Avonside Holdings Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA520/2013
[2014] NZCA 483

BETWEEN

AVONSIDE HOLDINGS LIMITED
Appellant

AND

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

24 July 2014

Court:

Stevens, Lang and Clifford JJ

Counsel:

N R Campbell QC and A M E Parlane for Appellant
B D Gray QC and C R Johnstone for Respondent

Judgment:

1 October 2014 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed in part.

BThe respondent is to pay to the appellant the contingency and professional fees determined by Mr Harrison, the appellant’s quantity surveyor.

CThe decision of the High Court on the allowance for external works is confirmed.

DThe respondent is to pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and reasonable disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

EIn the absence of agreement, the question of costs in the High Court is to be decided by that Court.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Clifford J)

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Avonside Holdings Ltd (Avonside), owned a rental property at 1146 Avonside Drive, Avondale, Christchurch (the Property).  The Property was insured in November 2009 under a Premier Rental Property Cover policy (the Policy) issued by AMI Insurance Ltd (AMI).  AMI’s liability under the Policy has been assumed by the respondent, Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd (Southern Response). 

  2. As a result of the earthquakes of 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011, the Property was, the parties agreed, damaged beyond economic repair.  Following each of those events, the Earthquake Commission (EQC) paid Avonside the maximum amount payable under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993, being the sum of $115,000 (including GST), a total of $230,000.

  3. The land on which the Property stood was red-zoned in June 2011.  Avonside accepted the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority’s Option 2 and sold the land to the Crown, retaining its rights against Southern Response under the Policy.  Avonside elected under the Policy to buy another house.[1]  In those circumstances, the Policy provided that Southern Response would:

    … pay the cost of buying another house, including necessary legal and associated fees.  This cost must not be greater than rebuilding your rental house on its present site.

    [1]Given that the land was red-zoned, Avonside’s “election” was more apparent than real.  As we understand matters, rebuilding the Property at that address was not a practicable option.

  4. Southern Response’s liability is for the excess over the amount paid to Avonside by EQC.

  5. This is an appeal by Avonside against a decision of MacKenzie J in the High Court at Christchurch determining whether, and to what extent, an allowance for contingencies, the costs of professional fees and the cost of replacing external works should be included in the calculation of the cost of rebuilding the Property.[2]

Facts

  1. The material facts are not in dispute.  In addition to those set out above, it is sufficient for us to summarise the relevant terms of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Avonside Holdings Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Service... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 483
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Avonside Holdings Ltd appealed against a decision of the High Court regarding the calculation of the cost of rebuilding their rental property, which was damaged beyond economic repair by earthquakes. Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd, which had assumed the insurance liability of AMI Insurance Ltd, was the respondent. The appeal focused on three contested items: contingencies, professional fees, and external works. The Court of Appeal held that the allowance for contingencies and professional fees should be included in the calculation of the cost of rebuilding the property, as these costs would be incurred if the property were actually rebuilt on the same site. However, the Court upheld the High Court's decision on the allowance for external works, allowing for the repair rather than replacement of those works if it resulted in a lower cost. The appeal was allowed in part, and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellant for the contingency and professional fees, as well as costs for the appeal and reasonable disbursements. The question of costs in the High Court was to be decided by that Court in the absence of agreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

Avonside Holdings Ltd owned a rental property in Christchurch that was damaged beyond economic repair by earthquakes in 2010 and 2011. The property was insured under a rental property insurance policy issued by AMI Insurance Ltd, which had been assumed by Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd. The policy provided for the cost of buying another house if the property was damaged beyond economic repair, up to the limit of rebuilding the property on its present site. The land on which the property stood was red-zoned, making rebuilding at the same address not practicable. The dispute between Avonside and Southern Response concerns the interpretation of the policy terms regarding the cost of contingencies, professional fees, and external works in calculating the cost of buying another house.

The case was initially heard in the High Court at Christchurch, where MacKenzie J determined that there should be no allowance for contingencies, professional fees, or a full replacement cost for external works in the calculation of the cost of buying another house. Avonside appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 24 July 2014 by Stevens, Lang, and Clifford JJ, with the judgment delivered on 1 October 2014.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the calculation of the cost of buying another house should include an allowance for contingencies.
2. Whether the calculation of the cost of buying another house should include professional fees.
3. Whether the calculation of the cost of buying another house should include the full replacement cost for external works, or if repairing or reinstating those works to an "as new" condition is acceptable.

Held
1. The appeal is allowed in part.
2. The respondent is to pay to the appellant the contingency and professional fees determined by Mr Harrison, the appellant's quantity surveyor.
3. The decision of the High Court on the allowance for external works is confirmed.
4. The respondent is to pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and reasonable disbursements.
5. In the absence of agreement, the question of costs in the High Court is to be decided by that Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part, confirming some aspects of the High Court's decision while allowing others. On the issue of contingencies, the Court found that the insurer should include an allowance for contingencies in the calculation of the cost of rebuilding the property, as the hypothetical assessment of rebuilding costs should include all costs that would be incurred if the rebuilding were to actually occur, even though it was not going to happen. This aligns with the approach of preparing an estimate based on the actual costs that would be incurred in a real rebuild, which includes contingencies. Regarding professional fees, the Court agreed with the appellant's position that professional fees necessary for an actual rebuild should be included in the notional rebuild cost, even if the rebuild is hypothetical. This means that costs such as architectural and engineering fees, which would be incurred in an actual rebuilding process, should be factored into the notional rebuild cost. Finally, on the issue of external works, the Court upheld the High Court's decision that the insurer is not liable for the full replacement cost if the external works can be repaired or reinstated to an "as new" condition, as this aligns with the policy's provision that the cost of buying another house must not exceed the cost of rebuilding on the same site. This decision was based on the interpretation of the policy wording, which allows for the reuse of undamaged parts of the property, thereby reducing the cost of rebuilding. The Court's decision in this case established that in the calculation of the cost of buying another house under an insurance policy, the insurer must consider all costs that would be incurred in an actual rebuild, including contingencies and professional fees, even if the rebuild is hypothetical. Additionally, the insurer is not liable for the full replacement cost if repairing or reinstating certain parts of the property to an "as new" condition is more cost-effective. This decision provides clarity on the interpretation of insurance policy terms related to rebuilding costs in the context of a notional exercise.