Maryville Courts Trust Board v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-000400 [2013] NZHC 1575

BETWEEN MARYVILLE COURTS TRUST BOARD Plaintiff

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION Defendant

Hearing: 13 June 2013

Appearances:

D M Lester for Plaintiff
N S Wood for Defendant

Judgment:

27 June 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

[as to plaintiff ’s summary judgment application]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff (“Maryville”) operates what is known as the Maryville Courts Retirement Village (“the Village”) in Christchurch.    Maryville comprises a community centre, 65 villas and 35 garages.

[2]      The Village was damaged in the Christchurch earthquakes of September 2010 and February 2011.

[3]      Maryville had a comprehensive insurance cover of Maryville with ACS Ltd, formerly known as ANSVAR (“ANSVAR”).

[4]      As the Village is a residential property insured against fire, the Village was deemed to be insured against earthquake and other natural disaster under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (“the EQ Act”).  Maryville made a claim against the defendant (“EQC”) for earthquake cover.   It was common ground that Maryville

had earthquake cover.

MARYVILLE COURTS TRUST BOARD v EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2013] NZHC 1575 [27 June

2013]

[5]      Both Maryville and EQC had work completed in relation to the assessment of damage and repair and the cost of repair.  Discussions took place in relation to those matters.  There were also discussions as to the apportionment of damage as between the two earthquake events.

[6]      This litigation concerns the outcome of investigations into the earthquake damage to Maryville and discussions which occurred between those looking after Maryville’s interests and those assisting EQC.  The most relevant personnel for the purposes of this application were two loss adjusters.  John Bell, a loss adjuster, appointed initially by Maryville’s insurer, ANSVAR, also had a role in looking after Maryville’s interests.  Keith Penny was the loss adjuster appointed by EQC.

[7]      The application before the Court requires the Court to determine whether statements made by Mr Penny following discussions which occurred particularly between the loss adjusters constituted, beyond argument, a decision of EQC.   If it did, did it thereby create an enforceable obligation upon EQC to pay to Maryville

$5,468,999.84 in relation to earthquake damage? A payment was subsequently made by EQC of $4,267,184.19.  Maryville now claims that there is still a balance owing of $1,201,815.

[8]      Maryville was looking to ANSVAR for the balance of its insured loss.   It accordingly wanted to know, when it came to dealing with ANSVAR, both how much EQC was paying and the apportionment of damage between the September and February quakes.  The concluding statements and calculations of Mr Penny proceeded on a 49 per cent (for September) and 51 per cent (for February) apportionment.    That  apportionment  was  later  (4  December  2012)  before  any payment was made to Maryville, revised by EQC to be 10 per cent (for September) and 90 per cent (for February).  The consequential calculations led to the difference of $1,201,815 for which Maryville now sues.

Two causes of action

[9]      Maryville pleads two causes of action.  It first says that the statements…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maryville Courts Trust Board v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1575
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered a case between Maryville Courts Trust Board (Maryville) and the Earthquake Commission (EQC) regarding earthquake damage to Maryville’s retirement village. Maryville sought summary judgment for damages amounting to $5,468,999.84, asserting that EQC had made a final determination of the claim and breached a statutory duty to pay insurance. Maryville argued that EQC’s loss adjuster, Keith Penny, had communicated this decision, and that it relied on this in settling with its private insurer. EQC denied the claim, asserting that Penny lacked authority to make such a determination and that any communications were preliminary. The Court found that Maryville had not established that EQC had no arguable defence to the claim. Regarding the first cause of action, the Court concluded that it was arguable whether Penny had the authority to communicate EQC's decision, and that there was no clear communication of a final decision. For the second cause of action, the Court found it was arguable whether Maryville had reasonably relied on any representation made by EQC. Consequently, the summary judgment application was dismissed, and the matter was set for a first case management conference.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established