Avonside Holdings Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-2536 [2013] NZHC 1433

BETWEEN AVONSIDE HOLDINGS LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 27-28 May 2013

Counsel

GDR Shand and AME Parlane for Plaintiff
C R Johnstone and S E Waggott for Defendant

Judgment:

11 July 2013

JUDGMENT OF MACKENZIE J

I direct that the delivery time of this judgment is

4 pm on the 11th day of July 2013.

.

Solicitors:           Grant Shand, Christchurch, for Plaintiff

Wynn Williams Lawyers, Christchurch, for Defendant

AVONSIDE HOLDINGS LTD v SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LTD [2013] NZHC 1433 [11 July 2013]

Background

[1]      The plaintiff (Avonside) is the owner of a property at 1146 Avonside Drive, Avondale, Christchurch.    The property suffered earthquake damage in the earthquakes of 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011.

[2]      The property was insured under a rental property policy issued by AMI Insurance Limited (AMI).  AMI’s liability under the policy has been assumed by the defendant (Southern Response).  The policy was first issued on 22 November 2009 and was renewed on 22 November 2010.  The two earthquakes were thus in different policy periods, but nothing turns on that.  The parties are agreed that the house is damaged beyond economic repair.   The plaintiff has chosen an option under the policy to buy another house.  The maximum amount to be paid by the insurer is the cost of rebuilding the house on its present site.

[3]      The parties have been unable to agree a figure for the cost of rebuilding the house on its present site.

[4]      Arrow International (NZ) Limited (Arrow), the project manager appointed by Southern Response for the assessment and management of all repair and rebuild projects of AMI insured houses, has calculated an estimated cost for rebuilding the house.   Ian Harrison and Associates Limited, quantity surveyors engaged by Avonside, have separately estimated the cost of rebuilding.  There are differences between their estimates.

[5]      I heard evidence from Mr Stewart Harrison of Ian Harrison and Associates for the plaintiff and from Mr Farrell of Arrow for the defendant.   In the course of hearing their evidence, as a panel, it became apparent to me that some of the differences between them would be difficult to resolve.  The different approaches which they had adopted to the preparation of their estimates meant that it was not possible to make a direct comparison between their figures.   I therefore adjourned the hearing overnight to give them an opportunity to prepare a scope of works on a common basis.  The purpose of that was to enable a direct comparison to be made between the two estimates so the monetary value of differences between them could be identified.  I record my gratitude to them for their efforts.

[6]      In conducting that exercise, Mr Farrell and Mr Harrison were able to resolve a number of issues, so that the scope of the dispute was narrowed.

The policy

[7]      The  policy  provides  replacement  cover  for  the  house  and  its  associated structures and works,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Avonside Holdings Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Service... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1433
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Avonside Holdings Limited (Avonside) sought damages from Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response) for earthquake damage to property at 1146 Avonside Drive, Avondale, Christchurch. The property was insured under a rental property policy issued by AMI Insurance Limited, which Southern Response had assumed liability for. The property was damaged beyond economic repair, and Avonside chose to buy another house. The parties could not agree on the cost of rebuilding the house on its present site, which was the maximum amount Southern Response was liable to pay. The High Court of New Zealand was required to determine the cost of rebuilding the house on the present site.

The court had to decide on the extent to which certain items should be included in the calculation of the cost of rebuilding the house on the present site. These items were: (a) builder’s margin, (b) contingency, (c) professional fees, (d) demolition costs, and (e) external works. The court found that a builder’s margin of 10 per cent calculated on the assessed cost, including preliminary and general items, should be allowed. No additional allowance for contingencies should be included in the calculation. Professional fees should be allowed in the sum estimated by the defendant, of $29,000. Demolition costs should not be included in the calculation as they were dealt with as a separate item under the policy. External works should be included in the calculation, but only the cost of replacing external works damaged beyond repair and the cost of repairing external works which are repairable and reusable.

The court held that the cost of rebuilding the house on its present site includes a builder’s margin of 10 per cent calculated on the assessed cost of rebuilding, which includes the preliminary and general expenses as agreed. It does not include any additional allowance for contingencies, any allowance for demolition costs, or an allowance for external works beyond $79,421.50. It includes an allowance of $29,000 for professional fees. The court reserved leave to the parties to apply for further directions in settling the terms of the judgment to be sealed. Costs were also reserved, and the parties could file memoranda if they were unable to agree.