C & S Kelly Properties Ltd v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-1273 [2015] NZHC 1690

BETWEEN

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION First Defendant

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED Second Defendant

HearingDates:

29 September - 3 October 2014

8 - 16 December 2014
3- 4 March 2015

Appearances:

GDR Shand and A Ferguson for Plaintiff
B A Scott, K Millard and N Bruce-Smith for First Defendant
C R Johnstone and A Shaw for Second Defendant

Judgment:

22 July 2015

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED v EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION AND SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED [2015] NZHC 1690 [22 July 2015]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PART I – INTRODUCTORY MATTERS

An overview of this case   [1] The EQC Act and the insurance policy   [6] Background  [14] The house         [14]

The history of the claim  [15]

The joint experts’ process  [27] The claim and the positions of the parties  [32] The Kellys  [32]

EQC’s response  [37]
Southern Response’s position  [39]

The issues  [41]

PART II –RESOLUTION OF LEGAL ISSUES

Can the Kellys make a monetary claim in the absence of any

pleaded challenge to EQC’s election to repair?

[42]

Overview  [42]

The absence of challenge to EQC’s election  [47]

Earthquake Commission v Insurance Council of New Zealand

Inc (Full Bench Decision)

[54]

Challenging contractual discretion  [66]

Application to the current proceeding  [75] The timing of EQC’s election  [91] Introduction  [91]

The competing arguments  [94] When was an election made?  [98] Is this issue able to be fairly addressed in this proceeding?                [109] Legal principles germane to delay  [112] Has there in fact been delay in this proceeding?  [114] The consequences of unreasonable delay  [122]

The reasonableness of the decision to reinstate  [138]

PART III – RESOLUTION OF FACTUAL ISSUES

Overview and recap  [140] Issues raised with the evidence  [142] Introduction  [142] Principles to be applied  [143] Challenge to defendants’ experts  [150]

EQC and Southern Response admissibility issues  [163] Summary on the evidential challenges  [148] Whether the floor dislevelment is earthquake damage  [169] Natural disaster damage  [173]

Years of inspections and assessments  [178]

EQC assessment - 21 July 2011  [180]

Joint assessment by EQC and Southern Response – October

2012

Southern Response’s assessment of the property – August 2011 to May 2014

[182] [184]

Mr Lamont’s review – August 2013  [198] Engineering assessments  [203] Revised approach  [212] Settlement of the land  [214] Neighbouring properties  [220] The land under the footprint of the house  [227] Geotechnical engineering evidence  [237] Other damage to the house  [253] Soffit at northwest junction  [262]

Conclusion on whether the floor dislevelment is earthquake damage

[297]

Have the Kellys proved that a Type 2A foundation is required?               [308] Introduction  [308] The nature of the dispute  [310] The Kellys’ engineering advice  [313] Mr James Bundy’s evidence  [351] Conclusions on the Kellys’ engineering advice  [355]

PART IV – OUTCOMES

Remedy  [360] Content of relief  [360] Mechanism of relief  [371] Summary of findings    [377] Costs               [379]

PART I – INTRODUCTORY MATTERS An overview of this case

[1]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C & S Kelly Properties Ltd v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1690
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

C & S Kelly Properties Limited (the Kellys) brought a claim against The Earthquake Commission (EQC) and Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response) seeking to recover damages for earthquake damage to their property. The key issues for determination were whether the Kellys' monetary claim could succeed in the absence of any challenge to EQC's election to repair, whether EQC was in breach of its obligation to settle the Kellys' claim within a reasonable time, whether the floor dislevelment constituted earthquake damage, and what relief, if any, resulted from the Court's findings. The Court found that the Kellys' monetary claim succeeded despite the absence of challenge to EQC's election to repair, and that EQC's election to repair came too late and was therefore ineffective. The floor dislevelment in the Kellys' house constituted earthquake damage, and the Kellys were entitled to a monetary award. However, the Kellys had not proved that a Type 2A foundation was required, and EQC and Southern Response were not required to adopt this particular remediation strategy. The Kellys had the option to choose between a cash payout of $53,768.50 (incl GST), plus the additional costs associated with relevelling the floor, or holding EQC to their purported election in September 2014 and making them undertake the repairs necessary to reinstate the house in accordance with this judgment. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.