Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-1332 [2015] NZHC 1427

BETWEEN

DAVID JOHN JARDEN AND JOANNE

JARDEN Plaintiffs

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 23-27 February and 10 March 2015

Counsel:

A J D Ferguson with J S Morriss for Plaintiffs
P J L Hunt with K J Rowe for Second Defendant

Judgment:

23 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS

Background  [3] The house the Jardens built  [3] Two earthquakes  [6] A site visit  [8] The policy of insurance  [12] EQC settles  [19] What the Jardens want  [22]

Issues  [27]

Issue 1: What natural disaster damage to the home (as defined in the

Lumley Policy) or residential building (as defined in the EQC Act) was

caused by the earthquakes on 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011?    [28]

The slab floor  [30] The external brick veneer walls  [55] The internal walls  [61] The roof and ceiling  [93] Other fittings and the garage  [103] Declarations  [107]

Issue 2: How should the natural disaster damage be apportioned to each earthquake?  [108] Issue 3: What reinstatement work is required to restore the

home/residential building to the standard required by the written policy

JARDEN & ANOR v LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED [2015] NZHC 1427 [23 June 2015]

of insurance by which the second defendant insured the plaintiffs?          [114] Brick exterior walls (house and garage)  [116] Lounge floor  [119] Lounge doors and windows  [120] Interior linings cracked and detached  [121]

Issue 4: What is the cost to repair the natural disaster damage or

alternatively rebuild the property if repair is not economic?  [122]

Issue 5: Is the second defendant in breach of any of its obligations to the plaintiffs?  [127] Issue 6: What relief (if any) are the plaintiffs entitled to from the second defendant?        [130] Issue 7: What is the effect of the EQC settlement?  [133] Result  [137]

[1]      The Jardens’ house was damaged in the 4 September 2010 and 22 February

2011 Canterbury earthquakes.  There is no doubt about that.  But their insurer says much of what the Jardens claim for is pre-existing damage, or just not damage at all.

[2]      The overriding issue in this case is what evidential standard policy holders must meet to prove an insured loss.

Background

The house the Jardens built

[3]      The Jardens live in a lifestyle property just north of Rolleston.  They built their house in 1998.  A labour-only builder was engaged and Mr Jarden, a former police officer, worked on the site as the “gopher”.  Mrs Jarden project-managed.

[4]      The house is 228m2 in area,1 built on a concrete slab foundation.  It has brick veneer cladding and a corrugated steel roof, in each case over a timber frame.  The form of construction is relatively conventional.  But there are some features of the house built to a higher than average specification.  The brick veneer cladding uses recycled  bricks  from  the  former  Rolleston  prison.    Their  replacement  now  is

difficult.  The family room is octagonal with a pitched chapel ceiling.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1427
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Jardens’ house was damaged in the Canterbury earthquakes of September 2010 and February 2011. The parties disputed the extent of the damage and its cause, and whether the damage was covered by the Jardens’ insurance policy with Lumley. The Jardens sought to establish that the damage was caused by the earthquakes and that Lumley was liable to pay for the repair costs in excess of the Earthquake Commission’s (EQC) liability. The Jardens also sought declarations to that effect. Lumley denied liability. The High Court was required to determine the extent of the damage caused by the earthquakes and whether it was covered by the policy. The court also had to consider the apportionment of damage between the two earthquake events, the reinstatement work required to restore the house and garage to policy standards, the cost of the reinstatement work, whether Lumley was in breach of its obligations, and the effect of the EQC settlement. The court found that the damage to the external brick veneer walls, the interior linings, the lounge floor, the lounge doors and windows, and the garage’s external brick veneer walls was caused by the earthquakes. The court rejected the Jardens’ claims that the damage to the concrete slab floor, the internal walls, and the roof and ceiling were caused by the earthquakes. The court found that the damage was apportioned 90 per cent to the September 2010 earthquake and 10 per cent to the February 2011 earthquake. The court found that the reinstatement work required to restore the house and garage to policy standards included removing the bricks to the extent required to ensure that the walls were correctly tied to the timber framing, replacing the lounge floor, fixing the lounge doors and windows, and raking, plastering, and repainting the cracked linings. The court found that Lumley was not in breach of its obligations under the policy because the Jardens had not incurred repair costs that exceeded EQC’s liability. The court made declarations to the effect that the Jardens’ house and garage were damaged by the earthquakes, that the damage was apportioned between the two earthquake events, that the reinstatement work required to restore the house and garage to policy standards was as set out in the judgment, and that Lumley was liable to pay the Jardens for those repairs once costs had been incurred and to the extent they exceeded EQC’s payment. The court reserved leave to apply for further directions and reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established