Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery v Ace Developments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

IN THE HIGH COURTOF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000863 [2015] NZHC 1027

BETWEEN

THE MINISTER FOR CANTERBURY

EARTHQUAKE RECOVERY Plaintiff

AND

ACE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED First Defendant

AND

ACE SALES LIMITED Second Defendant

Hearing: 1 April 2015

Appearances:

K M Paterson for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant
G D Jones and K L Maclean for First Defendant
J Moss and L Hill for Second Defendant

Judgment:

15 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

on summary judgment applications

THE MINISTER FOR CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE RECOVERY v ACE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED [2015] NZHC 1027 [15 May 2015]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] The claims and counterclaims ................................................................................[6] The Minister’s case              [6] The defendants’ cases  [8] Ace Developments’ counterclaim  [10] Summary judgment principles .............................................................................[14] Plaintiff ’s application      [14] Defendant’s application  [16] Compulsory acquisition of land under the CER Act ............................................[18] The statutory framework as to acquisition  [18] Provisions of the CER Act  [21] Provisions of the Public Works Act 1981  [24] Compulsory acquisition of this land ....................................................................[26] What the Crown did         [26] The involvement of the defendants with the property  [31] The claim process following the Proclamation  [36] This proceeding is commenced  [41]

The Minister’s claim for an order for vacant possession against

Ace Developments ...............................................................................................[50] The applicable statutory framework  [50] Discussion – has Ace Developments been in possession?  [52] Conclusion      [55] The Minister’s claim for an order for vacant possession against Ace Sales ........[59] The construction of “the owner of the land” under s 54(2) CER Act  [59] Ace Sales’ contended construction of s 54(2) CER Act  [61]

The construction of “an owner of the land” in the context of s 54(2)

CER Act  [65] The rule that words should have effect  [79] The implied exclusion rule  [83] Decisions in other jurisdictions  [89] Outcome – s 54(2) CER Act does not apply to Ace Sales  [92]

Ace Developments’ and Ace Sales’ claims in relation to offers of

compensation......................................................................................................[100] The claims  [100] Non-resolution of compensation claim – effect on the Crown’s rights          [104] The statutory requirement for compensation under the CER Act                  [110] Differences between the compensation provisions of the CER Act

and the PW Act  [115]

Conclusion – PW Act relevant for principles of compensation but not

procedure  [125] Outcome – the Minister is not required to make an offer  [132] Ace Developments’ counterclaim ......................................................................[133] The formulation of Ace Developments’ counterclaim  [133] Test on summary judgment application  [137] Declaratory relief on summary judgment  [138] Submissions for Ace Developments  [139] Submissions for Minister  [143] Discussion  [144]

Interest when compensation payment occurs after taking of possession       [150] Outcome on counterclaim  [151] Costs ...................................................................................................................[152] Orders .................................................................................................................[155]

Introduction

[1]      Christchurch and surrounding districts suffered a series of earthquakes from

4 September 2010.

[2]      In April 2011, Parliament enacted the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act

2011  (the  CER Act).    The  purposes  of  the  CER Act  include  the  provision  of appropriate measures to ensure that greater Christchurch and the councils and their communities to respond to, and recover from, the impacts of the Canterbury earthquakes.1

[3]      Part 2 of the CER Act  contains provisions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery v Ace Developmen... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1027
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand recently issued a judgment in the case of Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery v Ace Developments Limited. The case involved the compulsory acquisition of a property in Moorhouse Avenue, Christchurch, following the Canterbury earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. The Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery sought an order for vacant possession of the property against Ace Developments Limited, the registered proprietor of the property, and Ace Sales Limited, a party claiming an interest in the property. The defendants contested the acquisition, asserting that the Crown had not followed the statutory process correctly and that they were entitled to remain in occupation of the property.

The court addressed several legal issues, including the validity of the compulsory acquisition process, the rights of the defendants to compensation, and the applicability of the Public Works Act 1981 to the compensation process under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act 2011. The court found that the property had been lawfully acquired by the Crown and that the defendants were not entitled to compensation before giving vacant possession. It concluded that the Public Works Act 1981 was relevant to the principles of compensation but not to the procedure for determining compensation. The court rejected the defendants' claims for declaratory relief regarding compensation offers and dismissed their summary judgment applications. The court ordered the defendants to give vacant possession of the property to the Crown and reserved the costs of the proceedings for further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established