Kristinsson v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2016-409-000318 [2017] NZHC 456

BETWEEN

HUGO KRISTINSSON

Plaintiff

AND

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED First Defendant

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION Second Defendant

Hearing: 8 March 2017

Appearances:

ACC Hooker and M Hills for Plaintiff
RD Cuff for First Defendant
N J Bruce-Smith for Second Defendant

Judgment:

16 March 2017

RULING OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

(In Relation To Expertsʼ Conference)

[1]      An issue has arisen as to which experts should be involved in a joint review and joint reporting process which the Court directed take place in relation to this case in the Earthquake List.

The directions previously made

[2]      The Court in November 2016 made directions by consent that:

(a)       The defendants were to advise the plaintiff if they agreed or disagreed

with the [plaintiff’s] engineers’ reports by 25 November 2016.

KRISTINSSON v SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED [2017] NZHC 456 [16

March 2017]

(b)If the defendants disagreed with the plaintiff’s reports they would provide their own expert report(s) identifying the natural disaster damage and appropriate repair methodology by 16 December 2016.

(c)      The parties’ experts were to carry out a joint review at the site to identify areas of agreement and disagreement as to the natural disaster damage to the residential building and the appropriate repair strategy by 22 December 2016.

(d)Following the joint review, the parties’ experts were to file a joint report or, if that was not feasible,  separate reports identifying the earthquake damage  to  the residential  building  and  the  appropriate repair strategy for the earthquake damage, including identifying (if possible) the areas of agreement and disagreement by 27 February

2017.

[3]      In requesting those directions, counsel had identified the respective positions of the parties by reference to expert evidence each had obtained.

Plaintiff’s evidence

[4]      The plaintiff ’s evidence was summarised in the following paragraphs of the

joint memorandum:

20.Structura  has  identified  prominent  damage,  settlement/tilt  of  the garage and house, frame racking, lateral spread/liquefaction up to

1.5 metre indicating that it is flood prone.

21.In order to repair the house, new foundations are recommended as the repair methodologies have potential for future damage due to residual tension caused by lateral stretch.

22.Structura recommends that the exterior cladding of the house be removed, and the house be lifted to another site, ground floor structural framing may require structural repair or to be discarded due to the lateral stretch; new foundation be constructed; return the house to site; remove internal linings, bring house to level, plumb, square, fix to foundation and reline internally; house be positioned so first floor is level; install new brick veneer; make good architectural features; relevel the garage using low mobility grout;

repair slab; achieve original full bond or alternatively rebuild the garage in similar construction.

23.Topgrafo reports that the superstructure has racked and is on a lean as a result of 1.3 metres of lateral spread and the damage is not minimal; to return the house and garage to an ‘as new’ state which is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kristinsson v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kristinsson v Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited involved a dispute regarding the appropriate expert involvement in a joint review and joint reporting process concerning earthquake damage to a residential building. The plaintiff, Hugo Kristinsson, sought damages for the earthquake damage caused to his property. The first defendant, Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited, and the second defendant, the Earthquake Commission, were the respondents in this case. The High Court of New Zealand, Christchurch Registry, presided over the case. The primary legal issue in this case was determining which experts should participate in the joint review and reporting process regarding the earthquake damage to the residential building and the appropriate repair strategy.

The Court examined the roles and expertise of the experts involved, particularly focusing on Mr. Cowie, a surveyor, and his involvement in the process. The Court noted that while Mr. Cowie was qualified to provide surveying evidence, he did not have expertise in assessing earthquake damage to residential buildings or advising on repair strategies. The defendants argued that Mr. Cowie's involvement in the joint reporting process would not assist the parties or the Court in identifying the extent of agreement and disagreement on the damage and repair strategy. In contrast, the plaintiff argued that Mr. Cowie's expertise in surveying was relevant to identifying earthquake damage and that a collaboration between Mr. Cowie and the other experts would be most efficient.

The Court concluded that Mr. Cowie's fundamental area of expertise was in surveying. The appropriate layering of expert evidence meant that it was suitable for those whose fundamental area of expertise was in engineering to confer on causes of natural disaster damage and remedy. However, Mr. Cowie could still include in his report any opinions he was qualified to give. The expert engineers could then take it into account and obtain further information from Mr. Cowie if appropriate. The conference and joint report would remain the domain of the expert engineers.

The Court amended the direction regarding the joint reporting process, stating that the parties' experts who attended the inspection, with the exception of Mr. Cowie, should file a joint report or separate reports identifying the earthquake damage to the residential building and the appropriate repair strategy for the earthquake damage, including identifying areas of agreement and disagreement, by 27 March 2017. The proceeding was adjourned to a further case management conference on a date to be allocated by the Judicial Support Adviser after 10 April 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established