McLean v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV 2012-409-002284 [2013] NZHC 1105

BETWEEN  BRUCE DAVID MCLEAN, CHRISTINE LESLEY MCKEOWN AND PAUL LINDSAY BUTLER

Plaintiffs

ANDIAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         13 May 2013

Counsel:         A Hooker for Plaintiffs

C J Hlavac and D Weatherley for Defendant

Judgment:      16 May 2013

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

Introduction

[1]      I have been asked to resolve on the following issue:

Whether IAG’s obligations under the applicable policy wording to pay the “present value” of the home, includes an obligation to pay “professional” costs such as architects, engineers, surveyors, building consultants, legal and council fees.

Facts

[2]      Helpfully the parties have agreed the key facts:

(a)       The plaintiff trust owns a property at 9 Bradnor Road, Christchurch. (b)       The property is insured under NZI’s Brokerweb Group Home Policy

which is underwritten by the defendant.

(c)       The  property  suffered  significant  damage  as  a  result  of  the

Christchurch earthquakes.

MCLEAN, MCKEOWN AND BUTLER V IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED HC CHCH CIV 2012-409-002284 [16 May 2013]

(d)       The property damage suffered during the earthquakes is covered under the policy.

(e)       It is not economic to repair the property.

(f)       The plaintiffs do not wish to rebuild the property, either at its current location or at an alternative site.

(g)       The only basis on which the plaintiffs are entitled to a cash payment

under the policy is on a “present value” basis.

The contract

[3]      This proceeding concerns the following provision of the NZI/Broker Web

Group Home Policy:

SETTLEMENT OF YOUR LOSS

If you repair or rebuild the home, following a loss covered by this Home

Policy, we will pay:

1.the cost of repairing or rebuilding the home to a condition as similar as possible to when it was new, using current materials and methods, and

2.any cost of compliance with Government or local authority bylaws or regulations, provided that:

(a)      we pay the cost of compliance for only that part of the home

that has suffered loss covered by this policy, and

(b)      the home complied with all requirements that existed at the time it was originally built and at the time of any alteration.

However, we do not pay if notice of non-compliance has already been given to you before the loss.

3.        the following costs that are necessarily and reasonably incurred:

(a)      architects’,  engineers’,  surveyors’,  building  consultants’,

legal and council fees, and

(b)      costs of demolition and of removing debris and contents.

If you do not repair or rebuild the home, we will pay the present value of the home.

If the schedule shows an amount as the sum insured, then the most we will pay for any loss caused by an event, inclusive of fees and other costs, is the sum insured.

ALTERNATIVE SITE

If the home is totally destroyed and we agree, you may:

1.        rebuild the home at a different site, or

2.        purchase another home at a different site,

however, we will not pay more than…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McLean v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McLean v IAG New Zealand Limited involved a dispute over the interpretation of insurance policy wording concerning the payment of "present value" of a damaged home. The plaintiffs, Bruce David McLean, Christine Lesley McKeown, and Paul Lindsay Butler, sought to determine whether the defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited, was obligated to pay for professional costs such as architects', engineers', surveyors', building consultants', legal, and council fees as part of the "present value" payment. The plaintiffs' property, located at 9 Bradnor Road, Christchurch, was severely damaged due to the Christchurch earthquakes and was not economically repairable. The insurance policy in question was an NZI/Broker Web Group Home Policy, which covered the loss but required a cash payment on a "present value" basis since the plaintiffs chose not to rebuild.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the term "present value" under the insurance policy included professional fees necessary for the replacement of the home. The plaintiffs argued that the term should be interpreted to include all reasonable costs associated with replacing the home, including professional fees, as they logically form part of the cost of replacement. The defendant countered that the policy indemnified the insured for physical loss and that unless expressly stated, the insured is not entitled to make a profit from the insurance. They argued that professional fees were an added benefit for rebuilding and should not be included in the "present value" payment if the home is not rebuilt.

The court, after considering the policy wording and the context in which the contract was made, concluded that the "present value" of the home did indeed include reasonable costs to replace it, which necessarily involved professional fees. The court found that the inclusion of compliance and professional fees in the settlement clause indicated that the parties intended "loss" to include professional fees reasonably and necessarily incurred to remedy it. The court rejected the defendant's concerns about the hypothetical quantification of costs and the potential windfall to the insured, stating that the inclusion of professional fees in the "present value" payment was not superfluous and aligned with the indemnification principle, provided these fees were necessary for replacement.

The court did not make a final determination on the residual issue of whether costs of professional services already incurred should be discounted if they could be reused, as this matter was not thoroughly argued and did not affect the resolution of the preliminary question. The court suggested that only additional costs necessary to achieve replacement should be properly claimable to better accord with the indemnification principle. The final outcome was that IAG New Zealand Limited was obligated to pay professional costs as part of the "present value" payment for the damaged home.