that aspect of the claim is no longer pressed. The Bond University project related to the $18 million construction of the Abedian School of Architecture at Bond University’s Gold Coast campus. This project commenced around September 2011 and was completed around October 2013. The Robina project related to the $14 million construction of a single storey car park at the Robina Shopping Centre for Queensland Investment Corporation. This project commenced around July 2013 and was completed around March 2014. In both of these projects ADCO required crane hire services. Surf City Cranes Pty Ltd (SCC) is a crane hire company. SCC is the subcontractor to which I referred earlier in this judgment.Entities controlled by Mr and Mrs Morrish It is convenient at this stage to examine the features of business entities controlled by Mr Jonathan Morrish and Mrs Sharon Morrish. Mr and Mrs Morrish had the control and beneficial ownership of a number of entities, namely SCC, Crane Hire Pty Ltd (Crane Hire) and Morrish Investments Pty Ltd (Morrish Investments). At material times Mr Morrish was the sole director of both SCC and Crane Hire. Crane Hire was registered in 2011. Mr Morrish and the operations manager of SCC, Mr James Dawson, focussed on winning crane hire work, whereas Mrs Morrish and a book-keeper, Ms Mel Chittick (with the assistance of external accountants) focussed on the administrative side of the business. At all material times Morrish Investments was the trustee for the Morrish Family Trust. Morrish Investments owned all assets, including the cranes and the crane yard, and the trading name “Surf City Cranes”. Mrs Morrish was the director and sole shareholder of Morrish Investments. Mr and Mrs Morrish and SCC were beneficiaries of the trust. In the first half of 2012 Mr and Mrs Morrish decided to restructure their business such that SCC was the provider of crane hire services to the industry, and Crane Hire was the employer of crane operators, riggers and doggers and the supplier of labour to SCC. It is common ground that this structure was adopted for two reasons:1.Mr and Mrs Morrish accepted their accountant’s advice that it was in their financial interests, from a financial risk perspective, to separate the employer from the companies that held the assets in their business structure; and2.The intention of Mr and Mrs Morrish at the time was to position Crane Hire as a labour hire operation, not only for the SCC business, but potentially in future for others in the industry.Employment arrangements

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Subsequently the Director claimed:56A.On the basis of the matters pleaded in paragraphs 45 to 46 Mr Kitto refused to further engage Surf City unless Surf City signed a union EBA.56B.On the basis of the matters pleaded in paragraphs 45 to 46 it can be inferred that Mr Kitto refused to further engage Surf City because employees of Surf City were not covered by an Enterprise Agreement which covered the CFMEU.56C.In advising Mr and Mrs Morrish that Surf City would need to sign a union EBA to continue working for ADCO. Mr Kitto discriminated against Surf City in breach of section 354(1) of the FW Act because he refused to further engage Surf City because employees of Surf City were not covered by an Enterprise Agreement which covered the CFMEU.Relevant evidence The amendments to the further amended statement of claim in respect of Mr Kitto plead that Mr Kitto refused to further engage SCC for reasons in contravention of s 354(1) of the FW Act. Mr Kitto gave evidence in an affidavit sworn 24 March 2016 and orally under cross-examination. He was the Gold Coast Manager during the period in which ADCO performed services as lead contractor at the Bond University project. Mr Kitto gave evidence of delays to the project, Mr Duckett informing him that the CFMEU did not want SCC on the site, and his regular discussions with Mr Duckett and Mr Hawkins. In particular, Mr Kitto deposed as to his belief that Mr Duckett was capable of dealing with any concerns raised by the unions. Mr Kitto’s recollection of events around his meeting with Mr and Mrs Morrish was slightly vague, and he made reference to contemporaneous documents. Those documents indicated that Mrs Morrish had sought a meeting with Mr Bob Hill, the owner of ADCO, and that Mr Kitto had communicated with Mr Morrish to the effect that Mr and Mrs Morrish could come and speak with him about the issues concerning them. The meeting took place on 23 July 2013 at Mr Kitto’s office. His evidence continues:31.I took them into the office board room where I met with them. During the meeting:(a)I explained to them that it was not going to be possible for them to meet with Bob Hill. Being the owner of ADCO, Mr Hill does not get involved in the day to day running of the business and does not work in the office.(b)Either Mr or Mrs Morrish said to the effect “We don’t have an EBA with the CFMEU. We’ve asked them for a union agreement, but they won’t make one with us.”(c) I asked Mr and Mrs Morrish to the effect of why that was.(d)Either Mr or Mrs Morrish responded to the effect “We’ve been having a lot of trouble with the union. They call us ‘grubs’. We went to their office one day and sat there all day and non-one would see us.”(e)I said something to the effect of “Well, maybe you need to keep trying.”32.At that point, the predicament that the Morrish’s were in was clear to me. I understood from the discussion that the union were not letting them on building sites because they didn’t have an EBA with the CFMEU and that even though they were keen to negotiate one, the CFMEU appeared not to be interested in doing that.33.The Morrishes were open and frank about their predicament and expressed their frustration, and I was open and frank about the predicament that ADCO was in.34.I believe I could have said something to the effect that ADCO could not afford to fight the CFMEU because if ADCO utilised a company that the union did not approve of, then the unions would find a way to shut the sites down.35.It got to the point where I said something to the effect that I understood their frustration, but in the circumstances, there was nothing that ADCO could do.36.I did not say anything to the effect that ADCO would not use SCC and in fact, I said there would be other opportunities for SCC on other jobs.37.In the course of preparing this affidavit, I have read paragraphs 39 to 40 of Mr Morrish’s affidavit dated 8 December 2015. I have also read paragraphs 19 to 22 of Mrs Morrish’s affidavit dated 8 December 2015. In response to the allegations in those paragraphs:(a)I deny that the meeting took place on or about 27 October 2012, for the reasons set out above;(b)I deny that I said to the effect that ADCO had signed a “union EBA” to assist ADC in moving from the “Tier 2” type work they were performing to “Tier 1” type work. My view at the time was that ADCO was a Tier 2 building contractor and we were not looking to move to Tier 1, so I never would have said this;(c)I deny that I said to the effect that under the “union EBA” ADCO could only utilise companies with union EBAs. At no stage did I say anything about our EBA requiring that, as it does not say that and I would not have said this;(d)I deny that I said to the effect that Surf City would need to sign a union EBA to continue working for ADCO. At no stage did I tell them that they had to get a union EBA. It was clear to me from our discussion that this was something they thought they needed to do but they could not get the union on board;(e)I deny that I said to the effect that I had been given or seen a list of companies issued by the CFMEU that ADCO could utilise the services of.38.The meeting did not last very long and although I felt sympathetic to the position that the Morrish’s were in with the CFMEU, I did not indicate that ADCO was in any position to change anything.39.After approximately 20 minutes, Mr and Mrs Morrish left the office. I did not have any further discussions with sec after this meeting.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view the claims of the Director concerning Mr Kitto are not substantiated.CONCLUSION The material before the Court clearly indicates that SCC was not the employer of workers in the Morrish cranage operations business. The employer was Crane Hire. This arrangement was put in place by Mr and Mrs Morrish for legitimate business reasons. The workers were aware of the identity of their employer. I do not accept that the “real” employer was SCC simply because the primary entity and public face of the Morrish business enterprise was SCC. To accept that proposition would not only require a rejection of the separate corporate identity of Crane Hire, but a rejection of the practical reality of the employment arrangements in the Morrish business as well as the corporate structure of the group. Further I am satisfied that, even if SCC was the employer of the relevant workers, ADCO’s decisions to terminate SCC on the Bond University project and cancel its engagement of SCC on the Robina project were not for reasons contravening s 354(1) of the FW Act. I am also satisfied that Mr Kitto’s conversation with Mr and Mrs Morrish on 23 July 2013 did not involve a “refusal to engage” SCC for ADCO work for reasons alleged by the Director. In its decision-making, ADCO and its staff were not interested in any industrial arrangements SCC had with the CFMEU or otherwise. ADCO staff were interested only in ensuring that ADCO projects remained on time and within budget. If SCC was for any reason whatsoever to jeopardise ADCO’s position in respect of its projects ADCO was prepared to end its engagement of SCC (and it did so). In this case it was the avoidance of industrial disruption and consequent delay which would have arisen because the CFMEU objected to SCC being on the sites which motivated ADCO in its decision to terminate and refuse to engage SCC, not whether SCC (or, in this case, Crane Hire) employees were covered by an enterprise agreement to which the CFMEU was also a party. This was also made clear by Mr Kitto in his meeting with Mr and Mrs Morrish, which meeting was a courtesy to Mr and Mrs Morrish rather than any exercise in decision-making by Mr Kitto. Finally I note that, in Director, Fair Work Building Inspectorate v ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 602 Logan J reserved costs of the Director’s application to further amend the amended statement of claim. I will hear submissions as to whether costs should be ordered in respect of that interlocutory application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established