Sneesby v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2021-009-1694

[2023] NZHC 246

BETWEEN

JOHN ARTHUR SNEESBY

Plaintiff

AND

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 31 January 2023

Appearances:

G Shand for Plaintiff and Mr Ressels (applicant to be joined) T Weston KC and K Paterson for Defendant

Judgment:

21 February 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


SNEESBY v SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED [2023] NZHC 246

[21 February 2023]

[1]                 Mr Ressels has applied to be joined as a further plaintiff in this proceeding in which Mr Sneesby is presently the only plaintiff. It is necessary to set out the nature of Mr Sneesby’s claim and its history in order to explain why Mr Ressels wants to join the proceeding.

[2]                 Mr Sneesby’s house was damaged in the Canterbury Earthquakes. He lodged a claim with The Earthquake Commission (EQC) which assessed the damage to his house and organised the necessary repairs. EQC does not repair damage to driveways, fences, patios, paving and swimming pools. Damage to such items is known as Out of Scope Items (OOS).

[3]                 Mr Sneesby had cover for OOS with his insurer, AMI Insurance Limited (AMI), now Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response).

[4]                 Mr Sneesby’s OOS claim with AMI was accepted. AMI instructed Arrow International (Arrow) to assess the cost of repairing those items with that assessment completed in mid-2014. Arrow’s ‘Scope of Works’ recorded it would cost $29,588.70 to remediate the OOS. Mr Sneesby accepted a cash settlement at that figure.

[5]                 On 22 July 2021, Mr Sneesby issued proceedings in the District Court against Southern Response, alleging that the Scope of Works upon which he decided to settle was misleading because it made no express allowance for Preliminary and General (P&G), contingency or professional/design fees. Mr Sneesby alleges previous decisions have determined that a 10 per cent allowance for each item is required.1  Mr Sneesby says Southern Response misled him into settling by presenting a Scope of Works it knew did not make provision for the above allowances.2

[6]                 Mr Sneesby says that if 10 per cent were added for each of the three allowances above, he was short paid in 2014 by $9,793.86 and he seeks judgment for that amount plus interest.


1      Avonside Holdings Ltd v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd [2014] NZCA 483; Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd v Avonside Holdings Ltd [2015] NZSC 110, [2017] 1 NZLR 141.

2      Mr Sneesby relies on Dodds v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd [2019] NZHC 2016, [2019] 3 NZLR 826 which was upheld on appeal in part in Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd v Dodds [2020] NZCA 395, [2020] 3 NZLR 383.

[7]                 Mr Sneesby applied for leave to bring his claim as a representative on behalf of 7,500 to 9,500 other homeowners who are potentially in the same position as he is,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sneesby v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the plaintiff John Sneesby, represented by G Shand, sought to join the proceeding as an additional plaintiff in his existing case against Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited. The case arose from the Canterbury earthquakes, where Southern Response was alleged to have misled Sneesby regarding the allowances for preliminary and general costs, contingency, and professional design fees when assessing the damage to his out-of-scope items. Sneesby sought a cash settlement adjustment and representation on behalf of other homeowners in similar situations. The court dismissed Sneesby's application to sue as a representative, but Mr. Ressels applied to join the proceeding as a second plaintiff. The court held that Mr. Ressels' application was governed by r 4.56 of the High Court Rules 2016, and not by r 4.2. The court found that Mr. Ressels did not meet the requirements of r 4.56(1)(b) and dismissed the application, noting that joinder was not permissible based on the desirability and merits of the proposed representative action. The court further held that Mr. Ressels' alternative submission, based on rr 1.2 and 1.6 of the Rules, did not address the jurisdictional issues and was not a means of expanding the scope of joinder permitted by r 4.56. Accordingly, the court dismissed Mr. Ressels' application and ordered costs to follow the event on a 2B basis, together with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.

The court's decision was based on the specific requirements of r 4.56 of the High Court Rules 2016, which govern the joinder of parties in proceedings. The court found that Mr. Ressels did not meet the criteria for joinder under r 4.56(1)(b), as his presence was not necessary to adjudicate on and settle all questions involved in the proceeding. The court also rejected Mr. Ressels' alternative submission, which sought to rely on rr 1.2 and 1.6 of the Rules to justify joinder. The court held that such an approach would render r 4.56 redundant and was not consistent with the consistent application of the Rules. The court's decision highlights the importance of adhering to the specific procedural rules governing joinder in proceedings and the need for parties to demonstrate that their presence is necessary for the complete and effectual adjudication of the issues in the case.