Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

GOLDEN PLAINS FODDER AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v MILLARD

[2007] SASC 391

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice White and The Honourable Justice David)

8 November 2007

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - LIABILITY TO PAY COMPENSATION - LIABILITY OF EMPLOYER

EMPLOYMENT LAW - THE RELATIONSHIP OF EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE

Appeal from the determination of a preliminary issue by a District Court judge – appeal concerning the identity of the plaintiff’s employer – no written contract of employment – worker injured – actual employer one of two related entities – plaintiff’s action against one of these two entities was statute barred - consideration of the intentions of the parties – whether the involvement of the nominal employer was a sham – whether the documentary evidence reflected the reality of the arrangements – a decision of the Industrial Relations Commission concerning another worker reached the opposite conclusion to the District Court Judge – whether trial Judge’s reasons for decision were adequate.

Held: Appeal dismissed – regard to be had to the totality of the circumstances – business arrangement with nominal employer not a sham and did reflect the reality of the arrangements – decision of the Industrial Relations Commission distinguished – nominal employer held to be the actual employer – reasons of trial Judge adequate.

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) s 3, s 46, s 54, s 59; WorkCover Corporation Act 1984 (SA); Pay-roll Tax Act 1971 (SA); Occupational Health, Safety and Welfare Act 1986 (SA) s 4, s 20, referred to.
Perkins v Golden Plains Fodder Australia/Macpri Pty Ltd [2004] SAIRComm 5; Perkins v Golden Plains Fodder Australia/Macpri Pty Ltd [2004] SAIRComm 62; Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 21; Hunter v Transport Accident Commission & Anor (2005) 43 MVR 130; Carlson v King (1947) 64 WN (NSW) 65; Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247; Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd v Massoud [1989] VR 8; Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95; Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165; Snook v London & West Riding Investments Ltd [1967] 2 QB 786; Scott v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (No 2) (1966) 40 ALJR 265; Sharrment Pty Ltd v Official Trustee (1988) 18 FCR 449; FCT v Montgomery (1999) 198 CLR 639; Esanda Ltd v Burgess [1984] 2 NSWLR 139; Finance Sector Union v Commonwealth Bank (2001) 111 IR 241; Pitcher v Langford (1991) 23 NSWLR 142; In the matter of C & T Grinter Transport Services (In Liquidation) & Ors [2004] FCA 1148; Damevski v Guidice and Others (2003) 133 FCR 438; Romero v Auty (2001) 19 ACLC 206; Building Workers Industrial Union of Australia v Odco Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 104; Australian Insurance Employees Union v WP Insurance Services Pty Ltd (1982) 42 ALR 598; Costello v Allstaff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 391
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard concerns a dispute over the identity of the plaintiff's employer for the purposes of a workers' compensation claim. Shawn John Millard, the plaintiff, was injured at a hay processing plant operated by Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd. Millard initially sued Golden Plains for common law damages, but Golden Plains argued that it was not his employer and that another related entity, Macpri Pty Ltd, was his employer, rendering the claim statute-barred. The District Court judge found that Macpri was the plaintiff's employer, but Golden Plains appealed this decision on the grounds that the judge's reasons were inadequate and that the business arrangement with Macpri was a sham.

The central legal issue in this appeal was the determination of the plaintiff's employer for the purposes of assessing liability under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA). The court had to decide whether Golden Plains or Macpri was the employer, given the absence of a written contract of employment and conflicting evidence from the parties. The appeal also questioned whether the trial judge's findings were adequately reasoned and whether the documentary evidence reflected the reality of the business arrangements.

The appeal was dismissed by the court. The judges concluded that the business arrangement between Golden Plains and Macpri was not a sham and accurately reflected the reality of their relationship. They found that the trial judge's decision was adequately reasoned and that the totality of the circumstances supported the conclusion that Macpri was the actual employer. The court distinguished the decision of the Industrial Relations Commission in a similar matter, holding that the nominal employer, Macpri, was indeed the plaintiff's employer. The documentary evidence, when considered in context, supported the judge's findings. The court held that the reasons provided by the trial judge were sufficient and that the appeal did not succeed in overturning the decision.

The final orders of the court affirmed that Macpri Pty Ltd was the plaintiff's employer for the purposes of the workers' compensation claim. Consequently, Shawn John Millard's claim for common law damages against Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd was statute-barred, and the District Court's decision was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from the determination of a preliminary issue by a District Court judge on the ground that the claim was statute barred.Background Facts On 2 May 1998, Shawn John Millard, the plaintiff and respondent, injured his hand while working at a hay processing plant operated by Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd, the defendant and appellant. Mr Millard issued proceedings claiming common law damages from Golden Plains. On the application of Golden Plains, a District Court judge ordered that the action proceed to determination on the preliminary point of whether Mr Millard was employed by Golden Plains. Golden Plains submitted that it was Mr Millard’s employer and so sought an order for summary judgment on the basis that Mr Millard had no right of action at common law against Golden Plains due to the operation of section 54 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA). Mr Millard contended that Golden Plains was not his employer but that a related company, Macpri Pty Ltd, was his employer. In these circumstances it was contended that Mr Millard’s claim was not statute barred by section 54. The task confronting the Judge was to decide which entity was Mr Millard’s employer on 2 May 1998.The Legislative Scheme The WorkCover Corporation Act 1984 (SA) and the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act establish a scheme of compulsory insurance. With some exceptions, not relevant in the present case, all employers must register with the WorkCover Corporation. Upon registration, an employer is given a registration number. Thereafter employers pay premiums to WorkCover which in turn assumes the responsibility of paying to injured workers compensation assessed by reference to the terms of the scheme. The scheme limits an employer’s liability and bars a worker from any right to claim common law damages from an employer. Mr Millard would not be entitled to recover common law damages from Golden Plains if that company was his employer. Section 54 (1) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act relevantly provides:... no liability attaches to an employer in respect of a compensable disability arising from employment by that employer except —(a) a liability under this Act; “Employer” is defined in section 3 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act to mean:(a)a person by whom a worker is employed under a contract of service, or for whom work is done by a worker under a contract of service;(b)in relation to persons of whom the Crown is, under section 103A, the presumptive employer—the Crown;(c)in relation to persons of whom any other person is, by virtue of a provision of this Act, the presumptive employer—that other person,and includes a former employer and the legal personal representative of a deceased employer A contract of service is defined in section 3 as:(a)a contract under which one person (the worker) is employed by another (the employer);(b)a contract, arrangement or understanding under which one person (the worker) works for another (the employer) in prescribed work or work of a prescribed class;(c) a contract of apprenticeship;(d) a contract, arrangement or understanding under which a person (the worker)—(i) receives on-the-job training in a trade or vocation from another (the employer); and(ii) is during the period of that training remunerated by the employer

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It was common ground that there was no written contract of employment.The Decision of the Judge The judge found that the identity of the plaintiff’s employer was to be determined by reference to the intention of the parties. The judge accepted that the plaintiff had been indifferent as to the identity of the employing entity until he received correspondence from WorkCover after his injury which identified Macpri as his employer. He had thought that he was going to work at the “hay plant”, as that was the way that the business was known locally. He was aware of the name Golden Plains Fodder, as the hay plant was also known by that name. The plaintiff first heard of Macpri through the WorkCover correspondence after his injury occurred. The evidence of the plaintiff’s mother was to similar effect. Golden Plains led evidence at trial from Barry, Eyvonne and Stuart Price. Their evidence was to the effect that Golden Plains was (and had been intended to be) the employer of all workers at the hay plant, including the plaintiff. It was suggested that Macpri was a mere administrative convenience. It did not operate as a labour hire company but instead as a “payroll company”. This was solely for the convenience of Mrs Price who did the book-keeping work. The judge was not prepared to act on that evidence, as he regarded the evidence of each of the Prices as unreliable. In the Industrial Relations Commission of South Australia in 2003, Golden Plains defended an unfair dismissal application brought by another worker. Eyvonne and Stuart Price gave oral evidence and Barry Price provided a written witness statement. This evidence was a direct contrast to the evidence presented before the District Court. The judge considered that the Prices gave whatever evidence best suited their purposes at the time. The finding by the judge about the reliability of the evidence of the Prices was not challenged on the appeal. The judge concluded that it had been open to the directors of Golden Plains and of Macpri to select Macpri as the employer of the plaintiff, and that that is what they had done. He reached this conclusion by considering the intention of the directors.Who Did the Parties Intend to be the Plaintiff’s Employer? The finding of the judge concerning the state of mind of the plaintiff and his mother meant that no useful inferences about intention could be drawn from their evidence. Neither had considered the identity of the employing entity at all before the plaintiff suffered his injury. The rejection by the judge of the evidence of the Prices that they had intended Golden Plains to be the employer of the workers did not have the consequence that they must have intended Macpri to be the employer. It meant simply that their evidence could not be used to make findings of fact about the intention of either Golden Plains or Macpri. This left only the documentary evidence. The judge stated that none of the documents had assisted him and that none resolved the issue which he had to decide.[38] This means that the basis upon which the judge found that the parties intended Macpri to be the employer is not clear. Despite saying that the documentary evidence had not assisted him, the judge must have had regard to it. He said that he had considered, and relied upon, the totality of the relationship between the parties. He could not have done so without considering the documentary evidence. Further, the judge expressly referred to the statement of Ryan J in Bellechic that it was open to those controlling a business in which a number of separate corporate entities participated (other than as partners) to select which company should be the employer “consistent with the financial and administrative organisation of the business”.[39] The judge considered that reasoning to be apposite to the present case and stated that he was applying it. As the evidence of the Price witnesses was rejected, the financial and administrative organisation of the hay plant business could only have been ascertained by reference to the tendered documentary material.[38] Millard v Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd [2007] SADC 47 at [10].[39] Textile Footwear and Clothing Union of Australia v Bellechic Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1465.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.