Brooker v IAG New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2018-409-000349

[2019] NZHC 1225

BETWEEN

TONI JOANNE BROOKER

Plaintiff

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

HAH LIMITED (in liq) (previously Holloway Builders Limited) Second Defendant

AND

CRESCO ENGINEERS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

First Third Party

AND

CORNWALL CIVIL ENGINEERING LIMITED

Second Third Party

Hearing: 15 May 2019

Appearances:

P M Smith for First Defendant (Applicant) D J Ballantyne for Plaintiff (Respondent)

D H McLellan QC and S D Galloway for QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (in opposition)

Appearances of third parties (abiding) excused

Judgment:

31 May 2019


JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J

(on joinder application)


Introduction

[1]    The plaintiff, Toni Brooker, insured her home in Wainoni, Christchurch, with the first defendant, IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG). The home suffered significant

BROOKER v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2019] NZHC 1225 [31 May 2019]

damage in the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence. IAG accepted Ms Brooker’s claim under her policy, which required repair or rebuilding (as the case may be to an “as new” standard).

[2]    Pursuant to arrangements with IAG, Ms Brooker in 2014 entered into a contract with the second defendant, Holloway Builders Ltd (now in liquidation) (Holloway) for the repair works.

[3]    Holloway provided a Notice of Practical Completion in February 2016 but Ms Brooker had a number of issues concerning the work carried out by Holloway. In relation to some of those issues (painting issues) IAG paid Ms Brooker $119,041.81 in December 2016.

[4]    In 2017, Ms Brooker obtained a building report containing findings as to issues with the house in the interior (11 issues), exterior (five issues) and other (five) issues.

[5]    Following an exchange between respective solicitors, IAG denied it had any further liability and stated that if further work was required to rectify any defective work, Ms Brooker’s policy would not respond to those costs.

[6]    Ms Brooker also made demand of Holloway in relation to the issues identified in the building report. Holloway denied that there was any poor workmanship or that it had any responsibility for the issues.

[7]    By her statement of claim (which remains in its form as filed) Ms Brooker sues IAG for breach of contract, asserting that she is entitled to have IAG pay the sum required to repair the home to its condition as new or alternatively a declaration that IAG must perform its obligations under the policy and repair the home to an acceptable standard in accordance with the policy. Secondly, Ms Brooker sued Holloway for breach of contract, claiming the amount determined to repair the damage attributed to Holloway’s poor workmanship.

[8]    Upon service of the proceeding, Holloway joined as third parties Cresco Engineers New Zealand Ltd (Cresco), which had been engaged by Holloway to

provide engineering services in relation to the house and Cornwall Civil Engineering Ltd (Cornwall) which had provided certification that Holloway’s work had been completed in accordance with the relevant requirements of the building consent.

[9]The third parties…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brooker v IAG New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1225
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Brooker v IAG New Zealand Ltd, the High Court of New Zealand dismissed an application by IAG New Zealand Ltd for leave to join QBE Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd as a defendant in an insurance claim proceeding. Toni Brooker, the plaintiff, had insured her home with IAG. The home suffered significant damage in the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence, and IAG accepted the claim under the policy. Brooker sued IAG for breach of contract, alleging that IAG had not repaired her home to an “as new” standard as required by the policy. IAG sought to join QBE as a defendant to pursue a claim for subrogation against QBE based on a policy it held with QBE for Hawkins Management Ltd, which had project-managed the repair work. QBE opposed the application, and Brooker, who did not wish to pursue a claim against QBE, also opposed the application.

The Court found that IAG had not established jurisdiction to order joinder under r 4.56(1)(b) of the High Court Rules. The Court determined that QBE's presence was not necessary to adjudicate on or settle all questions involved in the proceeding, as Brooker's claim against IAG was for breach of an insurance contract, not defective repairs. The Court also found that the discretion not to require Brooker to sue QBE was strongly in her favour. The Court emphasised the complexity of the subrogation rights and the potential prejudice to Brooker in having to mount a claim against QBE, including the significant costs and delay involved. The Court dismissed the application for joinder but granted leave for IAG to join QBE as a third party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established