Fog v Frimley Estate Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-1990 [2016] NZHC 314

BETWEEN

MARIANNE FOG

Plaintiff

AND

FRIMLEY ESTATE LIMITED First Defendant

STEPHEN DUFF (aka NICK DUFF) Second Defendant

On the papers

Counsel:

R B Hucker for plaintiff
P M Fee and A R Durrant for first and second defendants

Judgment:

1 March 2016

JUDGMENT No 2 (Costs) OF PALMER J

This judgment was delivered by me on 1 March 2016 at 2 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Hucker & Associates, Auckland

Fee Langstone, Auckland

Fog v Frimley Estate Limited [2016] NZHC 314 [1 March 2016]

Summary

[1]      Ms Fog obtained summary judgment in relation to two of three subscriptions for shares that she made without a registered prospectus.1   She now seeks an award of costs on a 2B basis  with an uplift.   The defendants submit costs  should be reserved and/or reduced and, in any case, refused in relation to certain steps of the proceeding.   I agree that the plaintiff has succeeded and award her costs on a 2B basis, with no uplift and no reduction, but not in relation to certain steps.

The Law of Success

[2]      It is a fundamental principle that costs follow the event – a losing party pays a winning party a contribution towards their legal costs.2     However, as I have recently noted in another judgment,3 the question of who has won and who has lost litigation is not always straightforward.   The answer is at the discretion of the court (r 14.1 of the High Court Rules), guided by “the interests of justice”.

[3]      The extent to which a litigant has succeeded must be viewed as a matter of substance, not form.  It must be viewed through a realist’s lens, in “determining who in reality has been the successful party”.4

The Substantive Judgment

[4]      The substantive case here involved Ms Fog seeking summary judgment for repayment of three subscriptions for shares made without a registered prospectus.  I granted summary judgment in relation to two subscriptions, amounting to $50,400 plus statutory interest.  However I declined to grant summary judgment in relation to the original subscription of $99,000 because I was not satisfied a limitation defence

was unavailable to the defendants.

1      Fog v Frimley Estate Ltd [2015] NZHC 3301.

2      Rule 14.2(a) of the High Court Rules and Manukau Golf Club Inc v Shoye Venture Ltd [2012] NZSC 109, [2013] 1 NZLR 305 at [8].

3      McCaig v A Professional Conduct Committee No 2 [2016] NZHC 306 at [4].

4      Waihi Mines Ltd v AUAG Resources Ltd (1999) 13 PRNZ 372 (CA) at [5].  See also Packing in Ltd (in liq) formerly known as Bond Cargo Ltd v Chilcott (2003) 16 PRNZ 958 (CA) at [6] (calling for “a realistic appraisal of the end result”).

[5]      The defendants raised four defences to the summary judgment application which were resolved as follows:

(a)      A legal argument that s 37AL of the Securities Act 1978 required…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fog v Frimley Estate Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Marianne Fog brought an action against Frimley Estate Limited and Stephen Duff, seeking repayment of three subscriptions for shares made without a registered prospectus. The defendants raised several defences, including arguments that the proceedings should be stayed and that Ms Fog was not a member of the public. The Court granted summary judgment in relation to two of the three subscriptions, amounting to $50,400 plus statutory interest. However, summary judgment was not granted in relation to the original subscription of $99,000 due to a limitation defence.

The legal issues that the Court was required to decide were whether Ms Fog was successful in her application for summary judgment and, if so, what costs should be awarded. The Court found that Ms Fog was successful in her application for summary judgment, as she obtained judgment in relation to two of the three subscriptions. The Court also found that the defendants' arguments were not so unmeritorious as to deserve an uplift in costs. However, the Court did not award costs in relation to the commencement of proceedings, a memorandum of 13 November, and the submissions on costs. The Court awarded costs on a 2B basis, with no uplift and no reduction, but not in relation to certain steps.

In summary, the Court granted Ms Fog summary judgment in relation to two of the three subscriptions and awarded her costs on a 2B basis, with no uplift and no reduction, but not in relation to certain steps. The Court found that Ms Fog was substantially successful in her application for summary judgment and that the defendants' arguments were not so unmeritorious as to deserve an uplift in costs. However, the Court did not award costs in relation to the commencement of proceedings, a memorandum of 13 November, and the submissions on costs.