Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 2) [2022] FedCFamC2G 548

File numbers: MLG 806 of 2021
MLG 807 of 2021
MLG 808 of 2021
MLG 809 of 2021
MLG 810 of 2021
MLG 811 of 2021
MLG 812 of 2021
MLG 813 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 8 July 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – Application for recusal of trial judge – alleged apprehended bias – whether active case management gives rise to apprehension – objective assessment by hypothetical fair-minded lay observer – subjective concerns or lack of confidence not sufficient – application dismissed
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 548, 550, 570
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth), s 190, 191
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 39B
Cases Cited

Alvarez Nino v Kuksal [2022] FedCFamC2G 401
Charisteas v Charisteas (2020) HCA 29
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337
Gascor v Ellicott [1997] VR 332

Helljay Investments Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [1999] HCA 56
Johnson v Johnson (2000] 201 CLR 488 at 493
Pearlman v QA a/Information Commissioner [2019] WASC 257
R v Nicholas (2000) 1 VR 356
Re JRL Ex parte C.J.L (1986) 161 CLR 342
Re Polites; Ex parte Hoyts Corporation (1991) 173 CLR 78
Webb v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 41

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 68
Date of hearing: 4 July 2022
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Bunce
Solicitor for the Applicant: JobWatch Inc
Counsel for the Respondent: In Person
Solicitor for the Respondent: Erudite Legal

ORDERS

MLG 806 of 2021
MLG 807 of 2021
MLG 808 of 2021
MLG 809 of 2021
MLG 810 of 2021
MLG 811 of 2021
MLG 812 of 2021
MLG 813 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

WILMER JAHIR ALVAREZ NINO

First Applicant

ANA MELISA GARCIA CALVO

Second Applicant

JUAN CAMILO RIOS LONDONO (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

SHIVESH KUKSAL

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

8 JULY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent’s oral application for recusal made on 4 July 2022 is dismissed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE FORBES

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 4 July 2022, during the first day of what was to be the final hearing of these eight applications, the respondent made an oral application seeking that I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alvarez Nino v Kuksal (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, Alvarez Nino, an applicant, sought to challenge the decision of the respondent, Kuksal, to dismiss an application for recusal. The matter arose out of a series of proceedings initiated by the applicants under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) concerning alleged underpayment claims. Despite multiple attempts to proceed to a final hearing, the proceedings have been fraught with procedural disputes, contests, and numerous orders and directions aimed at preparing them for trial. The respondent had made several applications to the Court, including an oral application for summary dismissal of the applications and an application for the Court to recuse itself. Both applications were dismissed by the Court.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether there were sufficient grounds to justify the respondent's application for the judge to recuse themselves from the proceedings. The respondent argued that the cumulative effect of the Court's case management decisions and rulings, particularly in relation to procedural disputes and contests, created a reasonable apprehension that the judge would not bring an impartial mind to the issues in the proceeding. The respondent contended that the judge's decisions indicated a bias against them.

The Court found that case management decisions made in pursuit of the overarching purpose of civil practice and procedure were a necessary incident of the judicial system. The Court held that the subjective impression of a party that the tide of rulings is against them was not enough to ground a recusal application. The Court noted that the High Court had observed that the ground for disqualification was a reasonable apprehension that the judicial officer would not decide the case impartially or without prejudice, rather than that they would decide the case adversely to one party. The Court concluded that the hypothetical fair-minded lay observer, properly apprised of the facts and circumstances of the complicated proceeding, would not have a reasonable apprehension about the judge's capacity to bring an impartial mind to the issues that the Court was to determine.

The Court dismissed the respondent's application for the judge to recuse themselves from the proceeding. The Court held that there were no proper grounds for the respondent's application and that the judge was not disqualified from further hearing the applications. The Court found that the respondent's specific complaints did not establish a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of the judge. The Court also noted that the overarching purpose of proper case management included the just determination of all proceedings before the Court, the efficient use of the judicial and administrative resources of the Court, the efficient disposal of the Court's overall caseload, the disposal of all proceedings in a timely manner, and the resolution of disputes at a cost that was proportionate to the importance and complexity of the matters in dispute. The Court held that the respondent's application for recusal was without merit and should be dismissed.

In conclusion, the Court dismissed the respondent's application for the judge to recuse themselves from the proceeding. The Court held that there were no proper grounds for the respondent's application and that the judge was not disqualified from further hearing the applications. The Court found that the respondent's specific complaints did not establish a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of the judge. The Court also noted the overarching purpose of proper case management and held that the respondent's application for recusal was without merit and should be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

After hearing and considering the respondent’s submissions in support of the application, I did not accede to the application. These reasons explain my decision.BACKGROUND It is unnecessary to traverse the long and complex history of these matters, suffice to say that despite these 8 applications having been initiated under the small claims procedure of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)[1] (’the FW Act’) in April 2021, none has yet proceeded to a final hearing.[1]Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘FW Act’), s 548 The applications have been listed for final hearing on no fewer than 4 occasions, in November 2021, February 2022, March 2022 and again on 4 July 2022. The proceedings have been beset with procedural disputes and contests. What at first blush appear to be underpayment claims for relatively small amounts ranging from around $600 to $7,000 or so, disguises a litany of collateral legal and factual issues which have been agitated between the parties and which have occasioned numerous procedural rulings and adjournments. These applications have been the subject of numerous orders and directions in an effort to ready them for trial. Case management has been difficult and procedural orders have been made on seven occasions[2], dealing with amendments to the applications, the filing of evidence, lists of issues, outlines of submissions, referral to mediation and various other matters. Case management challenges have been compounded by the parties filing or seeking leave to file documents out of time, the ambiguous state of the respondent’s legal representation, the respondent’s robust engagement with opposing counsel and the Court, and his self-advocacy which includes frequent interjections, the use of emotive language and allegations of professional misconduct and judicial unfairness.[2] 21 June 2021, 20 October 2021, 7 February 2022, 24 February 2022, 15 March 2022, 15 June 2022, 4 July 2022 During the course of these proceedings it has been necessary for the Court to determine several interlocutory disputes. For example, the Court has ruled against the respondent’s oral application for summary dismissal of the applications as an abuse of process[3] and an earlier oral application that I recuse myself. The Court has also ordered that the respondent pay the applicants’ costs following an adjournment on 24 February 2022 occasioned by his late filing of an interlocutory application, an application he later discontinued. [3] Hearing on 7 February 2022 On another occasion, the respondent sought a stay of the proceedings after announcing to the Court on the morning of trial on 15 March 2022 that he had, that morning, filed an application in the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). In that application, the respondent sought judicial review of previous interlocutory decisions made by me in these proceedings as well as seeking declaratory relief and compensatory orders against the applicants’ solicitor and senior and junior counsel in relation to their conduct in the proceeding. I did not grant the stay nor did I recuse myself, for reasons given ex tempore that day.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Case management decisions made by the Court properly directed to the overarching purpose are a necessary incident of the judicial system. In an adversarial environment, directions, rulings and orders are necessary to move matters toward trial where the facts and legal issues in dispute can be determined. It will rarely be the case that parties will be happy with everything the judge does in exercising case management. However, the subjective impression by a party that the tide of rulings is going against him or her is not enough to ground a recusal application.CONCLUSION In my view, the hypothetical fair-minded lay observer, properly apprised of the facts and circumstances of this complicated proceeding, will not have a reasonable apprehension about my capacity to bring an impartial mind to the issues that the Court is to determine. For those reasons I see no proper basis to recuse myself from further hearing these applications. The respondent’s oral application made on 4 July 2022 is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Re JRL; Ex parte CJL the High Court observed:“It needs to be said loudly and clearly that the ground of disqualification is a reasonable apprehension that the judicial officer will not decide the case impartially or without prejudice, rather than that he will decide the case adversely to one party. There may be many situations in which previous decisions of a judicial officer on issues of fact and law may generate an expectation that he is likely to decide issues in a particular case adversely to one of the parties. But this does not mean either that he will approach the issues in that case otherwise than with an impartial and unprejudiced mind in the sense in which that expression is used in the authorities or that his previous decisions provide an acceptable basis for inferring that there is a reasonable apprehension that he will approach the issues in this way. In cases of this kind, disqualification is only made out by showing that there is a reasonable apprehension of bias by reason of prejudgment and this must be ''firmly established": Reg. v. Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Commission; Ex parte Angliss Group; Watson; Re Lusink; Ex parte Shaw. Although it is important that justice must be seen to be done, it is equally important that judicial officers discharge their duty to sit and do not, by acceding too readily to suggestions of appearance of bias, encourage parties to believe that by seeking the disqualification of a judge, they will have their case tried by someone thought to be more likely to decide the case in their favour.”[14][14] Re JRL Ex parte C.J.L (1986) 161 CLR 342, 352.CONSIDERATION In my view the respondent’s application that I recuse myself from sitting further in these proceedings has no proper basis and should be dismissed. Before turning to the respondent’s specific complaints, there are a number of contextual matters which in my opinion would inform the fair-minded lay observer’s objective assessment of my conduct throughout these proceedings. First, it is to be recalled that the eight applications being dealt with in these proceedings were all initiated as small claims pursuant to s 548 of the FW Act. As explained in my earlier decision on jurisdiction, where a proceeding is dealt with as a small claim proceeding the Court may not award more than $20,000 or such higher amount as may be prescribed by the Fair Work Regulations. In dealing with small claim proceedings the Court is not bound by any rules of evidence and procedure and may act in an informal manner and without regard to legal forms and technicalities. The small claims procedure permits the Court at any time to amend papers commencing the proceeding subject to sufficient notice being given to any party affected by the amendment. The right to legal representation requires leave of the Court, which may be granted subject to conditions. Secondly, case management of these proceedings is subject to the overarching purpose of civil practice and procedure set out at s 190 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) (‘the FCFCOA Act’), which identifies that Court rules or provisions made with respect to the practice and procedure of Division 2 of this Court should be applied to facilitate the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible. The overarching purpose of proper case management includes the just determination of all proceedings before the Court, the efficient use of the judicial and administrative resources of the Court, the efficient disposal of the Court’s overall caseload, the disposal of all proceedings in a timely manner and the resolution of disputes at a cost that is proportionate to the importance and complexity of the matters in dispute[15]. [15] s 190(2) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth)