Robinson v BMF Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Robinson v BMF Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) [2022] FCA 1191

File number(s): VID 798 of 2020
Judgment of: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 7 October 2022.
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – employment – identity of employer – whether corporation named in employment contract was applicant’s employer – whether written contract of employment had any features of a sham transaction – both respondent corporation and putative employer in liquidation – primary and accessorial liability of second respondent as director of both corporations – where second respondent ceased to be a director of putative employer corporation during applicant’s employment – causes of action in contract and equity – statutory causes of action under Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – application dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory application after close of evidence for leave to amend statement of claim to identify a non-party as the applicant’s employer –where the applicant had not availed himself of earlier opportunities to make that amendment – consideration of prejudice to the respondents – interlocutory application dismissed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law), ss 2, 18, 31, 236-239, 248

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44(1), 90, 117, 323, 340, 341, 342, 500(2), 550

Cases cited:

133 Walsh Street Pty Ltd v BMF Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 650

Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia v Wollongong Coal Limited [2014] FCA 878

BCR20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1043

Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Australian Postal Corporation [2017] FCA 1091

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1; 96 ALJR 89

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 50

Coote v Mainline Access Pty Ltd & Anor (No 3) [2019] FCCA 383; 344 FLR 1

EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2018] FCAFC 134; 360 ALR 261

Fair Work Ombudsman v Devine Marine Group Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1365

Fair Work Ombudsman v Priority Matters Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 833

Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1176; 198 FCR 174

Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard [2007] SASC 391; 99 SASR 461

Gothard, in the matter of AFG Pty Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liq) v Davey [2010] FCA 1163; 80 ACSR 56

Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 21; 96 ALJR 540

In the matter of C&T Grinter Transport Services Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) & Grinter Transport Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) (Controller Appointed) [2004] FCA 1148

JMC Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2022] FCA 750

McCardle v Johnson (No 2) [2022] FCA 168

Milardovic v Vemco Services Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2016] FCA 19

Murphy v Chapple [2022] FCAFC 165

Murrihy v Betezy.com.au Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 908

Pitcher…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson v BMF Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Robinson, sought to amend his statement of claim in order to identify a different employer from the one named in the original contract. The named employer, BMF Pty Ltd, was in liquidation, and the putative employer, Brandmet, was also in liquidation. The second respondent, Mr Wright, was a director of both corporations. The primary legal issue was whether the written contract of employment had any features of a sham transaction, and whether Mr Wright, as an individual, was Mr Robinson's employer. The court also considered statutory causes of action under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

The court dismissed the application to amend the statement of claim on the basis that it was an abuse of process to allow the amendment at that late stage, given that the applicant had not availed himself of earlier opportunities to make the amendment. The court found that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to support the proposed amendments, and that the delay in making the application would cause significant prejudice to the respondents. The court also found that the applicant had not demonstrated that the proposed amendments would be relevant to the issues in the case, and that the application was an attempt to relitigate issues that had already been decided.

The court concluded that the application to amend the statement of claim should be dismissed, and that the parties should bear their own costs of the proceeding. The court further ordered that the second respondent file and serve any submissions he wishes to make on the costs of the unsuccessful interlocutory application made by the applicant on 4 May 2022, and that the applicant file and serve any submissions in response. The question of the costs of the interlocutory application was to be dealt with on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. On or before 4pm on 21 October 2022, the second respondent file and serve any submissions he wishes to make on the costs of the unsuccessful interlocutory application made by the applicant on 4 May 2022.

3. On or before 4pm on 4 November 2022, the applicant file and serve any submissions in response.

4. Subject to further order, the question of the costs of the interlocutory application be dealt with on the papers.

5. The parties otherwise bear their own costs of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The proceeding was listed for a case management hearing on 12 May 2022. Mr Bartlett explained that the proposed amendments made allegations about further representations said to have been made by Mr Wright and BMF, allegations that Mr Wright was Mr Robinson’s employer or joint employer, an allegation that Mr Wright had induced BMF to breach a contract with Mr Robinson, and other allegations advanced in the alternative that the Court were to find Brandmet to have been Mr Robinson’s employer. On 13 May 2022, the Court ordered that the application to amend the statement of claim be dismissed, with reasons to be given in the Court’s final decision about liability. The proceeding continued to a hearing of final submissions about liability on 24 May 2022, with supplementary written submissions being finalised on 3 June 2022. The reasons for the Court’s decision to dismiss Mr Robinson’s application for leave to amend his statement of claim are found at [16]-[29], below.THE EVIDENCE The parties relied on affidavits from their principal witnesses, Mr Robinson and Mr Wright. Mr Robinson also read and relied upon affidavits from Mr Bartlett. There was a considerable amount of documentary material which was collected into a Court Book. A number of documents were tendered as exhibits during the hearing. After the hearing, the parties were given the opportunity to reflect on what documents they intended, and needed, to rely upon, and were invited to inform the Court of any documents in the digital version of the Court Book upon which they did not propose to ask the Court to rely. This process was designed to avoid any duplication in the evidence before the Court, and to ensure the parties focussed their attention on what they relied upon to prove their respective cases. It was also designed to ensure the hearing process was fair in particular to the applicant, who had experienced some difficulties with the unavailability of his counsel for the evidentiary part of the hearing. The parties cooperated in this process and produced an index to the Court Book indicating what they continued to rely upon, and what they did not. The amended Court Book was then marked as an exhibit. The Court has made its findings and reached its conclusions based on the evidence as reflected in the amended Court Book as submitted by the parties. Both Mr Robinson and Mr Wright were cross-examined. Harry Fung, a man whose role looms large in the events relevant to this proceeding, was not called as a witness by either party. Nor were any of the other people who worked for Brandmet or BMF Construction called as witnesses, despite several such people being mentioned in the documentary evidence, some relatively prominently.THE APPLICANT’S INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION DATED 4 MAY 2022 As I noted above, on 4 May 2022, Mr Robinson filed an interlocutory application seeking leave to file an amended statement of claim. This was accompanied by a supporting affidavit of Mr Bartlett, affirmed 3 May 2022, containing the amended statement of claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his affidavit evidence, Mr Robinson stated that he never did any work for Brandmet, except for creating one invoice dated 1 April 2020. Mr Wright disputed this assertion. His evidence was that all of Mr Robinson’s work was work for Brandmet, as the vehicle for providing his services to BMF, Wilson & Market, Magnum + Queens and other businesses. This of course reflects the parties’ competing views on the question of who was Mr Robinson’s employer.Mr Wright’s decision to change his business structure The narrative of events from this point coincides with the commencement of the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia, and around the world. That coincidence is not irrelevant to the course of events which unfolded. In the first half of 2020, the evidence suggests the relationship between Mr Robinson and Mr Wright began to change. Mr Wright proposed to enter into a joint venture with a property developer named Harry Fung. Mr Wright had commenced discussions with Mr Fung about this proposal in late 2019. Adam King, an individual who had been working with Mr Wright (including for some period of time apparently through Brandmet), had (on Mr Wright’s affidavit evidence) previously worked with Mr Fung and his company Base Group Property Pty Ltd on a number of property development projects for which Mr Fung had arranged funding through his business connections. Mr Wright was introduced to Mr Fung by Mr King. I accept Mr Wright’s affidavit evidence on these matters. He was not cross-examined on these issues. Mr Wright deposed that his intention was that Mr Fung’s connections and expertise in property development could help Brandmet expand from its role as a company providing administrative and support services and improve BMF’s chances of securing building contracts through that expansion. I accept that evidence, and Mr Wright was not cross-examined to suggest that evidence was untrue. A memorandum of understanding was executed between Brandmet and Base Group on 11 February 2020. The memorandum provided that Brandmet would be used as the vehicle for a joint venture in which Mr Wright and Base Group (or another entity nominated by Mr Fung) would each invest $500,000, apparently to service existing tax liabilities in Mr Wright’s group of companies, which had been consolidated in the Brandmet entity. Clearly, this was one of the key benefits Mr Wright sought to secure through the joint venture. Mr Fung was also to be appointed a director of Brandmet, which occurred on 15 February 2020. The proposal was for Brandmet to operate as the joint venture vehicle between Mr Fung and Mr Wright, providing project management services to Mr Wright’s businesses and Mr Fung’s businesses (chiefly, Base Group). According to Mr Wright, Mr Robinson was to continue as an employee of Brandmet, with his services to BMF or other businesses being charged out at an hourly rate from 20 April 2020. In other words, it was envisaged Mr Robinson would play a key role in the joint venture.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 2 February 2021, BMF was placed in liquidation. Pursuant to s 500(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the proceeding was therefore stayed as against BMF. BMF’s liquidators formed the view that there were insufficient funds to defend Mr Robinson’s claims or pay Mr Robinson on the relief he seeks. For the reasons given in Robinson v BMF Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 1064, the Court refused Mr Robinson’s application for leave to proceed against BMF under s 500 of the Corporations Act. Shortly after the Court’s decision, in September 2021, orders were made to list the proceeding for a trial of three days, commencing Tuesday 8 March 2022. On the Friday before the hearing was scheduled to commence, Mr Robinson applied to vacate the trial hearing because of the unexpected unavailability of his counsel. Mr Robinson sought to have the proceeding referred to a mediation to be held on Wednesday 9 and Thursday 10 March 2022. Given the delays likely in trying to find suitable alternative dates, and the fact the proceeding had taken longer than usual to come to trial in any event, the Court determined that the trial hearing would be postponed for one day and be limited to questions of liability, so that its estimated duration could be reduced to two days. The proceeding was then referred to a mediation to be conducted by 31 March 2022. The reasons for this ruling were published to the parties on Sunday 6 March 2022. The hearing of evidence and opening submissions regarding liability was conducted on Wednesday 9 and Thursday 10 March 2022. Due to the unavailability of counsel who had been briefed in the matter, and the difficulties in securing replacement counsel at short notice, Mr Robinson was represented at the hearing by Glen Bartlett, his solicitor. Mr Bartlett had the assistance in court of a legal clerk from his firm. It was clear that Mr Bartlett knew his client’s case well, and was familiar with the evidence to be tendered. The opening submissions included an exchange between the Court and Mr Bartlett in which he indicated that it was now intended to submit, in the alternative, that Mr Wright (as an individual) was Mr Robinson’s employer, despite that position not forming part of Mr Robinson’s case as it had been pleaded. As recounted in Robinson at [5]-[7], since at least February 2021 Mr Robinson had been aware of Mr Wright’s position in the proceeding, pleaded in his defence, that BMF had not been Mr Robinson’s employer and that Brandmet was his employer. It was plain this was an issue of fundamental importance to the proceeding. Nevertheless, Mr Robinson did not seek to reformulate his case to deal with the possibility that the Court would agree with Mr Wright on this issue. Orders made in February 2021 expressly to permit an amendment to Mr Robinson’s originating application and pleadings in relation to the joinder, removal or substitution of any respondents were allowed to expire without any application to amend, nor any application for joinder, being filed. In opening, Mr Bartlett accepted there was no pleading that Mr Wright as an individual was Mr Robinson’s employer. He appeared to accept an amendment would be required. He embraced the suggestion that if the evidence supported it, this contention would form part of his client’s final submissions. Responsively, counsel for Mr Wright accepted in opening that there would need to be an amendment application, and indicated Mr Wright would resist any such application.