Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd v Avonside Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 118/2014
[2015] NZSC 110
BETWEEN

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

AVONSIDE HOLDINGS LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

25 June 2015

Court:

Elias CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, Arnold and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:

B D Gray QC, C R Johnstone and S E Waggott for Appellant
N R Campbell QC and A M E Parlane for Respondent

Judgment:

22 July 2015

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant is to pay costs of $15,000 to the respondent, plus all reasonable disbursements, to be fixed if necessary by the Registrar.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

(Given by Glazebrook J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction [1]
The terms of the policy [4]
What is at issue [7]
  Contingencies [8]
  Professional fees [10]
High Court decision [12]
Court of Appeal decision [14]
Issues [17]
Relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 [19]
  Parties’ submissions [19]
  Our assessment [22]
Contingencies [23]
  The evidence [23]
  Parties’ submissions [34]
  Our assessment [38]
Professional fees [41]
  The evidence [41]
  Parties’ submissions [45]
  Our assessment [49]
Result [50]

Introduction

  1. Avonside Holdings Ltd (Avonside) owned a residential rental property in Christchurch (the property).  It was insured under a policy issued by AMI Insurance Ltd (AMI).  AMI’s liability under the policy has been assumed by Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd (Southern).

  2. The property was damaged in the earthquakes of 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011.  The property is in the residential red zone[1] and Avonside accepted the Crown’s offer to buy the land but retained its rights against Southern in relation to the improvements.[2]  It is agreed that the house is beyond economic repair.  As it was entitled to do under the policy, Avonside elected to buy another house.  The policy provided that the cost of the other house can be no more than “rebuilding your rental house on its present site”.[3] 

    [1]Delineated in June 2011.

    [2]For more information on the red zone and the Crown’s offers, see this Court’s judgment in Quake Outcasts v Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery [2015] NZSC 27 at [2]–[6].

    [3]It is accepted that the house area in the policy was understated but there is no issue needing determination by us in this regard.  We also note that, after each of the earthquakes, the Earthquake Commission (EQC) paid Avonside $115,000 including GST (the maximum amount available under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993), being a total of $230,000.  Southern’s liability is for the excess over the amount paid by EQC to Avonside.

  3. This appeal concerns whether there should be a sum for contingencies and the extent of an allowance for certain professional fees when calculating the amount payable under the policy.[4]  MacKenzie J in the High Court found in favour of Southern on those issues.[5]  These findings were overturned by the Court of Appeal.[6]

The terms of the policy

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd v Avonside Holding... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZSC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand against the decision of the Court of Appeal in favour of Avonside Holdings Ltd. The appeal concerns whether there should be a sum for contingencies and the extent of an allowance for certain professional fees when calculating the amount payable under the policy. The Court of Appeal had held that there should be an allowance for contingencies and that the amount allowed by Mr Farrell for professional fees was too low. The Court of Appeal’s approach was based on the principle that costs cannot be excluded merely because the rebuild is not going to happen and costs will not be incurred. The Court held that the relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 of the policy does not arise in this appeal as Avonside’s claim relies only on cl 1. The appeal was dismissed and Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd was ordered to pay costs of $15,000 to Avonside Holdings Ltd.

Background

Background to the litigation

Avonside Holdings Ltd owned a residential rental property in Christchurch that was damaged in the earthquakes of 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011. The property was in the residential red zone, and Avonside accepted the Crown's offer to buy the land but retained its rights against the insurer, Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd, in relation to the improvements. The house was beyond economic repair, and Avonside elected to buy another house. The insurance policy provided that the cost of the other house could not exceed the cost of rebuilding the rental house on its present site. The appeal concerned whether there should be a sum for contingencies and the extent of the allowance for certain professional fees when calculating the amount payable under the policy.

The matter was first heard in the High Court where MacKenzie J found in favour of Southern Response on the issues of contingencies and professional fees. The decision was appealed to the Court of Appeal, which overturned the High Court's findings. Leave for the appeal to be heard by the Supreme Court of New Zealand was granted, and the appeal was heard on 25 June 2015. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on 22 July 2015.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there should be a sum for contingencies.
2. The extent of the allowance to be made for professional fees.
3. The relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 of the policy.

Held
1. There should be a sum for contingencies.
2. The extent of the allowance for professional fees should be based on the approach of Mr Harrison, the quantity surveyor for Avonside.
3. The relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 of the policy does not arise in this appeal, as Avonside's claim relies only on cl 1.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand heard the appeal and provided its judgment on the issues of whether there should be a sum for contingencies, the extent of the allowance for professional fees, and the relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 of the policy. The Court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties and assessed the arguments based on the terms of the insurance policy and standard industry practices.

Regarding contingencies, the Court found that the fact that the rebuild was notional, rather than actual, did not affect the inclusion of an allowance for risks generally encountered in a rebuild project. Such risks were relevant to estimating the cost of an actual rebuild, and the Court accepted the inclusion of an allowance for contingencies.

As for the extent of the allowance for professional fees, the Court accepted Avonside's submission that the Court of Appeal's approach to this issue was correct. The Court found that Mr Harrison's allowance for professional fees was based on orthodox quantity surveying practice, and his approach was similar to the percentage (nine per cent) used by Arrow in its estimate of what it would actually cost to rebuild.

Finally, the Court found that the relationship between cl 1 and cl 4 of the policy did not arise in this appeal, as Avonside's claim relied only on cl 1. The Court accepted Avonside's submission that MacKenzie J mischaracterised architects' fees in his judgment.

The Supreme Court of New Zealand dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellant to pay costs of $15,000 to the respondent, plus all reasonable disbursements.