Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 4) [2023] FedCFamC2G 1051

File numbers: MLG 806 of 2021
MLG 807 of 2021
MLG 808 of 2021
MLG 809 of 2021
MLG 810 of 2021
MLG 811 of 2021
MLG 812 of 2021
MLG 813 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 24 November 2023
Catchwords: FAIR WORK – small claims procedure– multiple applicants –- where applicants claim underpayment or non-payment of wages and superannuation – whether applicants performed work as employees or independent contractors – whether applicants employed by respondent or corporations owned and controlled by the respondent - identity of true employer – whether applicants covered by fair work instrument – whether respondent liable as accessory if not the direct employer –whether declarations appropriate in small claim proceeding
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 12, 44, 45, 323, 357, 359, 536, 539, 545, 547, 548, 550, 557A, 557C

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act2021 (Cth) s 190, 192

Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic) s 336

Cases cited:

ACE Insurance Ltd v Trifunovski (NSD 1295 PF 2012) (2013) 295 ALR 407

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal [2022] FedCFamC2G 401

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 2) [2022] FedCFamC2G 548

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 3) [2022] FedCFamC2G 650

Casazza v McGuiness [2022] NSWSC 348

Central Innovation v Garner (No 4) [2020] FCA 1796

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union vPersonnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1

Curtis v Perth and Fremantle Bottle Exchange Co Ltd (1914) 18 CLR 17

Damevski v Giudice (2003) 133 FCR 438

Director of the FWBII v McCullough [2016] FCA 1291

EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2018] FCAFC 134

Fair Work Ombudsman v Devine Marine Group Ltd [2014] FCA 1365

Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage [2021] FCA 1241

Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1034

Fair Work Ombudsman v Hu [2019] FCAFC 133

Fair Work Ombudsman v PTES 928 Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 934

Fair Work Ombudsman v Pulis Plumbing [2017] FCCA 3013

Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 37

Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (2011) 198 FCR 174

Fair Work Ombudsman v Raying Holding Pty Ltd (No.2) [2017] FCCA 2148

Fair Work Ombudsman v South Jin Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1456

Golden Plains Fodder Australia Pty Ltd v Millard (2007) 99 SASR 461

Gothard v Davey [2010] FCA 1163

Hollisv Vabu Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 44

Humberstone v Northern Timber Mills [1949] HCA 49

Murphy v Chapple [2022] FCAFC 165

On Call Interpreters and Translators Agency Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No 3) [2011] FCA 366

Narich Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Pay-Roll Tax [1983] 2 NSWLR 597

Peckham v Moore (1975) 1 NSWLR 353

Pitcher v Langford(1991) 23 NSWLR 142

Re C&T Grinter Transport Services Pty Ltd (in liq) & Grinter Transport Pty Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 1051
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 4), the applicants, all foreign workers, brought claims against the respondent, Shivesh Kuksal, for underpayment of wages and superannuation, and for interest on these amounts. The applicants argued that they were employees of the respondent, or of corporations controlled by him, and that they were not paid the correct entitlements as required by the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The central legal issues in the case were whether the applicants had performed work as employees or independent contractors, and if they were employees, whether the respondent or the corporations he controlled were their employers. The court had to determine whether the applicants were covered by a fair work instrument and whether the respondent could be held liable if he was not the direct employer. The court also considered whether declarations were appropriate in the small claims proceeding.

The court found that the applicants were employees of the respondent, not of the corporations he controlled, based on the evidence that the respondent personally interviewed the applicants, made decisions about their engagement and pay rates, and gave directions regarding their work. The court rejected the argument that the applicants were independent contractors because they did not receive documents referring to any corporation, and the respondent did not claim to be acting on behalf of any corporation when engaging the applicants. The court also found that the respondent was the true employer because he provided the equipment, was responsible for receiving and processing the applicants' invoices, and made the payments. The court concluded that the applicants were covered by a fair work instrument and that the respondent was liable for the underpayments as the principal employer.

The court declined to make declarations about the alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act because it considered that the small claims procedure was not an appropriate vehicle for such relief. The court noted that the small claims procedure is primarily directed at correcting underpayments and does not permit legal representation or allow for the same evidentiary burden as in a conventional proceeding. The court held that if declarations were sought in relation to contraventions of civil remedy provisions, it would have been more appropriate to proceed through the conventional course of action. The court granted the applicants' claims for underpayments and interest, and ordered the respondent to pay the amounts owed to each applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In addition to the unpaid wages and superannuation entitlements, each of the applicants seek interest on the outstanding amounts calculated in accordance with section 547 of the FW Act to the date of judgment. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND For context, these reasons should be read with the three earlier judgments I have published in relation to these proceedings. I will not repeat observations already made in those judgments but they tend to underplay rather than overstate the case management challenges confronted by the Court in this complicated litigation. A perusal of the transcript of the various Court events will reveal the Court’s efforts to maintain order in this highly adversarial contest. Suffice to say, the final hearing of these proceedings has been delayed after a number of adjournments for numerous reasons. Nonetheless by 4 July 2022 the parties were squarely on notice that following earlier attempts at trial, the applications would proceed for final hearing on 29 and 30 August 2022 without any further delays or interferences. Unfortunately, when the final hearing day arrived, the proceeding found itself mired in further controversy, for which the applicants are entirely blameless. Consistent themes, such as the respondent’s aggressive self-advocacy, the ambiguous state of his legal representation, his belligerent challenges to the authority of the Court and applications for my recusal surfaced yet again. It is necessary to digress to explain the unusual circumstances which shaped the final hearing. I will endeavour to give context to some of the complications and delays which have attended the hearing and determination of these claims. The exercise of my discretion in dealing with the various issues which emerged on the morning of trial must also be viewed in the context of what had gone before, including the written and ex tempore reasons I have given for previous rulings and orders.The respondent’s representation during these proceedings Among his business interests, Mr Kuksal was at material times the beneficial owner and director of a law practice which operated under a series of different names including The People Shop, New Edge Law and Erudite Legal[15]. Mr Kuksal is not a lawyer or at least is not admitted to practice as such in Victoria. [15] Gabriella Marchetti affidavit affirmed on 4 February 2022 at [7]-[10] and annexures The legal practice was purportedly engaged to represent Mr Kuksal from time to time during the course of these proceedings, although the nature and scope of their engagement and role in this proceeding was often unclear. During the proceedings, solicitors and firms associated with Mr Kuksal came on and went off the record, confusing both the Court and the applicants’ representatives. Initially, on 20 October 2021, Mr Kuksal sought leave to be represented by a lawyer in relation to each of the applications. Under the small claims provisions of the FW Act leave is required and I granted it[16]. The final hearing was set down for 7 February 2022, and by Order 9 of the orders made that day I cautioned the parties that in the event of non-attendance I would grant leave for the matter to proceed on an undefended basis.[16] Orders made 21 October 2021, Order 1

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I was and remain satisfied that in all the circumstances Mr Kuksal had been afforded every opportunity to engage in the proceedings and prosecute his defence. Mr Kuksal was aware the proceedings would resume at 2.15pm and he offered no explanation for his non-appearance.Evidence Well in advance of the trial the applicants identified the affidavits they proposed to tender into evidence in support of the applications. Each of the applicants was called to give evidence and each swore to the truth of their affidavits and adopted them as their evidence in chief. The affidavits read by the Court and received into evidence were:(1)affidavit of Nicolas Moreno Rivero affirmed 25 February 2022[18]; (2)affidavit of Carolina Corrales Rhenals sworn 25 February 2022[19]; (3)affidavit of Juan Camilo Pinereos Torres sworn 25 February 2022[20]; (4)affidavit of Juan Camilo Rios Londono affirmed 25 February 2022[21]; (5)affidavit of Wilmer Jahir Alvarez Nino sworn 25 February 2022[22];(6)affidavit of Geraldine Torres Amezquita affirmed 25 February 2022[23];(7)affidavit of Ana Melisa Gracia Calvo sworn 25 February 2022[24]; and(8)affidavit of Leonardo Fabio Hernandez Alarcon affirmed 25 February 2022[25];[18] Nicholas Moreno Rivero affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB 327) (Moreno Rivero affidavit)[19] Carolina Corrales Rhenals affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB 300) (Corrales Rhenals affidavit) [20] Juan Camilo Pineros Torres affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB 238) (Pineros Torres affidavit)[21] Juan Camilo Rios Londono affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB 220) (Rios Londono affidavit)[22] Wilmer Jahir Alvarez Nino affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB178) (Alvarez Nino affidavit) subject amendment at paragraph [6] where ‘2016’ was amended to read ‘2017'[23] Torres Amezquita affidavit[24] Ana Melisa Garcia Calvo affidavit affirmed on 25 February 2022 (CB 212) (Garcia Calvo affidavit)[25] Hernandez Alarcon affidavit In each case before receiving the affidavits into evidence I asked the applicants about their understanding of English, confirmed that they had seen and understood their affidavits before swearing them and confirmed that they understood the oath that they had taken. I am satisfied that each of the applicants had a sound command of written English and that when they swore to the truth of their affidavits they understood the significance of doing so. In addition to the affidavits there was some further evidence received by the Court as part of the applicants’ case. Mr Alvarez Nino was shown and identified a series of emails between himself and Mr Kuksal and himself and the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO). These comprised emails which the witness had either authored or received in relation to his alleged employment[26]. These documents were tendered into evidence.[26] Exhibit A1 (CB 934-966) Counsel for the applicants also tendered a series of documents which had been exhibited to the affidavit of the applicants’ solicitor, Ms Gabrielle Marchetti sworn on 29 June 2022. Over Mr Kuksal’s objection, I had previously given the applicants leave[27] to file the affidavit of Ms Marchetti and to tender into evidence exhibits GM-1, GM-7, GM-10 and GM-11. More specifically:(1)GM-1 was a notice of decision by the FWO in relation to an FOI request[28];(2)GM-7 is a customer enquiry record of a communication between Mr Kuksal and the FWO [29];(3)GM-10 is a transcribed record of a phone call between Mr Kuksal and the FWO dated 9 January 2017[30]; and(4)GM-11 is a chain of emails between the applicants’ solicitor JobWatch and the FWO dated 14 June 2022 clarifying a date error in the telephone transcript[31][27] Reasons in Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 3) [2022] FedCFamC2G 650 (Kuksal [No 3])[28] Exhibit A2 (CB 373)[29] Exhibit A3 (CB 459)[30] Exhibit A4 (CB 482)[31] Exhibit A5 (CB 493)

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, in written[101] and oral submissions the applicants advanced a number of uncontested facts which inform the conclusion that Mr Kuksal was personally the employer. These included the following:[101] See in particular the Applicants’ submissions filed on 4 September 2022 at [29]-[40] and the evidentiary references therein(1)the outward manifestations of the dealings with at least five of the applicants pointed to engagement by Mr Kuksal;(2)Mr Kuksal personally interviewed most of the applicants. It was he who made decisions about the engagement and the applicable rate of pay;(3)Mr Kuksal did not say that he was acting on behalf of Kornucoppia or Avant-Garde or any other entity; (4)as the contracts were entered face-to-face, an inter praesentes presumption that the workers were dealing with Mr Kuksal personally may apply; (5)Mr Kuksal gave them no documents on engagement which referred to Kornuoppia or any other entity; (6)Mr Kuksal met the applicants at his home, not in a corporation’s office. Often meetings with the respondent were late at night. It is not a situation where the workers were interviewed in a corporate office, surrounded by company insignia; (7)many of the employees were international students and it cannot be presumed that they are familiar with Australian corporate structures;(8)Mr Kuksal told Alvarez Nino that invoices were to be issued ‘to him’; Mr Kuksal said to Alvarez Nino – ‘send me the invoice’ Mr Kuksal told Garcia Calvo – ‘he would pay me’. Mr Kuksal said to Pineros that he would pay and told Pineros to ‘send him an invoice’; (9)the offer to Alvarez Nino for ongoing work was an offer ‘to come and work for me’. The offer to Garcia Calvo was to ‘work for him’. Mr Kuksal told Rios ‘he was looking’ for workers. Mr Kuksal said to Pineros that work was ‘for him.’ Ms Xu told Alvarez Nino she was a manager working for Mr Kuksal, not that she was a manager working for Kornucoppia. Mr Kuksal said that the applicants work for him “you don’t work for Lulu”; (10)applicants sent tax invoices to ‘Shiv’ or ‘Shivesh’ and phone messages and texts about invoices and payment were directed to Mr Kuksal;(11)invoices were sent to Mr Kuksal and he was solely responsible for receiving, reviewing and processing the applicants’ invoices. Payments were made by Mr Kuksal: Bank account credits from ‘Shivesh Kuksal’ (description: “Payment 4 service”);(12)in relation to the FWO enquiries on behalf of Mr Alvarez, correspondence was addressed to Mr Kuksal (and not to any corporation) and Mr Kuksal did not respond that he had engaged Alvarez Nino on behalf of a corporation;(13)directions regarding work were given personally by Mr Kuksal. It was he who exercised the human resources management of the employees;(14)Mr Kuksal provided the equipment; and(15)as employees, the applicants should have received a payslip which should have contained the employer’s name and its ABN if they have one. No payslips were provided and so, for that reason, they are unable to rely on that information as to who is the employer. The workers should not be disadvantaged by the failure of the respondent, or a business under the control of the respondent as sole director and shareholder, to fulfil statutory obligations.Conclusion

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the avoidance of doubt, this is a conclusion I have reached on the evidence and on the premise that my primary findings may be challenged and found to be wrong.Declarations as to other alleged contraventions There are several contraventions of the FW Act alleged in each of the applications: s 44 (breach of NES), s 45 (contravention of a modern award), s 323 (frequency and method of payment) s 357 (sham contracting), and s 456 (the payslip provision). Counsel for the applicants informed the Court that he had been instructed to seek declarations in relation to each of those contraventions, despite them not giving rise to civil penalties under the small claims procedure. Furthermore, the applicants also invited the Court to find that Mr Kuksal’s conduct amounted to a serious contravention under section 557A. The applicants submit that the Court has power to grant broad relief pursuant to s 545. The applicants submit that although penalties are not available under the small claims procedure, it would nonetheless be appropriate for the Court to make declarations given the seriousness of the contraventions and to have the public record reflect the Court’s condemnation of the Mr Kuksal’s conduct. It is submitted in effect that compensation to each of the applicants should be regarded as insufficient to convey the Court’s opprobrium. Although I can see considerable force in the applicants’ submission, I am not inclined to make declarations in this proceeding Declaratory relief is not an entitlement which automatically follows a finding of liability. The exercise of judicial discretion to make declarations in any given case requires careful consideration[122]. [122] As to the appropriateness and purpose of declaratory relief, see Fair Work Ombudsman v PTES 928 Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 934 at [59]-[70] per Snaden J As I have discussed elsewhere, the small claims procedure is primarily directed at correcting underpayments as the principal (if not only) relief. The scheme of section 548 does not permit legal representation as of right, it relaxes the rules of evidence, and it aims to provide an informal right of redress where modest underpayments are concerned. Matters of proof are perhaps not as stringent as they might be if a respondent were facing the risk of civil penalties. The declarations sought by the applicants would in effect amount to findings that a party has engaged in quasi-criminal conduct for which civil penalties apply, even if no penalties are awarded. Even more so, a declaration of a “serious contravention” would in effect convey a finding by the Court that the respondent’s conduct engages the significantly higher penalty regime (x 10). The small claims procedure, at least on this occasion, is not an appropriate vehicle. If declarations are sought in relation to contraventions of civil remedy provisions under the FW Act it would in my view have been more appropriate to proceed down the conventional course, where the rules of evidence do apply and alleged breaches of civil remedy provisions are subjected to a more rigorous evidentiary burden.