Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-001332 [2016] NZHC 2820

BETWEEN

DAVID JOHN JARDEN AND JOANNE

JARDEN Plaintiffs

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (N.Z.) LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 24 November 2016 (Determined on the papers)

Appearances:

A Ferguson and J Moss for Plaintiffs
P J L Hunt and K J Rowe for Defendant

Judgment:

24 November 2016

COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      On 23 June 2015 the High Court issued a judgment on Mr and Mrs Jarden’s claim  against  their  insurer,  Lumley General  Insurance  (N.Z.)  Limited  (Lumley) arising out of damage to their home caused by earthquakes on 4 September 2010 and

22 February 2011.1     Mr and Mrs Jarden appealed the judgment to the Court of

Appeal.  That Court upheld the judgment of the High Court in all respects save one, relating to a breakdown of the sum received by Mr and Mrs Jarden from EQC on which the Court of Appeal had admitted further evidence.2

[2]      Mr and Mrs Jarden seek an award of costs against Lumley.  Lumley, in turn, seeks an award of costs against Mr and Mrs Jarden.  No costs issues arise in relation to the former second defendant, EQC, with which Mr and Mrs Jarden have settled,

receiving their statutory entitlement together with $55,313 for costs.

1      Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd [2015] NZHC 1427, [2015] 18 ANZ Insurance

Cases 62-077 [High Court judgment].

2      Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd [2016] NZCA 193 [Court of Appeal judgment].

JARDEN v LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (N.Z.) LIMITED Costs Judgment [2016] NZHC 2820 [24 November 2016]

Summary of the plaintiffs’ position

[3]      In the judgment in this Court the High Court Judge analysed the elements of damage to Mr and Mrs Jarden’s house and made findings of liability in respect of each.  Mr and Mrs Jarden say that they were successful in relation to replacement of the exterior brick cladding which Lumley proposed to repair, remediating cracks to the concrete floor, replacing floor coverings over cracks, and replacing the formal living room timber floor.  They say they also succeeded in persuading the Court to require that a 10 per cent contingency sum should be allowed for in the costings for the work to be undertaken, when those costings are carried out.

[4]      Given this measure of success, as they see it, Mr and Mrs Jarden argue that it is they who have succeeded in this proceeding and, on the principle that costs should follow the event, it is Lumley which should pay costs.  They say that costs should be assessed on the basis of Category 2 Band B.

[5]      Mr and Mrs Jarden rely on a number of established principles in support of their position.   They say a commonsense approach should be taken in relation to which party has succeeded, whether in whole or in part,3 that whilst success may be reflected in a complete win, it may also be achieved when, viewed overall, one party has substantially…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2820
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd, the plaintiffs, David John Jarden and Joanne Jarden, sought an award of costs against the defendant, Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited, after their appeal against the original judgment was dismissed. The plaintiffs argued that they were successful in several aspects of their claim, such as the replacement of exterior brick cladding, remediating cracks to the concrete floor, replacing floor coverings over cracks, and replacing the formal living room timber floor. They also claimed that the court should have allowed for a 10 per cent contingency sum in the costings for the work to be undertaken. Lumley, on the other hand, argued that the plaintiffs achieved very limited success, and their claim was rejected on key elements.

The court found that the only issue on which the plaintiffs succeeded at trial was in relation to damage to the lounge floor. However, when the claim and its outcome were viewed as a whole, the court found that the plaintiffs were not the successful party in this case. The court held that the plaintiffs did not substantially succeed, and they have lost on by far the greater part of the claim that they brought. Therefore, Lumley was entitled to costs against the plaintiffs.

Lumley sought an increase in costs, pursuant to r 14.6 of the High Court Rules. The court found that the plaintiffs pursued arguments that lacked merit and acted frivolously in continuing this case. The grounds for an uplift of costs under r14.6 were made out, and the percentage uplift sought by Lumley was appropriate in the court's opinion.

The final outcome was that the plaintiffs would pay to Lumley costs on a 2B basis, plus 25 per cent, together with disbursements which are approved in accordance with the schedule submitted by counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established