Wisewould v the Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

Wisewould v the Workers' Compensation Regulator [2015] QIRC 201

PARTIES:  

Wisewould, Bradley
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2014/336

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

25 November 2015      

HEARING DATES: 

1 and 2 July 2015

HEARD AT:

Cairns

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Black

ORDERS:

1.      The Appeal is allowed;

2.      The determination of the regulator in its decision dated 21 May 2014 about who was the employer of Kirstenfeldt is set aside and substituted with a decision that the employer is Rossal Pty Ltd (ACN 104 118 489);

3.      Costs are reserved.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - dispute over who was the employer of an injured worker - employment relationship or independent contractor relationship a consideration.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 11, s 30, s 32, s 550
Jiang Shen Cai T/A French Accent v Michael Anthony Do Rozario [2011] FWAFB 8307
Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard [2007] SASC 391

APPEARANCES:

Mr C. Ryall, Counsel instructed by Gayler Cleland Solicitors for the Appellant.
Mr S. McLeod, Counsel instructed by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, the Respondent.

Decision

Introduction

  1. Bradley Wisewould ("the appellant") appeals a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator ("the regulator") dated 21 May 2014 in which the regulator accepted a claim for compensation from Colin Kirstenfeldt.  It was not in dispute that Kirstenfeldt had suffered a compensable injury.  The error said to exist was that Kirstenfeldt was not employed by the appellant but had been employed by Rossal Pty Ltd ("Rossal") at the time of his injury.  Rossal was a company owned by Ross and Sam Frumento.  While the company was formed in 2003, Ross Frumento had been engaged in cane farming, cane harvesting and engineering since 1988.

  1. The sugar cane crushing season in North Queensland typically extends from June through to November or December each year.  At the relevant time cane crushed by the Tully Sugar Mill was harvested by approximately 35 harvesting groups.  Each group harvested the cane produced by designated growers.  Typically the groups were made up of a harvestor driver and three haul-out operators (also referred to as bin drivers).  Rossal had the rights to three harvesting groups.

  2. Under arrangements put in place by Rossal for the 2013 crushing season, one harvesting group was managed or operated by Ross and Sam Frumento, a second group was operated by Steven DeLacy, while the third group (Group 28) was operated by the appellant.  The effect of the evidence, as I understood it, was that the harvestor driver was the head of the work group or the person in charge.  The haul-out operators collected the harvested cane in bins and transported the bins to holding stations.  Tully Mill was then responsible for transferring the cane from the holding areas to the mill.

Nature of the Appeal

  1. The appeal to the Commission is by way of a hearing de novo.  To succeed with the appeal, the appellant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wisewould v the Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QIRC 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Wisewould v the Workers' Compensation Regulator, the dispute centred on the identification of the employer of an injured worker, Kirstenfeldt, at the time of his injury on 12 September 2013. The case was heard de novo in the Commission, and the appellant, Wisewould, sought to appeal the Regulator's decision by establishing that Kirstenfeldt was not his employee but was employed by another entity, Rossal. The primary issue for the court was to determine whether Wisewould was the employer of Kirstenfeldt or if Rossal held that relationship with Kirstenfeldt. The court had to consider the nature of the employment contract, if any, between Wisewould and Kirstenfeldt, and the evidence provided by multiple witnesses regarding the employment arrangements.

The court examined the evidence provided by eight witnesses, including Wisewould himself, to ascertain the nature of the relationship between him and Kirstenfeldt. Wisewould argued that he had an employment contract with Kirstenfeldt, paying him on an hourly rate until the start of the 2013 crushing season, after which he was paid on a per tonne basis. However, the court noted that the employment contract was not produced, and the invoices issued by Wisewould to Rossal Pty Ltd referred to "Contract Labour," suggesting a contractor relationship rather than an employment one. The court also considered Frumento's evidence, who claimed that he was the principal contractor and responsible for the operation of the three harvesting groups, and that he had entered into a subcontract arrangement with Wisewould to help him secure a credit rating.

The Commission concluded that Wisewould had not successfully established on the balance of probabilities that Kirstenfeldt was not his employee. The court found that the invoices issued by Wisewould to Rossal Pty Ltd indicated a contractor relationship rather than an employment one, and the evidence did not support the existence of an employment contract between Wisewould and Kirstenfeldt. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the Regulator's decision regarding the employer of Kirstenfeldt was upheld.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was dismissed, and the Regulator's determination that Wisewould was the employer of Kirstenfeldt remained in place. Costs were reserved for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appeal is allowed;

2. The determination of the regulator in its decision dated 21 May 2014 about who was the employer of Kirstenfeldt is set aside and substituted with a decision that the employer is Rossal Pty Ltd (ACN 104 118 489);

3. Costs are reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appeal to the Commission is by way of a hearing de novo. To succeed with the appeal, the appellant must establish on the balance of probabilities that at the time of his workplace injury on 12 September 2013, Kirstenfeldt was not his employee, but was employed by some other entity viz Rossal.Evidence During the course of the proceedings, evidence was provided by eight witnesses. The witnesses for the appellant were as follows: ·Bradley Wisewould·Dick Camilleri·Adrian Shepherd·Santo Contarino·Hayley Kuhnell·Paul Misale It was the appellant's evidence that during the 2012 crushing season and for the first five or six months of 2013 he was engaged full-time on an employment contract on an hourly rate. He said that he insisted on the payment of an hourly rate during the 2012 crushing season notwithstanding that the norm was for a per tonne rate to apply. The employment contract however was not able to be located and was not entered into the evidence. Frumento acknowledged that Rossal had a standard employment contract and confirmed that a document in the evidence as Exhibit 11 constituted such a contract. He said that the contract applied to employees under his banner (Rossal) and acknowledged that a term of a version of the standard employment contract was that total remuneration was determined by a payment "per tonne plus superannuation". However he did not concede that the appellant had been engaged on an employment agreement prior to the commencement of the 2013 crushing season and his evidence at T2-3 implied that a contract arrangement was in operation: The appellant agreed that before the start of the 2013 crushing season he would invoice Frumento each week to recover the cost of his labour. His invoice book is in the evidence as Exhibit 1. It shows that the appellant invoiced Rossal Pty Ltd on 19 May 2013, 25 May 2013, 2 June 2013, 9 June 2013, and 19 June 2013. Each invoice is made out to Rossal Pty Ltd and each one included the term "Contract Labour" and, except for the invoice dated 19 May 2013, all invoices specified a number of hours. The hours worked ranged from 41.5 hours to 54.25 hours. Each invoice was payable to Brad Wisewould with a Darwin address specified. The first three of the invoices also included what I understand to be an ABN number. No other information was provided. Further none of the invoices sought recovery or reimbursement for costs relating to anything other than the appellant's own labour. It was not in dispute that the appellant's remuneration method changed from an hourly rate to a per tonne rate at the start of the 2013 crushing season. Frumento said in effect that he invited the appellant to take charge of one of the harvesting groups under a subcontract arrangement. Frumento's evidence was that he held the principal contract and that he was ultimately responsible for the operation of the three harvesting groups. He owned the plant and machinery and he paid the insurance on the machinery. Frumento said that he entered into the new arrangement with the appellant to assist him secure a credit rating in circumstances where he had been denied finance to enable him to buy a new vehicle. Frumento evidence at T2-4 was:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.