C & S Kelly Properties Limited v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-1273 [2018] NZHC 56

BETWEEN

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION First Defendant

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED Second Defendant

Hearing:

21 December 2017

(On the Papers)

Counsel:

N R Campbell QC, G Shand and A Ferguson for the Plaintiff
B A Scott and J Moran for the First Defendant
C R Johnstone for the Second Defendant

Judgment:

07 February 2018

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      The parties have made applications for costs based upon their respective claims of success in respect of this litigation.  The defendants, the Earthquake Commission (EQC) and Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response), have additionally made an application for costs against the litigation funder, Claims Resolution Services Limited (CRS), and seek to resist the eligibility of the plaintiff, C & S Kelly Properties Limited (the Kellys), to receive costs as a result of its funding of the Kellys’ proceedings.  The costs issues arising from CRS’s involvement in the litigation have been parked awaiting my determination of the ordinary assessment of costs as between the parties which is the subject of this judgment.

[2]      The  proceeding  commenced  with  a  five  day  hearing  beginning  on  29

September 2014. The plaintiff’s evidence was not completed by the end of that week

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LTD v EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2018] NZHC 56 [7 February 2018]

and the trial resumed on 8 December for seven hearing days.  Two days were taken for the presentation of submissions, commencing 3 March 2015, before judgment was delivered on 22 July.1  After the Kellys elected to receive a monetary payment for the value of repair works, a quantum hearing occupied a further three and a half days, commencing 26 June 2017, with judgment delivered on 10 July 2017.2

[3]      Because of the way the litigation unfolded, two discrete hearings were held which resulted in separate judgments being delivered by two different Judges.  The issue of liability was determined by myself.3   The subsequent quantum hearing was held before Faire J. A convenient summary of the background to the proceeding and Faire J’s involvement is set out at the beginning of his judgment:

Background

[1]       The plaintiff company owns a home at 2B Vivian Street, Burwood, Christchurch.  It was the home of the shareholders and directors Suzie and Cameron Kelly (the Kellys). They lived there until the 22 February 2011, the time of the second Christchurch earthquake.  Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response) insured the Kellys’ home.  It was also insured by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (the Act).

[2]       The Kellys’ home was damaged by the September 2010 and February

2011 Canterbury earthquakes.  Disputes arose between the Kellys, EQC and Southern Response as to the extent of the earthquake damage and as to the appropriate scope and cost of reinstatement.  There was also a dispute as to whether EQC was entitled to settle the Kellys’ claim by undertaking reinstatement of the earthquake damage…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C & S Kelly Properties Limited v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a dispute between C & S Kelly Properties Limited (the Kellys) and the Earthquake Commission (EQC) as well as Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response) regarding earthquake damage to the Kellys' home. The Kellys sought a monetary judgment from both EQC and Southern Response. The litigation was bifurcated into two hearings, with Mander J determining the issue of liability and Faire J determining the quantum of damages. The High Court was tasked with determining the costs of the litigation. The Kellys sought costs against EQC and Southern Response, while EQC and Southern Response sought costs against the Kellys and the litigation funder, Claims Resolution Services Limited (CRS).

The court determined that the Kellys were successful in proving that the floor dislevelment of their home was caused by earthquake damage, but failed to prove the remediation strategy upon which their monetary claim was based. EQC and Southern Response were successful in proving that the cost of repairing the earthquake damage did not exceed the statutory cap, and that no monetary judgment was payable. The court found that the Kellys' approach to the quantum hearing was unreasonable, as they ignored the estoppel rulings and pursued meritless arguments.

The court concluded that each party should bear their own costs, as the Kellys' success in proving the cause of the floor dislevelment was offset by their failure to prove the remediation strategy. The court also found that Southern Response could not be distinguished from EQC in terms of costs, as both actively defended the proceeding on the same basis and lost on central issues.

The court dismissed the parties' respective applications for costs, ordering each party to bear their own costs. The court noted that the involvement of CRS may no longer be material, but if the parties disagreed, they could file memoranda and a telephone conference would be convened.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established