Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA401/2015
[2016] NZCA 193

BETWEEN

DAVID JOHN JARDEN AND JOANNE JARDEN
Appellants

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

21 April 2016

Court:

Randerson, Stevens and Wild JJ

Counsel:

K M Quinn for Appellants
P J L Hunt and K J Rowe for Respondent

Judgment:

11 May 2016 at 3:00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application by the appellants to adduce further evidence on appeal is granted.

B      The appeal is allowed in part. 

CThe judgment in the High Court is set aside only to the extent that it determined that the amount paid to the appellants by the Earthquake Commission for cover under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 was $179,163.  The correct figure was $123,850.

DThe appeal is otherwise dismissed.

E      There is no order for costs on the application to adduce further evidence. 

FThe appellants must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

GIf costs in the High Court cannot be agreed, they are to be fixed by that Court.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Randerson J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
The terms of the Lumley policy
The EQ cover issues

What was the amount of cover actually provided by EQC for earthquake damage?
Under what circumstances does Lumley’s liability for top-up cover arise?

Was the Judge wrong to reject the Jardens’ claim that specific items of damage were natural disaster damage within the meaning of the Lumley policy?

Damage caused by leaks from the roof of the house and garage
Internal walls of the house being out of plumb
Voids
Windows and doors jamming and out of square
Damage to the garage

Result
Formal orders

[1]
[6]
[12]

[13]

[17]

[29]

[33]
[53]
[65]
[71]
[73]
[76]
[77]

Introduction

  1. The appellants Mr and Mrs Jarden live on a lifestyle property just north of Rolleston.  They built their house in 1998 but it suffered damage in the major Christchurch earthquakes on 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011.  Mr and Mrs Jarden had a residential insurance policy with the respondent (Lumley).  This provided top-up cover for natural disaster damage in excess of the cover provided under ss 18 and 20 of the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (defined in the policy as EQ Cover). 

  2. Despite numerous expert reports since the earthquakes, the claims brought by the Jardens for the damage suffered were not resolved.  They issued proceedings in the High Court against the Earthquake Commission (EQC) and Lumley.  Shortly before the hearing in the High Court, the Jardens reached a settlement with EQC, the terms of which we discuss below.  The Jardens’ claim therefore proceeded solely against Lumley.  After a hearing occupying some six days, Kós J made declarations to the following effect:[1]

    (a)The Jardens’ house and garage were damaged in the September 2010 and February 2011 earthquake events in some but not all of the respects claimed.[2]

    (b)The damage was to be apportioned as between…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarden v Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

- **Parties, Dispute, and Court:**
The appeal was brought by David John Jarden and Joanne Jarden, the appellants, against Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited, the respondent. The dispute arose from claims for damages caused by earthquakes in Christchurch on 4 September 2010 and 22 February 2011. The High Court of New Zealand initially ruled in favour of the respondent, and the case was appealed to the New Zealand Court of Appeal.

- **Legal Issues and Court's Reasoning:**
The key issues were the determination of the actual amount of cover provided by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) for earthquake damage and the circumstances under which Lumley’s liability for top-up cover arises. The appellants argued that Lumley's liability should commence as soon as the total cost of repairs for natural disaster damage exceeds $123,850. However, the Court of Appeal held that Lumley's liability is contingent upon the actual statutory liability of EQC under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993, not the settlement amount with EQC. The Court found that the EQC had paid $123,850 for earthquake damage, not $179,163 as the High Court had determined.

- **Outcome and Orders:**
The appeal was partially allowed. The Court of Appeal set aside the High Court's determination that the amount paid to the appellants by EQC was $179,163, correcting it to $123,850. However, the appeal was otherwise dismissed. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs for a standard appeal, with usual disbursements. If costs in the High Court could not be agreed upon, they were to be fixed by that Court.

- **Final Orders:**
The application by the appellants to adduce further evidence on appeal was granted. The judgment in the High Court was set aside only to the extent that it determined that the amount paid to the appellants by EQC was $179,163, which was corrected to $123,850. The appeal was otherwise dismissed. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements. If costs in the High Court could not be agreed upon, they were to be fixed by that Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants, Mr. and Mrs. Jarden, own a lifestyle property in Rolleston, New Zealand, which sustained damage in the Christchurch earthquakes of September 2010 and February 2011. They had a residential insurance policy with Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited, which provided top-up cover for natural disaster damage beyond the cover under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (EQC cover). The Jardens claimed that their house and garage were damaged in ways that they attributed to the earthquakes, and they sought compensation from both EQC and Lumley. Before the trial, the Jardens reached a settlement with EQC for $179,163. The subsequent High Court proceedings against Lumley only proceeded to determine the extent of Lumley's liability for any costs exceeding the EQC settlement. The High Court found that some of the Jardens' claims for damage were substantiated but set the EQC cover at $179,163. The Jardens appealed this decision, arguing for a different interpretation of the EQC cover amount and claiming specific items of damage were due to the earthquakes.

The case originated in the High Court where the Jardens brought proceedings against both EQC and Lumley. Before the hearing, the Jardens settled with EQC. The High Court then determined that some of the damage claimed by the Jardens was due to the earthquakes, but it set the EQC cover amount at $179,163. The Jardens appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand against Lumley, challenging the amount of EQC cover and the High Court's rejection of certain claims of earthquake damage. The Court of Appeal allowed the Jardens to adduce further evidence on appeal and heard the case on 21 April 2016. Judgment was delivered on 11 May 2016.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What was the amount of cover actually provided by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) for earthquake damage?
2. Under what circumstances does Lumley's liability for top-up cover arise?
3. Was the Judge wrong to reject the Jardens' claim that specific items of damage were natural disaster damage within the meaning of the Lumley policy?

Held
1. The amount of cover actually provided by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) for earthquake damage was $123,850, not $179,163 as previously determined by the High Court.
2. Lumley's liability for top-up cover arises once the Earthquake Commission has paid or agreed to pay the EQ Cover, and it is the difference between the EQ Cover and the cover under the Lumley policy, subject to certain conditions.
3. The Judge was not wrong to reject the Jardens' claim that specific items of damage were natural disaster damage within the meaning of the Lumley policy. The Court upheld the Judge's findings regarding the leaks from the roof, internal walls being out of plumb, voids beneath the concrete slab, windows and doors jamming, and damage to the garage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal allowed the application to adduce further evidence, which revealed that the amount paid by EQC to the Jardens was $123,850 for earthquake damage, with an additional $55,313 paid to the Jardens' solicitors for legal costs. The Court found that Lumley's liability for top-up cover arises when EQC has paid or agreed to pay the EQ Cover, and it is the difference between the EQ Cover and the cover under the Lumley policy, subject to certain conditions. The Court held that the obligation on EQC under s 18 of the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 is to provide insurance against natural disaster damage for the replacement value of residential buildings up to the maximum sum of $100,000 (exclusive of GST). The Court concluded that the Jardens failed to prove that the specific items of damage they claimed were caused by the earthquakes. The expert evidence called by Lumley was convincing and was not effectively countered by the Jardens. Therefore, the Judge's conclusion on these points was upheld. The outcome is that the High Court judgment is upheld in all respects other than the finding about the amount the Earthquake Commission paid to the appellant for cover under the EQA.