Turvey Trustee Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-615 [2012] NZHC 3344

BETWEEN  TURVEY TRUSTEE LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing:         15 November 2012

Counsel:         G D Trainor for plaintiff

C R Johnstone and S E Waggott for defendant

Judgment:      11 December 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      In these proceedings, the plaintiff trust (the insured) sues as the owner of an Edwardian style villa in suburban Christchurch, claiming on a more extensive basis than the defendant insurer of the property (the insurer) considers is the limit of its liability under the relevant policy that was in place at the time the property was irreparably damaged. That occurred in the February 2011 earthquake.

[2]      There has been a measure of co-operation between the parties in distilling questions for argument on a summary judgment basis, with a view to the answers to the  interpretation  issues  either  enabling  remaining  issues,  including  those  of quantum, to be resolved between the parties, or at least for them to be substantially narrowed.   When that course was proposed, the parties had three issues of interpretation of the insurance policy, but those have now been reduced to two.

[3]      The  insurer  was  formally AMI  Insurance  Limited,  and  appears  to  have insured the property for a substantial period of years.  The house policy was on the

TURVEY TRUSTEE LIMITED v SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED HC CHCH CIV-2012-409-615 [11 December 2012]

most  comprehensive  of  three alternative forms  of cover offered  by AMI,  being categorised in a proposal completed many years before the loss as “full replacement cover”.  By the time of the claim under the policy, it was styled as “premier house cover”.

[4]      The relevant terms of the policy included the following:

1  What we will pay    a.    We will pay to repair or rebuild your house to an ‘as new’ condition, up to the floor area stated in the Policy Schedule.

b.    We will use building materials and construction methods in common use at the time of repair or rebuilding.

c.    If  your  house  is  damaged  beyond  economic repair you can choose any one of the following options:

ito rebuild on the same site.  We will pay the  full  replacement  cost  of  rebuilding your house.

ii     to rebuild on another site.   We will pay the  full  replacement  cost  of  rebuilding your  house  on  another  site  you  choose. This cost must not be greater than rebuilding your house on its present site.

iii    to buy another house.   We will pay the cost of buying another house, including necessary legal and associated fees.   This cost must  not be  greater than rebuilding your house on its present site.

iv    a cash payment.  We will pay the market value of your house at the time of the loss.

…

cover for additional costs

We will pay for the following additional costs.

….

4        Compliance with building legislation and regulations

a.If additional work is required, we will pay the reasonable costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turvey Trustee Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Turvey Trustee Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited, the High Court of New Zealand dealt with a dispute between an insured party and an insurer regarding the extent of the insurer's liability under an insurance policy following significant property damage due to an earthquake. The insured party sought to rebuild their irreparably damaged Edwardian style villa on a new site, claiming that the insurer was obligated to replicate the original house in all its distinctive early 20th-century features. The insurer, however, argued that its liability was limited to rebuilding the house using materials and methods in common use at the time of rebuilding.

The court addressed two primary issues: the interpretation of the insurer's obligation to "rebuild your house to an 'as new' condition using building materials and construction methods in common use at the time of rebuilding," and the quantification of the insurer's liability to compensate for additional costs of rebuilding occasioned by compliance with current building legislation and codes.

Regarding the first issue, the court held that the insurer's obligation was to meet the cost of constructing a new house of the same style and quality of materials as the property insured, subject to the requirement that the materials and methods proposed were in common use at the time and that reasonable consideration be given to substitute materials or methods where they would not affect the functionality or character of the replacement structure. The court concluded that the insurer was not required to replicate the precise materials used in the original construction if equivalent modern materials were more commonly used and reasonably available.

For the second issue, the court determined that the insurer's liability to compensate for additional costs of rebuilding was to be quantified by reference to the actual costs incurred at the new site, rather than the notional cost of rebuilding on the existing site. This interpretation avoided unnecessary artificiality and ensured that the insurer's liability was calculated based on the actual costs incurred in complying with current building regulations.

The court's decision provided clarity on the insurer's obligations under the policy and the methodology for quantifying the insurer's liability for additional costs, contributing to the resolution of disputes arising from the Christchurch earthquakes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.