Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA663/2016 
[2018] NZCA 6

BETWEEN

DAVID JOHN JARDEN AND     JOANNE JARDEN
Appellants

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

6 November 2017

Court:

Gilbert, Lang and Ellis JJ

Counsel:

N R Campbell QC and J Moss for Appellants
P J L Hunt and K J Rowe for Respondent

Judgment:

7 February 2018 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

B        The appellants must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on           a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

Introduction

  1. Mr and Mrs Jarden’s house at Rolleston, near Christchurch, suffered damage in the major earthquakes that occurred on 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011.  They claimed the damage caused by these earthquakes was so extensive that their house needed to be demolished and rebuilt.  The Earthquake Commission (EQC) considered that the house was repairable, as did Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd (Lumley) which had provided “top-up” insurance cover.  To resolve this impasse, the Jardens sued EQC and Lumley for the costs of demolishing and rebuilding the house (then estimated to be $1,080,488) and general damages of $50,000 against each for the “substantial distress, inconvenience and mental anguish” caused by the alleged breach of their respective insurance obligations.  They also claimed from Lumley the sum of $1,000 being a stress benefit payable under the policy in the event that the house was a total loss.   

  2. Shortly prior to the trial, EQC settled with the Jardens so the claim proceeded only against Lumley.  In their second amended statement of claim, filed on the second day of the trial, the Jardens maintained that it would be uneconomic to repair the house and it needed to be rebuilt.  They claimed that Lumley had “refused to meet its obligations under the policy by failing to settle the claim by agreeing to pay” the costs required to rebuild the house.  They sought judgment against Lumley for the estimated rebuild costs of $918,579 (taking into account the amount paid by EQC), the $1,000 stress benefit and $50,000 as general damages to compensate for Lumley’s allegedly wrongful conduct.  

  3. After a six-day trial, Kós J found that Lumley had not breached its obligations under its policy and was not liable to the Jardens in damages.[1]  The Judge considered that the Jardens’ claim was misconceived.  The Judge made what he described as “a limited declaration” (not in the terms sought by the Jardens in their prayer for relief) as to what damage had been sustained in the earthquakes, the repairs required to remediate that damage and how the repair costs should be apportioned between the two earthquake events.[2]  The Judge stated that Lumley “cannot be criticised for resisting the Jardens’ claim” which he found “in large measure could not be sustained on the evidence”.[3] 

    [1]Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd [2015] NZHC 1427, [2015] 18 ANZ Insurance Cases 62-077 [High Court judgment] at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appellants, Mr. and Mrs. Jarden, sought to appeal against the costs judgment in the High Court. The Jardens’ house had suffered damage due to earthquakes in 2010 and 2011, and they sought compensation from Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd for the costs of demolishing and rebuilding the house, along with general damages. The High Court found that Lumley had not breached its obligations under the insurance policy and dismissed the Jardens' claims. The Jardens appealed against the judgment, but their appeal was dismissed, save for a minor issue relating to the costs component of the settlement sum paid by the Earthquake Commission.

In the current appeal, the Jardens argued that the Associate Judge erred in finding that Lumley was the successful party overall, in awarding an uplift in costs to Lumley, and by not reducing any costs awarded to Lumley to reflect its failure on issues that significantly increased the Jardens' costs. The Court of Appeal considered these arguments and concluded that Lumley should be regarded as the successful party overall. The Jardens' claims for damages and declarations against Lumley failed completely. The Court also found that the Associate Judge was justified in awarding a 25-per-cent uplift on scale costs, as the Jardens pursued their claims without proper justification and failed to provide evidence to support their claims. Finally, the Court of Appeal disagreed with the Jardens' argument that the costs awarded to Lumley should be reduced and concluded that there was no justification for reducing the costs to which Lumley was otherwise entitled.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs for the standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Jardens' house in Rolleston, near Christchurch, suffered damage during the earthquakes on 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011. The Jardens claimed the damage was so extensive that their house needed to be demolished and rebuilt. The Earthquake Commission (EQC) and Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd (Lumley), which provided "top-up" insurance cover, considered that the house was repairable. To resolve this impasse, the Jardens sued EQC and Lumley for the costs of demolishing and rebuilding the house and for general damages for the distress caused by the alleged breach of their respective insurance obligations. Shortly before the trial, EQC settled with the Jardens, so the claim proceeded only against Lumley. The Jardens maintained that it would be uneconomic to repair the house and it needed to be rebuilt. They claimed that Lumley had refused to meet its obligations under the policy by failing to settle the claim by agreeing to pay the costs required to rebuild the house. They sought judgment against Lumley for the estimated rebuild costs of $918,579 (taking into account the amount paid by EQC), the $1,000 stress benefit and $50,000 as general damages to compensate for Lumley's allegedly wrongful conduct.

The case was initially heard in the High Court, where Kós J found that Lumley had not breached its obligations under its policy and was not liable to the Jardens in damages. The Jardens appealed against Kós J’s judgment, but the appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal directed that costs in the High Court should be fixed by that Court. Costs in the High Court were then determined by Associate Judge Matthews, who found that Lumley was successful overall and should receive costs calculated on a 2B basis with a 25-per-cent uplift and approved disbursements. The Jardens now appeal against the costs judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Associate Judge err in finding that Lumley was the successful party overall?
2. Was the uplift in costs to Lumley justified?
3. Should there be a reduction in the costs awarded to Lumley to reflect its failure on issues that significantly increased the Jardens’ costs?

Held
1. The Associate Judge did not err in finding that Lumley was the successful party overall. The Court upheld the Associate Judge's decision that Lumley was successful in defending the Jardens' claim and thus entitled to an award of costs.
2. The Court found that the uplift in costs to Lumley was justified. The Court upheld the Associate Judge's decision to award a 25-per-cent uplift on scale costs, considering the Jardens' pursuit of arguments that lacked merit and their failure to comply with court directions unnecessarily increased the costs.
3. The Court determined that there should be no reduction in the costs awarded to Lumley. The Court found that Lumley was entitled to costs as it successfully defended the Jardens' claim and that the Jardens' limited success on some issues did not warrant a reduction in the costs awarded to Lumley.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal addressed the appeal by the Jardens against the costs judgment in the High Court, focusing on three main issues: whether the Associate Judge erred in finding Lumley to be the successful party overall, the justification for the uplift in costs awarded to Lumley, and whether the costs awarded to Lumley should be reduced to reflect the Jardens' failure on certain issues. The Court found that Lumley was the successful party overall as the Jardens did not succeed in establishing their sole cause of action against Lumley or obtain any of the relief they sought. The Court upheld the Associate Judge's decision to award a 25-per-cent uplift in costs to Lumley, considering the Jardens' pursuit of arguments that lacked merit and their failure to comply with court directions unnecessarily increased the costs. The Court concluded that there was no justification for reducing the costs awarded to Lumley, as Lumley successfully defended the Jardens' claim and the Jardens' limited success on some issues did not warrant a reduction in the costs awarded to Lumley. The Court's decision was based on the principle that costs should follow the event, and the Jardens' failure to establish their claim did not entitle them to a reduction in the costs awarded to Lumley. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a party successfully defends a claim brought against it, they are entitled to an award of costs, and an uplift in costs may be justified if the opposing party pursued arguments that lacked merit or failed to comply with court directions.