Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 50

Appeal from: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 987
File number: QUD 683 of 2016
Judges: GREENWOOD, FLICK AND RANGIAH JJ
Date of judgment: 23 March 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to appeal – paragraphs of amended statement of claim struck out – paragraphs ambiguous or likely to cause prejudice or embarrassment – decision not attended by sufficient doubt – no substantial injustice – application for leave to appeal dismissed
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 342, 361, 362, 550, 793

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.23, 16.02, 16.03, 16.21, 16.41, 16.43, 16.45, 20.13

Cases cited:

Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170

Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Visy Packaging Pty Ltd(No 3) (2013) 216 FCR 70

Banque Commerciale SA v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

Bruce v Odhams Press Ltd [1936] 1 KB 697

Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658

Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397

Fair Work Ombudsman v Al Hilfi [2012] FCA 1166

Gould, Birbeck and Bacon v Mount Oxide Mines Ltd (in liq) (1916) 22 CLR 490

Krakowski v Eurolynx Properties Ltd (1995) 183 CLR 563

Lee v Westpac Banking Corporation [2015] FCA 467

Lion-Dairy & Drinks Pty Ltd v Sinclair Knight Merz Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 869

Maritime Union of Australia v Geraldton Port Authority (1999) 93 FCR 34

Minogue v Williams [2000] FCA 125

Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2016] FCAFC 99

Samsung Electronics Company Ltd v Apple Inc (2011) 217 FCR 238

Thorpe v Commonwealth (No 3) (1997) 71 ALJR 767

Wright Rubber Products Pty Ltd v Bayer AG [2008] FCA 1510

Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661

Date of hearing: 21 November 2016
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 73
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr H Borenstein QC with Mr J Fetter
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hall Payne Lawyers
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr A Duffy QC with Mr I Neil SC
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Ashurst Australia
Counsel for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Mr C Murdoch
Solicitor for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Corrs Chambers Westgarth

ORDERS

QUD 683 of 2016
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Applicant

AND:

BHP COAL PTY LTD (ACN 010 595 721)

First Respondent

BM ALLIANCE COAL OPERATIONS PTY LTD (ACN 096 412 752)

Second Respondent

DOWNER EDI MINING PTY LTD (ACN 004 142 223) (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGES:

GREENWOOD, FLICK AND RANGIAH JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

23 MARCH 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for leave to appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCAFC 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFME) sought leave to appeal against the decision of the primary judge who struck out certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim (ASOC) filed in the Federal Court of Australia. The ASOC alleged that BHP Coal Pty Ltd contravened specific sections of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by being involved in activities carried out by BMA. The primary judge ordered that multiple paragraphs of the ASOC be struck out, including paragraphs 28B, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 33A, 34, 35, 38, 39, 40, 40A, 41, 42, 43, 44 and 45. These paragraphs pertained to an agreement between BMA and Downer, which was alleged to have prejudiced BHP Coal in its supply of labour. The CFMEU argued that the primary judge erred in striking out these paragraphs, claiming that paragraph 29, in particular, raised an intelligible factual allegation and was not subject to the confusion alleged by the primary judge.

The court was tasked with determining whether the primary judge's decision to strike out the specified paragraphs of the ASOC was justified. The key legal issue was whether the primary judge's findings regarding the confusion in the pleaded agreement and the sufficiency of the detail provided in paragraph 29 were correct. Additionally, the court needed to assess if the interlocutory judgment had any impact on the CFMEU's substantive rights, considering the primary judge had granted leave to replead. The court's reasoning involved examining the applicant's arguments and submissions concerning the merits of the proposed appeal, focusing on the clarity and intelligibility of paragraph 29 and the relationship between this paragraph and the other paragraphs that were struck out.

The court found that the primary judge's decision to strike out the paragraphs of the ASOC was not attended by sufficient doubt to warrant leave to appeal. The court reasoned that the primary judge's findings regarding the confusion and insufficient detail were not erroneous. Furthermore, the court held that the interlocutory judgment did not affect the CFMEU's substantive rights since the primary judge had already granted leave to replead. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.

The court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

2. There will be no order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Paragraphs 44 and 45 of the ASOC alleged that BHP Coal contravened s 340(1)(a)(i) of the FWA as a person “involved in” the first of the contraventions by BMA. The judgment of the primary judge On 22 February 2016, BMA and BHP Coal filed an interlocutory application seeking summary judgment pursuant to s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), or alternatively, orders that a number of paragraphs of the ASOC be struck out. On the same date, Downer Mining and Downer Blasting filed an interlocutory application seeking summary judgment or, alternatively, that certain paragraphs of the ASOC be struck out. On 19 August 2016, the primary judge ordered that paragraphs 28B, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 33A, 34, 35, 38, 39, 40, 40A, 41, 42, 43, 44 and 45 of the ASOC be struck out. Paragraphs 29 and 30 of the ASOC were central to her Honour’s reasons. Those paragraphs read as follows:29In or about August 2015, BMA agreed with Downer for the supply of labour to carry out the Work being performed by the Employees in replacement of BHP Coal and the Employees (BMA-Downer Agreement).ParticularsFrans Knox informed the Employees of the BMA-Downer Agreement in a letter dated 20 August 2015. An announcement of the BMA-Downer Agreement was also made by Rag Udd on 20 August 2015. The BMA-Downer Agreement was also confirmed in a letter dated 31 August 2015 from Hilton Hurst of Downer Mining to Stephen Smyth of the CFMEU. The Applicant will refer to the full terms of these documents at trial. These documents may be inspected by appointment at the office of the Applicant’s solicitors.30 By making the BMA-Downer Agreement, BMA has or threatened to:(a)terminate the labour supply agreement with BHP Coal in relation to the performance of the Work;(b)alter the position of BHP Coal to its prejudice in relation to the supply of labour for the performance of the Work; and(c)refuse to make use of the services of BHP Coal in relation to the supply of labour for the performance of the Work.ParticularsA.On 20 August 2015, Udd (writing as Asset President, BMA) circulated an announcement to all email addresses on the BMA system. The announcement stated that BMA “has awarded” the Work to Downer, and that the contractual arrangements “contain performance guarantees that will enable us to achieve productivity targets and cost reductions”.B.On the same day, Knox wrote a letter (on BMA letterhead) to each Employee, advising them of the BMA-Downer Agreement, informing them the Work would be “outsourced” and that approximately 306 roles would be affected.C.At the 21 August consultation, Knox and McKenzie displayed a series of powerpoint slides bearing the BMA logo. The slides stated that in consequence of the BMA-Downer Agreement there was a “surplus” of 210 Employees and a “possible need for redundanc[ies]”.D.On 26 August 2015, McKenzie wrote a letter to the CFMEU (on BMA letterhead) confirming that the surplus of Employees ‘cannot be addressed by natural attrition’.E.Further consultation meetings between McKenzie and CFMEU representatives were held on 24 and 27 August, 2 and 22 September, and 14 October 2015, during which meetings it was explained that the surplus Employees would either be redeployed within the Mine, transferred to another Mine, or else offered a “voluntary redundancy”. During each meeting, slides featuring the BMA logo were displayed. After each meeting the minutes were circulated, on BMA letterhead.F.On or about 30 October 2015, BMA produced a document entitled “Blackwater Restructure Summary Data” which stated that BMA had completed its “decisions” about the surplus Employees, and had decided that BHP Coal would dismiss 43 of the Employees by way of “voluntary redundancy”, transfer 67 of them to other Mines, and redeploy 99 of them to other roles within the Mine.G.These decisions were implemented by BHP Coal in November and December 2015.H.The effect of the BMA-Downer Agreement is that BHP Coal is no longer required to perform the Work and it will instead be performed by Downer. The date upon which the labour supply agreement with BHP Coal was terminated, or will be terminated, is not presently known. Further particulars will be provided after discovery.I.The effect of the BMA-Downer Agreement is to prejudice BHP Coal in relation to its supply of labour for the performance of the Work by reducing its operations at the Mine and any revenue earned therefrom. Further particulars will be provided after discovery.J.The effect of the BMA-Downer Agreement is that BMA will no longer use the services of BHP Coal to supply labour for the performance of the Work and the labour will instead be supplied by Downer.(Underlining omitted.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Leave to appeal is more readily given where the interlocutory judgment affects a party’s substantive rights: Minogue v Williams [2000] FCA 125 at [19]. In this case, the judgment does not affect the applicant’s substantive rights since the primary judge gave the applicant leave to replead. Consideration The applicant’s oral submissions as to the merits of the proposed appeal focused principally on paragraph 29 of the ASOC. The applicant accepted that each of the succeeding paragraphs struck out was related to paragraph 29. The applicant conceded that in the proposed appeal the fate of each of the paragraphs struck out, other than s 28B, will depend upon the fate of paragraph 29. The applicant’s draft notice of appeal contains the following ground in respect of paragraph 29 of the ASOC:31.Her Honour erred in striking out paragraph 29 for the reason that it contained insufficient detail to enable Downer to answer it, and for the reason that there was confusion in the agreement pleaded, in relation to which the Applicant relies on grounds 1 to 6 above. Grounds 1 to 6 of the draft notice of appeal deal with paragraph 30 of the ASOC. Of those grounds, only ground 2 has any relevance to the striking out of paragraph 29. That ground states:2.Her Honour erred in finding that there was confusion in the Applicant’s case as to the precise nature of the BMA-Downer Agreement as defined in paragraph 29 of the ASOC, by herself confusing the defined agreement with the two formal contracts between BMA and Downer which were produced on affidavit by BMA. In its written submissions, the applicant argues that:30.Her Honour found that the “BMA-Downer Agreement” pleaded at ASOC [29] was to be understood as a reference to three contracts placed into evidence by the Respondent. That finding affected her Honour’s decision to strike out not only ASOC [29], but every other paragraph challenged, save for ASOC [28B]…31.Her Honour failed to consider and deal with ASOC [29] in its own terms. Her Honour was distracted by the contracts produced by the Respondents which led her into error. Her Honour wrongly assumed that ASOC [29] seeks to plead those formal contracts. It does not. It simply pleads an agreement – in the ordinary sense of a mutual arrangement or understanding – the effect of which is stated, namely, that Downer would “replace” BHP Coal. Further details of the agreement, and its implementation, are given in the particulars to ASOC [30].32.The question for her Honour was whether ASOC [29] raised an intelligible factual allegation. It clearly did and her Honour erred in striking it out.(Citation omitted.) In their oral submissions, counsel for the applicant said:And we made the point before her Honour that we were not suggesting or referring to any particular contract in a formal sense. We were referring to an agreement or arrangement, in the commonly understood sense, which called for certain things to happen, and then we plead that they happened.…The documents that we rely on are not contractual documents. We never said they were. But they are documents which contain, effectively, admissions from the parties of the arrangement. And the particulars which were given are also consistent with those admissions.